7 ms·
Enzymes from nine organisms combined to create new pathway to use CO2
- mixedmath 10y agoThis was first brought to my attention through an article at Popular Mechanics [1]. Comparing the differences between the writing and focus of the two articles leads to interesting idiosyncracies. Ars Technica seems to emphasize the challenge of combining these enzymes to produce a new cycle. It's not technical, but it does allude to some techniques. Pop Mech emphasizes how much more carbon gets taken out of the air, compared to photosnythesis. An indication of their attention to scientific content comes from their description of the methodology: > To oversimplify matters, they mixed together all their enzymes with some chemical fuel and calculated how much CO2 was being pulled out of the air. I actually didn't realize these were talking about the same paper until I noticed that I had opened up the same link to the original paper twice. [1]:http://www.popularmechanics.com/science/energy/a23938/fix-carbon-dioxide-useful-products/ http://www.popularmechanics.com/science/energy/a23938/fix-ca...
- wutbrodo 10y agoI'm always really impressed with the depth that Ars Technica goes into, considering that it's a pretty mainstream (well, sorta) site.
- highd 10y agoImportant point from paper abstract: >The pathway is up to five times more efficient than the in vivo rates of the most common natural carbon fixation pathway. Pretty awesome depending on how tight that "up to" bound is. As an aside, this sort of thing is why I don't worry too much about climate change - once the incentives become real I'm very confident in societies ability to invent solutions. Maybe, say, a star-trek-tier global weather control system :) The primary risk with that attitude would be if our best solutions are local in nature - this would likely result in impoverished countries and cities suffering the major brunt of climate change.
- stevenkovar 10y agoI'd like to think that as we become a more globalized society, it would be in our best interests to keep every region protected from CO2 proliferation—the 'rising tides lift all ships' philosophy.
- AnimalMuppet 10y ago"Rising CO2 lifts all thermometers"?
- Thrillington 10y agoI'd stick with the tides and ships as this is one of those rare times where the common metaphor could be both literal and ironic.
- ethbro 10y ago> The primary risk with that attitude would be if our best solutions are local in nature If the major ocean-based cycles are disrupted because of salinity change / warming / acidification, then it's not going to matter where the damage was done.
- etrautmann 10y agoThe time lag for noticing change and being able to respond may preclude the possibility of meaningful compensation
- maxerickson 10y agoA hurricane unleashes more power than humanity is currently harnessing. I doubt we figure out how to do anything that only works locally.
- raverbashing 10y agoYeah, I wonder when will we have a hurricane sized wind generator (with a huge set of batteries or other storage facility)
- Beltiras 10y agoI've always maintained that the solution to carbon capture and sequestration would be biological in nature. This is great news indeed.
- throwaway7312 10y agoMan produces CO2. Global warming. Man produces CO2-eating organism. Global cooling. Snowball Earth? [1] Wasn't there a campy French-Korean movie about this with Captain America in it? [2] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snowball_Earth https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snowball_Earth [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snowpiercer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snowpiercer
- ceejayoz 10y agoLet's just hope the solution to the Fermi Paradox isn't similarly biological in nature. Maybe CRISPR-style stuff is the Great Filter as we go and suck all the CO2 out of the ecosystem accidentally.
- mcbits 10y agoWe know a lot of ways to replenish CO2, and if that's not enough, our two nearest neighboring planets are swimming in it. Maybe the others weren't so lucky!
- gwern 10y agoFreeman Dyson would probably be pleased by this work.
- egypturnash 10y ago> The other thing is that the entire pathway can now be put inside cells, either normal bacteria like E. coli or the synthetic cells with a minimal genome that researchers are working on. If that's the case, then the need to supply all the chemical co-factors should go away, since the cells should be producing them anyway. More importantly, if the cell is made to depend on this pathway as its only source of carbon, evolution would have the chance to optimize it even further. Immediate thought: What happens when that bioengineered E. coli or whatever, which you're hoping evolution will make work even more efficiently, leaves your carbon-sequestering vats and starts reproducing in the wild? Eventually you reach a point where we're getting record low CO2 levels. Hello, new Ice Age. (I am sure there are many reasons this would not happen but it certainly makes for a nice bullshit explanation if I wanted to write a story set in a far-future ice planet.)
- Retra 10y agoThen we chop down all the trees and burn them!
- clock_tower 10y agoIndeed. One way or another, I think recent years have established that "not enough CO2 in the atmosphere" is a pretty easy problem to solve.
- dnautics 10y agoNo. It doesn't make sense to put this into E coli. In order to convert CO2 into usable carbon (usually, sugars), you need energy. And where is E coli going to get this energy? Breaking down sugars and burning them to create CO2?
- chongli 10y agoAnd where is E coli going to get this energy? From the sun? That's where plants and cyanobacteria get it.
- dnautics 10y agoHow is E coli mysterioulsy going to convert solar energy into biochemical energy? I know how plants and cyanobacteria do it; they have photosystem.
- chongli 10y agoEither by a symbiotic relationship with cyanobacteria or by transferring the genes from cyanobacteria. I mean, we're already talking about combining nine organisms into one, why stop there?
- dnautics 10y agoThat's semireasonable: you can give e coli glucose made by a cyano (using human glucose transporter). But you're still making glucose and then burning it... Why use a middle man? Why not just transform the cyanobacteria with this system to begin with?
- Tloewald 10y agoThe energy in the system seems to be coming from ATP which is used to move energy around in both animals and plants, so it could presumably be wired to photosynthesis (which I assume is what the researchers had in mind — take the process plants use to store energy by converting water + C02 into sugar and replace it with something more efficient). And that's the limit of my high school organic chemistry. And e coli can be modified to do photosynthesis too.
- 100ideas 10y agoBased on the details in the arstechnica writeup, it sounds like the wetlab work was all done with cell-free systems?
- mchannon 10y agoLooking at their diagram, there appear to be multiple injections of hydrogen peroxide, but no products of hydrogen peroxide. Maybe it just requires a finite amount to get the reaction started, or there's some subtle reaction going on that's not in the diagram. Or they decided a trickle of conventionally produced H2O2 was an acceptable price to keep the reaction going. Wonder what I'm missing.
- smaili 10y agoTake a moment to appreciate the scale of this accomplishment. In four billion years of evolution, life has only managed to evolve six known pathways that start with carbon dioxide and build more complex molecules. In just a few years, a bunch of grad students in Zurich added a seventh. Well done and kudos to all those involved!
- cronjobber 10y agoMaybe this one did evolve, but others displaced it for reasons we don't know yet. I sure hope that's what happened. I'm somehow emotionally attached to all the life forms plodding along using only those rotten old pathways, I don't know if I took kindly to lab life taking over.
- raverbashing 10y agoBut remember, that's evolution It's like a very old system that has been patched and repatched over and over and never refactored. 10 steps that kinda works works. Efficiencies only play a part when one resource is really limited, and even then there might be other ways of making up for it
- AlphaSite 10y agoWell no, it try's to refactor its self, randomly deleting genes, until it deletes one which can be loved without, removing some vestigial pathway or organ.
- raverbashing 10y agoYeah, that happens. But also this https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Noncoding_DNA https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Noncoding_DNA
- jschwartzi 10y agoIf it works in vitro, why do we need it to work in vivo?
- yetihehe 10y agoSo that your system is self-replenishing. Just add some simple chemicals from time to time and monitor temperature and you no longer need to synthesize more enzymes by yourself.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoI really find the notion of designing the metabolic steps this way interesting. Converting CO2 to mallic acid, converting sugars to oil, what ever. At some point there is an organic chemistry "programming" language where you specify at a high level what you have for input and what you want for output and your biometabolic compiler spits out a bunch of RNA modules for you to link together in your holding organism to operate.
- kctess5 10y agoThat would be an interesting compiler project.
- known 10y agoIs planting a tree that difficult?
- Elrac 10y agoNot that difficult, but it doesn't accomplish the same thing. First, have you noticed how long it takes for a tree to grow to a size where it's "working" at near capacity? Second, the new pathway seems to sport higher efficiency at converting energy + CO2 into useable carbon. Third, trees don't produce really useful carbon compounds. It takes a lot of energy to break wood down. Fourth, the carbon in a tree is only sequestered so long as the tree is standing or its wood is processed into something durable. A tree that falls down and rots releases its carbon back into the atmosphere.
- timbuchwaldt 10y agoAs cool as this is, the "20x improved efficiency" is not what that paper says it seems: > Over the course of the optimisation, CO2 fixation efficiency in the CETCH cycle improved by almost a factor of 20 until version 5.4 (Fig. 2). > This is comparable to the few reported attempts to measure the CBB cycle in cell extracts (1 to 3 nmol min−1 mg−1 CBB cycle protein, So what it actually says is: They improved CETCHs efficiency by 20x during the development, but it is not 20x more efficient than plants, but rather comparable (although it seems hard to measure what plant efficiency is)
- mikeytown2 10y agoSounds like this could be a way to terraform Venus if the bacteria can float.
- raverbashing 10y agoFloating is the easy part. The hard part would be surviving the 400C and acid rain on Venus (Though you might get it floating to a higher altitude and lower temperature, maybe that's what you're suggesting)
- mirimir 10y agoThis is extremely elegant work, no question. But there's a catch. The cycle requires a reducing agent (NADPH) and energy (ATP). So one would need to add components to get those from light or whatever.
- digler999 10y agowhat would be cool is if this could be combined with an ethanol production system. So fermentation bacteria produce ethanol, their CO2 biproduct goes straight to these enzymes, and if somehow their waste product could feed the ethanol. So you could in theory have a "sunlight in, ethanol out" plant that is almost completely neutral. Ethanol isn't great, since combustion engines' efficiency sucks, but it would bridge a gap to reduce carbon while we still rely on combustion engines. Or the ethanol could be used in "cogeneration" facilities that use the waste heat and produce electricity to get very high utilization of energy.