7 ms·
So, they want to encourage ride-sharing in the original meaning - carpooling. Not the "taxi company in disguise" meaning. Sounds fair enough to me. For context
by kalleboo 10y ago
So, they want to encourage ride-sharing in the original meaning - carpooling. Not the "taxi company in disguise" meaning. Sounds fair enough to me.
For context, the taxi regulation in Sweden is very light. There is no medallion system limiting the number of cars, and no regulation of prices. You just need an extended driver's license, an approved taxi-meter (same as how grocery stores need their scales to be approved), and the pricing plan listed clearly in the window.
There has been quite a bit of criticism of this lack of regulation, since some private taxi drivers will prey on tourists by overpricing their services by 3x and waiting at airports. Since their rip-off prices are displayed right there in the window, it's fully legal. Tourists don't know the typical price of a taxi, and fresh off an airplane are not sure what the local currency rate is (Sweden isn't on the Euro), and hence get ripped off.
- edblarney 10y ago"So, they want to encourage ride-sharing in the original meaning - carpooling. Not the "taxi company in disguise" meaning. Sounds fair enough to me." I'm not necessarily a fan of Uber, but this is ridiculous. If 'taxis' are legal in Sweden then there's no reason Uber should not be able to operate so long as they are obeying the laws. Ostensibly, this is about a specific issue - distance travelled and the lack of ability for tax authorities to measure that. Two things to know about Nordic countries: 1) They are super, super aggressive when it comes to tax things. Cheating on taxes is worse than some major crimes! 2) They are culturally anti-business and anti-entrepreneurial. I know this may seem odd given the number of startups - but their version of 'socialism' is cultural. To be a 'business person' or 'CEO' or to 'have your own company' even up until the 1980's was considered a 'dirty word'. They have this view that 'private business is immoral' in some ways. It's hard to describe. They are just default skeptical of anyone creating a business. Obviously that has evolved a lot over the last 30 years, but the underlying cultural phenom is still kind of there. Finally - this may simply be political. Taxi entities around the world are trying to find ways to get Uber banned, and so they find an issue or concern that gives them a legal footing. Again, I'm not for or against Uber really ...
- daenney 10y ago> "So, they want to encourage ride-sharing in the original meaning - carpooling. Not the "taxi company in disguise" meaning. Sounds fair enough to me." > I'm not necessarily a fan of Uber, but this is ridiculous. > If 'taxis' are legal in Sweden then there's no reason Uber should not be able to operate so long as they are obeying the laws. I think you've misunderstood what was said in the original article. This doesn't make Uber illegal at all in Sweden, they can continue providing taxi services like they have done. However, it makes the ride-sharing part of it, UberPOP for example, illegal. I.e if you want to ride share then that's fine, but you shouldn't be compensated for it. Bringing it back to the original concept of carpooling. However, Uber Black or UberX would be, from my understanding of it, perfectly fine and they can continue to offer those services.
- marcoperaza 10y agoYou are mistaken. UberPOP is already not operational in Sweden. UberX is what's being targeted.
- daenney 10y agoI don't believe so. UberX is not ridesharing, UberPOP is. Also, if I am mistaken, please point me to the source in the article that actually states that they're targeting UberX. The article explicitly mentions UberPOP, if it would affect X I'm fairly certain they would've mentioned that along the way. The fact that POP is not operational in Sweden at all doesn't mean it automatically targets X. UberPOP is just the ride sharing service most people are familiar with so it makes sense for Reuters to use that as an example, as well as add to the appeal of their article. There are however other companies that do provide for-profit ride sharing services in Stockholm. This just means that there's now going to be a law that prohibits UberPOP and similar for-profit ride sharing services entirely, regardless of if they already operate or not. As also noted by Uber itself, X is not ridesharing. UberX is the most popular private car service that Uber has to offer. It's commonly referred to as the "low-cost option" for riders, it allows you to quickly arrive at your destination without breaking the bank. To contrast with UberPOP With UberPOP, you can share your UberX and split the fare with multiple users. That's ride sharing.
- nothrabannosir 10y agosome private taxi drivers will prey on tourists by overpricing their services by 3x and waiting at airports. Since their rip-off prices are displayed right there in the window, it's fully legal. Tourists don't know the typical price of a taxi, and fresh off an airplane are not sure what the local currency rate is (Sweden isn't on the Euro), and hence get ripped off. Typically this should lead to more competition there. Is something preventing that? Taxi thug groups (i.e. cartels), lack of space, ..? If the price and product are clear, and if there's opportunity for competition, well.. I don't want to sound too libertarian, but, you know... :)
- wavefunction 10y agoTaxi thugs? Thug means someone who intimidates with threats of violence to get their way. Why would any taxi-driver feel like upsetting the apple-cart?
- nothrabannosir 10y agoIntimidating competitors. The taxi industry is notorious for this. Of course it's only a few bad apples that ruin the basket, but it's not unheard of.
- zzleeper 10y agoNot really. There is an econ paper that explains why (Xavier Gabaix's shrouded prices theory), but the idea is this: There are some consumers that are naive (tourists in this case) and you can exploit them (go to the airport, and wait until you get a naive guy). Now, suppose a competitor can find a way to educate consumers: you print pamphlets listing the true costs and hire someone to distribute them everywhere. Now tourists are well informed, but what's the benefit for the competitor? It just did something expensive but now he faces informed guys that will only pay the competitive price. So in equilibrium no one will teach the naive consumers.
- vasco 10y agoExcept you could just put a billboard right there in the airport exit saying how much an average trip to the city center costs for very little money.
- matwood 10y ago> There has been quite a bit of criticism of this lack of regulation, since some private taxi drivers will prey on tourists by overpricing their services by 3x and waiting at airports. Since their rip-off prices are displayed right there in the window, it's fully legal. Tourists don't know the typical price of a taxi, and fresh off an airplane are not sure what the local currency rate is (Sweden isn't on the Euro), and hence get ripped off. I was in Stockholm over the summer, and prior to going I read about this beforehand on almost every site I visited. Is it the most tourist friendly thing? No, but it is listed in big numbers on the taxi. It only takes seeing a few taxis to get an idea of what is a good price. Everything in Stockholm ended up being expensive, so the taxi was just a minor inconvenience.
- wavefunction 10y ago"ride-sharing" is ride-sharing. That's the only meaning it has. Ride-hailing is what Uber and Lyft and ArcadeCity and Fare and all the rest of the taxi-apps offer.
- hopfog 10y ago> You just need an extended driver's license, an approved taxi-meter (same as how grocery stores need their scales to be approved), and the pricing plan listed clearly in the window. You're omitting the most important thing here: the actual taxi traffic permit. That's the hard part in this process.
- dagw 10y agoThat's the hard part in this process. Not in Sweden. There are probably hundreds of taxi companies in Sweden and starting a new one is basically no harder than starting any other company.
- hopfog 10y agoI'm currently going through this process and there's some bureaucracy involved: 1. You need to show that you have financial resources of 100 000 SEK for one car and 50 000 SEK for all subsequent ones you're registering for. This needs to be reviewed and attested by an auditor. https://www.transportstyrelsen.se/globalassets/global/blanketter/vag/yrkestrafik/taxi/tstry1105-provning-ekonomi-taxi-juridiskperson.pdf https://www.transportstyrelsen.se/globalassets/global/blanke... 2. You need to be a certified traffic manager. https://www.transportstyrelsen.se/sv/vagtrafik/Yrkestrafik/Gods-och-buss/Yrkestrafiktillstand/Prov-i-yrkeskunnande-for-trafiktillstand/ https://www.transportstyrelsen.se/sv/vagtrafik/Yrkestrafik/G... Nothing super complicated but it's not just getting an extended driver's license like OP says.