4 ms·
Sounds like it is both intrusive and useless at the same time. If you're not going to see what people did on a site, what's the point? Presumably nefarious stu
by lordnacho 10y ago
Sounds like it is both intrusive and useless at the same time.
If you're not going to see what people did on a site, what's the point? Presumably nefarious stuff like pedo rings and dark markets will not stay in the same place very long.
At the same time, people can see what kind of politics you're into. Or porn. Or dating. Which is not terribly useful for the public interest, but you can see a cop abusing this for personal gain. I think Snowden mentioned his colleagues used to stalk their exes.
Also, anyone who's accidentally left WireShark open will know how much data you're sucking up. It's not actually a small amount, and it compounds if you're an ISP. And it sure isn't easy to filter huge pcap files, which you'll have to do if you want to find something specific. And then you have to glue the clues together, totally non trivial.
Last, how will this be used in court? Knowing what sites someone visited is not evidence they did something. Some guy visits an ISIS homepage, is that because he's curious or he's getting bomb manuals? At best you can use it to suggest some guy is a sympathiser, when he might well not be.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- nailer 10y ago> I think Snowden mentioned his colleagues used to stalk their exes. It's a matter of public record that MI5 staff have been abusing their powers and had to be disciplined: http://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/mi5-misuse-of-surveillance-law-revealed-rhrdrh6rk http://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/mi5-misuse-of-surveillance...
- noir_lord 10y agoYep and if you think 50-200,000 civil servants/others are going to be any better behaved you'd have to be very optimistic!. That's before some idiot walks out the door with the entire database for an ISP and leaves it on a train.
- m0nty 10y ago> If you're not going to see what people did on a site, what's the point? Because you are not a unique and special snowflake. If you regularly go to /r/The_Donald, it says something specific about your politics (probably). Same for /r/LateStageCapitalism or /r/trees. It might not say much, but it adds up to a profile of who you are and what you think about. If you are emailing certain people, or tweeting them or whatever, GCHQ can build a social graph of people you know, who they know, etc. If you are the friend (or friend of a friend) of a person of interest, you're more likely to be of interest yourself. There are not many criminals like the una-bomber working entirely on their own - most of us need encouragement and/or provocation, and nowadays much of that happens online. If your search phrases include things like "how to make a bomb", you're probably going to be on a database somewhere. There have been numerous serious court cases (e.g. murder trials) where the prosecution have presented evidence that the accused's search history included phrases like "how to dispose of a body" or "how to poison someone". In other cases, jurors have been dismissed for using Google to research the background to the case they are serving on. I wonder where the information about these searches came from? Metadata is important for identifying "interesting" people. When you have found them, you "zoom in" and start hoovering up all the information you can find, not just the metadata. It's the greatest spying tool ever, and a way to implement highly repressive government too - just start monitoring people with different lifestyles or "way out" opinions. http://ghanadailies.com/2016/11/22/uk-government-plans-porn-user-database/ http://ghanadailies.com/2016/11/22/uk-government-plans-porn-... https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2016/nov/23/niche-porn-sites-sex-spanking-website-videos-pornography https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2016/nov/23/niche-...
- paulajohnson 10y agoThis illustrates how slippery the distinction between communications data and metadata really is. The examples in the first paragraph would all just record that you had been to www.reddit.com.
- petra 10y agoIt's quite to look at your history and determine that you visited /r/The_Donald often, with good likelihood, automatically.