3 ms·
The part I don't get is: why use batteries for large infrastructural power storage? Why not flywheels? edit: looks like Oʻahu is getting flywheels: http://ambe
by masklinn 10y ago
The part I don't get is: why use batteries for large infrastructural power storage? Why not flywheels?
edit: looks like Oʻahu is getting flywheels: http://amberkinetics.com/amber-kinetics-and-hawaiian-electric-sign-agreement-for-flywheel-energy-storage-pilot-project/ http://amberkinetics.com/amber-kinetics-and-hawaiian-electri...
It's too bad Tesla seems all-in on batteries even for large-scale storage projects.
- sonium 10y agoI think this is because Tesla/SolarCity/SpaceX has this philosophy of versatility of components. They want to have one and only one energy storage technology and produce it at scale. This also one reason for the Tesla/SolarCity merger: you can use the same building block and scale it up. SpaceX is doing the same: use one rocket motor on booster and upper stage, and mass produce it. In contrast Ariane uses three different motors on one rocket.
- michaelbuckbee 10y agoThis is one of those really important business decisions that feels almost trivial but with profound positive results. It immediately reminded me of Southwest Air and how they credit some of their early success to _only_ flying 737s. Letting them standardize their maintenance and getting very good at keeping that one model of airplane flying.
- giarc 10y agoThis is currently happening with Canadian airline WestJet. For many years they only flew a single aircraft which made maintenance much easier (staff trained on a single aircraft, parts are easier to keep in stock). They since purchased a few larger aircraft to fly to London and Dublin and have been plagued with maintenance issues. Passengers are getting stuck in London while WestJet scrambles to fly in a mechanic and parts to fix the planes.
- jdietrich 10y agoThe computer industry is perhaps the most extreme example of this. From a dizzying array of different systems in the infancy of computing, the overwhelming majority of the market has consolidated to two instruction set architectures and a handful of operating systems. Magic things happen when your economies of scale are big enough.
- antisthenes 10y agoWhile your argument makes sense for Tesla/SolarCity specific case, there's no reason that the same efficiencies of scale could not be applied to flywheels overall for energy storage. The additional benefits of batteries over flywheels however is that utility-scale energy storage can be achieved with a wide range of battery quality. What I mean by that is that say, for example, a batch of batteries doesn't pass QC to make it into the Tesla cars by virtue of having only 85% of their desired capacity. They can still be used in energy storage facilities. Same goes for used battery packs from Teslas that have degraded to 70-80% of their original capacity over the years. I surmise it's quite more efficient to use these packs for grid storage than to recycle them right away. Space is probably not a huge constraint for them, so it's not a big deal to use packs that operate in the lower capacity ranges. Think of it as a big energy storage cloud like Backblaze's storage pods. They mix and match consumer grade hardware, but because of scale and redundancy, they can get away with it and still provide reliable storage. Same goes for energy. I'm not quite sure what the scales are for flywheel manufacturers compared to Tesla's gigafactory, but they're probably at least an order of magnitude smaller, plus flywheels generally can't be used as the main source of power in cars or portable electronics, while Li Ion cells can.
- leephillips 10y agoThis is exactly the approach planned by BMW: to use batteries that are no longer in good enough shape for cars in a home storage system: http://fortune.com/2016/06/22/bmw-energy-storage/ http://fortune.com/2016/06/22/bmw-energy-storage/
- russdill 10y agoI'm sure there are tradeoffs for both. Seems like flywheels would need some significant maintenance when compared to battery banks. The advantage here is that different Islands are trying different technologies. This will allow a long term analysis of those tradeoffs and costs.
- hannob 10y agoFlywheels have very different properties from battery storage. Most notably flywheels loose a lot of power over time and are mostly good for short term storage. So it depends a lot on the situation which technology makes more sense. In the case of that Island I assume what they need is that over longer timeframes they have enough sun and can store the oversupply of electricity for a relatively long time, because the occassions when there isn't enough sun are rare.
- masklinn 10y ago> Most notably flywheels loose a lot of power Flywheels with air-bound rotors on mechanical bearings do, flywheels with vacuum-bound rotors on magnetic bearings don't as most of the losses are frictional.
- ZeroGravitas 10y agoTesla seem to be making a bet on manufacturing scale reducing the price of batteries from where it is now. This applies to cars and storage, and obviously using it for both further amplifies the price reduction.
- 0xcde4c3db 10y agoIIRC, safety measures for high-energy flywheels end up being pretty expensive. Basically, if the wheel or bearing fails, something is going to get seriously fucked up, and an appropriate sacrificial structure is a task in itself. I was once told of a physics lab that, rather than attempting a containment structure, was located next to miles of forest in case its flywheels, er, escaped.
- Retric 10y agoKeeping them underground seems like the simplest solution when starting from scratch. Adding flywheels to an existing structure is a much tougher problem.
- greglindahl 10y agoIn datacenters, the purpose of a flywheel is to bridge from the start of a power outage to generator power being available. In that scenario, you don't need batteries. If you have batteries, they can come online as fast as a flywheel. This article talks about the issues a bit: http://www.zdnet.com/article/does-flywheel-have-a-future-in-the-datacenter/ http://www.zdnet.com/article/does-flywheel-have-a-future-in-...
- Dylan16807 10y agoA bit of searching suggests that flywheels cost at least 4x as much per kWh. Even if batteries don't improve over time, it's cheaper to set up a battery system and replace it three times as often.