9 ms·
I'm curious at which point did the science of "economics" changed from "let's see which laws govern the free commercial exchanges between private citizens" into
by paganel 10y ago
I'm curious at which point did the science of "economics" changed from "let's see which laws govern the free commercial exchanges between private citizens" into "let's see how we can govern people by imposing laws and regulations related to the commercial exchanges between them". I'm guessing this dates from Keynes's time.
- pjc50 10y agoEconomics started out being called "political economy", and regulation of commercial exchange goes back to the Romans. Regulation of coinage and weights and measures is a statutory feature of any society which has such things. There is no libertarian Avalon from which we have been expelled. (I like how they've quoted https://twitter.com/dsquareddigest https://twitter.com/dsquareddigest - he's an excellent person to follow for common-sense politics/economics with minor snark. And he's right that “‘it just isn’t done’ is basically the central organising constitutional principle of the UK.”)
- CalChris 10y agoThe word tax comes from the Latin taxo but taxes go back even further than the Romans. Egyptian Pharaohs had tax collectors. Probably further, it's just that we know more about the Egyptians because they kept records. In fact their tax collectors were called scribes. http://www.reshafim.org.il/ad/egypt/economy/taxation.htm http://www.reshafim.org.il/ad/egypt/economy/taxation.htm
- anigbrowl 10y agoThere is no libertarian Avalon from which we have been expelled. As an aside, I'm struck by how often theorists of both left and right unconsciously recapitulate the Garden of Eden narrative when attempting to articulate their basic premises. I'm starting to think there's a correlation between clinging to such unsupportable premises and hostility to the notion that humans are just particularly successful animals whose basic behavioral patterns are widely observable in the animal kingdom.
- ubernostrum 10y agoThis is why people should read Thomas Hobbes. His critique of "state of nature" thought experiments -- in which bright-eyed optimists somehow managed to convince themselves that people are naturally respectful of others and would only need to form extremely limited libertarian-style governments, and then only to deal with the tiny fraction of a fraction of people who wouldn't respect "natural" rights to life, property, etc. -- is devastatingly on point, showing exactly what such a "state of nature", if it ever existed, would look like and why a powerful centralized government would arise as the answer.
- pjc50 10y agoHobbes vs Locke vs Rousseau, if I remember rightly? Three very different views of this topic.
- icu 10y agoHaving lived in the UK for 8 years now. I would say this sentiment is better put as 'be sensible'. The knock on effect from being sensible is 'it just isn't done'.
- lhopki01 10y agoShouldn't that be the "science" of economics?
- Symmetry 10y agoIf we can call geology and linguistics sciences we can call economics a science too.
- notahacker 10y agoClimate science is the most obvious comparison. Both involve: - a few basic axioms, based on principles well understood at certain scales but not universally accepted to work in combination and on a bigger scale - a lot of very messy empirical data, such that you need to be well versed in statistical techniques to understand whether it supports a hypothesis or not - predictions that are on a small scale frequently wrong and little agreement on magnitudes, despite scientific consensus over the general direction of movement - a lot of debate over whether proposed regulatory or technocratic solutions will actually do more good than harm and relatively little evidence of the size of the benefit they might bring that isn't contingent on trusting said imperfect prediction models. And a fair bit of inertia about doing the regulating because the companies that proposed to be regulated have a pretty good idea about what they stand to lose. - a lot of arguments over whether it's all a big con, driven far more by politics than understanding of the subject matter
- laretluval 10y agoIt's the difference between science and engineering.
- carsongross 10y agoCalling economics either science or engineering is ridiculous. It has proven almost completely useless from a predictive standpoint.
- ktRolster 10y agoIt has proven almost completely useless from a predictive standpoint. That's not true at all, economics can predict many things. Here are some things that economics can accurately predict: mv = pq is very well tested. Economics can accurately predict that if you print too much money, you will get inflation. This has been verified over and over in many countries and at many times. The idea that increasing demand for a product (without modifying supply) will increase the price of that product is predictive and well supported. Price controls cause shortages: this happens over and over. When someone says, "economics is useless from a predictive standpoint" they are showing their ignorance.
- lucozade 10y ago> mv = pq is very well tested I presume you mean that m is usually positively correlated with p over some unspecified time horizon? A problem I often find with economic truisms is that they tend to carefully ignore the time component. Over a short enough time horizon this is clearly untrue. Over a long enough one it's pretty much tautological. Market theory has a similar property. > if you print too much money, you will get inflation Again, usually. Hasn't really been happening over the last few years in the US and Europe. Presumably we just wait for some arbitrary long period until inflation starts to rise again? Does the theory tell us how long? So it's not that economics can't make predictions. It's just that they're often not useful predictions. It is quite good at postdictions, of course. The utility of which is at least a tad suspect.
- 10y ago
- noir-york 10y agoEarly economics was really political economics and most early economist where political thinkers and philosophers. A couple of points: 1. negative externalities make necessary laws and regulations if you want an efficient market. 2. Keynesian economics (presumably what you referring to) has nothing to do with restricting free trade, but deals with the boom-bust cycle and how a government can manage it.
- paganel 10y ago> 2. Keynesian economics (presumably what you referring to) has nothing to do with restricting free trade, but deals with the boom-bust cycle and how a government can manage it. Yeah, I'm now reading Benjamin Constant (I've read guys like Jean-Baptiste Say and Jeremy Bentham before) and there was is close to no mention in their works about the government having the intrinsic need to "manage" anything. Which brings me to my second question: who has empowered the Government to actively manage economic cycles? And assuming it has acquired these powers all by itself, based on which premises/presumptions does it accomplish its economics-related actions? It's funny reading Constant and how he warns about the perils of moral hazard associated to the active involvement of Government in the economy. 200 years have passed and we still make the same mistakes.
- matt4077 10y ago> who has empowered the Government to actively manage economic cycles? Voters > based on which premises/presumptions does it accomplish its economics-related actions? Find causal relationships -> create causes for effects that you would like to see > the perils of moral hazard associated to the active involvement of Government Maybe the 18th century governments overstepped their boundaries when, dunno, they stopped slave labor of 8-year olds in coal mines. Today, the term applies almost exclusively to private industry. Mostly financial.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- aminorex 10y ago
- burkaman 10y agoThat's just the difference between observation and application, the same as any other science. Math vs. applied math, chemistry vs. chemical engineering, physics vs. applied physics, etc.
- MichaelBurge 10y agoWith the passage of the 16th amendment in 1913, establishment of the Federal Reserve in 1913, expansion of the interstate commerce clause in Wickard vs. Filburn in 1942, and Roosevelt's Social Security and other New Deal programs in the 1930s. After these, a lot of power shifted from the people to the federal government. And then the government needed economists to tell them how to use this new power. And because there are dozens of federal agencies employing economists, they're never going to say "We shouldn't be here at all" but rather "Let's hold back a little bit on using our power here". They're going to adjust their message so that politicians are more likely to appoint them to positions of power. Academia isn't any better: They crucially depend on government money, and the effort is always on more government influence(and money) even if a few professors write theoretical books saying otherwise. In finance, I believe economics is still useful since you can make measurable predictions, and execute trades and deals off of them. But, economists at finance companies aren't nearly as noticeable as economists in the government and academia. If you completely cut those items in the first paragraph, it would become nothing more than a moderately useful branch of philosophy.
- matt4077 10y ago> After these, a lot of power shifted from the people to the federal government. That's the fault in this line of reasoning: the people never had the economic powers of a government. Government derives its power from being the solution to a collective action problem. Or, in other words, the people gained power by pooling their decision making process.
- pmyteh 10y agoTo be fair, government is one possible solution to a collective action problem. There are other possible solutions involving various kinds of voluntary cooperation. It just turns out that some collective action problems (such as the existence of child labour, for example) are much easier to solve by a body with coercive power than one without. But you're quite right that the notion that 'the people' once had such power before being oppressed by the creation of collective government is an ahistorical idea, normally deriving from dubious state-of-nature theories.
- panglott 10y agoCapitalist and market economies rely on political systems that can deliver private property rights, independent courts, and inclusive economic and political institutions. Economics and politics are simply conjoined topics.
- RockyMcNuts 10y ago'free commercial exchanges' have co-evolved with very complex cultural, legal, technological systems. if you had to explain to an alien what happens when you go to a store and exchange a piece of paper for a candy bar and get some paper and metal back, you'd be there for a long time and have to explain much of human history and civilization. 'which laws govern' i.e. are naturally imposed and who is 'imposing [somehow unnatural] laws and regulations', seems to be largely in the eye of the beholder. the idea any of this happens in a state of nature seems naive.
- kazagistar 10y agoAgreed. Property itself is not natural but imposed by force via governance. The entire system of finance has always existed by coercion of non-participants.
- solipsism 10y agoThis is nonsense. Many non-human animals are territorial. Is that nest a community nest, or does it belong to a specific group of birds until they're done with it? Similarly, some non-human animals have organized systems that maintain cultural norms (like punishing individuals who steal). I don't understand this libertarian appeal to nature. Surely we can do better than the drunken walk of evolution that has led to present day "nature".
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 10y ago> Many non-human animals are territorial. Is that nest a community nest, or does it belong to a specific group of birds until they're done with it? Territory is very different from property. Territory is something you defend. Property is something society agrees to defend for you.
- anigbrowl 10y ago
- beefield 10y agoWell, theories of market failures belong to the rare species of economic theories that actually are falsifiable and thus scientific in popperian sense, so one could argue that answer to your question is, at that point when someone thought that it actually is good to add a piece of science into economics.
- pmyteh 10y agoFrom the very early days of the discipline (basically the eighteenth century, when it was called 'political economy') economics has had a strong normative slant. It's always been about what should be done, as well as about describing what currently exists. This is normal, because the foundations of a given society are intensely political and have a huge impact on the nature of economic activities that exist (whether independent courts will enforce loan contracts, for example, is a political decision with major consequences for capital flows). Recently, the public face of economics has been largely microeconomic modelling, which looks (from a distance) like an apolitical applied science. But the economic historians and the political economy people have always been part of the discipline as well, whether they be Marx or Milton Friedman.
- xapata 10y agoThe transition began once we started to understand that commerce is not a natural phenomenon, but something enabled by social organization. Whatever social policies (laws/norms) exist will affect how commerce proceeds. Studying economic dynamics under only one set of policies would be only a tiny portion of the field.
- anigbrowl 10y agoWhy do you think social organization is unnatural? There are (iirc) 17 eusocial species, most of which are insects but two or three of which are mammals, depending on how you define eusociality.
- xapata 10y agoNot social organization but free commerce -- a particular social organization. And "natural" in the sense of natural rights -- ethically correct and a stable equilibrium. Free commerce might be ethically correct, but that's certainly not obvious to everyone and it does not appear to be a stable equilibrium for social organization.
- anigbrowl 10y agoOh I see what you mean now. Thanks.
- vkou 10y agoPrior to Keynes' time, there was no such thing as 'free commercial exchanges between private citizens' either. Consider serfdom, slavery, guild systems, the Enclosure Act, private armies, strikebreakers, debter's prisons, workhouses, unequal pay for equal work, press-ganging... You can look all across history, and hardly find an example of free commercial exchanges at work.
- ThrustVectoring 10y agoEven today it's not "free". Try selling methamphetamine, or buying advance information from insiders on Alphabet's next quarterly earning report. What we have are markets that are designed to be safe, fast, easy, clear, and beneficial to society.
- vkou 10y agoWe're doing OK on the first three, but depending on the market, 'clear' and 'beneficial to society' are highly contentious. My point is that most of history's economic miracles were built either on the backs of theft, coerced labour, or government largess. There was no golden age when businessmen could be businessmen, and enterprise was free.
- ThrustVectoring 10y agoThe 'clear' markets are generally better functioning than ones that are more opaque, and there's been deliberate effort to making them more obvious. Think grain categorization and grading.
- ubernostrum 10y agoOne of my favorites: English labor law, prior to the 20th century, was still rooted in master/serf traditions. If an employer violated the terms of an employment contract, it was a civil matter and the employee had to fund the resulting lawsuit out of his own pocket (i.e., employee could not ever successfully fight a violation by the employer). But if the employee violated the contract, it was a criminal matter prosecuted free of charge by the state.
- anigbrowl 10y agoThat suggests to me that you've read very little economics outside of magazines. Adam Smith talks at lengths about the goals and responsibilities of national governments in the seminal economic text The Wealth of Nations - which is notable for not being called The Wealth of Private Individuals. As with the Bible, many people like to quote bits from it that seem to support their instant argument; very few have bothered to actually read the whole thing.
- adrianratnapala 10y agoAs others have pointed out, economics always was "political economy". Largely because it is about the whole of society, so it's actionable results tend to be in the realm of public policy. BUT: it seems there was a change around about the time of Keynes. Until then, economists talked mostly the general kind of systems that would produce prosperity. Even Marx talked like that -- he might have believed in rational planning, but he wrote about how the capitalist system as whole (mis)functioned, and how the proletariat would "inevitably" seize control. He did not detail already existing "levers" that be used by governors to steer the economy.
- rubberstamp 10y agoEconomies can be modeled to fit any way so that it is in balance with fundamental rules in play within of a sovereign country/region. First thing that needs to be modeled correctly is the government. Whats is it? Is it going to be authoritative or democratic. Now if it is authoritative, it servers a minority in power. If its democratic, shouldn't it be optimized for welfare of its citizens? Once that is defined, it becomes easy to model economy right. The right thing that should've been done is to let go of attitude "too big to fail" and let the market correct itself. Contracts were made between banks and investment banks. Those were valid contracts. Those who found themselves at the short end of the stick knew what they were getting into. It was the expert bankers who created those contracts. They didn't held their end of the deal. They basically caused a mess and got away scott free.