5 ms·
There's been a lot of criticism of hackerrank.[1][2] Are you doing anything to make sure your service gets more respect? [1] - https://news.ycombinator.com/it
by pmoriarty 10y ago
There's been a lot of criticism of hackerrank.[1][2]
Are you doing anything to make sure your service gets more respect?
[1] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12825953 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12825953
[2] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12667174&source=techstories.org https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12667174&source=techsto...
- arenaninja 10y agoI don't think I would enjoy HackerRank as an interview, but as a user I do enjoy being able to practice computer science problems.
- alexgotoi 10y agoJust wrote an answer above which i think is good for your concerns. What'do you think?
- sundvor 10y ago(Speaking as a coder here, although I've also done sysadmin through most of my 20 years of working in the industry). This would be quite nice. Going through the job searching process at the moment, the "aptitude tests" etc that I've seen are very good at blowing cobwebs off my obscure analytical skills, which I rarely if ever use, yet fail completely at getting any gauge of my ability to get every day stuff done in a clean, smell-free way. As a result I'm now doing kata training on Coderwars and am getting more used to this style of testing. It's actually good fun, and I think it'll help increasing my ability to just spit out code. In real life scenarios though, most of the time is spent analysing a problem or process flow.
- alexgotoi 10y agoYou just mentioned some of reasons why we are making this product. If you have more ideas, please share with us. Thanks
- arenaninja 10y agoI think if that's the approach SysAdminsArena is taking, it's quite good. More advanced problems could be replication, caching, etc.
- alexgotoi 10y agoThat's the approach and we are glad that you support it. Great topics for more advanced problems.
- alexgotoi 10y agoGlad you asked that. As i saw in the treads mentioned by you, the common problem is that the tests are more about theory, and less about practice. Which is true. Sometimes, in interviews, you are asked about algorithms that you studied in college and never used before. It's very difficult to score high in this tests. We propose to eliminate this gap by having real job, day to day, scenarios like: install apache, mysql, php, clone site, install database etc. These are recurring task in the daily activities of a sysadmin. What do you say?
- bovermyer 10y agoThose are pretty baseline things that get automated away pretty quickly. More useful to me (as both a practicing devops type and a manager in that capacity) would be tests gauging ability to write bash scripts to do various things, or simulated problems that need to be diagnosed/fixed using command line tools (e.g., strace, netstat, etc.).
- alexgotoi 10y agoIndeed, those are pretty basic tasks. We will have 3 levels of difficulty and the examples mentioned are in the easiest category. In a early phase of a recruitment process, an experienced sysadmin would solve in less than 3 minutes and this is helping screening process when you have a huge number of applicants. But for latest stages of recruitment process, we will have more advanced scenarios for the tests. Definitely your suggestions are great and we will discuss having tests in this area. Cheers!
- marcosdumay 10y ago> an experienced sysadmin would solve in less than 3 minutes Why do you think so? And, I'm hopping you don't rely on timing on this level. An experienced sysadmin would have little experience with basic tasks, since he solves them around once or twice per job. And you never know the environments they tried it before, that may be completely different from what you are presenting them right now. I'd say "installing X" is a test for encyclopedic knowledge, and a very unreliable test for expertize. That's the kind of test that gave bad names to IT certification at the early 2000's.