15 ms·
Professors Make More Than a Thousand Dollars an Hour Peddling Mega-Mergers
- viridian 10y agoThis seems like a problem that appears everywhere in science, not just in the case of economics. There is a known phenomena of science results agreeing with the organizations that fund the science, and this seems to be an extension to that. Is there any good way to solve it that won't result in less valid science work getting funded?
- harrumph 10y ago>Is there any good way to solve it that won't result in less valid science work getting funded? Bona fide science has peer review and falsifiability. Also imperfect, but nowhere nearly as commonly manipulated as is economics for hire by business interests and their think tanks. In fact, this seems like a good time to mention the only Senator I've ever seen in decades of observing politics who actively attacks this problem is Elizabeth Warren. https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/how-elizabeth-warren-picked-a-fight-with-brookings--and-won/2015/09/29/bfe45276-66c7-11e5-9ef3-fde182507eac_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/how-elizabeth-warren...
- euyyn 10y agoFunnel plots are used in meta-analysis to detect the self-censoring bias of publishing only results when an effect showed up. Maybe they can be used or adapted for this too?
- arcanus 10y agoMost of economics is an intellectual veneer to justify politically motivated policy actions. The 'science' is seldom predictive, nor does it even attempt to be. It has more in common with augury. This blurb, for instance, openly admits their expert opinions are for sale, 'Economists have an “incentive to get a reputation as someone who will make a certain type of argument. People will hire you because they know what testimony you will give,” said Robert Porter, an economist from Northwestern who has never testified on behalf of a corporation in an antitrust matter.'
- cmdrfred 10y agoIndeed I suspect a great number of people who scream on TV never actually read The Wealth of Nations or at least not this passage: "It is but equity...that they who feed, clothe and lodge the whole body of the people, should have such a share of the produce of their own labor as to be themselves tolerably well fed, clothed and lodged."
- btilly 10y agoThe Wealth of Nations should be understood as the attempt of someone whose cultural tendencies (from Scotland) were socialist, to explain the wealth of a rabidly free market society (England). Nobody from inside of England could have written the book - it would be like a fish trying to explain water. But his underlying sympathies emerge in numerous places.
- dredmorbius 10y agoAny particular examples? Is this your interpretation or based on Smithian scholarship? I've studied a fair bit of that and not run across this particular view.
- btilly 10y agoThat's a personal interpretation based on my knowledge of the times, ongoing economic changes, and the cultures involved. Smith was born not long after England (whose per capita wealth was around 5x that of Scotland) took over Scotland. He lived during a period where England was building a worldwide trading empire, Scotland was benefiting from exposure to England, and the Industrial Revolution was just starting. Oh right, and two civil wars (the Jacobite rebellions) about whether Scotland wished to continued to be united with England. A definite intellectual challenge for the Scots of the day was how it was that England, in every way seemingly worse than themselves, should be the ones in charge. Smith provided part of the answer.
- JetSetWilly 10y ago
- mikeyouse 10y agoSlightly off topic, but ProPublica does really great investigative work. They recently took over many of the technical functions that The Sunlight Foundation was going to shut down. They do important work on civil rights, criminal justice reform, asset seizure, public corruption, corporate corruption, etc. If you have some spare cash, setting up a recurring monthly donation in any amount really helps them operate and plan for the future. I've added a subscription to the WaPo and recurring donations to ProPublica, ACLU, and The Marshall Project. This work is too important to neglect.
- aluminussoma 10y agoThere are some stories they do that are really good. But as with all stories - ProPublica or not - please understand there may be an implicit bias or agenda. On a different matter involving trial lawyers and an industry group, they reported a "scandal" where there was none. I am familiar with that issue (so I have my own biases!). It was my opinion that they were repeating the trial lawyer's argument and calling that an investigative journalism piece. Others may disagree with my assessment. I do not want to link to that story here. This is one reason why I choose not to financially support ProPublica. EDIT: I'm getting sick of the downvotes on Hacker News. This is not reddit where a downvote == disagree. Just don't upvote it. It's frustrating to take a few minutes to write a comment and then watch it get nuked because it's "controversial". But please feel free to downvote away because my off-topic rant.
- mikeyouse 10y agoFair point, they won't be perfect for everyone and they may rightly or wrongly ding organizations that people hold in high esteem (e.g. when they displayed the rank incompetence of the Red Cross a few years ago). I'd argue that funding ProPublica and then funding an outfit who takes a contrary position on whatever issue is important to you is a better solution though. We need more journalism not less.
- nitrogen 10y agoThat's a useful concept. Sort of like a free speech hedge, or like buying carbon offsets. Could be gamed, though -- start an extreme paper to pump donations to your centrist paper ;)
- aluminussoma 10y agoIt's not just economists. I recall professors in other departments were contacted for "consulting" work. General Electric offered one political science professor a lucrative hourly rate (I think it was $650/hr) to consult on a legal case for the Dabhol power plant. This was years ago, so surely the fees have gotten larger. The professor turned it down for other reasons but said it would have been "easy money".
- ghaff 10y agoBased on my personal experience, that seems like a fairly typical ballpark number for hired expert work in legal cases. It can take a big chunk of time (and it may not see the light of day), but it can be interesting and the pay is quite good.
- jononor 10y agoTake the money, write the op. But before sending it off, offer the academic you disagree with most fervently half, and ask her/him to write a counter-opinion. Publish both.
- delinka 10y agoAnd never get asked again.
- JadeNB 10y ago> And never get asked again. I understand that jononor's post https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12971712 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12971712 was describing the most intellectually honest, rather than most profitable, approach; and in that capacity it's not clear, I think, that your objection is really an objection.
- delinka 10y agoIndeed it is not clear. ;-)
- deleted 10y ago
- denzil_correa 10y agoThe best way to handle this seems to be accountability. There needs to be a reasonable way to hold companies to what they say. Currently, a company says the effect would be X in 5 years. In 5 years, these effects should be studied and if the variance is more than a reasonable standard - the merger should be relooked at and appropriate recommendations should be taken. The current system looks at merger decisions as a one time policy decision. It should take it up as an iterative exercise.
- oli5679 10y agoThis is really interesting. One solution would be social norms expressing scepticism towards pundits that made bold claims without publicly placing a large bet corresponding to the position.
- oli5679 10y agoThis is really interesting. One solution would be social norms expressing scepticism towards pundits that made bold claims without publicly placing a large bet corresponding to the position.
- 1024core 10y agoI don't understand. Why doesn't some academic analyse these professors' claims and show that they're bunkum, as the article claims?
- droopyEyelids 10y agoBecause there is limited time in the day, and you can't run a simple experiment to prove these issues, and you need money to eat and have shelter. This is really a case study in how the morality of individuals in a country determines the fate of the country.
- cerrelio 10y agoThen that academic can make a company out of it, and charge $2000/hr. :) The issue is academics cashing in on their research. I think this is fine in general. Having been through grad school I've worked with professors who I felt placed their entrepreneurial endeavors ahead of their educational requirements. This is an ugly practice. Ethical standards need to be in place to address this. If you're primarily conducting business using your academic credentials, then relinquish your chair to someone else, and take up some "fluff" title and pay your grad students out of your own kitty. Also, pay the university for the non-human resources you use, because it's like you're a hairstylist renting a chair in a salon to obtain and service clients. I think this is primarily the reason why there's a generation of postdocs sitting on the sidelines waiting for a full professorship. They eventually get bored (and hungry) and move into the private sector, robbing academia of fresh blood and new ideas. So a de facto privatization of research emerges. We all lose when this gets out of hand.
- JadeNB 10y ago> If you're primarily conducting business using your academic credentials, then relinquish your chair to someone else, and take up some "fluff" title and pay your grad students out of your own kitty. This may be fair to ask of the professor, but it is perhaps reasonable to consider whether it is fair to ask of his or her graduate students (who are probably not to be blamed for their advisors' extracurricular habits). I work in math, where corporate sponsorship is (generally) not an issue, and so my opinion may be skewed; but it seems to me that a graduate student of someone with a 'fluff' title might be perceived less seriously than a graduate student of someone with a grander academic title, and so suffer even if his or her work is sterling. (On the other hand, perhaps driving students away from working with corporate consultants is a desireable side effect …?)
- mathattack 10y agoWhile in school I went to an event hosted at the home of an Econ professor who worked on the Microsoft trial. It was lakefront property in a very posh suburb. We called it "The house that Bill Gates built."
- jccalhoun 10y agoI'm an adjunct instructor. I'll do it for half that.
- confounded 10y agoSee also, Google's anti-competition monopoly-shill joining the Trump team https://theintercept.com/2016/11/15/google-gets-a-seat-on-the-trump-transition-team/ https://theintercept.com/2016/11/15/google-gets-a-seat-on-th...
- calcsam 10y agoOne of my favorite econ professors at Stanford got an inquiry from a big oil company. They wanted her to do some consulting for them, relevant to mergers, acquisitions and the result on oil prices. She wanted to politely tell them no. So she quoted triple her normal hourly rate, already hundreds of $ per hour. They said "sure" -- so she had to tell them no the old-fashioned way :)
- jazzyk 10y agoThe sad fact is that academics these days occupy themselves with chasing money and power, not science (at least the ones in "elite" schools). Check out the movie "Inside Job": - Glenn Hubbard (the Dean of Columbia University School of Business). His work for Countrywide Financial for $1200/hr, attesting that the lender's loans were no worse than a control group of mortgages and not fraudulent, was examined by an attorney for MBIA. MBIA was suing Countrywide over its mortgage practices. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glenn_Hubbard_(economist) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glenn_Hubbard_(economist) - Frederic Mishkin, who, according to the Wall Street Journal, was paid almost $135,000 by the Icelandic Chamber of Commerce in 2006 to author a report that praised the stability of Iceland's economy and banking system—two years before they collapsed. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frederic_Mishkin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frederic_Mishkin Most of the profs in "elite" business schools sit on boards of big companies like GE, are members of Council on Foreign Affairs, etc. Just sad.
- beambot 10y agoGenuinely curious: You think business school profs serving on the boards of big companies is "sad"? If I wanted to get an MBA, I would prefer to learn from people who have actual real-world experience rather than studying with someone whose experience was purely theoretical...
- lallysingh 10y agoI think there's a valid concern about academic independence from industry. Without a reputable source of independent research, we fall into gaslighting pretty quickly.
- yuhong 10y agoThis also reminds me that I really wish the restrictions can be reduced or removed so board of directors (like @pmarca) and CEOs can tweet more on public companies, which is part of what I mean by "Yishan-style CEOs".
- 10y ago
- beambot 10y agoI guarantee the lawyers are making way more than $1000 per hour... so why vilify the professors?
- tnuc 10y agoWhat next? Vilify the lobbyists?
- notgood 10y agoLawyers from the very first day in law school are _intended_ to serve their clients (guilty or not); in the other hand professors -and educators in general- are supposed to be a lighthouse for knowledge, not another source of bad science due being paid.
- beambot 10y agoIn this context, calling professors "educators" is like calling lawyers "paralegals." Professors are academics. They are being paid for their professional, informed opinions based on knowledge and years of study. This is the same as lawyers sharing their legal opinions based on educational background (knowledge of the law) and real-world experience. Also: In mergers, there is no "guilty or not". There is contract law, risk mitigation, strategy, and negotiation. Lawyers do so much more than simply saying what is "legal or illegal."
- edblarney 10y ago"in the other hand professors -and educators in general- " An economist need not be either a prof or an educator. Tons of them work for banks, specialists just like devs, consultants, mathematicians, lawyers etc..
- gaius 10y agoThe is why The People are sick of "experts".
- tankenmate 10y ago« They debated who had the better case. Carlton conceded that AT&T and T-Mobile would have found it hard to win at trial, according to an attendee. But he wished it had gone to court. He was eager to try out a new and provocative argument for mergers: That even though prices would have risen for customers, the companies would have achieved large cost savings. The gain for AT&T shareholders, he contended, would have justified the merger, even if cell phone customers lost out. » According to this, obviously hearsay, Carlton truly wanted to argue that a merger was beneficial because shareholders won even though customers lost; this boggles the mind because the major intent of anit-trust law is to protect customers!
- matthjensen 10y agoThis article is focussed on anti-trust regulation, but the problems it addresses are much broader. Every spending and tax law, for example, is scored by the Congressional Budget Office/Joint Committee on Taxation to determine the budgetary impact. Economists are hired to lobby these organizations about the "right" way to score policy, and then the organizations might or might not adjust their methodologies. Sometimes Congress can place pressure on the scoring organizations, too. This would all be fine, except that neither the economic methodologies nor the data are publicly available. Sure, the big picture methodology is disclosed, but not the key assumptions. If the economic methodologies were disclosed in full, I'd be all for outsiders suggesting ways to improve the methods. Then a scientific discussion could be carried out in public, and I think it would be obvious to anyone observing the process that the JCT or CBO economists are trying to do the best job that they can. One step towards disclosing methods is through documentation, but given the importance of detail in the types of analyses that JCT and CBO do, supplemental documentation is unlikely to be sufficient. Instead, the organizations need to make their analytical code available. In other words, CBO and JCT should make their code available to the public and take outside suggestions for improvements. They should be open source! Granted the data won't always be available to the public given that CBO and JCT rely on administrative data that is highly private, but they can at least produce dummy datasets and detailed summary statistics. All of this same reasoning applies to the anti-trust situation. They ought to open source their analyses as well. [Disclaimer, I'm a contributor to a few open source models for public policy analysis.]
- mtw 10y agoIt is possible mega-mergers make sense economically. However economists do not take into account individual ambition. A chairman or a CEO might say satisfying words for a merger, but with real plans to increase prices due to increased market share
- vasaulys 10y agoI never knew you could get a job writing automation scripts. That's pretty cool.
- qwrusz 10y agoAs someone who studied economics and works as an economist, I agree economics today is full of bull$h^t and biased "experts" and politicking masquerading as legit social science work, I see it daily. And it goes on in mainstream and heterodox economics, in industry and in academia. (I'd preferred to call my job something like "statistician focused on economics and finance" - not economist, but it didn't fit on the business card) I just wanted to point out $1000 an hour pay is a quite common amount paid to any/all professions when law firms needs an outside expert opinion for a case. This $ is not unique to company merger cases nor economists. e.g. if a lawsuit needs a medical expert or engineering expert it's likely they are getting paid ~$1000 an hour for this time. And I don't doubt the clients are being billed way more than that - $1000 is just the expert's cut. Not defending anything, just pointing out this amount is what law firms commonly pay for outside "professional expert" opinion work.
- ada1981 10y agoCurious if there is a way to force these companies to place bets on the predictions that they make. They say that a merger is going to do XYZ -- well, with what degree of certainty? And are you willing to take a position tied to the outcome? Because as it stands, they can make an argument it will help with consumer choice -- but that isn't the driver, it's about profits. So if the idea is to protect the consumer or benefit them, make a prediction about that and then take a position where you will get an additional payoff if you are right. If you are wrong, you'll be "fined" by having to cover the bet.
- iamleppert 10y agoDennis Carlton is as crooked as they come. Smart for sure, selfish of course. He has a legion of poorly paid graduate students publishing his junk science and manipulating data from flawed studies to say whatever it is he likes. And at the end of the day, what makes you smart does not mean you're intelligent. Just because you can master a discipline to achieve your goal of extreme wealth accumulation is unimpressive. I feel that some day when money does not matter, rich people who actually created very little value (and may have even been a net negative) will be looked on as one of the great evils of society.