3 ms·
Another LIBOR-style scandal. This asking for an unverifiable number from people with an interest in that number being high is an ideal vehicle for collusion. If
by pessimizer 10y ago
Another LIBOR-style scandal. This asking for an unverifiable number from people with an interest in that number being high is an ideal vehicle for collusion. If yesterday's average turned out to be higher than the number you reported yesterday, just up your number to the average. If you feel the market can bear a price rise, just up your number well above the average for a time and see if everyone follows, then lower your number the closer the average gets to your ideal number. The only risk you take is that to push the average up enough that others adjust, you take the risk of reporting a price high enough to attract attention - but if companies trade off on leading the charge, it just looks like a high variance. Each supplier has a different set of contract relationships, so any short-term variance could be rationalized.
In the end, it works out like a perfect continuous democratic system for price-fixing.
- Scoundreller 10y agoLIBOR-style indeed. What's wrong with market based prices? The other issue with LIBOR is that it fails to take into account the volume that a supplier can move. Taking the average/median of a number of suppliers that are willing to sell one chicken doesn't say much.
- bboreham 10y ago> What's wrong with market based prices? Both LIBOR and this chicken price are _supposed_ to be market-based; however the price negotiations are all confidential. An alternative is to mandate total visibility of all bids and offers, as is generally done in equity markets. This brings its own distortions: you have to pay people to operate the public venue; it enforces a bid-offer spread. And many people don't like regulations forcing them to do business a certain way.