4 ms·
US gained 230K jobs and 135K robots, other countries probably lost 1 million jobs to compensate. Automation goes full speed ahead, but what about sharing in the
by visarga 10y ago
US gained 230K jobs and 135K robots, other countries probably lost 1 million jobs to compensate. Automation goes full speed ahead, but what about sharing in the benefits?
- plafl 10y agoI don't know, but maybe it had a net positive impact on the world. Maybe not everything is about reducing labor costs, maybe it improved car quality or assembly speed. It would be great to know what is the most important incentive auto companies have for installing robots.
- croon 10y agoHypothetical: Let's say GP was right and 1M jobs disappeared. Robots are cheaper. Are cars going to get cheaper? My bet is on no. Where does that money go? Up. Who will buy the cars? Definitely not the 1M people losing those jobs. I'm not saying we should go backwards, but just producing more stuff cheaper with less labor without a goal in sight isn't a net positive impact on the world, and the economic inequality will only grow steeper. I'm saying this as a cushy white collar business owner that will likely be comfortably ahead of that curve. But we're still just lemmings scurrying to get ahead of everyone else, while a whole lot will be left behind. This is what decided this election, regardless of anyones politics (I certainly didn't agree with the choice).
- akytt 10y agoThat's not how capitalism works, you know. The prices will go down. Look at the car you get today and compare it to a car 10 years ago. Bang per buck has increased while brands like Dacia are coming in from below.
- visarga 10y agoDacia, my first car :-)
- kbart 10y agoCar industry is very competitive, so you can assume that decrease of the expenses will result in lower price. Maybe not directly price in currency, but better car for same money. Compare any new car to cars made even 10 years ago - they are better in pretty much any metrics. Heck, I remember times when air bags were counted as luxury and I'm not even that old. Take Tesla for example, such technologies and parameters were only available in luxury sport cars (Ferrari, Porsche etc).
- croon 10y agoSure, and my computer is a thousand times better than 25 years ago. It still costs LESS even disregarding inflation. That technology goes forward doesn't warrant price inflation. Like you said, your car hasn't gotten cheaper. So why would it going forward?
- witty_username 10y agoBecause of robotics.
- witty_username 10y agoIf money is going up (shareholders?) then one should invest in that car company. If it's going excessively to the managers, then the shareholders should change the management's compensation. It is a net positive (shareholders or management and consumers gain), but not necessarily Pareto efficient (some people lose). > Definitely not the 1M people losing those jobs. Why? They would get a lesser paying job, but I think they could still buy a cheap car.
- aaron695 10y agoYes I suspect this too. Look at a small part, in a small area and you see positive. A lot of things are moving back home because of automation, devastating some countries. Garment workers are about to be fucked. Robots are getting cheaper than cheap labour. So why not process it next door to the subsidized cotton. But even from a selfish point of view, things currently at home are also going to be devastated. One industries small renaissance at home is probably coupled with another's larger destruction.
- madengr 10y agoI'm wondering why garment production wasn't automated years ago.
- kasey_junk 10y agoLots of it is, but a big driver for why automating garment work being more costly than other kinds of automation is soft things, like cloth, are harder to deal with consistently than hard things like metal. It folds and distorts in shape in much less normal patterns, requiring more sophisticated algorithms.
- aaron695 10y agoIt's really hard http://www.economist.com/news/technology-quarterly/21651925-robotic-sewing-machine-could-throw-garment-workers-low-cost-countries-out http://www.economist.com/news/technology-quarterly/21651925-...
- Pica_soO 10y agoThere was a third worldwar when the replicator was invented. Gene Roddenbery warned us!
- visarga 10y agoActually I think we got a better chance of creating a self replicating factory than AGI. We have robots and materials, we just need to make the whole system 100% automated, and it's looking good with all the 3d printing and CNC innovations. Such a self replicating factory would be organized like a computer. It would have memory, which will be the storage space, and a data bus, which is the logistics system, and a CPU which is the collection of processing units (3d printers, cnc, ovens, presses, etc). We will program it with an API and define products like we define software, then the factory would compile it to production and actually produce it. When the factory is able to reproduce its own tools, it can create more of itself and jumpstart the process. You could also say it works like a cell or an organism - self reproducing, self healing, able to survive. We're self reproducing factories ourselves. It's the birth of a new life form, when robots don't need us to reproduce and repair themselves.
- spiderfarmer 10y agoSharing. In the current political climate of the US? Good luck with that.
- aeturnum 10y agoI think it's always worthwhile to look carefully at happenings that appear to cut against the grain of the conventional wisdom. It makes sense that the opportunity cost for these jobs is the loss of jobs overseas and that we should consider the morality of such a system. It's also likely that our understanding of the job / automation tradeoff is flawed and things like this can help us better understand how we misunderstand it. Alternatively, this could be an aberration and not generally applicable - but either way it's worth looking at the thing itself and not immediately pivoting to secondary concerns.