4 ms·
I consider my athletic experience in college (on a varsity team which definitely did not make money or prestige for the school) to be one of the best and most e
by jessriedel 17y ago
I consider my athletic experience in college (on a varsity team which definitely did not make money or prestige for the school) to be one of the best and most educational parts of college. Do your really think there are many programs which lose money and are doing harm to the students or the university?
I see basically two types of programs: a handful which exist solely to drive money and prestige to the university (big-time football, basketball, etc.) without regard to the tiny number of students participating, and the vast majority which are mostly focused on their primary purpose, providing a great experience for the athletes themselves.
I don't see many programs which are sucking a bunch of money away from research for nothing.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoYour athletic program did harm students - it raised tuitions for everyone. You probably got more benefit than the average tuition increase, but most students did not. Universities should not be in the habit of forcing all students to pay for the recreational activities of a select few. Incidentally, universities pocket about 50% of research money and put it into the general fund, which then gets spent on stuff like varsity sports.
- jgg 17y ago>Universities should not be in the habit of forcing all students to pay for the recreational activities of a select few. Yes, thank you. If they're going to pay for someone to play football, they might as well fund me to play Chess or Go. They could probably also fund that guy down the hall from me to play Tetris all day; I'm sure he'd be able to find something "educational" in that.
- jimbokun 17y agoHow about playing an instrument? Acting in or directing a play? Dance? Painting? Drawing? Are these recreational activities, educational, both, neither? Is competing in a sport at a high level more or less educational than these things? I read somewhere the suggestion that basketball and football players in big time programs have the option of majoring in their sport, just like a Dance, Drama or Art major might. At least it would drop the pretense that those students are doing anything else.
- jdminhbg 17y agoIn a number of schools, athletic departments are self-sufficient, so it's certainly possible the parent poster drew no general funds for his varsity sport participation. Further, your argument about recreational activities for a few can be applied to pretty much every non-class activity at a university, from theater to quiz bowl to student radio. Why single out athletics?
- yummyfajitas 17y agoActually, for the most part I do extend it to pretty much every non-class activity at a university [1]. I only singled out athletics since that is what we were discussing. As a rule, I believe the cost of non-class activities should be paid for in full by participating students, not by taxpayers or other students.
- jessriedel 17y agoAs others have stated, this argument could be applied to any university activity. Also, it could applied to high school. The universities are making the decision to encourage sports participation because they understand its value in education.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]