3 ms·
Part of this discussion, which doesn't get enough daylight, is that depictions of Mohammed are no more "contrary to Islam" than depictions of Jesus are contrary
by patio11 17y ago
Part of this discussion, which doesn't get enough daylight, is that depictions of Mohammed are no more "contrary to Islam" than depictions of Jesus are contrary to Christianity: both Islam and Christianity have long, fragmented traditions on the matter, including some people/sects which believe quite passionately that they are an offense against God and some people/sects which believe quite passionately that they are a core part of worship. There exists a tradition of Muslim iconography -- religiously motivated art -- which proudly depicts Mohammed.
It is just a certain subset of Islam is recently arguing that a bunch of things which had historically been non-controversial are now crimes against Islam. Giving them the authority to define what Islam is simply because they'll kill you if you disagree too loudly is far more of an insult to the religion than a few drawings, from my Catholic perspective on the matter. (Individual Muslims are free to disagree, but not to kill me.)
- vegashacker 17y agoWow. Thanks for this comment. I know this is what up-voting is for, but I felt like this needed an extra shoutout.
- Jun8 17y agoRight on! This is one of the best responses I've read. As you point out, there is no such thing as "the Islam" on matters such as these, there are various traditions. A similar debate is raging in Europe over the wearing of head scarves, again a traditional approach from a small sect in Islam. One quick clarification though: AFAIK, Mohammed is always depicted with a veil in Islamic iconography.
- patio11 17y agoAFAIK, Mohammed is always depicted with a veil in Islamic iconography. That is factually inaccurate -- that is certainly one historically mainstream option, but it is not true in all times and all places. See generally the Wiki article. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Depictions_of_Muhammad http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Depictions_of_Muhammad
- kloncks 17y agoI'll accept that there is no such thing as "the Islam" and that in practice it's a very diverse religion. But some traditions aren't simply "a traditional approach from a small sect in Islam" The Hijab (head scarves) is an Islamic requirement. The different sects will disagree on its implementation, style, enforcement, and other details...but the vast majority of Muslims will agree that it's not simply "again a traditional approach from a small sect in Islam" Depictions of holy figures is another example. Yes, there is Persian, Turkish, Indian, and other art depicting the prophet, the angels, god, etc. Yes, some Shia Muslims will have no problem depicting the prophet respectfully. Yes, some Sunni Muslims are more liberal than others. But in reality, when you look at the whole Islamic population, those groups are the ones that historically have represented a small sect in Islam. The vast majority of Muslims stand against such depictions; it's important to note that the vast majority of them will also simply boycott or ignore said depictions, rather than go through more violent channels. Just my two cents.
- RK 17y agoHijab may be be a requirement, but hijab doesn't necessarily = head scarves. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hijab http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hijab
- kloncks 17y agoLike I said: The different sects will disagree on its implementation, style, enforcement, and other details...but the vast majority of Muslims will agree that it's not simply "again a traditional approach from a small sect in Islam"
- MartinCron 17y agoI just have to say that "Individual Muslims are free to disagree, but not to kill me." is one of the best sentences I've read in some time. Reminds me of a British group I heard about on NPR a few months ago, I think the name was "British Muslims for Secular Democracy" who hold up protest signs that say "To those who choose to insult The Prophet... Let's agree to disagree."
- affiliator 17y agoThere are two parts to this issue, the most minor of which being that depictions of mohammed are forbidden. Indeed depictions of any prophet are frowned apon by the majority of muslims. Disney's 'The Prince of Egypt' was banned in many predominantly muslim countries for example. The reasoning behind this is that the worshiping of stone idols was the religion of the day in Mecca before Mohammed started evangelizing. It was the desire for Islam to be far removed from these practices. Yet for any rules that are in place for muslims, non-muslims are not required to adhere to them, hence no-one at Disney was threatened or murdered. There is some cross-over of course, where a non-muslim cannot for example walk around half-dressed in a muslim country but making depictions of mohammed in a Western publication is certainly not one of them. I cringe when I hear people say something like 'Mohammed's image might be sacred to muslims, but not us'. Muslims are, you could argue, some what responsible though as mohammed has been elevated to something far above a human being in some of their minds, ironic when his one message was that God alone is worthy of worship. The real issue and what is being continuously glossed over when this brouhaha boils over is that some muslims take deadly issue with mohammed or Islam being mocked. There are a few accounts of poets in mohammed's lifetime who slandered either him or Islam and were subsequently murdered. Most muslims doubt these accounts are factual, believing perhaps they were made up to suit someone's agenda after mohammed died. after all Mohammed was constantly berated by a multitude of detractors while he was alive and he didn't call for their deaths, but rather peace treaties. Some muslims though - the dangerous ones - see them as valid and regard them as instructions as to how to conduct themselves when a similar situation arises. If you managed to watch the video clip revolutionmuslim created, you will hear that the audio which plays over the montage is of an imam discussing some of these stories. So this is why the Danish cartoonists are being threatened, not because they made an image of mohammed but because they slandered him. This is why Theo Van Gogh was murdered and this is why the South Park creators are being threatened. Behind the mask of these veiled threats of course lies a sub-section of muslims who wish to rouse their brethren to engage in a full-on assault of the west. The vast majority of muslims will ignore them but those already holding a vendetta might give them ear.
- jsm386 17y agoFor an interesting history of the back-and-forth of Christian iconography in the Byzantine Empire (Eastern Roman Empire) see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Byzantine_Iconoclasm http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Byzantine_Iconoclasm I studied this in a college - very fascinating all the fighting and back and forth over simple images. Leave it to Wikipedia to offer up something I never read about: 'According to Arnold Toynbee, it is the prestige of Islamic military successes in the 7-8th centuries that motivated Byzantine Christians into evaluating and adopting the Islamic precept of the destruction of idolatric images.'
- sigzero 17y agoUnfortunately, "militant" Islam is what the world sees.