6 ms·
Sounds like iif it's anything that comes from one of their "Solutions" then it's NC, ND, free for private use but can't be used for anything to do with location
by pbhjpbhj 10y ago
Sounds like iif it's anything that comes from one of their "Solutions" then it's NC, ND, free for private use but can't be used for anything to do with location (eg mapping, direction finding, etc.). Pretty far from "open".
However on the legal page [2] they say it's CC-BY-SA for "Mapillary Photos [by which] we mean the publicly available street level photos."
It goes on "Attribution should include a clearly visible link to mapillary.com or to the Mapillary photo page directly. Suggested text: "Photos from Mapillary, CC-BY-SA, by @username. ".
The they say "Other photos, videos, logos, map tiles or graphic material on the site are not included in this license.". Which puts the final nail in the coffin of having any idea if a particular photo is a) provided by a solution and so not CC-BY-SA but proprietary, b) an "other photo" and so not licensed at all.
Not sure how you get to the photos without using their "Solutions" either. Prima facie it's a pretty confusing position; I've read a few copyright licenses [ie lots] in my time too.
I'd have to assume the position they're aiming for is "do what you like and if you make money or leech our userbase then we'll sue the ass of you".
This is good though:
"If you would like to use a Mapillary photo in a Wikipedia entry, go ahead and donate the photo to Wikimedia Commons. If you like, we can do it for you. Just send us an email and describe where you want to use it, and we will donate." (/legal.html, === (version 2, April 29, 2014)) //
So presumably it just needs someone to list all the photos and say "please add these to Wikimedia Commons" and all those images will be, per their agreement, released to CC-BY-SA without their specified form of attribution (as that license simple requires reasonable attribution AFAIR).
[But now we need the full legal terms to be able to tell if a "Mapillary photo" is one they created, one on their service, or something else; you'll notice it's not capitalised and so is not the same Mapillary Photo as elsewhere.]
Licensing is hard, yo.
[1] https://www.mapillary.com/terms https://www.mapillary.com/terms
[2] https://www.mapillary.com/legal.html https://www.mapillary.com/legal.html