6 ms·
I don't think I saw any concrete structures when I was in Afghanistan. We used Hesco bastion for everything. I think even the furthest-back hospital was just sh
by chrisseaton 10y ago
I don't think I saw any concrete structures when I was in Afghanistan. We used Hesco bastion for everything. I think even the furthest-back hospital was just sheet steel siding construction, surrounded by Hesco.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hesco_bastion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hesco_bastion
Hesco is another very interesting material. Cheap, extremely light and easy to deploy, until filled, which can be done by anyone with an entrenching tool (small infantry shovel/spade that everyone carries) if required, and then basically indestructible.
How many of those concrete walls can a helicopter carry? One? It's going to take a long time to build any wall or structure. Or do you send an armoured cement mixer and create on-site? That's not realistic in a place like Afghanistan.
I'm not an engineer but I would also guess that Hesco survives better - a box of stones can lift up and crash back down with an explosion where if concrete cracks it's permanently broken.
- karyon 10y agoThe article says > Existing structures [abandoned buildings] surrounded by walled compounds of some type were selected because there was little in the environment to use for protection—such as dirt to fill sandbags, earthworks, and existing obstacles. so that might be part of the reason.
- AcerbicZero 10y agoHesco barriers were pretty wide spread in Iraq as well. Baghdad was the only place I saw where the concrete barriers outnumbered the Hescos.
- dogma1138 10y agoBecause hescos do not need logistical support 2 people can deploy one and fill it with sand and gravel even by hand if needed. Hescos are also better since they don't cause ricochets and they don't shatter on impact creating shrapnel. From my experience when concrete walls are used for fortifications the SOP was to cover them with a sheet of Kevlar like fabric between two layers of metal webbing (concrete bolt/nail gun was used to secure the webbing to the barrier) to protect personnel from secondary impact risks. If that wasn't available then you usually had a layer of either sand bags or a spaced secondary wooden or sheet metal wall with sand filling the gap between it and the concrete. When bullets are flying at you you want to be behind a barrier but not near a bare concrete wall.
- sedachv 10y agoAlso, when heated/on fire cement will explode.
- dogma1138 10y agoIf it's not dry yeah, tho if you are taking in napalm you have bigger issues than exploding concrete.
- LoSboccacc 10y agowould be interesting to develop a gluing agent to convert local gravel into a concrete like material that could be formed like Hescos but in thinner, taller L shapes for the purpose of erecting barriers as in the article. drying would be the main issue, probably.
- dogma1138 10y agoCement plus sand, this is what most walls in the middle east are made of they are very soft tho, you can crumble them with your fingers if you get past the outer layer of plaster. The upside is that they don't ricochet as much if at all, the downside is that bullets leave pretty large impact craters and if the wall isn't thick enough simply pass through like it wasn't there. But the problem remains if it's hard bullets will ricochet and it will splinter into shrapnel, if it's soft it's not an effective barrier and the wear on it is very high. Hescos or any other similar fortification are simple and effective, there is a reason why we still use sandbags and planks of wood with sand in between them, sand is a great bullet trap and you can shoot at hescos and sandbags all day long and you won't really do much damage. there needs to be a pretty big hole for the sand to sip out since it's kept in place by the pressure and compression.
- sandworm101 10y agoHescos also have a lower surface area to weight ratio. They are therefore much less likely to be moved by nearby explosions. And their softer insides make total failure, shattering, almost impossible.
- sandworm101 10y agoHescos are different object for a different purpose. They are meant to stop inbound fire, not inbound people. Climbing over them is trivial, at least in comparison to a 3m tall concrete wall. Hescos are therefore useful only where they can be monitored. They are great for bases, but if you want to stop people from entering or exiting something as large as a city then you want something you don't have to patrol 24/7. There is another upside to the Hescos. They are much more difficult to undermine (literally). They are relatively soft and will likely collapse any hole under them. Concrete structures don't slump and so can be undermined.
- walrus01 10y ago> I don't think I saw any concrete structures when I was in Afghanistan. Seriously? You never saw the giant prefab concrete walls around Bagram and Phoenix, and Eggers? Where were you in Afghanistan? I have been to just about every significant ISAF base (while it was still called ISAF, not RS) and US DoD base in the country, and can assure you that giant prefab concrete walls lifted into place with cranes are everywhere.
- chrisseaton 10y ago> Where were you in Afghanistan? A FOB somewhere near Lashkargah. I never went to Bagram, Phoenix or Eggers. I spent a few days in Bastion, which, as the name suggests, was also constructed from Hesco bastion.
- walrus01 10y agoI'm guessing you never saw the Kandahar airfield, because that place is full of concrete barrier walls... https://static01.nyt.com/images/2010/07/15/blogs/atwar-afghan-poster/atwar-afghan-poster-blogSpan.jpg https://static01.nyt.com/images/2010/07/15/blogs/atwar-afgha...
- AlgorithmicTime 10y agoTo be fair, KAF would look like the picture on the right when a nice big dust storm kicks off.
- _d8fd 10y ago> A FOB somewhere near Lashkargah My Google-fu thinks FOB is short for Forward Operating Base.
- ci5er 10y agoYup. For small units on the move (or operating all stealthy-like), you can airdrop a few C-containers (FOB-in-a-box) right at (or behind!) the front line and be up and ready to go in not-that-many hours.
- nawtacawp 10y agoThe title states "modern" battlefield, which I believe they are equating to a more urban enviornment -- than a outpost in Afghanistan. The use of concrete walls to segregate a city into sections is the main benefit. This article is rather anecdotal and appears to just be the opinion of the author.
- Spooky23 10y agoTraditionally with nation state opponents urban warfare is either a siege or blowing up everything in sight. With this lower intensity warfare, the army needs to reduce complexity by scoping their problems. This isn't new. That Boer war reference left out a few details... the British couldn't defeat mobile cavalry with pack howitzers, so they built fences, pillboxes and watchtowers across the countryside to restrict movement. Then they evacuated towns and villages to concentration camps and starved the non combatants until the soldiers surrendered. It's a pretty common theme used in the Indian wars and vietnam by Americans, Germans in Angola and Europe, French in Algeria, etc as well.
- djrogers 10y agoConsider the terrain - an FOB in rural Afghanistan is going to have access to a lot of dirt/sand/etc to fill the Hescos, while simultaneously not having restrictions on wall depth due to existing infrastructure. In a dense urban environment there isn't likely to be thousands of cubic feet of readily available fill material, and a 3-5 foot thick Hesco is going to be much more difficult to emplace than a 12" thick concrete barrier.
- nightcracker 10y agoIsn't Hesco basically a modern sandbag?
- walshemj 10y agoA gabion is what you are thinking of
- mcguire 10y agoI'd imagine you'd have a hard time using Hesco barriers in an urban environment. One, they're too big. Two, you'd have a hard time finding loose fill. And three, they're slower to deploy.
- rtkwe 10y agoThey mention the reason for not using Hescoes in passing in the article. In the cities there wasn't an easy source of dirt to fill them so it would have required trucking in a lot of the dirt to fill them.
- steamer25 10y agoReminds me of reinforced earth which I learned about from this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0olpSN6_TCc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0olpSN6_TCc (which is also from the pretty great Practical Engineering channel).