10 ms·
This Pizzeria Is Not a Child-Trafficking Site
- wyldfire 10y agoSmells like 4chan manufactured not just the claims but perhaps even the outrage. But they got what they wanted: NYT coverage. YHBT. HAND. Times: please don't feed the trolls.
- argonaut 10y agoNo. There are actual voters that believe(d) this [1]. It's trolling but it needs to be addressed. [1] https://twitter.com/ch402/status/796409197411713024 https://twitter.com/ch402/status/796409197411713024
- eoirs 10y agoIf you think fake news is what made trump the PEOTUS the you are a fool.
- hansen 10y agoYeah, this thing is semi-big on reddit, and to me it looks like a lot of nuts actually believe this. But the question remains, was this thing initialized by some /pol/ übertrolls, or was it only conspiracy nuts from the beginning?
- Tsugumo 10y agoStarted with people finding what they thought were pedo keywords in the Podesta emails. More searching led to circumstantial evidence. Besta Pizza is the one they think is most guilty. Besta Pizza logo looked a lot like a secret symbol used by pedos, until they recently changed it. Not sure how Comet fits in. Maybe Podesta ordered from them for the many 'pizza parties' referenced in his emails, with lines like 'i don't like hair on my pizza.' Combination of strange references to 'pizza' in the emails, the logos, the utter distrust of establishment politicians (especially those connected to Hillary), fuelled by ongoing theories about so-called elites' child trafficking rings (Epstein).
- hansen 10y ago> what they thought What makes so sure about this? These claims are so nonsensical that it could be “what they wanted the reddit conspiracy hive-mind to believe”.
- gnarbarian 10y agoYep you're 100% on the money. I've been watching this unfold since it started with anons croudsourcing the podesta email dumps looking for crimes.
- MollyR 10y agoThe new york times has no credibility with a large portion of liberals and conservatives after the last election. I don't think them addressing anything right now is a good idea. Half of my liberal friends dont trust the mainstream media at all anymore, and ALL of my conservative friends are taking the new york times articles as PROOF something is afoot.
- argonaut 10y ago* no credibility with a large portion of liberals and conservatives after the last election Citation needed that people think the NYTimes is lying (as opposed to selectively reporting). I don't dispute some conservatives believe the NYTimes is lying.
- krige 10y agoIf it were wholly manufactured, then the timing of strikes against wikileaks and other CP uncovering agents was way too convenient for the trolls. I don't think that's the case.
- akhilcacharya 10y agoGood god you can't be serious.
- justsumbody 10y agoDid you learn nothing from Nov 8? These people are not just not joking, they are literally this uninformed and stupid that they would elect a man guaranteed to pass legislation that hurts them financially, all because he's a baggard, racist and serial sexual harasser. Why are people acting surprised by it anymore? Why are people acting surprised by Trump installing a white nationalist as his chief of staff? None of this is surprising, funny, or shocking to those who've been paying any amount of attention in the run-up to the election. Stop laughing. Stop acting incredulous. Start pushing back against neo-Nazis and those who wish to re-subjugate LGBT people. (Or shock their genitals to turn them straight).
- makomk 10y agoAt this point, I'd frankly be satisfied if the NYT stopped feeding the literal white supremacist neo-Nazis, but that doesn't seem likely to happen. (Seriously, they recently gave someone that even Breitbart doesn't seem willing to give the time of day to a huge platform to expound his views, political goals, and his importance - all of which would otherwise be irrelevant, because he had almost no audience or power.)
- hyperion2010 10y agoWhen I want to know which way the wind is blowing I take a trip down to 4chan. Not because they know anything about the outside world, but because there are many who frequent the site who have an almost intuitive understanding of how to manipulate the presentation of information on the internet for maximum effect. Why? No idea, but maybe it has something to do with the fact that the only way to keep your thread for vanishing into the realm of the overlooked and 404ed is to post just the right combination of words and pictures to draw the attention of hundreds of different brains. Adverse selection at its finest.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tnones 10y agoIt's also a great place for motivated actors to pour gasoline on some minor embers and turn them into a wildfire, allowing an irrelevant minority to seem like a representative majority.
- samstave 10y ago>When I want to know which way the wind is blowing I take a trip down to 4chan. Meta: I love this sentence. Is there a term/understanding of how digital culture navigates all the shit we think and talk about online? We know that reddit has a "reply archetype culture" that is unique to reddit, HN has its own, other sites have theirs - but between HN and Reddit - they basically have the best pulse on the understanding of how people reply to whatever info they are sharing/receiving... If we climb a bit higher, who is the thought-leader in understanding the modes of and presentations of how humans communicate/participate/comment in a world where we have such extensive access to information and can comment/teach/interact/criticize/etc a VAST array of topics with SMEs in most areas and garner the research of tons of people on a single topic with just a few moments online? Truly the information age - but do we have an agreed upon lexicon of how to describe such matters?
- samstave 10y agoI came up with a phrase: "The internet litmus"
- purephase 10y agoIt's not racism. Check. It's not misogyny. Check. It's not bigotry. Check. We get it. There are disenfranchised folks in the US that feel under-represented and even targeted/blamed etc. But this, this nonsense, is beyond the pale. You got your president elect. Worst case, thousands will pay the price in rights, access to services or the ability to live in a democratic society, free from the challenges (life threatening or otherwise) that they sought splice from. It's a small business. Parents, customers with children, sullied by this insane, malicious group of alt right sociopaths who make up The_Donald and other locations. To justify or support this shit obliterates any legitimate credibility, however remote, they may have had.
- loeg 10y agoI think it's safe to say these kinds of trolls do not represent, in any way, the majority of republican voters.
- CalChris 10y agoWhy? 71% of Republicans doubted Obama's birthplace. https://www.google.com/amp/www.nbcnews.com/politics/2016-election/amp/poll-persistent-partisan-divide-over-birther-question-n627446 https://www.google.com/amp/www.nbcnews.com/politics/2016-ele...
- krige 10y agoThe sample size of this poll is inadequate, and it's online w/preselected sample.
- Frondo 10y agoThen we can look to the republican voters to denounce their actions. That is, after all, the standard that we hold Muslims to. As well as the standard we hold progressives to when anarchists try to turn peaceful protests into riots. The party of personal responsibility is often quick to hold groups accountable for the actions of individuals.
- quilted 10y agoFunny how the article doesn't address any of the actual content from the Podesta emails that led people to this conclusion.
- swivelmaster 10y agoI think it's pretty clear from the article that there wasn't really any relevant content in the emails besides that Podesta was in contact with the restaurant once about organizing a fundraiser. And it goes without saying, but I'll say it anyway, there wasn't anything in Wikileaks that in any way even so much as implied that there was actually a child trafficking ring run by the Democratic party. I really hope you weren't trying to insinuate that the Wikileaks emails actually said that. The fact that there even needs to be a discussion about that indicates the sad, sad state of journalism and media in America. edit: Also, I'll note that the above commenter's account was created literally three minutes ago, likely to post the comment above. Insinuating that the Democratic Party is involved in a massive conspiracy to traffic children is NOT the type of thing that flies here on HN, so if you came here expecting to get into those kinds of discussions and spread that kind of misinformation, you're going to have a bad time.
- vinayan3 10y agoDo you know where the specific detail of child trafficking was manufactured? The NYT article doesn't say it. Also, did the people who made this up think it was a joke? I really don't see how else a hair brain idea like this could be made.
- Rebelgecko 10y agoI believe it came from an email ordering cheese pizza. Cheese pizza and child pornography both abbreviate to CP, so obviously Hillary Clinton and her staff are all ordering children to abuse. Out of morbid curiosity I looked at some of the other 'evidence', and it goes downhill from there (to the level of "so and so went to Portugal on vacation, and while he was in the country a young girl went missing"). The people involved at this point are either trolls or delusional. Probably a mix of both.
- danso 10y agoNot that I frequently jump to Yelp when something hits big on the news, but this is the first time I've seen this "Active Cleanup Alert", currently in effect for the pizzeria: https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Cx1p9w_UsAAaB0L.jpg https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Cx1p9w_UsAAaB0L.jpg https://www.yelp.com/biz/comet-ping-pong-washington https://www.yelp.com/biz/comet-ping-pong-washington I was just going to say, "Seems like this is new since that one dentist killed the famous lion", but I guess these alerts started at around that time: http://www.thesempost.com/yelp-adds-new-active-cleanup-alerts-for-local-businesses-in-the-news/ http://www.thesempost.com/yelp-adds-new-active-cleanup-alert... Meanwhile, Google seems to be putting in little effort to block the brigading of its place reviews: http://i.imgur.com/e6uCqan.png http://i.imgur.com/e6uCqan.png
- jknoepfler 10y agoI can't be alone in thinking that every individual who participated in or retweeted or whatever that information ought to be personally financially and criminally liable for their actions. If not every person, then pick the nodes in the graph that have the highest fanout. If you knowingly post and spread damaging fake information (deliberately engineered to accuse people of child molestation) on the internet, you have committed a crime, and you should be subject to both civil and criminal action. You are responsible for the things you write online. This is no different from "yelling 'FIRE!' in a crowded theatre."
- chrischen 10y agoI think technically you have comitted a crime, 94 at least a sue-able offense. It's just really expensive to enforce.
- Gargoyle 10y ago>If you knowingly post and spread damaging fake information (deliberately engineered to accuse people of child molestation) on the internet[...] What you're missing here is that they genuinely believe it to be true. As incredible as that may seem to you and me, that is the reality of it. I've actually been lurking in r/pizzagate since the start, watching in horror and fascination as people convince themselves of the most outrageous things. But they're convincing themselves, and they do actually believe.
- mckoss 10y agoLibel does not require that the writer knows what he is saying is false (though doing so will increase the amount of damages you can collect). You can successfully sue for libel by only showing that the statements made against you were false, and that you were damaged by them.
- pcardh0 10y agoFirst a pizza place in the Rust Belt won't cater to a hypothetical gay wedding and now this. I guess that Pizza is the new front-line in the culture wars. Pretty sad in my opinion. That said, if there is a war, I hope Domino's and Pizza Hut don't make it. They are the true villains of Big Pizza.
- jjellyy 10y agoI like how they hand-wave away the entire thing by saying "its been debunked" with no analysis or article link. Also why is NYTimes at liberty to decide whats real and fake news ? Agree or disagree, their political analysis leans heavily left.
- res0nat0r 10y agoIt isn't on the NYT to disprove the owners aren't child molesters, it's the crazies posting conspiracy theories which are still just that. This type of thinking above I think is a major problem these days. Just because someone says something crazy on the internet doesn't mean that the person being accused is automatically guilty until they take the time out of their life to disprove said thing, it's the exact opposite.
- 464192002d7fe1c 10y agoIts not so much that I think its true (I don't) its just that I wouldn't, exactly, at this point be surprised if it was. In any event, most of the stuff I read is less "omg guys this is totally 100% correct" and more "this is a seriously strange and disturbing set of coincidences" mixed with a lot of memeing circlejerk. And after things like http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/news/corey-feldman-elijah-wood-hollywood-897403 http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/news/corey-feldman-elijah-w... and things like Jeffrey Epstein and the whole Jimmy Savile thing, I'm just not sure anymore of ANYTHING. Honestly, the fact that the NY times feels the need to publish an article debunking it is a (very very tiny) shove towards it being true.
- res0nat0r 10y agoIt really is just natural followup from the election and Trump winning. I've seen it firsthand constantly the last few months on my FB feed. When ~50% of the electorate gets their news from Facebook only and it is 99% nonsense conspiracy theories not rooted in reality, the NYT and others have had a reality check that they should start calling out this nonsensical crap since so many people are gullible and actually are swayed by it.
- 10y ago
- cperciva 10y agoI know where I'll be eating dinner if I ever visit Washington DC. If enough people make a practice of standing up for victims like these, we might see less use of weaponized slander.
- m0nastic 10y agoThis is a wonderful sentiment, but as someone who lives next door to this place, you absolutely don't want to eat there. If you come to DC, by all means buy some food from there, but then throw it in the garbage and I'll happily treat you to a much better dinner.
- DigForTheKids 10y agoLook at the archive of this man's instagram. Judge for yourself. Don't just take the NYTimes' opinion as sacred. This is a massive scandal that is breaking as we speak.
- techsupporter 10y ago> Look at the archive of this man's instagram. Judge for yourself. Done and done. Saw a bunch of happy customers posting pictures of their kids having a blast at a family restaurant...all captioned with misleading and, occasionally, vile captions.
- Melchizedek 10y agoNot saying you are right, but I found a summary of what this is about that gives some understanding of why a lot of people seem to believe in this stuff: https://www.reddit.com/r/pizzagate/comments/5da0kp/comet_ping_pong_pizzagate_summary/ https://www.reddit.com/r/pizzagate/comments/5da0kp/comet_pin...
- meric 10y agoAfter completely failing at predicting Trump's election victory and completely misjudging the views of the populace, the mainstream media is now taking advantage of this situation using the tag 'fake news' to label competition to restore its credibility. A Pizza Shop on a crusade against 'fake news', new term for this month, who knew?
- sooheon 10y agoYou can deride the NYT, but none of what you said makes this pizzeria owner's plight any less real. It is a very real problem that the populace can be manipulated to the point of irrational misdirected hate like this.
- thirdsun 10y ago> It is a very real problem that the populace can be manipulated to the point of irrational misdirected hate like this. It's things like these that sometimes make me question the democratic system. These people aren't fit to vote.
- dennisnedry 10y agoWho are you to determine who is fit to vote or not vote? The point of democracy is that EVERY citizen has a say in their government, despite how insane their belief system may be.
- sofal 10y agoThe point of democracy is that EVERY citizen has a say in their government, despite how insane their belief system may be. Presumably this is why the poster you responded to is questioning the democratic system, so you haven't really presented a counterargument here.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dluan 10y agoI was just thinking about the recent Black Mirror episode about how easy it is for a hivemind of righteous (or totally false wacko) anger to appear and make victims. The way twitter/4chan/facebook work is that it's basically a streaming tube of recency, where content gets pushed through it and everyone is forced to look at the top of the heap, ie the newest memes. If you actually had a graph the size of your network, and the font size of the comments/content your friends' post actually reflect their voice in context of the whole network (e.g. smaller), maybe you'd see it less as a spotlight and more as background noise.
- sneezeplease 10y agoHas anyone here even looked at the case presented against CPP? Incredible to think that there is no one here against this pizzeria and the CP ring it supports. Cognitive dissonance and ignorance at its best.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- nbb 10y agoSounds like something a child molester would say.
- 464192002d7fe1c 10y agowtf how?
- lifeisstillgood 10y agoWhile I understand this is likely an ironic joke, even in the context of this thread this is not an acceptable accusation to make. I am sure you did it mean it to be taken at face value. I urge you to edit the post and / or delete ?
- sctb 10y agoIt should be obvious that this comment doesn't reach the bar of civility that we ask for on this site. This account has been posting mostly unsubstantive comments, so please stop or we have to ban it. We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13011995 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13011995 and marked it off-topic.
- pizzathrowaway 10y agoThis reminds me a lot of #SpiritCooking, which had a big effect on the election. For a traditional-valued person who thinks that participating in #SpiritCooking performance art is immoral, it's not much of a stretch to believe that the participants would also abuse children. For those of us who are familiar with liberal culture and gay culture, Tony Podesta's art and James Alefantis' instagram feed seems harmless. For people with more traditional values, it's incredibly weird and degenerate. If you're curious to read more about the pizza/pedophile theory (which I think is nonsense, by the way), see reddit.com/r/pizzagate.
- puranjay 10y agoTrouble is, there is no smoking gun (at least yet) to suggest anything actually wrong. But the optics just don't work out. Performance Art is almost always weird even for most liberal people. It appeals to a very small percentage of the world. As a politician, you don't want to be associated with that - at least not in public
- pyre 10y ago> For people with more traditional values, it's incredibly weird and degenerate. For people with "traditional values," anyone that is not "normal" is a "pervert" and once you've crossed the line into pervert territory anything that could qualify you as a pervert is equally acceptable. This is why you get people stating that transwomen/transmen are also pedophiles... every single one of them. Why? Being a transwoman or a transman makes you a pervert, and once you're a pervert you're equally likely to engage in anal sex as you are to rape a child (according to their logic) because perverts don't see any difference between the two.
- Gargoyle 10y agoAs I mentioned below, I've followed this from the beginning. I was reading the Podesta emails and following discussion in r/dncleaks when this stuff started popping up in there. I suppose it may have started on one of the chans first, I don't know. The "code words" list had the feel of an expert in the memetic arts. Anyway, I think you're right, it was the art of Tony Podesta and Alefantis that triggered a lot of people over. There was that one article about Podesta's collection mentioning the art photos of naked teens in his house where they took glee in the fact they shocked guests. Having been around art people a lot, I certainly understand the desire to provoke. Sometimes people will get provoked. You get different reactions outside the bubble.
- 2scary2reply 10y agoThere was a comment here previously by [redacted] which said: "There are just so many pieces that almost neatly fit together - it's gross. Too many coincidences to just hand-wave away. More context: https://www.reddit.com/r/pizzagate/ https://www.reddit.com/r/pizzagate/ Their reaction to this article specifically: https://www.reddit.com/r/pizzagate/comments/5e8lg7/the_nyt_j.. https://www.reddit.com/r/pizzagate/comments/5e8lg7/the_nyt_j.... Insane ramblings of paint-huffers? Or people who maybe saw something they shouldn't?" They deleted their comment - I guess they were getting too many downvotes. But I created this account to reply, so screw it: How can anyone ever disprove a conspiracy theory like that? It's impossible. I saw in passing an interview with someone who thought that Hillary was ordering child abuse victims using "Pizza" as a code word. I never actually realized it was a serious accusation. "False news" isn't the issue. It's people are completely unable to evaluate how likely something is in any meaningful way if that person is on the opposite side of politics.
- dclowd9901 10y ago> How can anyone ever disprove a conspiracy theory like that? It's impossible. Indeed, you cannot. To even address it directly gives it credence and power. It is so absolutely asininely absurd as to warrant complete disregard.
- dang 10y agoHey, if a user deleted their comment, that's their prerogative and it's unfair to override that without their permission. People here need to treat each other better than on the internet at large, or what sort of a community are we? It's extremely rare that we'd edit a comment but I don't think you have property rights over this one, so I'm going to redact the username you put in there and ask you not to do this again.
- Gargoyle 10y agoSomething I've wanted to ask, then... Why is there a relatively short cutoff period for deleting one of your own comments?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- puranjay 10y agoI'm no conspiracy nut, but the way Podesta and others talk about food in Wikileaks emails is kinda weird. But then, weirdness != criminality.
- slowmotiony 10y agoOwner of the pizzeria posting pics of tied up children to his instagram is also "kinda weird".
- puranjay 10y agoIt is. Definitely is.
- Fraterkes 10y agoIf there really is some top-secret pedoring, why would they post that shit online?
- slowmotiony 10y agoPerhaps because they're fucked in the head.
- shostack 10y agoFor all the people saying this is fabricated here, has anyone had any explanations for these aspects of it? Have to say that Instagram account set my Spidey senses off unless it was hacked.
- cronjobber 10y agoIt's a full blown moral panic and it isn't pretty. But it doesn't help when the NYT simply invents a stronger version of the story right off the bat, probably for effect: > All of them alleged something that made Mr. Alefantis’s jaw drop: that Comet Ping Pong was the home base of a child abuse ring led by Hillary Clinton ... I've heard of this story before, and I can't remember a version of it that had Hillary Clinton in that role. I don't think making up facts for extra effect really helps debunk a story.
- lvs 10y agoThere are a disturbing number of new accounts being formed to comment idiotically on this thread. Mods should lock. The troll brigades are landing. The real target of this misinformation campaign is very likely to be the site Media Matters, as the article obliquely suggests.
- staticelf 10y agoSome americans are so fucking stupid it's beyond me. Unfortunately that is also true for the population in my country and much likely the entire world.
- BuckRogers 10y agoNo, we more than likely have you beat. People blame Hillary for "losing the election" (that she won, actually). It's the minority of voters who happen to live in privileged areas that get to choose our next President who chose the nitwit over a Yale Law grad. Smart has been out in my country for a while now and it's really a shame considering the superpower status.
- suby 10y agoIt's nonsense to claim that Hillary actually won the election, because by doing so you're changing the rules of the contest after the fact. The goal was to get the most electoral votes, and Trump (for better or worse) followed a strategy that allowed him to obtain more than Hillary. Had the goal at the start of the election been to win the most votes in total, then the strategy followed by both sides would have been massively different. We really can't say one way or the other who would have won the popular vote in such a scenario. People need to rip this band aid off already. Hillary lost, and it's her own fault.
- BuckRogers 10y agoMore people, ~2.5 million voted for her. People vote, counties/states do not. How would you feel if you simply were born in the wrong part of the country and you're with the majority and your vote didn't end up mattering? To have your vote matter, you need to be in Ohio or Michigan. The Yale Law grad is at fault for losing to that barbarian? Wrong again. The minority of the voting public, who believe they are victims- are at fault. And the USA is the one that will end up losing.
- guelo 10y agoThe fake news thing is really starting to dampen my faith in democracy. There's just no way to counteract it in the age of viral media. It's the DDoS of the political sphere. And it's a national security threat since countries can use it to undermine each other's elections. If democracy doesn't work maybe the best we can hope for is a competent benevolent autocratic state. Maybe China is the right model after all.
- gremlinsinc 10y agoIt's dampening my faith in humanity and education in America.. First thing you learn in any college English class: verify your sources -- when doing projects/reports you don't use wikipedia, you use peer reviewed articles/etc.. We can't always do that on the web, but some sites def. are more trustworthy than others... I generally don't trust CNN/Fox/MSNBC either as they are so tempered by opinions lately... and I use aggregators to get equal sides of an argument. Seems to me American's were a lot more intelligent when the news was required to play opinions from both sides of an issue... Sad that Reagan killed that little law.
- matt_wulfeck 10y agoSounds a bit melodramatic. Maybe you're having a hard time understanding why your country voted for someone with whom you have fundamental disagreements? I'm perfectly capapable of considering the pros and cons of a candidate and making a judgement about their ability to lead the country in a direction I think is desired thank you. It's amazing to me that everyone living in a "coastal citidel" is still so absolutely flabbergasted that 2016 went to the Republicans. The people that voted for Trump are not like you. If everyone wants to hold on to the narrative that they were a bunch of racicists motivated by fake Facebook posts or Russia then so be it. That type of thinking lost 2016 and it will lose 2020 also.
- guelo 10y agoIt's not a partisan complaint. I've seen plenty of fake stories circulating on the left too. Though the conspiracy theories seem much more elaborate on the right.
- 10y ago
- DigForTheKids 10y agoHow are people so quick to dismiss what they are talking about on 4chan and reddit? What if this is a legitimate pedophile ring of Washington elites, and what if they are using their influence to brush it under the rug? Doesn't that possibility bother you? Why not examine the evidence (intentionally omitted from this article) yourself?
- pyre 10y ago... and posting hashtags on Twitter, sending death threats, and hurling accusations at anyone within a mile radius of this pizzaria is how you go down in history for blowing the lid right off this story and getting to the truth, right?
- MollyR 10y agoSocial pressure on people in charge works. I'm not saying its good or bad here. The new right seems to taken a huge page from saul alinksy and the control-left in their tactics.
- pyre 10y agoIn this case, we're talking about 'social pressure' on a pizzeria that should be innocent until proven guilty, but is being smeared by accusations based on little to no evidence (other than "wake up sheeple" type evidence).
- m8urn 10y agoAnd what if they were wherewolves, wouldn't you want to know that too? The problem here is the confirmation bias and logic errors going on with all the theories that there really is no believable proof unless you actually suspend your belief in rational think7.
- adevine 10y agoI'm kind of saddened and dismayed by the number of comments that need to be downvoted into oblivion in this thread. I really appreciate that Hacker News is a place where I can learn something from other points of view, and where even if I disagree with someone, a lot of times I will gain an appreciation for their way of thinking. But now with a number of comments insinuating that somehow this story is invalid because it's reported by NYT, and NYT is the real fake news, is baffling and infuriating. I think the NYT may have some problems, but blithely and falsely reporting that a presidential candidate is running a child sex ring out of a pizza parlor isn't one of them.
- sofal 10y agoStories like this tend to come with a brigade of new accounts and posters filling the threads with as much nonsense as possible almost as if it were a mandate they're following from elsewhere.
- defgeneric 10y agoWhat the NYT gets wrong is that #pizzagate is an Internet phenomenon, not something from the "alt right". The internet is basically slandering a certain network of people in DC but few really care because the whole network seems to benefit from rampant influence peddling. I mean we're talking about David Brock's former partner--he may be innocent, of course, but Brock is hardly a bystander in the internet wars. I think it's a mistake to see these people only as victims--they're associated with pretty vicious propagandists, big power-brokers, and the like... Being the (brief) target of the hivemind almost has a poetic justice to it. It will go away if they don't feed the trolls.
- dragonwriter 10y agoNo, you're wrong and the NYT is right. It's not "the internet" doing it, it is a specific political faction in an echo chamber reinforced forcing a particular ideological basis creating and magnifying a politically-motivated fantasy.
- 10y ago
- dang 10y agoAll: we've closed this thread to new accounts. I don't like to do that but it's sometimes necessary to counteract abuse of this site. If you have a new account and you'd like to comment in the thread (in good faith of course), you're welcome to email hn@ycombinator.com and we'll help.
- nkurz 10y agoI saw this mentioned in the Wikileaks AMA in Reddit, and it seemed so ridiculous that I felt compelled to look at what was being said. My conclusion was that that it wasn't a joke --- the people doing the research on Reddit genuinely believed what they were writing, and while likely wrong about the specifics of all their accusations, they in fact might have discovered enough oddities to be justified in thinking that "something just wasn't right". For example, here's an example of the sort of email they felt might be 'coded' pedophilia: With enormous gratitude to Advance Man Extraordinaire Haber, I am popping up again to share our excitement about the Reprise of Our Gang’s visit to the farm in Lovettsville. And I thought I’d share a couple more notes: We plan to heat the pool, so a swim is a possibility. Bonnie will be Uber Service to transport Ruby, Emerson, and Maeve Luzzatto (11, 9, and almost 7) so you’ll have some further entertainment, and they will be in that pool for sure. And with the forecast showing prospects of some sun, and a cooler temp of lower 60s, I suggest you bring sweaters of whatever attire will enable us to use our outdoor table with a pergola overhead so we dine al fresco (and ideally not al-CHILLo). https://wikileaks.org/podesta-emails/emailid/10052 https://wikileaks.org/podesta-emails/emailid/10052 While I'm almost certain that a message sent to a listserv talking about transporting "Ruby, Emerson, and Maeve Luzzatto (11, 9, and almost 7) so you’ll have some further entertainment" is just a way of encouraging people to bring their own children of similar age by pointing out that there will be other kids attending, I can see that the odd phrasing might raise suspicion in some contexts. One of those contexts would be finding out that some of the people involved in the email chain are "friends of friends" of people who in fact have been convicted of child molestation, and it seems possible that this is indeed the case. At the least, it seems to be something they believe they have found. Anyway, if you want to dive into it to see for yourself, here's an summary of some of the 'evidence' they dug up: https://www.reddit.com/r/pizzagate/comments/5da0kp/comet_ping_pong_pizzagate_summary/ https://www.reddit.com/r/pizzagate/comments/5da0kp/comet_pin...
- etherael 10y agoIt's pretty hilarious that amongst the pearl clutching and virtue signaling and holding up the NY times as if it was a crucifix against vampires, there is flat out deafening silence when you bring up just a shred of the things that have been revealed during the affair in question. I don't know what to think either, but the response amongst otherwise intelligent people on this is pretty weird, in both the positive and negative case directions.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ozgurozkan 10y agoI was expecting a reply for each accusation and found nothing. Can you please reply about 65 grand pizza? This is so simple.
- Shorel 10y agoYears ago a writer friend of mine asked me about and idea of how a group of people all doing the same thing at the same time could do the most damage in general. I surely did not have good enough ideas for a writing, but this pizzagate thing seems to be one terrifying answer to that inquiry. Just that in this case the damage is very concentrated and it seems to affect only on a few group of people.
- internaut 10y agoI don't know what to believe, but I'm not going to take the New York Times at its word. I see it has already lied once in the article. Remember 2003, Iraq war, WMDs? That took thousands of dollars out of your pocket. Let's agree on one thing here. Spreading false information is unhelpful.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- camperman 10y agoThere are a number of factual errors with this article. "He found dozens of made-up articles about Mrs. Clinton kidnapping, molesting and trafficking children in the restaurant’s back rooms." There are no articles that claim Mrs. Clinton has been doing this. Not dozens - zero. "While Mr. Alefantis has some prominent Democratic friends in Washington" Yeah, and the Titanic was just a boat. Alefantis was named one of the Top 50 Influential People in Washington D.C. by GQ magazine. Because he is. The article mentions this later. "was a supporter of Mrs. Clinton, he has never met her," This is highly unlikely. Not only has he visited the White House hundreds of times, he received a personally signed letter from Hillary Clinton for catering at a fundraiser at John Podesta's house. He displayed this letter on his Instagram, along with many images of children that raise plenty of red flags. Why not link to these and let readers decide for themselves? "Amanda Kleinman, whose band, Heavy Breathing, has performed there several times, deleted her Twitter account after the abusive comments became overwhelming." Perhaps the author could link to some of Amanda Kleinman's videos which contain single frame images of torture, famous pedophiles and child exploitation images? "His customers include some high-powered locals, such as Tony Podesta, the brother of John Podesta, whom Mr. Alefantis knows casually." Casually? Then why are there photos of them together at functions at Comet Ping Pong? John Podesta's emails have conversations which are highly disturbing to the casual reader. Why not show us some examples to see what the fuss is? At this stage, all evidence for there being a pedo ring operating out of Washington D.C (with Comet Ping Pong playing a major role) is only circumstantial. But there is a LOT of it, literally hundreds of data points.
- nkurz 10y agoThere are a number of factual errors with this article. I agree completely with your complaints about the NYT article: it's terrible reporting, and essentially a PR release. Personally, I'm bothered most by the failure to mention that Alefantis is listed in GQ's Top 50 Influential People in DC, and the implication that he's a powerless pizza store owner. But I don't think the problem is that it's not "factual", rather it's being selective about which facts to mention so as to persuade the reader in a particular direction. Why not link to these and let readers decide for themselves? I'm pretty sure that the author believes that "nothing to see here" is the correct conclusion, and fears that the readers, not understanding the situation as well as she does, will reach the wrong conclusions. I'd guess the author has personal connections to some of the people involved, and is confident in her judgement that the accusations are false. This is essentially the definition of 'elitism', but the author's logic is likely correct. At this stage, all evidence for there being a pedo ring operating out of Washington D.C (with Comet Ping Pong playing a major role) is only circumstantial. But there is a LOT of it, literally hundreds of data points. Not only circumstantial, but really flimsy. While it might strike people as unfathomable that their government officials could actually be preoccupied with finding the best 'cheese pizza', this really isn't evidence that 'cheese pizza' equals 'child pornography'. One could argue that it's consistent with the behavior of a ring of pedophiles, but unless you've started with the conclusion that you are probably dealing with pedophiles, even 100 similar data points still don't add up to a likelihood that approaches the chance of a false positive. So what's the solution? I have no idea.