18 ms·
What will they replace the reduced mass with, to bulk up the product so it doesn't appear smaller? My guess is it sure as hell won't be actual cocoa :/ [1] [1
by GordonS 10y ago
What will they replace the reduced mass with, to bulk up the product so it doesn't appear smaller?
My guess is it sure as hell won't be actual cocoa :/ [1]
[1] https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:9ihtAGGkUggJ:https://www.ft.com/content/9e71ebe2-ab56-11e6-9cb3-bb8207902122+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=uk&client=firefox-b https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:9ihtAG...
- sdegutis 10y agoMy guess is artificial sweetener, which by technicalities gets to say it's safer than it really is because of number-rounding laws. Or something?
- CoryG89 10y agoI think the idea is that they can now remove 40% of the sugar and still achieve the same sweetness with no other sweeteners needed.
- sdegutis 10y agoI guess I'm more cynical and skeptical of businesses which only have financial incentives in mind to do "good" things like this, but no ethical incentives.
- fritzw 10y agoIf they remove 40% of the sugar they have to replace it with 40% of something else. Candy is sold by weight. Removing the sugar only solves part of the problem
- CoryG89 10y agoThey don't have to replace it with anything if they don't want to. They could just make it smaller, sell it at a higher price (per weight).
- sp332 10y agoHershey has already done this quite a few times with their chocolate bars. They just get thinner and the texture gets waxier, I assume for structural integrity.
- scopecreep 10y agoI'm shocked that this is the only mention of wax in the entire thread. Last Hershey bar I tasted reminded me of those old novelty wax lips they used to give kids around Halloween. It's already to the point where you can actually taste the wax if you know the flavor.
- grok2 10y agoFTA: "The company, which makes Kitkat and Aero, says its researchers have found a way to structure sugar differently, so that it uses 40% less." Seems like they re-invented something like Splenda?
- GordonS 10y agoThe difference here (if true) is that they say it doesn't affect taste - I've never had an artificial sugar than tastes anything like sugar.
- riffraff 10y agoI've found xylitol tastes close enough to sugar, compared to all other sweeteners I've tried. It does appear to get "dissolved" faster though, I can't really explain.
- cptskippy 10y agoXylitol is a sugar alcohol and not an artificial sweetener.
- logfromblammo 10y agoWhile it is technically a natural sugar alcohol, and can be refined from birch trees, most of the xylitol used in food products now is full synthetic or fermented with yeasts. It is sweet. It is artificial (sometimes). It may also draw additional water into your colon and have a "cool" mouth-feel, and it does add calories. Erythritol may be preferable for those reasons, even though it is less sweet. A common non-sugar sweetener mix is erythritol and stevia, which can, when proportioned correctly, add the same sweetness as an equal mass of refined sucrose.
- jquast 10y agoxylitol is actually beneficial for your teeth. I really welcome a future of kit-kat bars made with xylitol, if its at all reasonable.
- Sharlin 10y agoThey can't really use artificial sweeteners to add bulk because those are much much sweeter than sugar per unit mass.
- sdegutis 10y agoBalance the artificial sweeter with some sawdust to achieve the same mass and sweetness. Pretty sure that's legal...
- CoryG89 10y agoInteresting. I wonder how much smaller a KitKat would be with 40% less sugar and nothing else added to make up the difference.
- JadeNB 10y agoAccording to http://www.kitkat.co.uk/content/kitkatcollection http://www.kitkat.co.uk/content/kitkatcollection , about 54% of the mass is sugar, so reducing that by 40% would cut the mass by roughly 22%.
- mholmes680 10y agoOther attempts at changing products "without any affect to the taste" have very much ruined their taste for me. If they do that to KitKat, I might have to take a day/week off work for mourning. I'm hoping since this is just a different sugar structure, I'll be ok. Maybe around October next year I'll buy a spare freezer and start stocking up.
- nommm-nommm 10y agoKraft actually succeed in (stealthily) removing artificial colors from Mac and cheese and keeping the bright orange hue that we all love. Didn't change the taste. I say stealthily because they didn't announce the change until a year later and nobody seemed to notice for a year.
- dbg31415 10y agoI'm sure it'll be something along the lines of, "Hey, we're using 40% less sugar... we will be adding in some things like cane-juice crystals, corn syrup solids, and refiner's syrup to compensate." Don't you feel better already?
- GordonS 10y agoIn the UK, concentrated grape juice is often added to products marketed for small kids and babies. Presumably a lot of parent read that and think 'oh, fruit, that's good for you!', not realising that this is essentially pure sugar.
- Declanomous 10y agoThey do that with apple juice in the United States. Apples and apple juice are incredibly cheap here.
- tracker1 10y agoIn the U.S. can say the same of Apple Juice.
- pbhjpbhj 10y agoBet they could rename sugar as "root vegetable extract" if it's derived from sugar-beet.
- problems 10y agoOf course, cocoa would affect the taste, a lot of people don't like dark chocolate. They're talking about another sugar that would dissolve faster in the mouth. Should be interesting at least.
- GordonS 10y agoTrue enough, but most milk chocolate products would have to add a lot of cocoa before they were considered dark chocolate. Just 20% is fairly typical here in the UK, which results in something far too sweet and barely recognisable as chocolate. But I'm one of those freaks that actually likes dark chocolate up to 85%.
- tudorw 10y agotake a walk into pure darkness sometime, good luck...bitter is not the word! https://www.montezumas.co.uk/bars-c1/100-cocoa-chocolate-bar-absolute-black-p249 https://www.montezumas.co.uk/bars-c1/100-cocoa-chocolate-bar...
- ashmud 10y agoAlso, (unsweetened) cacao nibs: http://navitasnaturals.com/product/439/Cacao-Nibs.html http://navitasnaturals.com/product/439/Cacao-Nibs.html
- masklinn 10y ago> But I'm one of those freaks that actually likes dark chocolate up to 85%. 85% seems fairly commonly OK, I've rarely found other people who like 95+, let alone my best friend the 99% (http://www.chocolate.lindt.com/shop/excellence-cocoa-99-1 http://www.chocolate.lindt.com/shop/excellence-cocoa-99-1).
- Declanomous 10y agoI'll eat pretty much any dark chocolate. The best place to find inexpensive, yet good, dark chocolate in the United States is ALDI. Another great thing about their dark chocolate is that it doesn't contain any dairy. One of my friends was on an extremely limited diet for a while doctors tried to figure out what was causing a mysterious allergic reaction. That meant no dairy. She missed chocolate so much she nearly cried when I gave her the first chocolate she could eat in several months.
- binarymax 10y agoMy bet: Soy Lecithin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lecithin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lecithin
- voidlogic 10y agoSounds better than sugar! I wonder if they consider using isomalt.
- AstralStorm 10y agoSwitching to isomalt will drop ~50% in the caloric content, but change mouth feel and water retention a lot. A different confection will be the result.
- xorxornop 10y agoYep. Adding another lower/zero-calorific sugar but with a positive heat of dissolution (to counter the negative one of isomalt) can really help here. Similarly, you can choose sugar pairs to promote or suppress crystallisation, as the recipe style requires. This is done by selecting sugars with similar or dissimilar molecular geometry and charge distribution.
- xorxornop 10y agoWhy not erythritol? Isomalt can cause some pretty severe gut issues (to which I can personally attest, unfortunately!). It's also still quite calorific (that is, it is metabolised) - erythritol isn't. I can eat it in high quantities to seemingly zero consequence. It's also got an entertaining mouthfeel, where it cools the mouth; so does isomalt, incidentally, but it's not nearly as noticeable. I have done quite a bit of cooking with erythritol, simply swapping sugar out for it, and it usually works great. Erythritol is only about 70% as sweet, so it can sometimes be necessary to adjust for that, but really, most things are already overly sugary, so it's usually unnecessary.
- dingaling 10y agoMy wife's standard approach to any cake or confectionary recipe is to immediately half the listed quantity of sugar. Apparently this is common amongst pastry-chefs in catering and doesn't appear to affect the final result other than being a bit paler after cooking. We even made half-sugar doughnuts recently which were still delicious ( no topping or filling needed ). So I reckon Nestle will just produce a slightly less bulky confectionery, for the same price of course.
- Xcelerate 10y agoWhat if the recipe doubled the required amount of sugar in anticipation of people cutting the amount they add?
- bennyg 10y agoIt's more likely that a greater amount of people use the recipe as-is, instead of halving. My guess is the recipes aren't playing reverse-psychology with cooks.
- debacle 10y agoSugar can change the texture greatly of cakes especially. I do the same thing that you do, but it does have an impact on the mouth feel.
- mc32 10y agoWhen I bake at home I do the same thing. I'm still a bit hit or miss with regard to having things come out with the same texture/feel (how they rise or not, etc.) My basic question is how to compensate for the proportions new proportions. But overall, the taste is much more palatable because there is much less sugar-shock.
- notalaser 10y agoMe and my girlfriend (we both really, really like cooking) do that with a lot of recipes that involve sugar. It does affect the texture, but I think it often improves the taste. There are things that ought to be sugary (like thick syrups used for preserving), but most pastries, jams, jellies and deserts in general need surprisingly less sugar than recent cookbooks would imply. Adding just enough sugar to take the edge off of bitterness or sourness ends up being more rewarding than cramming everything full of sugar to the point where all you feel is something odd next to the sweetness.
- lazyjones 10y agoWho cares, you can get proper 100% chocolate (organic, fair trade, blah...) easily from Zotter, if you want it. It doesn't really matter what Nestle comes up with next, people who eat that stuff don't care about such details.
- Shivetya 10y agothere are many great places to buy the world's chocolates from (my favorite is chocosphere) however for many it is what they will see in the check out lane or quickie mart that matters. if they can still get their fix without all the excess calories; sugar isn't the worst thing; then please, encourage it more. now just slip some fiber in there to make people feel full
- lpa22 10y agoIn the US, I would argue that it is significantly easier to get Nestle chocolate than Zotter chocolate at grocery stores. The amount that the average person cares about the sugar content does not outweigh the extra effort required to acquire Zotter chocolate... Nestle is ubiquitous.
- dagw 10y agoMy wife occasionally buys 100% chocolate. Personally I think it tastes pretty terrible. 90% can be OK, but personally I don't like much over 80-85%
- neves 10y agoI care. There isn't a Zotter in my country.
- tomascot 10y agoSuppose it has 5% sugar, if you reduce that amount 40% it won't be much. Maybe they add some soy byproduct
- devb 10y agoI don't know where you're getting the 5% figure. It's more like 50% sugar content for most commercial chocolate products. http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/262978.php http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/262978.php (One teaspoon weighs approximately 4 grams)
- hinkley 10y agoJust found a nutritional chart that says a 41g piece of Nestlé milk chocolate (probably worst case scenario) contains 27g of carbs. Now, a volume of liquids and solids when mixed together do not necessarily add up to the same volume of the originals. For instance mixing a fluid ounce of alcohol and water won't result in 2 ounces of combined fluid. So while they're talking about taking ~13g of sugar out of each serving (32% of the weight), that does not mean they need exactly 32% filler to make up the difference. Could be a lot less than that.
- pbhjpbhj 10y agoSeveral chocolate products in the UK seem already to have done the foam trick (add air), particular ones like Thorntons (individual chocolate box chocolates). You can only do that so much though. They used to be one of my favourites but now they're more like mousse than anything, the mouth feel is very poor and the flavour is greatly reduced - adding air with individual wrapped chocolates works commercially because they don't have a weight marked on them. Cadbury, trimmed bars using carefully designed shapes (rounding off corners, adding curled edges) that seem as big; also adding cheap filler like popcorn or puffed rice.
- dperfect 10y agoA 40% reduction of an ingredient doesn't mean that somehow there's a void in anyone's product (they could reduce the product size also, but that's a separate matter). It just means that the other ingredients together will represent a higher proportion of the final product in relation to the reduced ingredient. Think of it this way: 1% milk has some of the milk fat removed/reduced, but that doesn't mean any other ingredient has to replace what is taken out (again, some may choose to add other things, but that's a separate choice), and your milk carton doesn't have to get any smaller. It just means your same milk carton has a higher percentage of the other components of milk. To be clear, the article states: "this can be done without affecting the taste... Its scientists altered the structure of sugar so that it dissolves more quickly. This fools the taste buds, with the effect of raising the sweetness." The way I read that, it seems to support the idea that nothing else has to replace the reduced sugar. But practically speaking, yes - if the other ingredients are costlier than the reduced sugar (as a higher percentage of the final product), then there's a good chance some other fillers could be added to maintain product weight and size.
- DavidWanjiru 10y agoIf I'm not mistaken, 1% in milk refers to the butter fat content, but if a chocolate is 60% sugar, isn't that by weight? Like if a bar is 100 grams, 60 grams is sugar? If that is how it works, you'll notice the missing sugar, I think.
- dperfect 10y agoIf they're claiming a 40% reduction in sugar (by weight or by volume - the same principle applies) without affecting taste, then no, apparently you wouldn't notice the missing sugar. They're saying that an altered structure of the sugar itself makes it taste sweeter, so less sugar ends up tasting the same[1]. I am skeptical that it wouldn't affect other desirable properties of the chocolate, but I guess only time will tell whether or not their claim is actually true. [1] There have been other similar breakthroughs in altering the structure of ingredients to allow for reductions without significantly affecting taste/texture. One notable example is low-temperature extrusion ("slow churned") ice cream.
- desbest 10y agoThat google cache will expire. Here's a version of that link that'll last forever. http://archive.is/CyGmc http://archive.is/CyGmc
- danudey 10y agoIf milk chocolate is 50% sugar, and they cut sugar by 50% and replace it with cocoa, then wouldn't that make it 25% sugar and 75% cocoa? That sounds like not even remotely what people want.
- ThrustVectoring 10y agoUhm, nothing? Sugar dissolved in solution takes hardly any additional volume. It depends on the exact chemistry involved, but probably what you end up with is the same volume product with "healthier"-looking nutrition facts and significantly less mass.
- johnward 10y agoThey've gotten away with shrinking products for years. When cost increase they make the product cheaper, aka smaller, instead of increasing prices. That's why the giant sized candy bar at the checkout line seems like a normal size from 10 years ago. I don't see how this will be much different.
- jdietrich 10y agoAir, the cheapest ingredient in food manufacturing. Make the wafer biscuits in a Kit Kat less dense. Add more bubbles to the Aero. Change the shape of bars so that they appear bigger. Add puffed rice or pieces of biscuit to pad out solid chocolate. It's part of the standard marketing repertoire. http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2421568/Revolt-Cadburys-rounder-sweeter-bars-Not-classic-rectangle-shape-Dairy-Milk-changed-customers-also-sugary.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2421568/Revolt-Cadbu... http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-37904703 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-37904703 https://www.marketingweek.com/2015/02/12/mondelez-to-continue-cost-cutting-strategy-in-an-effort-to-turn-around-profit/ https://www.marketingweek.com/2015/02/12/mondelez-to-continu...
- joelthelion 10y agoSomething like flour, maybe?
- smegel 10y agoPolydextrose.
- aaron695 10y agoYes, this is a major issue that people seem to be missing. Sugar is used to bulk products. It's cheaper than almost all other ingredients. Often you add salt to stop it getting to sweet. If people wanted smaller products they could just eat 40% less so there will have to be something to replace it.