17 ms·
Big Tech Companies Pounce as the Allure of Startups Fades
- johnm1019 10y agoI have to wonder if part of the trend is that a generation of software developers came out of college and jumped into the startup scene during its most recent run. These folks are now forming relationships and starting families, or wanting to spend more time doing not-software dev things. They are realizing that stability in your job lets you do and plan other things in your life. Given that there is no economic certainty in working for a small start up in a city with an astronomical COL, many are deciding the risk isn't worth the rewards. It's also possible that there are really large challenges being undertaken which require resources that actual start-ups with 10 million in VC can't do. Things like autonomous cars (Uber isn't a start-up anymore IMO), rocketry, aerospace, energy, foundational biology. Is it possible that many great minds see these as more worthwhile pursuits?
- adrenalinelol 10y agoInnovation is hard to come by from behemoths because it's easier to convince MBAs on squeezing labor costs and cornering markets vs. going to the moon.
- di4na 10y agoOr maybe the big names are suddenly trying to get back in the game.
- mdorazio 10y agoI think you nailed it with your first point. The startup craze (re)started around 2010. A lot of the 22 year old fresh grads enamored with the startup scene at that time are now nearing 30, have probably been burned once or twice by startups not turning them into millionaires, and are now starting families and wanting to work "normal" hours with people close to their own age. Add on the fact that most startups are located in areas that are too expensive by far to make home ownership a real possibility, and you've got a decent size demographic in the software dev space for whom big companies are starting to look more appealing.
- randomdata 10y agoI'd argue that the startup craze restarted in 2008, on growth in the mobile app market. The reason: All the money flowing out of failing housing market went straight into tech and commodities. Suddenly these startups were bursting at the seams with investment money and everyone and their brother were trying to get a piece of the pie. But now, commodities have already crashed. Money is starting to flow back into housing. It stands to reason that the easy money in tech has also left. 'Everyone and their brother' are starting to move on to the next get rich quick scheme.
- nostrademons 10y ago08/09 were terrible for startups - I had one that folded up in mid-08, and I was early. Most of the Web 2.0 generation called it quits over the next 2 years. Sept 2008 was the last time you could get easy funding until about 2010 - it was when Twitter did its big raise, then Sequoia's "RIP Good Times" presentation came out in October. The current technology cycle started in '08, and most of the really big players today were either in search mode then (AirBnB, Uber, Instagram, Whatsapp, Kickstarter, Pinterest) or were in the early phases of growth (DropBox, Heroku, YC). A lot of them didn't raise Series A until late 2010 or early 2011. I think it's fair to call that the restart of the startup market.
- amyjess 10y ago> then Sequoia's "RIP Good Times" presentation came out in October. I worked at a Sequoia-funded company at the time. It was bad... hiring ground to a near-halt, and attrition was used to shrink the engineering department. Eventually, I got laid off over a year later (February 2010), and by that time we weren't any financially better off than when Sequoia made that presentation. The reason for my layoff was because our VCs had given us less money during our Series D than we were expecting.
- jordanb 10y agoI think part of this is perhaps a shift in strategy among big non-tech companies. They used to be extremely aggressive about outsourcing and offshoring tech roles. My sense is that this strategy is changing among many of them as they come to see technology as a core profit center for them.
- dkarapetyan 10y agoThe only time technology is a core profit center is if technology is the actual business. Just because a business requires technology doesn't mean it can be turned into a profit center. Most businesses just shuffle paper but now they do it digitally. At best that's a cost saving strategy. You need something else to make it a profit center and few businesses are in a position to do so and even fewer decision makers have the willpower and foresight to make it happen at said businesses.
- Taylor_OD 10y agoI work in Merchandise Mart in Chicago home to 1871 (start up hub) and a number of large companies like Allstate, Motorola, Yelp, Braintree (paypal) and its interesting to see the shift in where people are taking job. It seems the large companies have shifted to creating new exciting teams and thus snatching up a lot of talented engineers that I have seen going to start ups over the last couple years.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoI used to work in Chicago, and the startup scene was never that great. People asked me why I left when I could've worked for Groupon or SpotHero. There is nothing innovative going on in Chicago unless you're in the financial speculation industry, and its at least well paid.
- mempko 10y agoI worked at HERE maps which has a large office (800+) in Chicago and worked on a computer vision system that processed 3D LiDAR and imagery. There are teams working on building crazy 3D tools and processing for building maps for autonomous vehicles. Its sad that nobody knows they are in downtown Chicago because its pretty damn interesting work.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoRight, but you could have done the same work remotely (fully remote) for Mapillary.com, which is using crowdsourced outdoor images to perform photogrammetry for 3D representation through their public site [1], as well as deep machine learning to tag the images for consumption by self-driving vehicles teams. Same work as HERE, but without having to be in Chicago. No point in me ever sticking out a Chicago winter ever again. Challenging, exciting work isn't geographically constrained there. * I admit this moves the goal posts a bit when I said there is no exciting work going on in Chicago. I never even knew HERE was in CHI doing that sort of work. I hope they consider remote workers in the future. C'est la vie. My beef with Mapillary is that their crowdsourced imaging license is too restrictive compared to the competing OpenStreetView project. https://www.mapillary.com/ https://www.mapillary.com/ http://www.openstreetview.org http://www.openstreetview.org
- cx1000 10y agoI agree that working at a startup for equity is akin to the lottery, but the perks of startups are so much better than big companies. Catered lunch, free food in the kitchen, kegs onsite, etc. I could never go back to a cubicle with no windows in sight!
- bpicolo 10y agoThere are a ton of big companies with good perks and no cubicles.
- Excluse 10y ago> Catered lunch, free food in the kitchen, kegs onsite etc. Pretty much every Big Co. in SV offers these perks and more. And yes, they also have windows.
- toephu2 10y agoReally? Name more than 10 in Silicon Valley (and exclude SF). I can only name a few: Google, Facebook, Yahoo, Adobe?, ... ?
- dmode 10y agoApple (free dinner), LinkedIn, SAP, WalMart, Twitter...those are the ones that come to mind. There are probably others as well.
- toephu2 10y agoSAP has free lunch? Twitter is in SF, I said to exclude SF.
- callmeal 10y agoAMD, Cisco, Apple, Ebay, HP, EA, NVidia, Netflix, Oracle, Tesla, Nvidia?
- toephu2 10y ago
- techxit 10y agoI've noticed this change as well. My fear is that the toxic startup culture (open-plan offices, Agile) will spread into Corporate America proper and make those jobs just as bad as the SV-funded startup jobs.
- quantumhobbit 10y agoOpen office and Agile are already well established in corporate America.
- techxit 10y agoAgile is terrorism for people who aren't technical enough to make bombs.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- DashRattlesnake 10y ago> Open office[s] and Agile are already well established in corporate America. Corporate "agile" is often a misunderstood and cargo-culted version* . Same with big-company open offices: An open office for a team? Probably OK. A (single) open office for 300 developers in a department working on different things? Not so much besides a recipe for noise and distraction. * My employer uses an "agile" process, it was designed by a bunch of PMs and middle managers. Team empowerment was not on the agenda.
- dang 10y agoAs we've told you many times, you're banned from HN and can't do this here. We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12950423 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12950423 and marked it off-topic.
- clifanatic 10y agoWhy in the world would this comment be marked off topic?
- techxit 10y agoDonald Trump's campaign and the Silicon Valley scene are basically the same thing: High Frequency Experimental Assholery. You try things (in politics, nasty nicknames; in business, open-plan offices and "Agile" neo-Taylorism and reduced health benefits) and use what plays and toss aside what doesn't. Just as Trump A/B tested nicknames until he found ones that stuck (regardless of their truth value) the Silicon Valley economy is one that A/B tests new ways to squeeze workers, customers, and to a lesser degree because they're savvier and more in on the game, investors. People with enough talent to comprise leverage are starting to realize that "startup" is just the new corporate ladder, but with worse health benefits and more instability. The promises of fast promotion and investor-level introductions and lucrative exits almost never come through. Within 5 years, it'll be the leftovers who remain in the venture-funded scene. Good programmers will be extremely thin on the ground. That's the good news. The Y Combinator/Donald Trump model of business is short-focused and won't survive. The bad news is that there aren't a whole lot of jobs in "regular" Corporate America for top talent either. There are a few, but most of what these large companies do is just as boring as what the VC-funded startups these days are doing.
- dang 10y agoHN bans persist across sockpuppets. No more of this, please.
- conjectures 10y agoIf I had any alicorn I'd use it to make a potion that would banish the word 'unicorn' from the English language for a decade.
- pyrrhotech 10y agoI've worked at 3 startups (~50 employees, ~300 employees and ~120 employees) and 1 big company. I'll definitely never be working at a startup again unless I own it. I didn't realize how underpaid and overworked I was until I joined the big co. Nor did I realize how narcissistic and demagogic my leadership was. Of course there were some benefits like less bureaucracy, but the pros of working at a big company far outweigh the cons.
- Cranzatz 10y agoI've worked mostly at smaller companies my whole career. Two years ago I joined a company with 4k employees, which merged with a 50k+ employee company. It's a very uncomfortable situation for me. I absolutely hate how political and bureaucratic my current company is. It's so difficult to get anything done, because of the micromanagement and second-guessing for the sake of "collaboration." It's dreadfully slow. Nearly all management has family and kids; most of my direct coworkers don't. Two are engaged, one is married with two kids. I'm gay and am not planning to ever have kids. So I have a ton of free time in comparison to my straight coworkers. My plan is to start my own company in a few years. I don't think I can tolerate an atmosphere where I can't set my own pace. I'm a pretty competitive person who likes quick results. I get the feeling I'm out of place in my current environment.
- pyrrhotech 10y agoI totally understand what you are saying. Small companies may be better for you. For me, I'm only at work to get a paycheck. I'm also a very competitive person, but that's why I want to have a strong work/life balance -- so I can have time to work on the things I want to work on, like my game (http://wizardsofzenith.com http://wizardsofzenith.com) and improving my PRs at road races. But I definitely understand if your heart is really in the work you do at your job that a big company environment would be very frustrating.
- mahyarm 10y agoThere is different kinds of big companies. Salesforce will be different than google which will be different than cisco. Some of them will be far more positive than others.
- CalChris 10y agoTL;DR Millenials are turning 30.
- sangnoir 10y agoLots of millennials are in their (early-mid) thirties already.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- hibikir 10y agoThe way startups run today and the way compensation is often structured just makes startups a bad deal economically in the best of times. Imagine for a second that you become employee 10 in a new startup that you believe in. You dedicate it 15 hours a day for 5 years, everything went awesome, and now the company is worth 5B. Your stock options would be worth millions in case of a liquidity event. Great, right? The thing is, it's 5 years later the company is probably 300-800 people now, and therefore is a very different company than the one you joined, and if it's still growing, it's be a different company still next year. But there's no liquidity event: You cant exercise your options because you can't pay the taxes. If you want to exercise anything, the company has to go public, and you sure don't control that. So you either wait in a job that probably doesn't fit you anymore, or your stock compensation was worth nothing. Therefore, whether the startup does great or not, you have to apply the 'I might want to quit' discount. If I am assuming 8 years to IPO, which is not insane that discount is going to be huge by itself. I'd not rate my chances of staying in a job for 8 years as 1/10. And that's without considering that, career wise, you'll be learning more changing jobs every couple of years or so. Let's compare this to a public company: Their stock compensation has none of that complexity, especially now that RSUs are the way to go. You can sell them for cash immediately at the stock price that day. The downside is minimal, and chances are your first block of shares comes after one year, so if you hate your job, you sit there a year, sell your shares and quit. Given how much stock the bigger companies are awarding developers, you have to completely ignore compensation to go to a tiny startup: You kind of have to bet in the world around you changing to make exercising options early to be more or less free, along with believing that the startup will go the distance. Those are odds I'd not take
- benmathes 10y agoYes. Nobody who understands the risk-adjusted rewards of startups does it for the money. Best odds of getting rich? Go work at Google and bank your check/bonus. At best, startups are a faster way of getting experience. [1] Employees don't even know they are making that bet, though! Most don't even know the details of what they are getting, let alone how to evaluate it. I've been working with AngelList to help fix this, much more coming very soon. [1]: http://startupljackson.com/post/135800367395/how-to-get-rich-in-tech-guaranteed http://startupljackson.com/post/135800367395/how-to-get-rich...
- ryandrake 10y ago> “It does me no good to get rich when I’m 45 when I’m 30 now,” goes the thinking of many prospective hires these days, he said. That’s helped him make some hires out of companies that would have been tough to recruit from a year or two ago, including Uber and Airbnb, he said. This part doesn't make sense to me. Wouldn't it be the opposite? Doesn't the "want to get rich now" crowd prefer the start-ups and the "want to get rich later" group prefer the larger, stable companies? (Spoiler: Chances are, neither of these groups are going to "get rich", sorry.) The people that big companies ought to be going after are the ones who TRIED to get rich early, ended up holding worthless lottery tickets, and are content to toss them away for a little stability.
- werdna123 10y agoI agree. I'm starting to think this Bloomberg article is a puff piece
- pm90 10y ago> The people that big companies ought to be going after are the ones who TRIED to get rich early, ended up holding worthless lottery tickets, and are content to toss them away for a little stability. Why? Broad generalizations really don't help here. Here is a counter: Its likely that people who have worked at BigCo's are better at working with their bureaucracy, they know that they won't get immediate results but understand the system and are willing to work with it to get things done. So they are more likely to succeed in that environment.
- poof131 10y agoI recently made the jump from startups to bigger co. For me there were a few considerations: 1. We’re at the end of a bubble and doing a slow pop. Multiple companies that have raised a lot of money don’t have the revenue or unit economics to be sustainable. Employees with compensation tied up in stock aren’t going to do well. Had a friend leave two companies within 6 months (didn’t bother vesting) that both raised over $100 million because the executive teams were celebrating $900 deals. 2. Startups don’t exit anymore. Waiting 8-10 years for an exit is unacceptable. It might be okay for founders who take a couple million off the table at the B round or VCs who keep the IRR on their books, but for employees it’s a fail. 3. Founders as rockstars. The narrative is hurting the industry. People I like and respected raise money and become narcissistic assholes. Last founder I worked for who I considered a friend told me “he was like Elon Musk or Larry Paige, a technical genius, and not to question his leadership”. This was after he fired his cofounder and chased off the one other employee of our seed stage startup. 4. Risk vs. Reward. As an employee with founders trying to keep 50% of the company to be like Zuck, companies never exiting, and no idea what the terms of later rounds are, working at a startup is becoming stupid. Saying it’s about the mission, it’s about learning not earning, when the VCs and founders are doing great is disingenuous. We’re at the end of the cycle. I’ve seen 3 now: 2001, 2008, 2016. Hopefully in the next round the powers that be will figure out how to better reward everyone who takes risk working at startups. Right now employees take almost as much risk as founders for much less reward.
- ryandrake 10y agoWow, great comment. You've put to words a lot of what now keeps me away from start-ups. It's no longer "probably financially rewarding" to be employee number 30. Seems like in earlier cycles (1990s and before), the cream was spread much more evenly among the people taking the career risk, where now, it's almost entirely captured by founders and investors.
- sulam 10y agoThe cream has never been evenly spread. It likely never will be, although it could be improved. In order to evenly spread it, you have to be able to measure contribution. Good luck with that. Previously VCs got most of the cream, founders got to ride out the public markets for their pay day, and early employees had to hope they were working at a Microsoft.
- Yhippa 10y agoLet's say that startups do indeed become less attractive as time goes on. Do coding bootcamps prepare their students for jobs at BigCorp?
- vanadium 10y agoGiven the stacks at BigCorps (at least here in Chicago), I would say "it depends". Working in an enterprise environment where everything is older and battle-tested, probably not, given most of the camps gloss clean over the details, opting for training against the MEAN stack or variants thereof as far as front-end options go, that would enable someone coming out of these camps to hit the ground running. It'll be an interesting observation to see if that comes to pass, but insofar as I'm concerned, they're training front-end students for startups building platforms.
- hiou 10y agoLaunchcode certainly does[0] [0] https://www.launchcode.org https://www.launchcode.org
- Yhippa 10y agoThis is the first time I've heard about this but I really like what I'm seeing based on what's on the site. This sounds like a really good way to get the candidate you need if you're a BigCorp. I wonder what the acquisition cost of going through Launchcode is vs traditional channels?
- bdcravens 10y agoI'm not convinced they prepare them for startups.
- sfaf 10y agoAs a coding bootcamp grad, I agree. I think bootcamps are better for mid to large companies actually where you will get mentorship and processes to help you graduate from being an apprentice to a contributing member of your team. Many of my bootcamp colleagues at small stage startups regretted the decision.
- sulam 10y agoI love how this article manages to contradict itself completely in the space of two paragraphs. Paraphrase #1: Salaries at startups aren't very high, without considering options. Paraphrase #2: Yelp is having to raise compensation to compete against startup job offers. Past the very early stage, the first statement is untrue. I sincerely doubt that Uber is paying less base salary than GE. Certainly it is in the ballpark -- because every well-funded startup out there (there's a lot of them) pays "market rate" which nets out to "we match salaries for everyone except Google employees."
- pj_mukh 10y agoYea, I was confused by this narrative. Startups are raising so much money but they are paying lower salaries than the big cos. Where is that money going?
- werdna123 10y agoAlso, the "Bloomberg startup barometer" graph does not match its own title...
- pm90 10y agoI don't think its a contradiction: every tech company has to raise salaries to get talent, including startups. But the total compensation may be lower by startups. Uber/Yelp are no longer startups. I think the article is referring to companies much earlier in the life cycle.
- maxlamb 10y agoYelp was founded in 2004, Uber in 2009 - they are not startups anymore. I think the statements are still holds true if we consider startups new companies that are less than 4-5 years old.
- megablast 10y agoHe is suggesting that people are taking a wage cut to work at startups, because of the chance of a big payout later on. Yelp has to pay a lot more, not to beat their startup salary, but their expectation of a big payout.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- samfisher83 10y agoThis is just like the early 2000s. I bet you could write this same article in 2025.
- bdcravens 10y agoMost of the commenters here seem to think it's a dichotomy. There's many small, bootstrapped companies, where you can do some cool things tech-wise.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]