3 ms·
It should not be the rule, but when you call someone a pedophile and breed a feud of hate and misinformation under their nose don't expect your welcome to last
by raverbashing 10y ago
It should not be the rule, but when you call someone a pedophile and breed a feud of hate and misinformation under their nose don't expect your welcome to last
And no, Reddit is not a democracy, there's no free speech there. Still, it is much, much more tolerant than facebook. But a limit exists
- rfrank 10y agoI'm missing the point.
- wmeredith 10y agoI think the point being made is his actions are understandable in context.
- rfrank 10y agoAnd I think that is incorrect, and spez's actions are inexcusable.
- Mithaldu 10y agoAh, ok, so you're saying if i managed to convince a a few youtube personalities that you're a child trafficker and they talked to their audience and invited them to attack you over it, and the thousands hound you for a month over it on every possible venue you might frequent, including actually calling your home for the lulz, you'd be an emotionless rock and vulcan overlord with not so much a twitch as a reaction, despite things being actively and effectively disrupting for your personal and professional life for a month. Is that it?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 10y agoWhat part of "free speech" do you not understand? Is I think how the rest of this argument goes, ad infinitum.
- Mithaldu 10y agoMan, i can't tell which one of us you just brutally owned. Edit: Ok, i got it, and i salute you, good sir. :D
- samstave 10y ago/u/spez is free to say whatever he wants. He is not-excused of literally editing another persons' post. If I am in a room with you and you say something verbally, and I say a contrarian/different view - it does not edit YOUR statement just made. /u/spez editing others' comments is not "free speech" its the opposite.
- tptacek 10y agoI'm not going to respond to comments that aren't specific about what Huffman did. He didn't randomly edit comments. Be specific, and I'll respond. Or, you know, argue with someone else on HN. I'm of no particular importance here.
- rfrank 10y agoBy his own admission he's had user mentions turned off for years. Avoiding trolls isn't nearly as hard as people here are making it seem. If you don't want to deal with trolling, don't become the CEO of reddit immediately after their ridiculous community ousted Ellen Pao. The mainstream media and an awful lot of the internet (including the majority of users on this site) paint Trump supporters as racist, sexist, homophobic, uneducated, etc. on a daily basis, but calling spez a pedo is somehow beyond the pale? And that justifies him editing user posts to appear as if they've said something they haven't?
- Mithaldu 10y ago> Avoiding trolls isn't nearly as hard as people here are making it seem If you truly believe this then you're amazingly ignorant. I'd rather believe you're trolling on this matter than imagine someone this ignorant. Also, feel free to answer on this, but i don't believe i'll be arsed to respond to you further.
- rfrank 10y agoIf you truly believe internet randos are some unstoppable force of human nature, then you're amazingly ignorant, and probably cripplingly sensitive. That must suck, sorry about that.
- intopieces 10y ago>The mainstream media and an awful lot of the internet (including the majority of users on this site) paint Trump supporters as racist, sexist, homophobic, uneducated, etc. on a daily basis, but calling spez a pedo is somehow beyond the pale? Racism, sexism, homophobia and lack of education are not crimes, and never imply criminal activity that police actively investigate. Pedophilia is not a crime but implies a proclivity towards actions that are a crime and that police actively investigate. Yes, implying or directly accusing someone of harboring an innate proclivity for sexually abusing children does exceed in severity accusations of racial, gender, or anti-gay bias or lack of education. That people who proudly and on national media flaunt these attributes in themselves is evidence of such.
- yladiz 10y agoDefine the "limit".
- raverbashing 10y agoWhy should I? If somebody invites me to their house, is it ok to torch it? According to you it must be ok then, since it was not explicitly forbidden
- rfrank 10y agoComparing users talking on reddit to being invited into a home is pretty ridiculous on its face.
- siidooloo 10y agoAccusing people of being pedophiles is not just 'talking.' The trolls are intentionally trying to convine people that their political enemies are pedophiles to dicredit them.
- rfrank 10y agoIs accusing people of being racist, sexist, homophobic, uneducated, etc. not just 'talking'? Because an entire election cycle just completed where one side used those words to discredit their political enemies.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- syshum 10y agoThere should only be 3 options to moderation that are acceptable 1. Removal of Post outright 2. Editing of post WITH ATTRIBUTION or Acknowledgement of edit 3. Banning of user/thread/topic/etc with full and open disclosure This habit of Redit and other sites have of "hidden" moderation needs to end The Practice of silent moderation, silent editing of post, shadow bans, etc should not be acceptable to anyone that values free Speech And before you go off on your moronic tangent about Reddit not being a democracy. Yes Reddit can legally choose to censor anyone they want, or do anything they want really on their platform, that is not the topic of debate. The topic of debate is around do YOU a presumed reddit user want to continue to support such a site. Do you want to visit an ecochamber of heavily censored topics and discussion? Reddit became popular on the back of having very very very few limits on expression, the reason people flocked to it was because of open and uncensored discussion. If the site Admin's want to turn it into a Democrat echo chamber free of any alternative view points they are free to do so. I am also free to fucking call them censorious fuckwits if they do Some how I have a feeling you would not hold the same opinion spez did this to a community you approve of, or on topic you approve of //and for the record, and I should not have to say it but I feel I need to which is telling in itself, I did not vote for, nor do I support Donald Trump. I have been for more than 20 years a Libertarian, and voted for Gary Johnson in 2016
- raverbashing 10y agoI think Shadowban has an important role in spammers and (heavy) trolls. It should not be discarded Free speech has a limit, unfortunately, because large groups can't police themselves. And then the trolls take over (either on the internet or outside, see Antifa) > Do you want to visit an ecochamber of heavily censored topics and discussion? No, but if you go to the_donald that's what you get. Or do you really think they don't censor certain discussions? > Some how I have a feeling you would not hold the same opinion spez did this to a community you approve of, or on topic you approve of The topic or community is irrelevant, because it was directed to a troll. A message like "F U $ADM" has no place in any subreddit
- syshum 10y ago>>Free speech has a limit, unfortunately, Sorry no. The second you limit speech it is no longer free speech. This is a concept people have a hard time grasping. People that say reddit is not free expression are correct. It is limited expression. There used to be fewer limits, than today, and reddit seems to want to massively increase those limits even more. >because large groups can't police themselves Based on your subjective view on what they should and should not say they cant. >No, but if you go to the_donald that's what you get. Or do you really think they don't censor certain discussions? Dont know, never once visited, dont care what they do We are not talking about the Policies of a indivual subreddit. Most subreddits are not for Free Expression, most are topic based and heavily censoured to ensure the topic of discussion stays on topic. For example posting political threads on /r/sysadmin is not allowed, I have no problem with this as the rules are fully disclosed, open, and I know what I am getting into when I subscribed You see I have no problem with Moderation. I have extreme problems with SECRET moderation. >A message like "F U $ADM" has no place in any subreddit I would tend to agree, and would have no problem the SPEZ removing the posts. But redirecting F U $ADM to F U $MOD secretly is not the solution, it is childish and should not be viewed as acceptable.
- pbhjpbhj 10y agoAs it's being reported the user called spez didn't remove the posts or ban the users or any of the normal things. Instead they committed the same act, calling someone [else] a paedophile but added misattribtion (fraud, libel) and admin abuse to what had already been done. Hasn't Reddit claimed it is a place for public and free speech as reason for not shutting down some subreddits? Admins manually editing posts they see as offensive would seem to create a liability for the owners as they can't then argue they don't control/monitor content. If someone calls me a paedophile on Reddit (again! it's a not uncommon juvenile taunt) will I be allowed to edit their post, presumably not. I don't think anyone imagines Reddit is a democracy but the administration should nonetheless adhere to reasonable moral conventions such as flagging moderated posts and giving the same powers to censor personal abuse to all users.