8 ms·
I liked Pebble as a company because they knew how to make just the right engineering compromises to make their product work. The smartwatch everyone wants has a
by modeless 10y ago
I liked Pebble as a company because they knew how to make just the right engineering compromises to make their product work. The smartwatch everyone wants has a battery that lasts for weeks, a high contrast always-on color screen visible in daylight and total darkness, no bezel, and a round case only a few mm thick. That perfect watch is impossible to build, but Pebble found compromises that worked. They chose different compromises than those of Apple and Google, and IMHO better ones. The Pebble Time Round is a tiny little triumph of smart engineering compared with any other product on the market, including the Apple Watch.
In particular it's incredible what the Pebble firmware team was able to accomplish. They built a bespoke OS that's extremely reliable (certainly more reliable than Android Wear), with an app SDK and store, plus a well thought out user interface with a striking visual design and even fun little animated flourishes, despite running in a fraction of the power budget of Apple or Android smartwatches. How many companies could have done that? Fitbit is getting a bargain, if that team is still intact.
- camillomiller 10y agoIndeed, 40M is astounding
- argonaut 10y ago"Our source said that Fitbit is now paying between $34 and $40 million for the company and is 'barely covering their debts.'" After paying debt and preferred shareholders, I won't be surprised if the founders and employees see absolutely nothing (as in, absolutely $0), although employees will probably receive retention payouts.
- camillomiller 10y agoNot selling to Citizen for 750M in 2015 was a hell of a mistake. I really would to be behind the rationale to say no to a deal like that, when the market was clearly seized by Apple and way richer competitors...
- on_and_off 10y ago> (certainly more reliable than Android Wear) weird. I stopped using AndroidWear, but only because I have no interest in wearables, the OS itself has worked like a charm for me. > if that team is still intact from what I understand, employees have been leaving from quite some time since pebble has been in the red for a while.
- tokenizerrr 10y ago> In particular it's incredible what the Pebble firmware team was able to accomplish. They built a bespoke OS that's extremely reliable That doesn't match my experience at all. A few months ago I was completely ready to jump on the smartwatch bandwagon so got a pebble. First of all, and somewhat unrelated, but the watch band itched and was uncomfortable and seemed to be low quality. More importantly, the Pebble randomly disconnected from my Android phone multiple times a day causing notifications not to show up. The watch would also crash occasionally, resetting to its homescreen and forgetting what I was doing. I am now a happy Moto 360 user (gen 2).
- modeless 10y agoAndroid Wear may have improved, but in my year or so of wearing a Moto 360 v1 I experienced such various bugs as showing the wrong time on the watch face (yes!), boot loops which were completely unrecoverable without the use of the charging dock, missing notifications due to silly Android permission issues, failure to turn the screen on for notifications, "Unfortunately, Android Wear has stopped", and plenty of bluetooth disconnects. All that among various hardware issues such as general slow performance, touchscreen unreliability that requires you to stare at the watch to confirm the receipt of each swipe, and a heart rate sensor that might as well be replaced with a random number generator. Switching to Pebble Time Round after that was a revelation.
- tokenizerrr 10y agoI actually have the 2nd generation Moto 360, and have not experienced any of those issues at all. The only thing I could complain about is how the watch face resets when the watch runs out of power. Not a big deal, the time is still shown correctly, and to set the correct watch face I'd just have to open the Wear app again and tap it. But still annoying. The heart rate sensor also seems consistent at least, though I have nothing to compare it with. Anyway, funny to see how these things go and how our experiences are basically opposites.
- Klathmon 10y agoI know it probably doesn't matter to you now, but the M360v1 is widely regarded as one of the worst android wear watches. It was built on a platform that the company making it left the business partially through it's development. It was made with a different screen type (and processor arch IIRC) than other watches, it was significantly slower than other watches, and has had some QC issues where batteries at this point are beginning to swell up and make the watch unusable (it seems to be hitting everyone, the only factor is how long it'll take). I loved my v1 like how I loved my first shitty car, and that might just be a mix of stockholm syndrome and nostalgia (not sure if that's the right word there...), but I currently have a fossil founder that my wife got me as a gift and it clearly improves on the M360v1 in just about every way. Obviously you do you, but if you ever end up wanting to take another look at the landscape, just know that your experience with android wear was probably the worse you could have had, and that things are all around much better now.
- bambax 10y ago> That perfect watch is impossible to build Do not compare to the Apple watch; have you looked at Garmin's Fenix 3? It has an always-on screen, a compass that works EVERYWHERE including indoors, on airplanes, in underground car parks, etc., a super-accurate GPS, and all the other functions you would need. Its battery lasts over a week when not using GPS, or 24hrs with GPS. It doesn't need a phone to operate, it's very sturdy and what's more, it's round (square watches are ugly, how do makers of other "smart" watches not see that???) It's a bit thick but not too heavy. I've had it for a year and couldn't live without it.
- wpietri 10y agoCould you say more about your use cases? For me, the point of a smartwatch is that it serves as a secondary interface to my phone. I like that my phone stays in my pocket more, because then I'm less likely to be rude because of my phone, or to have to drag it out just to see what that notification was. I've owned and used an earlier Garmin watch for running and I loved it, but eventually stopped using it because I just didn't need to maintain another separate device. But clearly you're up to something else than me.
- bambax 10y agoWell, glancing at your watch when you receive a notification is even ruder, because then the other party thinks you're bored! ;-) I really like having a compass, I'm not sure why but when I get lost in a town (at night) I usually can find my way back if I know where North is. Some people always know where North is -- not me, but I usually can figure out where everything else is, relative to the North. I sometimes take walks in the woods with my kids and like to track where we've been. You can do this with a phone but then you have to have the proper app, launch it, etc. I don't like to use my phone for anything else but calls (I'm old). With the Fenix it's just the push of a button. You can use GPS also to record where your car is, and it will direct you back to it; this is useful everywhere. Also, as a photographer, if you record your tracks when shooting you can later import GPS data to photographs (some cameras have GPS but not all, it doesn't work too well and it drains the battery). It remembers my sleeping patterns, which is completely useless but nice to look at, in a narcissistic kind of way.
- fuck_google 10y agoLimited resources and other restrictions fuel creativity. Apple and Google have just about unlimited resources, and it shows.
- kobeya 10y ago> How many companies could have done that? Fitbit is getting a bargain, if that team is still intact. There's been an exodus from Pebble for months now. Our team already picked up a few competent people. :( Sad because I really like Pebble's products.
- ClassyJacket 10y agoI don't know why anyone cares about week long battery life. It would give me literally no advantage. I take my watch off when I go to sleep, so I simply put the charger on the table near my bed, and that's where I put it. It's no more effort to charge it than to not charge it. I can understand 2 days since you might stay at your girlfriend's house or something, but mine already can do 2 days anyway.
- brlewis 10y agoI don't know for smartwatches in general, but for Fitbit people like to track their sleep and also not leave steps uncounted, so there's really no good time to recharge.
- tolien 10y ago> battery life. It would give me literally no advantage. I take my watch off when I go to sleep Can't do that if you're using the watch for sleep tracking. I've got into the habit of putting mine (an Apple Watch Series 2) on charge when I get up and leaving it there till I'm about to leave. Other than the odd top-up (if I've been using the Workout app and thus the heart rate sensor), no problems. More battery life would be good though - if it used to be worse with the original AW, it's not hard to see how that would be a problem.
- crb 10y agoOne of the great functions of a smart watch (or other fitness wearable) is sleep tracking. If you have to take it off overnight, you can't do that. I charge my Pebble once a week. Before that, wearing a bog-standard digital watch, I took it off ~never.
- 3poundkilograms 10y agoAs a Pebble user, I sleep with my watch on as it wakes me up in a much gentler way than any audio alarm does. However, having a week long charge is also about more than just being able to avoid charging it at night. It also means that the remaining battery capacity (wear, age) will matter less. Is your battery dying, with only 50% of the design capacity left? Who cares, the watch still lasts for days. Not only that - the slow discharge also means that the battery will take ages to even experience reduced capacity. The Apple Watch, on the other hand, sprints through the battery charges, and will both be completely intolerant to reduced battery capacity and reach reduced battery capacity faster. ... So yeah. It matters.
- rockostrich 10y agoI think Pebble benefitted a ton from being the first company in the space. There were definitely a ton of hiccups with the original Pebble watch. There was barely a store and when the store did come into being it was buggy as hell. The hardware design decisions have always been pretty great though. Even today, I'd probably take the original Pebble over an Apple watch or anything from Android wear for practicality.
- ohsnapman 10y agoI made the mistakes of backing a number of smartwatches on Kickstarter and IndieGoGo. The Pebble, for its faults, was still the most stable, polished item out of all the crowdfunded items I've ever back. Separate note: I don't crowdfund anything anymore. Learned my lesson.
- fudged71 10y agoThis comment perfectly describes Fitbit as well. They were able to take a huge chunk of market share by being the first mover. And they had their own issues with rashes etc.
- this-dang-guy 10y agoI agree. I backed pebble each time on kickstarter, and bought some of them for friends, too. They are by far and away my favorite smartwatch. The others have just no appeal to me at all. Fitbit, however, makes awful devices, IMO. I really hope they don't kill the Pebble magic.
- mercer 10y agoI know almost nothing about Fitbit, but for the most part their image is positive. Could you elaborate on what's wrong with Fitbit devices?
- larcher 10y agoI've been pretty happy with the devices, when they work. But they don't seem built to last. Of the 6 Fitbits I've had in the last 5 years (the original, 2 Fitbit Ultras, 3 Fitbit Zips), only one of them didn't fall apart or otherwise stop working .. and that one I lost. The Zip in particular seems to have an issue with the battery cover, where it wears out and becomes too loose and the device won't stay powered on.
- this-dang-guy 10y agoExactly. Build quality, reliability, etc. Very cheaply made in my experience.
- karlding 10y agoUnless they've recently made changes, their OS firmware is actually built on top of FreeRTOS, with a bunch of backported features and memory optimizations for the lower-end and first-generation devices. I think the most impressive engineering feat is what they're able to accomplish in their software, given their hardware limitations.
- rkangel 10y agoFreeRTOS (while being absolutely fantastic) is 'just' a series of low level primitives allowing task scheduling and so forth. The Pebble platform is a much richer 'operating system' for pebble apps.