14 ms·
Alien life could be so advanced it becomes indistinguishable from physics
- maxxxxx 10y agoIIRC that was the idea of the book "2001" (not the movie). First the aliens developed starships and over time they used space directly and became one with it.
- DashRattlesnake 10y agoIt's also a theme in some of Stephen Baxter's books, where lots of very "hot and fast" life developed almost immediately after the big bang in very extreme (to us) environments, and influenced cosmological history by doing things like changing the balance between matter and anti-matter. Human-like life, on the other hand, developed later and is physically larger, colder, and slower.
- juanpabloaj 10y agoWhat are the title of those books? To search
- copacope 10y agoThe Xeelee Sequence books (Vacuum Diagrams, Raft, Timelike Infinity etc) or The Manifold Series, all by Stephen Baxter
- tpeo 10y agoPersonally, 2001 (the movie, haven't read the book) was the only depiction of aliens I actually like. IMO, FTL travel might require harnessing such crazy physics (negative energy, for instance) that any civilization advanced enough to do it would be completely different from anything we know, or might be even past the need of actually going anywhere. But instead science fiction often makes spacefaring civilizations exactly like our own, but with spaceships intead of trucks.
- golergka 10y agoMay be they just wouldn't need FTL travel because sublight travel is fast enough for their perception of time and life expectancy.
- pavel_lishin 10y agoLike the Outsiders of Known Space.
- wruza 10y agoThere was similar being in [it seems] earlier book, "The City and the Stars". Still one of my favorites among science fiction.
- jaequery 10y agoAnyone ever read 2010? I thought the 2010 was way more interesting and filled with a lot more sci-fi "facts" than 2001.
- maxxxxx 10y agoI only watched the movie which made me lose interest in the book. May have to check again.
- snowwrestler 10y ago2001 is a much better movie than book. 2010 is a much better book than movie. The rest of the sequels are not great in any medium IMO.
- yoo1I 10y agoOT: "Nautilus uses cookies to manage your digital subscription and show you your reading progress. It's just not the same without them." I don't have a digital subscription, neither do I need my "reading progress" displayed to me. What does that even mean ? What makes that so important that they just can't show me the content, if they not also show me my "reading progress". I'm a fully grown adult who has been reading for many, many years. Maybe I know a thing or two about my "reading process". If you want to show me ads and/or sell my "reading progress" to the highest bidder, at least say so, and don't hide behind some bullshit.
- ncallaway 10y agoThey use cookies as almost every website does. Some jurisdictions require a notification of it, so there's a notification. If you don't like it, disable cookies in your browser: * https://support.google.com/accounts/answer/61416?hl=en https://support.google.com/accounts/answer/61416?hl=en * https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/enable-and-disable-cookies-website-preferences https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/enable-and-disable-cook...
- ymse 10y agoAmusingly, as someone who has first-party cookies disabled by default, those annoying "we use cookies" notifications appear every time instead of just the first. Way to go EU..
- teilo 10y agoThis is nothing but speculation, and represents the nullification of science by providing the answer: "It's Aliens!" It is functionally equivalent to arguing for intelligent design.
- jsprogrammer 10y agoThe title, at least, does not nullify anything. It only presents a possibility.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tbabb 10y agoNautilus' main activity seems to be dressing bullshit up as intellectual depth.
- erikpukinskis 10y agoNo, speculation and arguing for something are fundamentally different. Also, theorizing an entity beyond our understanding is fundamentally different from theorizing an entity beyond our universe.
- landryraccoon 10y agoAll simulation theories of the universe require an entity beyond our universe.
- TheOtherHobbes 10y agoNot if the simulation container evolved spontaneously in its own universe.
- landryraccoon 10y agoIt depends on the semantics of "universe". I consider a simulation to be its own universe, if you don't agree with that definition then it's a different universe - but it might be one with completely different physical laws.
- runeks 10y agoIf a life form can become so advanced that it becomes indistinguishable from what it observes, won't we too cross that border at some point, and if so, when will we know that we've crossed it? If we've already crossed that border without knowing it, we could be observing our own life form in physics, and not that of "aliens".
- jsprogrammer 10y agoDoes everything that can happen, actually happen? I think, probably not.
- givinguflac 10y agoIf the universe were truly infinite then I think it may. Either way it's impossible to know.
- jsprogrammer 10y agoDo you have a proof of that? Could there be structures that are provably impossible to create after some time?
- freshhawk 10y agoBut there is no reason at all to think the universe is infinite. Plenty of evidence it isn't. The idea it is is entirely from either the religious or secular versions of "Dude, I'm going to blow your mind"
- f_allwein 10y agoGiven the history of life on earth (3.5 B years of life, 100.000 or so of human covilization), I think it's much more likely that any alien life we discover would be very primitive - say, bacteria living on a moon in the solar system, or maybe plants on a planet somewhere.
- beambot 10y agoProbably true for alien life we discover. But also possible: any life that discovers us may very well be more advanced than us by a similar margin.
- wruza 10y agoOtoh, most evolutional progress happened after global catastrophes, and maybe some worlds had it earlier. For example 3.3 B years of life, 800.000 or so of alien civilization.
- pault 10y agoThat was part of the premise of the Three Body Problem (slight spoilers ahead): technology advances so quickly on a universal timeline, that in the time span between detecting an alien civilization and being able to do anything about it (assuming no FTL communication/travel), the detected civilization will have advanced to the point of being an existential threat to your own civilization, so the only logical response to detecting another civilization is to immediately destroy it if possible, or remain hidden otherwise. This is his answer to the Fermi paradox. I thought it was quite clever.
- f_allwein 10y ago... or the detected civilization will just have died out in the same time span. How much time do we have left as a species? Given climate change and our current consumption of non renewable resources, I doubt any civilization that detects us today would be able to reach us on time. Three Body Problem sounds interesting. Will check it out.
- Gammarays 10y agoAlthough some have pointed out that the article is pure speculation, this is a topic that interests me. Are there any recommendable books that explore similar topics? I've tried googling, but there's just too many "Alien" theory books out there. Hoping for some solid recommendations.
- marcofloriano 10y agoThere's a lot of interesting stuff in the comments section of the article.
- Ralfp 10y agoIf you are looking for fiction, Lem's Solaris is good exploration "too alien" concept.
- Gammarays 10y agoBoth. It feels as though both could offer interesting perspectives on alien intelligence. Since there's so much we don't know, I assume many theories would be labeled as fiction to be proven otherwise.
- zorpner 10y agoLem's His Master's Voice is also in the same genre, but the section A New Cosmology from A Perfect Vacuum is much more specifically about this topic.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoCixin Liu's Three Body Problem trilogy explores this problem pretty strongly in the last book (Death's End), and also foreshadows it a bit in the first two. I recently binge-read them all and I give a very high recommendation for them. Calling the guy "China's Clarke" may not be a stretch.
- hawkice 10y agoIt might be overselling Arthur C. Clarke, who is largely known for strange stuff like 2001. Three body has a much more salient blend of pure hard sci fi and human drama. Maybe an Orson Scott Card? It is kind of a newer style.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoReminds me a bit of one of the points of the book Death's End (third part of the Three Body Problem trilogy by Cixin Liu). A small spoiler follows. The point raised in this book is - the Earth looks much different thanks to life it has than it would without it. Consider e.g. mountains that erode slower because there are forests and foliage that disperse the wind. Would it not be the case that advanced alien life existing in the universe also affects its evolution? So what if some of the physics we study is actually not how the universe looked at the start? Could the speed of light have changed because of aliens weaponizing physics in past wars? Could the curled up dimensions string theory postulates be actually be another consequence of powerful entities doing wide-scale manipulation of the universe? Maybe initially, before life, the universe actually had 11 full, expanded spatial dimensions? I do highly recommend the book.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ythn 10y ago> Could the curled up dimensions string theory postulates be actually be another consequence of powerful entities doing wide-scale manipulation of the universe? So what you are saying is that there is a chance Godlike beings with advanced mastery over physics could exist?
- TeMPOraL 10y agoGodlike power is a function of technology and what the universe allows. The universe allows for splitting atoms, and thus we've packaged that ability into a bomb that's l̶i̶k̶e̶ ̶L̶a̶n̶g̶h̶o̶r̶n̶e̶'̶s̶ ̶o̶w̶n̶ ̶R̶a̶k̶u̶r̶a̶i̶ a bigger direct display of power than almost anything the God of the Bible did post deluge. Or consider we've fucked up the climate change problem and Earth suffers from runaway global warming. We all die. 500 years from now, an alien probe from Proxima Centauri passes through the Solar System. The aliens would see Earth and wonder how a Venus-like planet formed in (what we call) a habitable zone. Maybe they'd end up reconsidering their models of planetary evolution ("Surely it couldn't be aliens", they'd say, "that's ridiculous! There's no proof of other life out there except our own!"). Maybe the wide-scale manipulation of what we today consider fundamental physics is possible. Surely, a lot of popularly accepted sci-fi technologies would be able to do that if one would follow them to their obvious conclusions at scale (one shovel can dig you a ditch; a thousand shovels will dig you a great canal). And if it is possible, what's to say it hasn't already happened?
- DanielBMarkham 10y agoEpistemological point: if from the modern world you dropped in on Christopher Columbus with all your gadgets and tried to explain them, it might sound like magic. If from the modern world you dropped in on a hominid 100k years ago in his cave with all your gadgets and tried to explain them? You'd be a god. Things that exist outside of our ability to have language to describe them are godlike. (There is an open question about whether the set of such things is irreducible or open to conquest at some point in time) If the caveman trapped you and tried to figure out what you were up to? Yes, to him it would be physics. However -- this is just another way of saying that he'd have no symbols to grasp your behavior and would be forced to create various mental models that he could share with others. Donald Rumsfeld famously talked about knowns and unknowns[1]. But there is another dimension of things we have no symbology to begin discussing. There be dragons. 1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GiPe1OiKQuk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GiPe1OiKQuk
- JackFr 10y agoIt gets even worse with aliens. Our brains have convinced us that they are universal computation machines, but consider that there are possibly true representations of the universe that are literally unknowable to us.
- sklivvz1971 10y agoWhole article in a sentence: "These possibilities might seem wholly untestable, because part of the conceit is that sufficiently advanced life will not just be unrecognizable as such, but will blend completely into the fabric of what we’ve thought of as nature. But viewed through the warped bottom of a beer glass, we can pick out a few cosmic phenomena that—at crazy as it sounds—might fit the requirements." Meh :-)
- stefs 10y agothis is an offtopic question: does anyone know, why online magazines like nautil.us, vox.com and many others still don't use https? certificates are free and the additional server cost is minimal nowadays, so why don't they encrypt traffic? are ads and tracking the reason?
- pmoriarty 10y ago"only about 5 percent of the mass-energy of the universe consists of ordinary matter: the protons, neutrons, and electrons that we’re composed of. A much larger 27 percent is thought to be unseen, still mysterious stuff" What about the other 68 percent?
- flaviojuvenal 10y agodark energy and dark matter AFAIK: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:DMPie_2013.svg https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:DMPie_2013.svg
- dev_throw 10y agoOur universe might just be an alien's Docker container.
- ivanhoe 10y agoNot sure what "physics" exactly means in this context, I presume that gravity, EM or nuclear forces are just products of some supreme alien technology? Isn't that just the same, and equally as (un)likely, as the concept of God that rules the Universe?
- RichardCA 10y agoShane Carruth, the guy who gave us Primer and Upstream Color, wrote a screenplay for a movie that would have been called A Topiary. It's essentially an exploration of this idea. It starts with a traffic engineer in the 80's finding strange patterns in accident data, and ends with a group of adolescents building a device of non-human design. The key idea is that spectra are the manifestation that ties it all together. The screenplay is available online and would make an excellent SF novel.
- eva1984 10y agoThis is pure speculation, or fiction. What is the real meat here?
- terrestrial 10y agoIt's just preparations for the impending first contact. Now we'll be a little less surprised when they mention they've been around all this time. Perhaps Kurzweil wasn't that far off after all..
- firethief 10y ago> But if the surrounding universe ever got too warm—too filled with thermal refuse—things would stagnate. Luckily we live in an expanding and constantly cooling cosmos. What better long-term investment by some hypothetical life 5 billion years ago than to get the universe to cool even faster? I'm not a physicist, but isn't that not how heat death works at all? Reducing temperature by spreading out matter doesn't help the "problem" that low-entropy energy becomes scarce.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ChrisClark 10y agoSo, we're still living in the 'plain text' part of our universe. Everything open and visible to the ones who've moved to the encrypted dark matter. ;)
- amasad 10y agoAny sufficiently advanced new age theory is indistinguishable from rubbish.
- TheOtherHobbes 10y agoAny sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from physical reality.
- dschiptsov 10y agoLife is indistinguishable from physics.
- Retra 10y agoWell, I seem to have no trouble with the distinction.
- dschiptsov 10y agoWell, I just got tired of hipster bullshit and memes. There is the only one way to prove something - it is to show that there are logical truth of all the statements and implication all the way back to the starting assumptions. Students learn this in an undergrads AI class, leave alone the basics of mathematical logic. This shit is full of gaps in logic, just a pile of memes upon memes (dark energy, my ass!) and bullshit all the way down. Just a single flaw in logic anywhere in the chain of statements is enough to throw away all the crap. A single failed assertion. Things which are not confirmed by independently replicated experiments are beliefs not facts. Socially constructed memes. The people who speculate about unproven sets of beliefs are sectarians, not scientists. This and similar bullshit is no different from the cosmology on the walls of Egyptian pyramids or the stories about angels pushing the planets to keep them moving on its orbits.
- imchillyb 10y ago> "The people who speculate about unproven sets of beliefs are sectarians, not scientists." -@dschiptsov The entire realm of astrophysics and particle physics would beg to differ with you. Just because we don't yet know the maths, or truths, behind the studies does not relegate the science to the realm of sectarians or religious figures.
- bitwize 10y agoI fail to see how terrestrial life is distinguishable from physics.
- goatlover 10y agoIf that were the case, there would be no need for biology. It's one thing to say that life is made up of physical stuff. It's another entirely to say it's indistinguishable from physics. That's a form of extreme reductionism that isn't born out by science, although one can adopt a philosophical view that physics is all there is. Epistemologically, we humans can't explain life only in terms of physics, thus the reason for biology.
- wallace_f 10y agoMy interpretation of his comment was that he's just poking fun at the title. An alternative title might have been: "alien life might be found in observations physicists struggle today to explain."
- proteinbased 10y agoI think just the opposite is true. Biology can not explain life without physics, there might not be a complete understanding yet, but physics and math are the only tools that will get us there. Chemistry too, needs physics all the time. I think separating science is a historical relic, everything we know is physics and math, even if it might be hard to recognize in some biological phenomena. But after all, they tend to be rather complex. I am not sure what indistinguishable from physics is supposed to mean, but it sounds philosophical to me.
- Koshkin 10y agoIt must be noted though that life is an emergent phenomenon, therefore the idea that it requires physics to explain it is clearly reductionist. For instance, if you were to simulate chemical (let alone higher-level) processes characteristic to life using a computer, you would definitely not need to start with Schrödinger's equation. Even organic chemistry can be modeled based on high-level "axioms" of its own, and those axioms, or principles, do not even have to be the same as those used in modeling general chemical phenomena.
- codethief 10y agoDoes the website stay blank on a mobile device for anyone else? (I'm using Firefox on Android.)
- ofcapl_ 10y agoI have it blank too (edge, wp10)
- lbenes 10y agoWe don’t directly see anything. Our brains are trapped inside our head. The whole concept of "reality" and solid things is just a useful construct for beings made of matter. We evolved to see in the visible spectrum because it mostly bounces off of stuff like us(not totally, put your hand up to a bright light). We are beings of condensed energy. Would we be “real” to beings in the neutrino / dark matter world of physics? Or would we "nothing" in their reality? Even if they studied us, would a rock appear to be any different than a human when viewed from the realm of WIMPs? To hear physicists Dawkins and Krauss think about this and the concept of “nothing”: https://youtu.be/CXGyesfHzew?t=1229 https://youtu.be/CXGyesfHzew?t=1229
- seanp2k2 10y agoYeah, I've totally had these thoughts before too. The interesting part would be proving any of them :)
- wallace_f 10y agoThe article talks about the interesting apparent coincidence of timing b/w the formation of earth and the increased acceleration of the universe. The article discusses a possible connection b/w life and expansion, but maybe it's more simple: perhaps it's only possible we can ask this question because had it not been for the accelerated expansion of the universe, we'd would have had neighbours close enough that they might not be too happy we popped in and were working on our own ideas about what to do in the neighbourhood.
- known 10y agoAnd Hawking says humans will extinguish in 1000 years
- johndoe4589 10y agoTo me it sounds like yet another attempt by materialism to get to grips with a non materialist view. We all know at some level that the universe is not just full of "dumb rocks" (quoting Alan Watts). Evolution CAN coexist with the unknown. We're all mapping a sandbox from the inside, so to speak. Evolution is a thing, physics is a thing, and it can all happen in consciousness. But the notion of "god" and "intelligent universe" are so loaded these days, that a materialist has to find all kind of funny ways around it. I think it's valuable, to try to express old ideas in a more modern language... But let's be honest theories like the "universe is a imulation", or that intelligence somehow pertains to alien life ... are just ways to postpone the hard problem of consciousness. Potentially related: The Physicalist Worldview as Neurotic Ego-Defense Mechanism http://realitysandwich.com/320896/the-physicalist-worldview-as-neurotic-ego-defense-mechanism/ http://realitysandwich.com/320896/the-physicalist-worldview-...
- monktastic1 10y ago> To me it sounds like yet another attempt by materialism to get to grips with a non materialist view. I actually commend that. Opening up to the idea that physical reality is something far stranger than we've imagined is a great way to open oneself to the possibility that "physical reality" isn't at all the sort of thing we've long imagined it to be. Same with the simulation hypothesis. There was this article recently: http://ieet.org/index.php/IEET/more/Edge20161030 http://ieet.org/index.php/IEET/more/Edge20161030 And it contained this gem, which may actually get the right wheels turning in some minds: "If the universe is a computer simulation then we should look at the player, not the level."
- chiefalchemist 10y agoSo there are intelligent living things that influence our world that we can't see and don't understand? Funny, that sounds an awful like a God to me. Or what about, Musk's we're living in a virtual reality? That is, a reality defined and determined by unseen powerful forces. Is Science finally preparing to offer Religion at the table of "What is Life? And Why?"
- AsyncAwait 10y ago> So there are intelligent living things that influence our world that we can't see and don't understand? Funny, that sounds an awful like a God to me. "influence" is an interesting word, because the difference is, if they influence or world in terms of nature, that's a wholly lot different than the concept of God, a powerful entity watching your every step, ready to place you on a burner for eternity at any point, if you don't please him or if he is just having a bad day. Bacteria also influence our world, I would argue however, that they're quite removed from the concept of God.
- given 10y ago> Part of the fabric of the universe is a product of intelligence. Look, it's simple: God made the whole thing. But you don't want to believe in God so you invent funny theories to explain away God.
- abritinthebay 10y agoGod is t an answer. It explains nothing. It's the absence of an explanation hand waved away and given a name. Even IF a god existed the same questions would still apply
- gormo2 10y agoAn intelligence that exists in the physical laws of the universe? Well that's not novel or science fiction, it's been posited by thinkers for thousands of years and is commonly referred to as "God"
- monktastic1 10y ago:)
- jyriand 10y agofnord
- crimsonalucard 10y agoThere is nothing in this universe that is distinguishable from physics.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- sriku 10y agoThe article reads like a wish for a god, or gods, underlying the fabric of the universe, within the scope of physics.
- jacobmorse 10y agoI know of an ancient book that has been saying this all along.