6 ms·
>Walmart pays exactly what they and the employee agreed to at the onset of the employment agreement. // Seriously, do you think that's how it happens? Is that
by pbhjpbhj 10y ago
>Walmart pays exactly what they and the employee agreed to at the onset of the employment agreement. //
Seriously, do you think that's how it happens? Is that bluster, naivety, or what?
"He sonny, do you want to eat dirt or accept our below healthy subsistence wages?" seems closer to how it goes. People don't work for low wages because they can't bargain, they work for low wages because the alternative is for them not to work and the government won't mandate a Living Wage.
It's not fair because people who have less resources, from birth usually, are in a far worse bargaining position and usually don't have the occasion to negotiate their wages. The only chance they have to create leverage is to unionise and force the company to decide whether to waste 20% of their workforce and do a massive employment and training drive (or suffer a strike, or ...) or to accede to paying a, for example, inflation matching wage increase.
- sillysaurus3 10y agoSeriously, do you think that's how it happens? Is that bluster, naivety, or what? Why not assume they're genuinely curious to learn rather than attack them? It gives better conversation.
- danharaj 10y agoGoing over the same basic points over and over again might be a better conversation, but it's always the same comversation, which gets tiresome.
- randomdata 10y agoThe funny part is that not a single reply to my comment (so far) touched on any of the points being made, which was entirely about definitions of terms, but rather continued with the same tired and emotionally fueled talking points every union discussion has. I have to wonder if anyone actually read my comment, or just saw the word union and started replying with their stock responses.
- anigbrowl 10y agoI did respond to you in kind, but I was disinclined to do so because insisting on defining terms is both an aggressive debating tactic and shows a lack of manners by failing to even address existing widely accepted definitions that many others may prefer to rely on, preferences which are just as valid as yours. At the very least, it suggests that you haven't done your homework and are arguing pompously from a position of ignorance.
- mikeryan 10y agoThe funny part is that not a single reply to my comment (so far) touched on any of the points being made, which was entirely about definitions of terms, but rather continued with the same tired and emotionally fueled talking points every union discussion has. Perhaps most here find your points tired and emotionally fueled which is why they choose instead not to engage?
- randomdata 10y agoMaybe. In which case, can you point to other discussion about this so I can move other there? I'd like to actually have a discussion about it instead of getting a bunch of off-topic replies that can never go anywhere.
- manicdee 10y agohttp://reddit.com/r/The_Donald http://reddit.com/r/The_Donald
- randomdata 10y agoSomething tells me you won't find much in the way of discussion about usage of the english language and the phrases in question there?
- enraged_camel 10y ago>>The funny part is that not a single reply to my comment (so far) touched on any of the points being made The funny part is that if you're genuinely curious about the topic, you can do some introductory research yourself. The information you seek is a single Google search away. To demonstrate: http://i.imgur.com/E6Prs3R.png http://i.imgur.com/E6Prs3R.png
- anigbrowl 10y agoBecause people who issue pedantic demands to be taken seriously while simultaneously leading with facile arguments rarely prove to be honest disputants.
- wpietri 10y agoOnly if they're genuinely curious. Otherwise, it's just a pointless exercise in explaining something that a) they could have learned already, and b) they actively don't want to understand. As Heinlein said, "Never attempt to teach a pig to sing; it wastes your time and annoys the pig." Like pbhjpbhj, I doubt that randomdata was as incredibly naive as he sounded. I took it as a rhetorical device. But using that device here amounts to either denying the malfeasance that can occur when people with wildly differing power levels negotiate or saying that the exploitation of workers is fine because market outcomes are always right. The former is not a credible position; history provides too many counterexamples. The latter is a sort of reptilian free-market fundamentalism that often hides behind rhetorical devices because "might makes right" it not a moral standard most people will openly subscribe to.
- baddox 10y ago> "He sonny, do you want to eat dirt or accept our below healthy subsistence wages?" seems closer to how it goes. And which of those options is better?