11 ms·
> Others wonder if a significant population from The_Donald will migrate to Voat, a Reddit alternative. Oh let them please do that. Rats belong in the sewer A
by raverbashing 10y ago
> Others wonder if a significant population from The_Donald will migrate to Voat, a Reddit alternative.
Oh let them please do that. Rats belong in the sewer
And I have no qualms about what Spez has done. Internet trolls deserve it.
- rfrank 10y agoIs administrators editing users' posts as a norm of the internet something you would be comfortable with? Are spez's actions acceptable in a vacuum, or should they be a norm of internet moderation in your eyes?
- taurath 10y agoWhen did it become a norm?
- rfrank 10y agoThat has literally nothing to do with the question. Considering whether an action is acceptable only in an instance, or universally, is an extremely basic way of determining if it is morally correct. Do you think spez's actions can or should be made a norm?
- Pyxl101 10y agoKant called this the categorical imperative: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Categorical_imperative https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Categorical_imperative - a philosophical statement about morality: "Act only according to that maxim whereby you can, at the same time, will that it should become a universal law."
- rfrank 10y agoThank you. That's exactly what I was thinking of, it's just late haha.
- raverbashing 10y agoCorrect (in the philosophical sense) However hindsight is 20/20 and you can't make rules for everything Wanting to make everything an universal law is missing the trees for the forest. Because things change and situations change and what has worked before may not work anymore or have a detrimental effect. Violence might not be moral, but it works.
- rfrank 10y agoSo many words, so little to say.
- Mithaldu 10y agoFine and all, but what exactly is the law here?
- siidooloo 10y agoIs Falsely accusing people of being pedophiles for political gain an action that should be made a norm?
- rfrank 10y agoDo you actually think most people are questioning whether or not their witch hunt was the right thing to do? Jesus christ.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- raverbashing 10y agoIt should not be the rule, but when you call someone a pedophile and breed a feud of hate and misinformation under their nose don't expect your welcome to last And no, Reddit is not a democracy, there's no free speech there. Still, it is much, much more tolerant than facebook. But a limit exists
- rfrank 10y agoI'm missing the point.
- wmeredith 10y agoI think the point being made is his actions are understandable in context.
- rfrank 10y agoAnd I think that is incorrect, and spez's actions are inexcusable.
- Mithaldu 10y agoAh, ok, so you're saying if i managed to convince a a few youtube personalities that you're a child trafficker and they talked to their audience and invited them to attack you over it, and the thousands hound you for a month over it on every possible venue you might frequent, including actually calling your home for the lulz, you'd be an emotionless rock and vulcan overlord with not so much a twitch as a reaction, despite things being actively and effectively disrupting for your personal and professional life for a month. Is that it?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 10y agoWhat part of "free speech" do you not understand? Is I think how the rest of this argument goes, ad infinitum.
- basch 10y agofrom the trolls perspective, and only in that context, it should be funny though. he should be their hero now. they should give props for beating them at their own game. hugs all around. instead now is the time when everyone gets serious. it will be hard to separate the principled outrage from the faux manipulative outrage. a new poes law of sorts.
- samstave 10y agoExactly: Lets draw some parallels; * "No, judge, I was not speeding through that intersection" | JUDGE: "Well, hang on a second - my edit to your ticket states that you were... Takem 'em away boys!" WTF: im livid that anyone on HN would defend literally debasing the credibility of any system with a single freaking action of a CEO/Employee with such an obvious abuse of a root-level position.... I am so angry about this I can't even articulate it well...
- Fluid_Mechanics 10y agoPrecisely this. CEOs should have the right to remove vile content from their website. I don't see how this is such a revelatory or unprecedented move - doesn't this capacity to modify content exist on virtually all digital platforms?
- thinline 10y agoBig difference between removing posts and re-writing them. You don't see that?
- Fluid_Mechanics 10y agoThe only point of this controversy is to make the CEO's life miserable. The capacity to do this has always existed and the circumstances are incredibly trivial.
- leereeves 10y agoCovertly editing their posts is basically lying about what they said. We used to trust that when reddit said a user wrote X, they actually did write X (excluding hacking). This was a violation of that trust.
- leereeves 10y agoDownvotes, seriously? Because of the actions of their CEO, reddit was falsely telling everyone who viewed the relevant comments: > Fluid_Mechanics [score hidden] some time ago > Fuck /u/spez While knowing that Fluid_Mechanics had not written that. (Names have been changed to illustrate the point.) Lying, and a violation of trust, seem like appropriate terms.
- samstave 10y agoliterally, not basically
- samstave 10y ago#CEOLivesMatter???
- yladiz 10y agoWithout being in the loop of the pizzagate drama, it's really hard to see this as "okay" (the actions that Spez took). I can understand frustration and wanting to edit comments as payback to people that have wronged you, but this is a pretty dangerous action by an administrator. If he wanted to close the thread(s) or disallow posting on the_donald, sure, it's a visible action and I could understand that. I could even understand removing comments he finds offensive (even if it's not right, I can understand it and it's a visible action). But surreptitiously editing a comment is not okay, because while this is a relatively minor use of that power it's not unthinkable that other admins with that power might use it for less minor things.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Mithaldu 10y agoHere's the problem: thedonald is a subreddit full of both real trump supporters, AND trolls who're acting surreptitiously to rile up the real supporters and piss off everyone else; which is also spilling over and affecting other parts of reddit, including /all. The problem for the reddit admins is how to control and contain it and punish the trolls without affecting real people, or being overly censurous. So for someone who's basically being sniped at by hundreds of guerilla warriors who can make thousands of other people dance as their puppets, it's not surprising they'd reach for a similar tool in frustration when attacked directly, wrongly and frivolously.
- tdkl 10y agoThey shouldn't though, if they want to be credible and the site they own/market. Now this is lost.
- slowmotiony 10y agoWas reddit ever really credible?
- 10y ago
- wattt 10y agoI just clicked one of the Voat links in this thread and I had an _even worse_ mobile experience than Reddit. Hard to believe! All I saw was a white background and one character (or two!) per line on the left. What garbage.
- stefantalpalaru 10y ago> Internet trolls deserve it. Even those advocating violence over musical preferences like, say, the bashing of ravers?
- cryoshon 10y agoreally? no qualms about secretly editing user comments to say something different? have you ever heard of how slippery certain slopes can be?