13 ms·
Google’s top news link for ‘final election results’ is a fake news site
- adamors 10y agoIronic that WaPo should call out anybody for being fake this election cicle. For those downvoting, read at least this: http://nypost.com/2016/10/12/how-the-washington-post-killed-bernie-sanders-candidacy/ http://nypost.com/2016/10/12/how-the-washington-post-killed-...
- JumpCrisscross 10y ago> Sanders pieces took a negative tone by a ratio of 5 to 1, whereas opinion pieces on Clinton were about evenly split between favorable and unfavorable. What is the baseline? Also, these were clearly-identified opinion pieces. Fake news doesn't identify itself as such.
- whybroke 10y agoHere is an example of the exact reason Trump voters are so mysterious: Nonsensical beliefs and faulty reasoning are deprecated (and ideally not represented at all) in any well informed clear thinking venue. Here that manifests, quite sensibly, by the downvote. And any meritocracy would eventually eliminate nonsensical views entirely. So the problem comes when a political movement harnesses nonsense while clear thinking people have systematical eliminated it entirely from their discourse. And after that movement's unexpected triumph, the clear thinkers try to understand what happened. A hard problem I would say.
- scholia 10y agoThe Trump campaign exposed some serious problems with traditional newspaper reporting, which tries to be even-handed. This is based on the assumption that presidential candidates will generally be honest, and will generally base their arguments on facts. Trump broke that convention by basing his political career (starting with Birtherism) on lies, which led to "false equivalence" in the coverage. In other words, serious reporting (as opposed to opinion pieces) treated lies as though they were truths. This could only be considered harmful. There has been quite a lot of discussion around this. See, for example: The Death of 'He Said, She Said' Journalism http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2016/09/the-death-of-he-said-she-said-journalism/500519/ http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2016/09/the-deat... Big lie, little lie, and the media’s role in telling the difference http://www.cjr.org/criticism/trump_birtherism_lie_media.php http://www.cjr.org/criticism/trump_birtherism_lie_media.php It’s Not Too Late for the Media to Fix Its Election Coverage: A final plea for sanity in how we report on Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton. https://newrepublic.com/article/136848/its-not-late-media-fix-election-coverage https://newrepublic.com/article/136848/its-not-late-media-fi...
- grzm 10y agoThanks for the links. There's also the issue of false balance (Edit: which is the point of your links, actually, so I'm just stating explicitly). I think the media, in an attempt to appear more unbiased, has been more giving air to statements which are misleading or arguably not true. Politicians have noticed this and taken advantage of it. (This is independent of actual bias in the media.)
- scholia 10y agoThings may be about to get much, much worse, because Trump is an obvious threat to America's First Amendment rights: https://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/style/our-first-amendment-test-is-here-we-cant-afford-to-flunk-it/2016/11/13/9e8722ce-a83f-11e6-8fc0-7be8f848c492_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/style/our-first-ame...
- whybroke 10y agoIncluding three tweets in a hour just yesterday strongly condemning the NYT for simply repeating his goal of nuclearizing Japan and S Korea eg [1] [1]https://twitter.com/realDonaldTrump/status/797832229800050688 https://twitter.com/realDonaldTrump/status/79783222980005068...
- grzm 10y agoI can hear the arguments now: "Of course the MSM is going to say that! They're obviously biased against Trump! They're just representing their own selfish interest!" Yup. A lot of media organizations endorsed Clinton over Trump. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newspaper_endorsements_in_the_United_States_presidential_election,_2016 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newspaper_endorsements_in_the_... I've been (admittedly amateurishly) looking for research on media bias. Research is limited by its methods, and researchers hold opinions, results can be subject to confirmation bias, so this whole area is difficult for the every day person to sift through. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Media_bias_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Media_bias_in_the_United_State... I find it hard to believe that no bias exists, and I think a lot of journalists try to be objective, with varying success. The question to me is how much bias there is, how we can keep that in mind, and how we can agree on some shared understanding of facts. It's also in the interest of these organizations to support the First Amendment. Hard to ask them to be against — or even neutral — the First Amendment, just as we'd expect for any business to support aspects of the Constitution or law that are in their own self interest (regardless of whether we agree with it). It's also in the interest of Americans in general for strong First Amendment rights. It has broad support across parties. This kind of nuance doesn't fit easily in 140 characters or support the easy "us vs them" characterization.
- treehau5 10y agoI am with you, friend. On reddit's /r/politics, there was a heavy influx of Correct The Record shills, and now that the election is over, things have returned to relatively normal there. With Bezos controlling WaPo, I have no reason to believe things are not being manipulated here as well. The only thing, and maybe good, this election cycle has done was throw out the window the small shred of faith I had in fair and unbiased reporting in this country in critical moments. They throw a puff piece, or a good piece of journalism here and there on side topics, but when it comes to crunch time -- as shown by the WaPo days leading up to the Democratic Primaries, they unleash the full weight of their propaganda machine with no remorse. The only thing I'll turn to these corrupt giants now is weather events. Can't slant those in any way. We need to break up the 6 corporations that control our media, ASAP.
- scholia 10y agoDiscrediting honest reporting has been the foundation of the whole alt-right approach to the media, and getting acceptance for the lies broadcast by sources such as Breitbart News and Drudge Report. In fact, it's essential to discredit honest reporting if your lies are going to get any traction. And, evidently, it has worked on you. Sadly, it's even worse than it sounds, because now even the alt-right websites can't tell the truth. For an interesting short piece about this, see the final section of "Donald Trump broke the conservative media" (1). Quote: One of the chief problems, Sykes (2) said, was that it had become impossible to prove to listeners that Trump was telling falsehoods because over the past several decades, the conservative news media had "basically eliminated any of the referees, the gatekeepers." "There's nobody," he lamented. "Let's say that Donald Trump basically makes whatever you want to say, whatever claim he wants to make. And everybody knows it's a falsehood. The big question of my audience, it is impossible for me to say that, 'By the way, you know it's false.' And they'll say, 'Why? I saw it on Allen B. West.' Or they'll say, 'I saw it on a Facebook page.' And I'll say, 'The New York Times did a fact check.' And they'll say, 'Oh, that's The New York Times. That's bulls---.' There's nobody — you can't go to anybody and say, 'Look, here are the facts.'" "And I have to say that's one of the disorienting realities of this political year. You can be in this alternative media reality and there's no way to break through it," Sykes continued. "And I swim upstream because if I don't say these things from some of these websites, then suddenly I have sold out. Then they'll ask what's wrong with me for not repeating these stories that I know not to be true." (1) http://uk.businessinsider.com/conservative-media-trump-drudge-coulter-2016-8 http://uk.businessinsider.com/conservative-media-trump-drudg... Edit/insert: (2) "Charlie Sykes, a popular conservative talk show host in Wisconsin"
- pavanred 10y agoWhat is the top news link, isn't part of the problem that what I see when I search for 'final election results' is different from what any one else would see, personalization, in other words?
- MaxfordAndSons 10y agoI am able to reproduce, both incognito and signed into chrome. I'm guessing it's not personalized because the actual search is short circuited by a specialized result view, with Google's own "2016 US election results" widget appearing above the search listing. Though ironically it's now been bumped to second by the WaPo article about it.
- sethbannon 10y agoWe were previously worried about filter bubbles -- that is, people only seeing true news that agreed with their worldviews. This election cycle we seem to have a rise in blatantly false news that agrees with people's worldviews spreading through social media. Everyone is talking about Facebook and Twitter fueling this problem, but it seems not even Google is immune. A healthy democracy relies on an informed citizenry, so this phenomenon is truly a threat to democracy itself.
- splawn 10y agoThis is always going to be a problem unless critical thinking becomes a skill that everyone accepts as fundamental as reading and math.
- waqf 10y agoIf the propaganda is good enough, I don't think any amount of critical thinking will save you. (For example, critical thinking has helped me to date — I believe — because it's not worth going after me as you only need 50% of the population to win an election. Just as it isn't worth trying to write a Nigerian scam email that's good enough to get me because there is plenty of lower-hanging fruit.)
- splawn 10y agoThats a pretty good point. As far as I know critical thinking is our only "weapon" against propaganda, so I hope you are wrong.
- knz 10y ago> As far as I know critical thinking is our only "weapon" against propaganda, so I hope you are wrong. Speaking up and attempting to educate people if they are buying the propaganda is another "weapon". Of course it isn't always effective but if enough people challenge someone hopefully they may reconsider.
- maxerickson 10y ago
- spiderfarmer 10y agoWhat can Google do to prevent this from happening? If Google really wants to organize the worlds information and make it usable for everybody, they have to make sure Google news is a news source you can trust. Pagerank is not going to cut it. A couple of suggestions: - prevent less reputable websites from showing up for political queries at all - ignore articles with headlines in ALL CAPS - work with a dedicated team of editors, like politifact, to give websites an honestyrank - be transparent, show honesty rank in the search results Any other ideas?
- jrnichols 10y agoA start would not let anything that is run on Wordpress or Tumblr become the top news result for something. That's where most of the spam/fake websites seem to be these days.
- treehau5 10y agoThen you filter out legitimate news websites. source: run a legitimate news site built on Wordpress.
- Nition 10y agoI assume you mean your site runs on a Wordpress back-end, but in the case of this article the dodgy 70 News site is literally running on Wordpress.com's free hosting (it's 70news.wordpress.com). I suspect that's what the original poster meant since they mentioned Tumblr as well.
- thisisdallas 10y agoBe fair I didn't read the article. Just judging by the site, the headline, and current events, I assume the problem is that the content of the page is opinion instead of fact. Ok, what's wrong with that? If that site/blog post has gained more traffic, social signals, backlinks, etc. etc than it's "competitors" shouldn't it naturally be top ranking?
- libeclipse 10y agoThat's not what the article is about. It's about misinformation; the fact that people are citing these sites and touting numbers that "prove" that Hilary lost on both electoral and popular vote.
- thisisdallas 10y ago> touting numbers that "prove" that Hilary lost on both electoral and popular vote. Which is moot point until someone can scientifically prove the person who's calculations showed Hillary losing the popular vote are indeed inaccurate, correct?
- 0xfeba 10y agoI've seen some (really condescending) comments doing just that. I thought they were on drugs or just trolls.
- guelo 10y agoIt pretends to be a fact, not opinion.
- mikeash 10y agoWhat gives you the impression that it's opinion and not fact? The article in question is making a factual claim, it just happens to be completely wrong. It's like googling "moon landing date" and the first hit is a page that sincerely argues "the moon landing never happened."
- thisisdallas 10y ago
- dougmany 10y agoI typically go to the state registrar of voters for official vote counts. Aggregating them over multiple states is hard though.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- eva1984 10y agoFake news is a hard business. Even human cannot tell whether it is true or not, if without intensive fact checking.
- ctdonath 10y agoI've been wondering about that for some months now: for all the stuff I see reported as news, I'm increasingly suspicious about how any of it comes into being as reported.
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoWhat's funny, is now this article is the top result for "final election results" on Google. :) And then the article they're talking about shows up second.
- danso 10y agoKind of surprising...as I remember it back in 2013 working at a news startup, getting listed in Google News seemed like a manual, hand-curated process. Not perfect, but frictiony enough to block this kind of crap edit: by "manual", I only know what it was like on the news outlet side. You had to fill out a form, provide a real address and phone for contact info among other bits of company info, and the wait was several days if not a week. It felt like the process one goes through when a human has to verify the info, like an iOS app.
- angry-hacker 10y agoYou still do, b t if something goes viral, the specific viral page can be shown there. I know since I run a site that had similar scenario.
- imgabe 10y agoGoogle also includes the correct election counts in a big box directly above any of the search results...
- ctdonath 10y agoQuestion is: what constitutes "correct"? The Federal Elections Commission hasn't released the official results. Google does (in light gray) mention that there's still 20 electoral votes to account for. It does not, however, give any disclaimer to the very precise looking "popular vote" count[1], which will change significantly when those 20 EVs are finally accounted for, and change again if[1] more counting occurs. A whole lot of arguing is going on over that popular vote, which indications are actually puts Trump ahead even though Clinton is authoritatively presented by Google as having more. No major site is showing Trump having the 306 EVs which he will undoubtedly have; the stalling at this point is getting suspicious. [1] - To clarify: the USA presidential election does not establish a winner from the straight count of all voters. Since we are the United States, voters in each state vote in their jurisdiction, the state decides how to handle the results, and then each state submits a set of votes (weighted by population in a way to ensure low-population states aren't invariably washed out by a dozen major cities elsewhere). We don't necessarily complete the vote count because, mathematically, there comes a point (usually) where the remaining votes simply don't matter (say, candidate T is ahead by 200,000 votes and there are 100,000 votes remaining to count) because the allocation of the state's electoral votes are provably complete (and because counting every vote usually gets pretty messy at the end; look up "hanging chad").
- ctdonath 10y agoBTW: the official results will be published here - http://www.fec.gov/pubrec/electionresults.shtml http://www.fec.gov/pubrec/electionresults.shtml
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoThey're offering up AP's count, but if the results below Knowledge Graph are fake, the best Google can offer is "trust that Google is right on the top section". Given that the first search result is so wrong, it's hard to trust Google in this regard. Also, consider Google often tries to answer questions based on text from high-ranking results. So while final election results may get you the Knowledge Graph section, asking a specific question about the election results may inadvertently cause Google to source it's answer from a bad link like 70news.
- lowbloodsugar 10y agoHilarious that WaPo is complaining about other people spreading fake news. Stealing some of their readership no doubt.
- j_bond 10y agoThere seems to be a lot of focus on the popular vote and the fact that Clinton won the popular vote but lost the presidency. But is it really useful to look at the popular vote for a close elections like this? I feel like people's behavior would change if the metric to elect the president was solely based on the popular vote. Many people that live in very red or very blue states feel like their vote "doesn't matter" and are not enthusiastic to vote. Not to mention campaigning strategies would be very different. We don't really know how the election would go under a popular vote scenario. It seem kind of disingenuous - like focusing on strikes out in a baseball game instead of the score.
- heimidal 10y agoIt is important to look at it to get a sense of how strong of a mandate the party in power should claim. Given the current statistics, it's clear Trump's mandate is particularly weak; if he oversteps his bounds, it's likely to bite him hard in his 2020 reelection bid.
- AngrySkillzz 10y agoNo one is saying that campaigns and voting behavior wouldn't change. Just that the electoral college is a ridiculous system in the first place and should be gotten rid of.
- mi100hael 10y agoI feel like I'm in the minority these days, but I personally think the Electoral College is a clever system that should remain. As large, coastal cities like NYC & LA continue to grow, they risk becoming entirely self-serving at the expense of the rest of the US. Voters in fly-over states often deal with agricultural and manufacturing issues that aren't even on the radar for voters in urban centers, so it's important to ensure the voice of middle-America isn't totally drowned out.
- Klathmon 10y agoWouldn't that be better served by reducing federal government's in favor of more local systems (like states, or even cities)?
- protomyth 10y agoI really think they need to look at what the difference between "news" and the web is. I thought news was a list of sites that I could exclude if I felt they weren't worth reading. They also have a bug with the interpretation links to snopes.com that has been reported to them[1]. I wonder if that affects any other site? I would doubt it would be just one. 1) after filling out their form on news.google.com, I posted here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12384851 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12384851
- hellofunk 10y agoI am already missing the days when all information disseminated to the masses was hand-curated by passionate, serious, intelligent professionals who staked their careers -- their lives -- on accuracy and objectivity. Those are days that went out with the internet.
- jotadambalakiri 10y agoWow, self-criticism from WaPo? I applaude that.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- w8rbt 10y agoHow do you define 'fake' news sites now after all the mainstream media outlets called the election so completely wrong? It all seems like propaganda with people trying to push their views.
- ctdonath 10y agoThere's a difference between succumbing to your own bias when seeking out & reporting news, vs willfully making $#!^ up as clickbait.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- randomgyatwork 10y agoWho gets to decide what the real news is? Like if you make a white list of legit news, then you are creating an inherent bias. What if the real news list chooser doesn't like a certain website, so they black list it? Isn't trying to control this unintentional or maybe even intentional censorship?
- xs 10y agoIt's a bias that you can trust but verify. For instance, AV software, and web filtering apps rate websites you visit with a score and could block you from visiting sites with a low score to keep you "safe". If web filtering vendor A is a competitor of vendor B or doesn't like the world view of candidate X, they could easily block you from going there. So we have to trust but verify. This is why open source is helpful so we can see the algorithm or reasons why something is blocked.
- randomgyatwork 10y agoI see the problem you are describing.... But if google or Facebook blocks something, its totally possible that you won't even be able to verify... Things will vanish forever.
- JacobJans 10y agoShouldn't blantantly false information vanish forever, or at least be pushed out of the platform? For example, the meme on Facebook that said the Pope endorsed Donald Trump. It was blatantly false; and yet it was shared over a million times.
- randomgyatwork 10y agoTruth is super subjective, plus people should be able to spread the memes they choose... It's up to the reader to decide what is real and true. If someone else gets to decide its censorship.
- danso 10y agoI guess while we're on the topic, and since it appears in the WaPo's screenshot, can someone give insight on how the hell Heavy.com is almost always at the top ofbreaking news links when doing standard Google News searches for people suddenly in the news? Things like: "John Doe: 5 Facts You Need to Know" Here's one: http://heavy.com/news/2016/09/keith-lamont-scott-charlotte-north-carolina-police-shooting-daughter-facebook-live-video-brother-officer-name-photos-reading-book/ http://heavy.com/news/2016/09/keith-lamont-scott-charlotte-n... Entirely cribbed from real news sites' coverage when it's not just innuendo. And yet when the news is fresh, Heavy.com is almost always at the top, beating out original coverage and even sites that do it much better (DailyMail comes to mind). I get that prioritized placement of proper nouns in the headline and page title can boost SERP, but this is ridiculously effective SEO-gaming, the likes which were mostly stopped when Google's Panda was thought to drastically hurt content farms like Demand Media [0] Even the article the WaPo screenshot, which is the very first link for "clinton vs trump", is just fluff: http://heavy.com/news/2016/11/popular-vote-clinton-trump-hillary-2016-2012-2008-uncounted-ballots-electoral-college-presidential-election-results-california/ http://heavy.com/news/2016/11/popular-vote-clinton-trump-hil... The first 3 lines: > There are millions of ballots that haven’t been counted yet from the 2016 presidential election. How many? The New York Times estimated on November 12 that there are 7 million uncounted ballots in the country. How is this beating actual URLs to live poling data that have Clinton vs Trump in the title? [0] http://searchengineland.com/google-panda-update-costly-112062 http://searchengineland.com/google-panda-update-costly-11206...
- 0xmohit 10y agoAI will eat the world.
- tmaly 10y agoThis reminds me a lot of Ryan Holiday's book, Trust Me, I'm Lying: Confessions of a Media Manipulator. Except that is it something that happens via automation rather than through methods listed in the book. Still the book is a good read if just to get acquainted with how one can manipulate media in this day and age.
- mikebay 10y agoEvery corporation try to hide now they hate against Trump. Sad that there is so many liars in corporate world. I Don't trust anything that Google, Facebook & Twitter is pushing. Trust issue is really understatement.
- brentm 10y agoIt is a crazy time that we live in. We have a massive group of people that openly reject mainstream news and were lead there by the now President elect. Trump spent his entire campaign crafting an alternative reality and now millions of people are all in. If he continues down this road of trashing mainstream media institutions while pointing people to his cronny owned newsertainment entities like Breitbart I am very concerned about the future. The Trump bubble has to burst eventually and I think the American's that voted for him are in for a rude awakening when it does. I just hope the fallout doesn't bring down too much of the country.
- tunesmith 10y agoI just googled for "Was there a Trump wave?" for legitimate reasons, and the top news result (second entry) was a Breitbart article next to an image of Trump with the words "Sieg Heil!" This is so upsetting.
- brentm 10y agoI noticed this on Sunday but it seemed par for the course for a Google news result. I wish they would use better signaling on any domain being returned as a news result. A domain registered less than a year ago with a link profile almost all alt-right is probably not the best source.
- ern 10y agoZuckerberg seems to be downplaying Facebook's fake news problem, and I'm not particularly optimistic about Google taking it seriously either. Software engineers are smart- software engineers who work for Google and FB especiallly so. It isn't inconceivable that they, and the people they know, are smart enough to see right through fake news, and that the idea that anyone can be fooled by fake news is probably absurd to them. Unfortunately in the real world, many otherwise normal, functional people just aren't equipped to do basic fact-checking. Just yesterday, I got a forwarded fake news meme from my uncle, about a woman who had 11 babies[^]. My uncle, in his 50s, is a college dropout and of above-average (though not stratospheric) intelligence. He is simply not equipped (along with many others I know) to deal with a world where hostile, greedy and mischievous actors are working to shape their reality. This is an example of where some diversity would help improve tech. The monoculture at the top seems to have isolated the industry from its customers and their intellectual weaknesses. [^]It happened to be a Whatsapp family group, so I was able to see the story and tell him it was fake...my FB feed is already filtered to hide that sort of junk.
- cpeterso 10y agoGoogle News allows you to tune which news sources to prefer (under Personalize > Adjust Sources). I have a long list of "news" sites that I mute. It would be useful if there was a way to export or share these lists, similar to some Twitter blocklist sharing services.
- dforrestwilson1 10y agoThe printing press dramatically changed the sociopolitical landscape of the world. Should we expect less from the internet?
- dkrich 10y agoThis is an extreme example that illustrates something that happens all the time. In this case the publisher is reported as a "fake news site" but I would argue that any publication that cites sources that are not thoroughly researched and fact-checked should be considered a fake news site. Huffington Post does this all the time- they link to their own articles and other sites' opinion pieces to make points and pass them off as legitimate fact-based sources.
- seoseokho 10y agoI think one of the issues is, unlike the printing press days, you can't unsubscribe from bad news outlet. In the old days, you'd cancel your subscription and delivery. Now your best shot is adding 70news.com to adblocker or something.
- nerfhammer 10y agoI googled "safety pin" and 50% of the top results are clickbait garbage
- 37 10y agoI googled "kardashian" and 90% of the top results are clickbait garbage
- awqrre 10y agoWhy does Google wait so long to report the real election result? They don't want to make Hillary look as bad as she did in the election?