3 ms·
> then yes, some people would have to take it as medicine and never stop. Which is a problem since it would probably be a monoclonal antibody and those are the
by ars 10y ago
> then yes, some people would have to take it as medicine and never stop.
Which is a problem since it would probably be a monoclonal antibody and those are the most expensive drugs to make. Like hundreds of thousands or even millions per year expensive (depending on what dose is needed).
If it really does cost millions per year the US couldn't afford it - it would cost over a trillion per year to treat everyone in the US, and more than 40 trillion to treat everyone (and that's just for the medicine).
(For comparison total healthcare spending in the US is 3 trillion.)
So better hope that either the price goes down, or that it only requires a limited course of treatment. Can you imagine a cure for HIV, and we can't afford it?
- nopinsight 10y agoWhat are the reasons behind such prohibitive cost? Rare expertise, advanced factories, amount of time required, lack of economy-of-scale, monopoly, something else? If the cure is proven, the society will likely be able to mobilize much more resources, particularly to scale up operations. Special expertise can be trained to other biologists (the underemployment problem would be mitigated as well). More biologists could be trained. Likewise for factories, materials, etc. Monopolies can be broken. What factors cannot be scaled up with such an approach? (Honest question. I do not know anything about antibody production.)
- ars 10y ago> What are the reasons behind such prohibitive cost? Rare expertise, advanced factories, amount of time required, lack of economy-of-scale, monopoly, something else? The first 3. Monopoly doesn't help I'm sure, but this drug class in inherently very expensive to produce, there's a reason there is little outcry over the prices charged. It's extremely labor intensive, and very hard to scale up. They are also inherently dangerous, so there is a need for extreme purity. (See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TGN1412 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TGN1412 for what a monoclonal antibody can do, you would not want that to happen by accident.) As of right now this drug class remains the most expensive of all drugs, I would assume if it were possible to make it cheaper they would have. But we'll only really know once the first generics enter the market.
- toufka 10y agoIt's curious, because in the near future monoclonal antibodies, as produced by your own body, should be the very cheapest 'drugs' (sic; read 'therapy' or 'cure') to make. If your own body is the manufacturing plant, it's just the cost of delivering the blueprints, once (very cheap). You design the monoclonal antibody, figure out its sequence, deliver the sequence back into your own body (via some HIV-like virus), and now your body has an unlimited continuous access to the therapeutic. Production of the therapeutic-delivering virus could be done in such a way as to produce a global scale for a small amount of money that would never need to be administered again. For example, in lab I can produce enough (lab quality) purified protein for a single one-time dose for a few thousand dollars and a week's work. On the other hand, I could produce enough therapeutic virus for dozens of people to forever produce their own versions of that same protein for a few hundreds dollars and an afternoon's work. This is very unlike any other 'drug' of the 20th century.