7 ms·
See also the Intel NUC thing: http://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/nuc/nuc-kit-nuc6i7kyk-features-configurations.html http://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/n
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
See also the Intel NUC thing: http://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/nuc/nuc-kit-nuc6i7kyk-features-configurations.html http://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/nuc/nuc-kit-nuc6i7kyk...
What really astonishes me though is how you can have these really nice machines and Apple doesn't bother to update the Mac mini. Seriously, an Apple version of this would be a nice desktop.
- daxorid 10y agoI have the Skullcanyon NUC, and this is not comparable. I've been waiting for someone to offer me ECC in a small form factor. This is the first time I've ever seen it.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoI've got one of these: https://www.supermicro.com/products/motherboard/xeon/qm77/x9spv-m4.cfm https://www.supermicro.com/products/motherboard/xeon/qm77/x9... which is mini-itx. Pretty small form factor. Using an M.2 boot drive. Not very cost effective though.
- ptomato 10y agoIn the mini-itx space, there's also http://asrock.com/mb/Intel/X99E-ITXac/index.us.asp http://asrock.com/mb/Intel/X99E-ITXac/index.us.asp which is DDR4, not SODIMMS, and your choice of processor, including V4 Xeons. I have one with a E5-2680V4 + 64GB of ram in it. (128 should be feasible with 64GB sticks as far as I know, but as they're about $700 each last I checked I haven't tried it.)
- cylinder714 10y agoRight! The Skull Canyon NUC is brilliant, but the lack of ECC RAM is regrettable.
- Matthias247 10y agoJust interested: What's your use case for ECC? Do you intend to run a server on it and aim for highest stability?
- Declanomous 10y agoI'm putting money on something to do with ZFS. Turns out bit flips are significantly more common than had been thought in the past, which makes a error-correcting file system somewhat risky to use with normal non-ecc ram.
- Someone 10y agoBut if you use ZFS, chances are you will want to have lots of disk space and lots of disks, too. If so, why buy a small box?
- Declanomous 10y agoBecause you are paranoid and also have a small apartment. I have a mini-itx home server build with 16 gb of ram and 4 WD 3tb RED drives. It doesn't run ZFS because I don't have ECC ram in it, but it's the smallest computer I could buy that would fit the hard disks I already owned. If I were starting from scratch I'd probably use 2.5" drives instead, and if I wasn't working for a non-profit, I'd probably use SSDs now that they are about $.27 a gb.
- Someone 10y agoMini-itx I can understand, but this box has one drive of 1.5TB max (according to http://www.hp.com/go/Z2mini http://www.hp.com/go/Z2mini). You would have to connect any other drives externally. If you do that, the result probably takes more room than that mini-itx.
- Tomte 10y agoZFS isn't worse than other file systems without ECC RAM. It's just that it's much better with ECC RAM.
- Tomte 10y agoIn the safety industry everyone knows that bit flips (SEUs) are way more common than laypeople believe. And that's for embedded microcontrollers and RAM that aren't nearly pushing it to extremely small processes. Let me just quote IEC 61508, where "FIT" means 10e-9 h: Causes of soft errors are: (1) Alpha particles from package decay, (2) Neutrons, (3) external EMI noise, (4) Internal cross-talk. External EMI noise is covered by other requirements of this international standard. A soft error occurs when a radiation event causes enough of a charge disturbance to reverse or flip the data state of a low energized semiconductor memory cell, register, latch, or flip-flop. The error is called “soft” because the circuit itself is not permanently damaged by the radiation. Soft-errors are classified in Single Bit Upsets (SBU) or Single Event Upsets (SEU) and Multi-Bit Upsets (MBU). The soft error rate has been reported (see a) and i) below) to be in a range of 700 Fit/MBit to 1 200 Fit/MBit for (embedded) memories. This is a reference value to be compared with data coming from the silicon process with which the device is implemented. Until recently SBU were considered to be dominant, but the latest forecast (see a) below) reports a growing percentage of MBU of the overall soft-error rate (SER) for technologies from 65 nm down. The following literature and sources give details about soft-errors: a) Altitude SEE Test European Platform (ASTEP) and First Results in CMOS 130 nm SRAM. J-L. Autran, P. Roche, C. Sudre et al. Nuclear Science, IEEE Transactions on Volume 54, Issue 4, Aug. 2007 Page(s):1002 - 1009 b) Radiation-Induced Soft Errors in Advanced Semiconductor Technologies, Robert C. Baumann, Fellow, IEEE, IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON DEVICE AND MATERIALS RELIABILITY, VOL. 5, NO. 3, SEPTEMBER 2005 c) Soft errors' impact on system reliability, Ritesh Mastipuram and Edwin C Wee, Cypress Semiconductor, 2004 d) Trends And Challenges In VLSI Circuit Reliability, C. Costantinescu, Intel, 2003, IEEE Computer Society e) Basic mechanisms and modeling of single-event upset in digital microelectronics, P. E. Dodd and L. W. Massengill, IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 50, no. 3, pp. 583–602, Jun. 2003. f) Destructive single-event effects in semiconductor devices and ICs, F. W. Sexton, IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci., vol. 50, no. 3, pp. 603–621, Jun. 2003. g) Coming Challenges in Microarchitecture and Architecture, Ronen, Mendelson, Proceedings of the IEEE, Volume 89, Issue 3, Mar 2001 Page(s):325 – 340 h) Scaling and Technology Issues for Soft Error Rates, A Johnston, 4th Annual Research Conference on Reliability Stanford University, October 2000 i) International Technology Roadmap for Semiconductors (ITRS), several papers.
- jpt4 10y agoI also have the Skullcanyon, as a laptop replacement machine. None of my previous personal computers have had ECC RAM, but none have had more than 16GB either. What is your use case that benefits from error-correction, if you please?
- ianai 10y agoIt can mess up graphics work and zfs pools.
- jclulow 10y agoIt can mess up _any_ file system. ZFS is, under some conditions, more likely to _tell_ you that you've had a problem. That said, if a bit flips in the wrong place in RAM, even a checksumming file system will not protect you. The file system will happily write out the corrupted data if the checksum is calculated after the bit flip occurs.
- bzbarsky 10y agoThe #1 consumer use case that would benefit from error-correction would be not having remote exploits due to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Row_hammer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Row_hammer
- jpt4 10y agoThank you, that is a compelling argument.
- homarp 10y agothe wikipedia page says: " Tests show that simple ECC solutions, providing single-error correction and double-error detection (SECDED) capabilities, are not able to correct or detect all observed disturbance errors because some of them include more than two flipped bits per memory word." http://serverfault.com/questions/674214/what-is-the-rowhammer-dram-bug-and-how-should-i-treat-it http://serverfault.com/questions/674214/what-is-the-rowhamme... adds "ECC effectively turns the Row Hammer exploit into a DOS attack. 1bit errors will be corrected by ECC, and as soon as a non-correctable 2bit error is detected the system will halt (assuming SECDED ECC)."
- technofiend 10y ago>What really astonishes me though is how you can have these really nice machines and Apple doesn't bother to update the Mac mini. IMHO there is indeed a great deal of pent-up demand for more powerful Mac Minis. I really wish Apple wouldn't just treat them as incidental devices, but presumably there's not much incentive from their perspective since these are lower margin than their other offerings.
- ilaksh 10y agoAlso see larger but still small and powerful Gigabyte Brix UHD.
- kristianp 10y ago> an Apple version of this would be a nice desktop. It would compete with the IMac then, and with their notebooks too. Maybe Apple should charge enough of a premium for the mini to justify that loss.
- blacksmythe 10y ago>> It would compete with the IMac then, and with their notebooks too. Companies that try to avoid competing with themselves often fail quickly and spectacularly (after this approach appearing to work well for an extended time).
- djrogers 10y agoApple historically hasn't had a problem competing with itself - iPod mini - iPod nano - iPhone, each of these completely destroyed an existing product or product line.
- squarefoot 10y agoApple probably is an exception rather than a rule here; their products are so overpriced that any new product success easily makes up for previous products losses. It might be a bit different for "normal" companies though.
- orangecat 10y agoWhat really astonishes me though is how you can have these really nice machines and Apple doesn't bother to update the Mac mini. It would almost have been better if they didn't update it. The 2012 mini was fantastic; you could take it to a quad i7 and 16GB for under $1000 thanks to user-accessible RAM. For most purposes that's much better than the current $1000 mini.
- thirdsun 10y agoAbsolutely - my main computer is an iMac, which will soon be replaced by another iMac (5K), however as someone who builds and upgrades a gaming rig as well, I always look with envy towards the very affordable world of PCs. I'd love to be able to slap macOS on custom build computers for a fraction of the price that is attached to Apple hardware.