5 ms·
If your password is compromised, it will only work until the next reset. That's better than having one that works for years.
by sp332 10y ago
If your password is compromised, it will only work until the next reset. That's better than having one that works for years.
- nitrogen 10y agoIf your password is compromised, you've already lost. Since password rotation policies incentivize weak passwords, they are more likely to result in a compromised password. Thus, password rotation with weak passwords is not better than a single strong password that is never rotated.
- phire 10y agoNow that I think about it "Don't worry about detecting attackers, they will get kicked out when we next rotate passwords" is not an attitude you want anyone to develop.
- nitrogen 10y agoPlus, chances are pretty good that if they compromised one password undetected, they can compromise the next one in the same way (spear phishing, malware, etc.).
- rconti 10y agoThat's true, but I'm having hard time thinking of a use case where a sustained, hidden compromise is 'worse' than a one-time compromise. I mean, I guess they could login to your bank every week and transfer out $50 instead of just transferring out all your money on day 1, but... ?
- mschuster91 10y agoI have previously worked in the gambling industry. The worst nightmare of any gambling device manufacturer is a group of people that discover a bug and exploit it on small scale - no one will bat an eye and investigate if a machine pays out 50 bucks more or less. However, in most cases people are dumb, greedy or the combination of both - e.g. in February 2014, a concerted mass hack occurred across Germany and over 10M € were reported as losses (http://www.spiegel.de/spiegel/print/d-126511954.html http://www.spiegel.de/spiegel/print/d-126511954.html), and most other bugs surface fairly quickly because people exploit them until the machines run dry and the owner/manufacturer inspects them. So, in the case of gambling machines/casinos, a small-scale hidden compromise is far worse than a "big blow" - thankfully for the industry, greed usually prevails over common sense.
- bsilvereagle 10y agoThere are quite a few scenarios where a sustained, hidden compromise is an (or several) order of magnitude worse than a one time obvious compromise. The first to come to mind is a corporate espionage scenario. Do you want to know what your competitor is up to today, or do you want access to their briefings/CAD/code for the next 12 months? Long duration compromises also allow you to slip data out slowly, so a NAS doesn't show 200GB being transferred off in a matter of hours, but a slow drip of 100MB a day. At a personal/home use level, long term access to a bank account allows an attacker to build up a spending profile, which depending on your habits, could be used for blackmail.
- Spooky23 10y agoThe reality is that passwords are being deprecated as strong security boundaries. We've been working under this fantasy that it's acceptable to make a "strong" password and have a meaningful expectation that you can maintain the security and integrity of access. Multi factor authentication is the best solution to this problem -- a moderately complex password with MFA is stinger than a password. If you want to compromise somebody long-term, you move laterally within the targets network and infect multiple devices.
- dpark 10y agoPassword rotation doesn't fix that because the difference between myLongPassWordThatDoesntChange and myLongPassWordThatRotates7 is effectively meaningless. An adversary who has your current password can almost certainly guess your next one because changing the 7 to an 8 is a pretty obvious step, and it's one that most people do when forced to rotate. Forcing password rotation guarantees that most people will just use the shortest possible password and stick some rotating suffix on it because your policy is pointless and annoying. You make yourself the adversary when you enforce policies like this and people stop trying to be secure and just try to get on with life.
- bleachedsleet 10y agoAnecdotal and only related to your last paragraph, but as a security researcher I can say that 99% of the time attacks on a personal bank account are never "long term." Most of time, regardless of skill, hackers get in, cash out and disappear. It's far more lucrative (and generally safer) to empty the account than try to blackmail someone based on spending habits.
- freehunter 10y agoUnless you can only change on a pre-defined interval, the attacker can always change your password for you to avoid being locked out. I don't know many users who would complain their their password seemingly never expired.
- mark-r 10y agoThese are often combined with a requirement to not reuse some number of recent passwords, so the attacker can't change the password right back again. When you can't log in then your password will be reset and they've lost access.
- freehunter 10y agoThat's true, I hadn't thought of that. Holiday week has my brain off in the clouds.