3 ms·
> Jacobsen thinks that this water may help explain why Earth is the only planet we know to have plate tectonics. “Water mixes with ocean crust and gets subducte
by tzs 10y ago
> Jacobsen thinks that this water may help explain why Earth is the only planet we know to have plate tectonics. “Water mixes with ocean crust and gets subducted at convergent plate boundaries,” he says. “Introducing water into the mantle promotes melting and weakens rock, likely helping out the motions of plates like grease.”
I am completely befuddled by plate tectonics. In particular, every drawing I've seen of the plates shows the surface of the Earth as kind of like a jigsaw puzzle, with the pieces being the various plates, and everyplace being part of some plate.
I don't see how there can be any significant relative motion of the plates. For instance, take this plate diagram, found on Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plate_tectonics#/media/File:Plates_tect2_en.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plate_tectonics#/media/File:Pl...
That looks like it should be pretty much locked up. For anything to move, something else would have to give way, and for that to move, something else would have to give way, and so on, and you'd end up at most just being able to make the whole assembly move as a unit.
For there to be significant movement, it would seem that the plates would need to be changing shape in addition to moving. Is that something they do that is simply left out of the popular science explanations?
- stouset 10y agoI find it helpful to imagine the plates are flexible and not rigid. They have forces acting on them that cause them to want to move in a direction, whether or not they're capable of actual doing so. When they can't, pressure builds up until something gives and… you have an earthquake. This, plus plates deforming, I believe should solve your confusion. They are locked up against one another (in the case of strike-slip faults, moving past one another). There are also have other fault types, like subduction zones where one plate gets pushed beneath another (plate tectonics are 3D, not just 2D!). All this twisting and squeezing and pushing with nowhere to go until something fails. If this is a bad mental model, someone please correct me.
- ponyous 10y agoI have been taught that because of moving plates mountains can rise, besides that one plate may be slowly moving under another - confirming your hypothesis that plates do change shape, but shape change is not required to move.
- wycx 10y agoDo an image search for "subduction zone", you will get some images that show you what is going on, schematically in cross section. A simplified summary: New oceanic crust is created at mid ocean ridges, but since the earth is not expanding, when you create new crust, subduction must occur elsewhere. For instance, new crust is created in the pacific, and subduction is occurring beneath Japan in the east and the west coast of north america in the west. Once the oceanic crust subducts far enough into the mantle, minerals that make the oceanic crust change to more dense forms in response to the increased pressure, (basalt to eclogite transition) and the resulting rock is more dense than the surrounding mantle, meaning it wants to sink further and further, providing a "slab pull" component to subduction (as opposed to "ridge push" due to new crust formation at the mid ocean ridge). Oceanic crust will almost universally subduct beneath continental crust due to density (~2.3 g/cc for continental, 2.7 for oceanic, >3 for mantle). Continental crust is too low density to subduct into the mantle, so you make mountain ranges like the Himalaya when continents colide. After new oceanic crust is erupted at mid ocean ridges, it remains hot, and experiences sustained interaction with seawater forming new minerals with structural water/OH- (i.e. chlorite), as well as accumulating a veneer of sediment that includes clay minerals also with structural water. When that oceanic crust then subducts back into the mantle, it heats up, the hydrous minerals are no longer stable, and they release their H2O into the overlying mantle. This addition of water lowers the melting point of the mantle such that it will melt under the ambient temperature conditions, this melting is ultimately manifest as volcanic arcs, such as that that extends from the andes, north through central america, mexico, the cascades, the aleutians , kuriles, japan, philippines, indonesia, new guinea, solomons, fiji, down to new zealand. These volcanoes are characterised by high H2O contents, leading to explosive eruptions, in contrast to the style of eruption seen in places like Hawaii. Not all the water (structural OH-) is released when from the subducting slab, and makes its way deeper into the mantle, and aspects of the ultimate fate of this is the subject of the article.