8 ms·
MacBook Pro with Touch Bar review: a touch of the future
- alessioalex 10y agoMy potential issue with the Touch Bar is that I never look at the keyboard when I type, so if I need to adjust the volume / screen brightness I would have to change my behavior.
- mangeletti 10y agoI never look at my keyboard when I type, either. I do, however, always look at my keyboard when I adjust the screen brightness or volume, or control iTunes (pause, next, previous). The one exception to this is ESC, and I use it gratuitously.
- audunw 10y ago> The one exception to this is ESC, and I use it gratuitously. macOS has a built-in option to remap caps-lock to escape. I haven't used it yet (I'm not a VIM user, so I mostly just use it to cancel dialogs), but I've ordered the new MBP and it's the first thing I'll do. Should take care of that issue and even improve ergonomics. I should have remapped caps-lock ages ago, I never use it, but haven't had the incentive until now.
- falcolas 10y agoIf only these were actions I took more often than using the F keys for various other applications, it wouldn't bother me as much as it does currently. Honestly, I'll get over it; I'll set up other key chords to take the place of the various F keys I use today. It still bothers me that I'm the one who has to make these adjustments to support something that I have no need for. It's a short term productivity hit, combined with a long tail of annoyance as my hands use their muscle memory and will incur some random state change on my computer.
- raverbashing 10y agoSo, I guess you lose iTunes control keys while another app has control of the Touch Bar? Or maybe some controls can be global? This is a big issue in media apps
- pilif 10y agoThe controls are global. You can try it out with the Touch Bar simulator in the current XCode.
- AdventurerSen 10y agoI didn't want to make a new thread. Appleinsider's review is a lot more in-depth. http://appleinsider.com/articles/16/11/14/review-apples-late-2016-15-macbook-pro-with-touch-bar http://appleinsider.com/articles/16/11/14/review-apples-late...
- Ralfp 10y agoArs's one with benchmarks: http://arstechnica.co.uk/apple/2016/11/macbook-pro-touch-bar-13-15-inch-touch-bar-review/ http://arstechnica.co.uk/apple/2016/11/macbook-pro-touch-bar...
- blauditore 10y agoIt looks like Apple is trying to find an alternative to touchscreens just because Steve Jobs once said they're bad. For me, touchscreens are perfectly useful on laptops, since directly tapping something is much quicker than moving my hand to the trackpad, locating the cursor, moving it around and finally clicking something.
- guitarbill 10y agoI love tablets but hate touch screens on laptops. More often than not, it doesn't work that well (edit: although last time I tried a touch laptop is now 1.5 years ago). And, oh god, the smudging. It frustrates me that almost every Windows laptop with a nice screen is now touch. I assume you can turn it off, but you do pay more for a touch screen. This just reenforces my (outdated?) notion that it's a consumer, not professional device.
- slantyyz 10y ago>> It frustrates me that almost every Windows laptop with a nice screen is now touch. As someone who's just started researching to buy my next laptop, I don't find that to be very true at all unless you're only looking at ultrabooks. One of my almost-gotta-haves is a touch screen, and for any models with an HQ/HK level processor plus a discrete GPU, there only seem to be a handful of models with touch screens (and when they are there they are usually optional) at the highest end configurations.
- blauditore 10y agoI was a bit afraid of smudges too, but it's really not an issue. Under normal conditions, they're not visible while the screen is on. And when it gets too dirty, a touchscreen is much easier and safer to clean than a standard one. As a power user, you probably use the keyboard most of the time and occasionaly a single mouse operation (like moving focus somewhere). For that, it's quite intuitive to tap.
- intoverflow2 10y agoThink it's more a case that a Surface-like MacBook Pro would completely cannibalise the iPad Pro and Cook is more fond of the iPad Pro than the Mac line. The touchbar as a design decision makes a lot more sense when the brief is "Add touch to the Macbook Pro line... but under no circumstances step on the toes of the iPad Pro"
- HelloYouPerson 10y agoThis reminded me of this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZFsOUbZ0Lr0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZFsOUbZ0Lr0
- guitarbill 10y ago> I have little doubt that in a couple years, the technology Apple has been waiting for will arrive and this vision, or something closer to it, will be complete. Apple just released this machine too soon, or was too aggressive in the decisions it made. This summary makes sense to me. Luckily, I put 8GB of RAM in my Macbook Air five years ago, and it'll probably do another year. That said, does anybody use a Macbook for development? If I need to use dongles anyway, I think I could live with one port.
- phaedrus 10y agoIn fact I do use a 12" Macbook for development (C++). It does alright; certainly no worse than the 2011 13" Air it replaced. I should mention the CLion IDE makes it get hot and drains the battery unless you turn off certain IDE features. Code::Blocks does fine on it performance-wise, but initially the UI was too fuzzy to read due to incompatibility with Retina display. I can't remember if that's fixed in the latest version or if I found a work-around. I haven't tried to use XCode. My favorite thing about it is that the taller aspect ratio of the screen reminds me of older 4:3 monitors and IMO is a better layout for programming. Edit: I have yet to plug anything into the single USB-C port except the charger. I don't own any dongles. I just use WiFi and bluetooth.
- sz4kerto 10y agoAll the use cases they show would be much more intuitive on a touchscreen.
- robert_tweed 10y agoOne thing I got from this review is that the touchbar brings keyboard shortcuts to people who wouldn't normally bother to learn keyboard shortcuts. I personally won't buy one because I've very picky about my keyboards (the squashed arrow keys are as much of a problem for me as the missing escape key). But for average users, I think Apple has managed another UX win here. I just wish they had made the bar a bit smaller and kept the physical ESC key. I'm not a VIM user so don't care about frequency of use. My biggest issue is how do you CMD+ALT+ESC if an app crashes, locking up the touch bar?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- rahoulb 10y agoFrom what I read, the touch bar is a separate system, with its own processor and running watchOS - effectively a remote display - so an app crash shouldn't affect it.
- robert_tweed 10y agoI would certainly guess that the OS gets pre-emptive access to it in much the same way as it can trap system key interrupts before they go to applications, but I'm still wary until there's a lot more information available on this. Another case is what if the app decides to replace the ESC key altogether? If that's prohibited somehow then what's the advantage of removing the physical key? TBH, a separate OS sounds like one more thing to go wrong, which is also worse, not reassuring. I'm also not keen on the idea of someone remotely rooting my touch bar - also not a problem I currently have to worry about.
- rahoulb 10y agoJust read the Ars review - it looks like the bar is divided into three, with only the middle area fully under app control (the left hand area showing dialogue box controls or escape). It does say that the bar slows down under heavy load though.
- 59nadir 10y agoThere's nothing in this review that convinces me that the touch bar is improving anything. If anything, paragraphs like these convince me it's at best on par with just regular keys: > you no longer have one-touch access to brightness and volume adjustments; instead, you need to tap the button and then dial in your changes on a slider that pops up beside — not beneath — your finger. I’d be annoyed by that, but fortunately you can move the slider without actually touching it, by keeping your finger held down on the bar. It’s surprisingly inelegant, in that you end up controlling a slider that you aren’t actually touching. But it is efficient, and I got used to the new control scheme within a day, able to operate it by muscle memory the same I would a physical key. They don't seem to have integrated this themselves, even. Why introduce something that you can't even use reasonably yourselves?
- kennysmoothx 10y agoFor the power users, those of us who learn and have hotkeys streamlined into our work environment, the Touch Bar doesn't add much to us, except perhaps a new medium of fine controls (think sliders) However to the users who aren't savvy, or who don't know hotkeys, this brings controls that would otherwise be in deep within the menu bar, right in front of the user. I think that could be incredibly useful to a lot of people.
- laumars 10y agoWhile that's probably true, there used to be a time when the MacBook Pro was specifically aimed at power users. Which is likely why these features are being viewed from that perspective.
- slantyyz 10y agoThe hardest pill for a lot of people to swallow with the latest generation is that Apple has moved on from these "power users" and are selling premium mass market computers while keeping the "Pro" suffix.
- ralfd 10y agoThough I never use the function keys for setting shortcuts. Beside volume/brightness it is a largely ignored row of keys.
- mafro 10y agoSteve (quite probably imo) wouldn't have allowed this to happen! I have little doubt that in a couple years, the technology Apple has been waiting for will arrive and this vision, or something closer to it, will be complete. Apple just released this machine too soon, or was too aggressive in the decisions it made.
- wh0rth 10y agoWhile I agree with you here, I do think that using Steve Jobs as a consistent counterpoint to new Apple developments isn't always useful. Sometimes we forget that Steve was behind the Lisa and the original Apple TV. And the Magic Mouse original.
- StRoy 10y agoI'm not old enough (and certainly wasn't in a household wealthy enough to afford it at the time) to know what's going on with the Lisa, but there was nothing with the Apple Tv, or Magic Mouse. For those products, we're simply not the audience. I know plenty of casual mac users who were doing fine with those things. People in tech circles love to go on about Apple's mouse deficiencies but from my experience around casual computer users, PC users too, is that most people barely know about the second mouse button and the very concept of a "context menu" is alien to them. I keep having to remind my stepfather how to do things like copy and pasting in some apps because he always forgets about the context menu and even remembering something as simple as Ctrl+C + Ctrl+V is something he's not willing to do for a reason I can't even fathom myself, it literally makes no sense to me, it's just how it is. So, from my point of view, Apple insistence on mostly forgetting about secondary functions on mouses is the right thing. The Magic mouse doesn't have a middle click? Most people don't even know how to right click. The only thing a mouse for casual users needs to do right, is left click and scrolling and the magic mouse has perfect touch scrolling. For the same reason Apple has hidden functionality like Cut&Paste from the finder. You need to hold the option key to activate the "move item". Apple wants you to drag&drop instead. The "default" in Apple land has always been to serve the need of the common, not the expert. So there's no traditional CTRL+X CTRL+V. Instead you need to do CMD+C as if you were copying, then CMD+OPT+V to "move". Everything advanced tends to be hidden into OPT key. It also changes the behavior of various menus to show things Apple doesn't want to show to the commons. The touchbar is actually a very, very clever thing, we're just not the audience once again. I firmly believe it will never have much use among professionals who have nothing against learning many keyboard shortcut combinations or who even do things like customizing them (Karabiner to the rescue!). The touchbar is for people who didn't even use the mouse right click, and who don't understand concepts like context menu that change based on, gasp, context. It's actually going to be a boon for these people. Even exposing basic functionality like copy paste is going to help average users be slightly more productive with their devices. The only issue is the MBP audience having a lot of techies and audio/visual professionals. The touchbar would be more sensible on something like the iMac and Macbook.
- tbrock 10y agoFine, it has a new keyboard thing that you may or may not like, we are going to buy it anyway. But how does the verge not address what everyone really cares about: the CPU! The MacBook without the touchbar has a MacBook Air class CPU while the one with a touchbar is in another class. How do the non touchbar models compare with the previous air models and how do the touchbar models compare with the previous pro generation? If the CPU is mostly the same performance wise as the last generation you are better off going for a refurb of the last gen if you don't care about the keyboard thing or having the new new.
- Fluid_Mechanics 10y agoArstechnica has a more comprehensive review: http://arstechnica.com/video/2016/11/the-2016-13-and-15-inch-touch-bar-macbook-pros-reviewed/ http://arstechnica.com/video/2016/11/the-2016-13-and-15-inch... A relatively marginal increase in Single-Threaded CPU performance in the touchbar model.
- Matthias247 10y agoAs far as I have seen in some benchmarks the new non-touchbar model (with the lower TDP CPU) is as about the same speed as my last-gen (2015) MBP 13" with the 28W TDP CPU. So it's a lower speed CPU class but due to the newer CPU generation the performance is the same. You can see it in a positive way: It didn't get slower Or in the negative way: You get an actually worse CPU class for more money than the previous gen was.
- tbrock 10y agoSince the non-touchbar model has the MacBook Air class CPU and your 2015 MPB has the higher voltage pro class CPU I'd say that's quite an improvement. This years "MacBook Air" like model is as powerful as last years MacBook Pro? Money should be flying out of our wallets.
- rayiner 10y agoDoes anyone care about the CPU? In any case, Intel laptop CPUs are basically thermally limited since Sandy Bridge or even before. Skylake isn't a major advance in that regard, neither will Kaby Lake be.
- rayiner 10y agoI think the touchbar is the way to go for desktops and laptops. You can imagine Apple rolling out a touch bar enabled desktop keyboard. But touch screens are totally impractical for use when your computer is docked, which means you can't really incorporate them into your workflow. The battery life point is really depressing. Every MacBook since the original has been improving on that front and this is such a huge regression. If I wanted just 5-6 hours of battery life I'd buy a PC.
- mtw 10y agoOne major let-down for me in macbook pros is the lack of a nvidia GPU. You can't do serious machine learning on those laptops. I actually had to buy a previous-gen macbook pro I'm not sure what to do if I had to get a new laptop. On one hand, I have a few iOS projects, and on the other hand, it's always nice to run locally and quickly a few deep learning algos. The limited connections are also a let down
- drvdevd 10y agoInteresting point I had never considered, thanks. Yet another reason why I'll probably be purchasing a PC running Linux as my next laptop.
- terhechte 10y agoThere're some external GPU enclosures with Mac-Compatible Nvidia cards that connect via USB-3. None of that is officially supported, and it is expensive, but based on cursory searches I did, it seems to work for people. It's still expensive and can only be used when you're at a desk, but those are imho fair compromises. Now, I'd love for Apple to release an official external GPU (like Blazer did with the Blazer Stealth) but I highly doubt they'd do it. https://bizon-tech.com/us/bizonbox2s-egpu.html/ https://bizon-tech.com/us/bizonbox2s-egpu.html/
- jsjohnst 10y agoWith Thunderbolt 3 (via the four USB-C ports), you could quite easily run desktop class GPUs in a relatively small enclosure. There's a couple of them previously available on Amazon, but I'm sure the offerings will skyrocket after the first of the year given the new laptop.
- mrgreenfur 10y agoCons: "Touchbar needs time to grow." What the hell is growing?
- pawadu 10y agoLets not forget, it is also a touch of the past: http://www.hp.com/hpinfo/newsroom/press_kits/2008/connecting/ds_bn_6530b.pdf http://www.hp.com/hpinfo/newsroom/press_kits/2008/connecting... (not claiming the two are similar in some way, just following the idea back to where it was born) I remember when this laptop was being sold I considered it since was "small" for that time, but ended up buying something else since I didn't like the touch panel below the screen.
- cptskippy 10y agoThis is like the Creative Nomad vs the iPod. HP was first to market with everything that's in the new MBP but it's incredibly unpolished and downright cumbersome to the point that it's hard to tell that these products do mostly the same thing. This how Apple captures the market, when they release a product it's so polished and functional, and they commit 100% to it that it almost always succeeds. HP and others don't spend much time if any refining ideas, they just throw sh*t against the wall and hope it sticks.
- pawadu 10y agoAgain, I am not trying to compare the two. Just to provide some history, something tech journalists are seemingly very bad at.
- jsjohnst 10y agoThey also seem to be bad at parroting baseless claims, like faulting Apple for not releasing a processor that doesn't exist yet.
- cptskippy 10y agoI think it's a great observation about journalism and an an apt comparison. Apple rarely invents something new but they can consistently take the same box of Lego everyone plays with and build something much cooler.
- liminal 10y agoI'm using a touchscreen Windows laptop and can't imagine going back to non-touch. Windows bit the bullet and reworked their UI for touch. It cost them some time, but it seems like they are in a much better position now in that regard, than Apple.