10 ms·
How Green Is That Grocery Bag Ban? (2014) [pdf]
- swampthinker 10y agoDoes anyone have a link to the full study they cite about litter? They only citation they have is a memo brief, and that graph raises some serious questions about methodology. Namely, tobacco products accounting for 32% of all litter. It seems like they made a cigarette butt equivalent to one plastic bag, which is not a fair comparison environmentally or visually.
- hammock 10y agoThis whitepaper is from 2014 and is still just as true. The great garbage patch is also a myth, perpetuated by a fake photo that usually runs with the story in the news. They banned plastic bags in Chicago. The thin ones. All that happened was now every store gives you a free "reusable bag." These new bags are the same bags as before, but thicker. They are not reusable bags. So in this town it's very clear the regulation was a net negative on reducing plastic consumption.
- fragsworth 10y agoIn L.A. we've had a ban for a long time. The thin bags are banned, so they are all thick bags now. And stores are also required to charge at least $0.10 per bag. Everyone I know just pays for the new thicker bags. It's $0.30 for three bags on a $100 grocery bill. The real annoyance comes from people not knowing exactly how many bags they need, and usually guessing too low (not wanting to be wasteful), so the baggers take longer trying to figure out how to squish everything in the bags... and sometimes the customer has to pay an extra $0.10 if they need another bag. Which gets them to dig around for a dime. This probably slows down checkout lines by a significant amount (10% or so?).
- lettergram 10y agoMy friend and I estimate an extra 45 seconds at every checkout for this stupid tax. I say this because they always ask (regardless if you brought your own bags) if you want new bags and it'll cost $0.10. Couple that with the fact on average people visit three stores per week, make an average of $60/hour and that there are roughly 7 million people in the bay area and you get this bag tax costing the bay area an estimate: $15,750,000 per week in lost productivity from wasted time at check outs (.75 minutes per checkout X 3 times per week / 60 minutes per hour) X $60 an hour average salary X 7 million people To me the tax is insane and doesn't help the environment. It just got voted on and passed too. Just force paper bag use, and the environment would be cleaner. Simple, it'll save the economy and do more. I realize this seems like an (and is likely a slight) over estimate of the cost. However, you can do it yourself, we waste a lot of times due to this.
- maxerickson 10y agoWhy do you wait 40 seconds to say no?
- lettergram 10y agoI don't it usually on average it takes me roughly 10-15 seconds to have the interaction: "Do you want the bags? That will be 10 cents" "Ugh, yeah - give me three please" Then occasionally I screw up and need another. Or the bag rips because I have too few. That takes like an extra 4 or 5 minutes plus money. Plus if I'm doing it on an automated machine there is usually a lot of lag. Regardless it's not just the 15 seconds for me. There is a rough average of 2 people in line ahead of me so: 15 seconds for me + 30 seconds for others ahead in line
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- bronson 10y ago> That takes like an extra 4 or 5 minutes plus money. An EXTRA five minutes? That also sounds very unlikely. Maybe time yourself with a stopwatch next time? I think you'll be pleasantly surprised.
- fragsworth 10y agoIn some cases, the burden could affect business owners more than customers, if they open more checkout stands to account for longer delays to maintain a similar level of service.
- jonknee 10y agoYou could also just bring your own bags...
- WillPostForFood 10y agoIt is worse than that, because now there is often an awkward sharing of responsibility where customers start to pack their own bags, then stop to pay, and the cashier/bagger isn't sure whether to take over, and usually doesn't
- mturmon 10y agoAlso in LA. The main thing I notice is people bringing their own cloth or plastic bags into the store. I have not noticed the "dig for a dime" thing. People do spend more time fitting stuff into their bags.
- oneplane 10y agoSo you have people that work at a store doing nothing else other than putting stuff people bought into bags?
- alkonaut 10y agoThis always blows my mind about the US shopping. Baggers. And greeters. I fail to understand how there can be any unemployment :D I self checkout my groceries (the scanning and payment as well as the bagging). Normally I interact with zero people while shopping for groceries. High payroll taxes and near 0% cash use makes it a natural direction to go. I bag the groceries in the store so that costs no extra time at checkout.
- abootstrapper 10y agoI understood the "great garbage patch" is not an actual island, but more of a vast stew of what is essentially plastic plankton. Mostly invisible to the naked eye, certainly not solid, but probably more environmental toxic than a mythical plastic island. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Pacific_garbage_patch https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Pacific_garbage_patch
- WillPostForFood 10y agogoogle "great garbage patch" and note the misleading photos of visible trash that will accompany just about news report or blog post.
- corysama 10y agoOK. The photo is misleading. I still consider a continent-sized patch of dense plastic particulate cause for alarm even if it doesn't photograph well.
- hilop 10y agoThe "misleading photos of visible trash" are even more trash in the ocean , in addition to the miles and miles of plastic particles.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- DSMan195276 10y agoInteresting - do they at least give you less of the "reuseable bag"s? On that note, whenever I've seen these bans I always assumed they worked similar to what Aldi's does around where I live (And I presume everywhere): They have no bags at all, and simply have things like discarded boxes that you can use to carry your food out with. You can purchase an actual reusable bag, but besides that there are no bags. That said, I can see how that might be tough for stores with more customers, and in places where you may be carrying your food a ways and not just to your car. Being from a suburb in Ohio I can't say I know tons about living in Chicago ;) But the setup does work well over here and absolutely decreases the number bags. Aldi's is the only one that does it though.
- swehner 10y agoIs it true or is it reactionary drivel? Come on.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 10y agoNot in Chicago but I re-use the thicker bags.
- mercer 10y agoInteresting. Here in Holland they banned the free thin plastic bags everywhere a while ago. To buy a plastic bag of any kind costs about 10 eurocents. Judging from my own behavior as a rather lazy consumer and from observing the people around me, it seems to have been pretty effective. Most of the people around me bring a bag to the store and personally I buy many fewer 10c bags these days.
- abreu 10y agoBasically, this "law" is more effective in some cultures than others.. (My wife studied in .nl long enough to adopt some Dutch habits, and now she demands I bring a bag every time I go to the store.)
- cerebellum42 10y agoPretty much the same situation in Germany. That paper really only applies to the US, in Europe the whole shopping culture is so different it's hardly comparable. Starting with the fact that Europe is much less car focused, which leads to more trips with smaller amounts being bought each time. The more condensed European cities lend themselves to that kind of behaviour, since the trips are going to be pretty short and likely to be made on a bike, walking, or using public transport. From my experience, I would estimate maybe 20% of checkouts include a 10c bag, the rest just use their own backpacks, cotton bags or the reusable sturdy kind of plastic bags. I don't even know when I last saw someone buy multiple 10c bags to carry their groceries.
- detaro 10y agoAnd when going shopping with the car: put everything back in the shopping cart, take the cart to the car, load everything in the car (e.g. in boxes in the trunk), 0 bags and 0 carrying needed.
- Someone 10y agoThere's an EU directive that states that countries must work towards decreasing the use of disposable bags. How they do it is up to them, so you will find various solutions, from outright forbidding them to requiring some payment. AFAIK, you still can get free plastic bags if they are part of necessary packaging, for example on farmer's markets. EU Directive: http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CELEX:32015L0720&from=EN http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CELE... says: "Member States may choose to exempt plastic carrier bags with a wall thickness below 15 microns (‘very lightweight plastic carrier bags’) provided as primary packaging for loose food when required for hygiene purposes or when their use helps prevent food wastage."
- gorhill 10y ago> All that happened was now every store gives you a free "reusable bag." ... They are not reusable bags. I don't get it. How do these "reusable bag" look like? This is a typical reusable bag we use where I live: http://imgur.com/a/GLT0t http://imgur.com/a/GLT0t I myself I've had these bags for probably more than 10 yrs (paid $1-piece at the time), and I still use them.
- hilop 10y agoNot every bag regulation was as stupid as Chicago's
- ajkjk 10y agoHow do you know it's true? What about the numerous objections in this comment section?
- officemonkey 10y agoWashington, DC has 5 cent fee for a store-supplied bag. You can still get one, but you get to make that choice.
- Kenji 10y agoIt's a classic case of environmentalist authoritarianism backed up by emotional arguments from bored politicians. That's why I oppose green parties so harshly despite caring a lot about nature and environment.
- exodust 10y agoThrowaway mentality on a global scale is not good for the environment. Re-use and recycle is good for the environment. Would a "see spot" diagram help? The conclusions don't mention that banning plastic bags is meant to be one contribution towards fixing our throwaway culture, not the silver bullet that saves us all. Pointing your finger at some report and rejoicing "see, we can keep throwing plastic bags by the millions onto landfill, the PDF says we can!" is not "caring about nature". Opting for products with less packaging is a good thing to do for the environment. Maybe buy more things in bulk. Avoid those stupid little individual tubs of yoghurt. Avoid 600ml bottles of water. Avoid that 250ml latte cup... I'm sure you can think of others if you try.
- callinyouin 10y agoSorry, but I don't buy that you care "a lot about nature and the environment" if you oppose environmentalism in general. We do a lot as human beings to harm the environment, and climate scientists generally agree there is a point of no return that we're heading towards. I'd cite a source or two, but we all know there are plenty of sources and by now you're either going to believe the overwhelming evidence or you're going to live in denial. Even if that were not the case, pollution in general is and has been visibly harmful to a number of ecosystems - oil spills, smog, etc. have an obvious negative impact on humans and animals alike. If you cared about the environment as you claim you do you would not oppose efforts to lessen the damage we do to it.
- Kenji 10y agoIf you cared about the environment as you claim you do you would not oppose efforts to lessen the damage we do to it. I don't oppose efforts to lessen the damage. I oppose efforts that do not change the damage in any way, shape or form, or efforts that impose large costs at little or no benefit at all.
- dbg31415 10y agoTL;DR: Banning bags has no measurable benefit. Conclusions Proponents claim that banning plastic shopping bags will benefit the environment. Yet, as this study has shown, there is very little empirical support for such claims. Indeed, the evidence seems to point in the other direction for most environmental effects. Some of the alleged benefits are simply false, such as the claim that eliminating plastic bags will reduce oil consumption. An assessment of the San Francisco ban on plastic bags suggests that while there may have been a very small reduction in the amount of litter generated, some emissions—such those of greenhouse gases—may well have increased as a result of the ban. At the same time, concern about the environment is only one of many issues affecting consumption choices. When it comes to shopping bags, the look, feel, and—likely most important for the majority of consumers—function are very important. HDPE plastic bags are strong, light and highly convenient (there is no need to remember to take them along when shopping, since they are supplied by the store). Also, they are typically reused for various purposes. These features have made them very attractive to consumers. By contrast, reusable NWPP bags are bulky (causing inconvenience when shopping), must be washed between shops if they may have come into contact with harmful bacteria, and must be remembered prior to going shopping (making them far less convenient); moreover, households using NWPP bags will typically purchase more garbage bin liners. In spite of widespread media attention to the largely false claim that plastic bags are environmentally harmful, bans on the use of plastic bags are not popular: A recent Reason-Rupe poll showed that 60% of Americans oppose plastic bag bans, while only 37% are in favor. Opposition is non-partisan, though it is stronger among independents (64%) and Republicans (71%) than Democrats (52%). Environmental groups that really care about the problem of litter, such as Keep America Beautiful, have generally promoted solutions that substantially reduce the amount of litter generated, such as public information campaigns focused on litter reduction, and facilitating clean-up operations. In other words, they target littering behavior, which is the actual cause of litter, rather than opposing the existence of certain types of product that might become litter. Meanwhile, environmental groups that really care about the protection of marine animals know that litter is not the prime culprit of diminished marine life and generally focus on other issues, such as policies that promote overfishing. Unfortunately, policymakers have been cajoled into passing ordinances that ban plastic bags. That is bad news for consumers. It is also bad news for the environment, since the public has been misled into believing that by restricting the use of plastic bags, the problems for which those bags are allegedly responsible will be dramatically reduced. As a result, they are less likely to undertake activities—such as reducing littering and supporting policies that would lead to better protection for marine animals—that would actually benefit the environment.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- londons_explore 10y agoThis research is valuable, but the quality of this paper seems rather lacklustre. Do research well or don't do it at all. Don't publish an un-peer-reviewed paper with the phrase "is parroted by" in it. The scope is too wide considering the research it draws from - pick a sub-topic like "plastic bag restrictions effect on tonnage of plastic recovered from street surfaces". Drawing a chart of "number of bag bans"? Really? We could make that down to one if we just outlawed it nationwide. It isn't a sensible thing to measure. I really want to see this research done well, but sadly this isn't it.
- CalChris 10y agoThe Reason Foundation is funded by the Koch Family Foundations and David Koch sits on its board of directors. Koch Industries includes plastics manufacturing. http://reason.org/trustees_and_officers/ http://reason.org/trustees_and_officers/ http://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php/Koch_Family_Foundations http://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php/Koch_Family_Foundations There is no disclosure of these facts in this report.
- wool_gather 10y agoI recognize the importance of skepticism about sources of information, but why would a paper like this need to specifically "disclose" one of the board members of its publishing organization?
- oxide 10y agoIt seems like a conflict of interest, IMO. This is very much a political topic. When you take into context where the funding came from, the "research" presented in this abysmal paper looks a lot more like a wolf in sheep's clothing.
- azinman2 10y agoEspecially since the Koch brothers use their money to sway policies.... and effectively at that.
- Simaramis 10y agoI have thus far failed to get an answer from anyone as to what the revenue of this tax, albeit tiny, is being used for. As it stands it just pads the grocer's bottom line. Whereas it should be used to fund research and protecting the environs. But everyone is mum. At least in California.
- CalChris 10y agoIt isn't a tax. It's a minimum price. The money goes to the grocer. The bill also required a 10 cent minimum charge for recycled paper bags, reusable plastic bags, and compostable bags ... http://www.ncsl.org/research/environment-and-natural-resources/plastic-bag-legislation.aspx http://www.ncsl.org/research/environment-and-natural-resourc...
- ZeroGravitas 10y agoIt the UK most shops donate it to charity.
- Simaramis 10y agoI have thus far failed to get an answer from anyone as to what the revenue of this tax, albeit tiny, is being used for. As it stands it just pads the grocer's bottom line. Whereas it should be used to fund research and protecting the environs. But everyone is mum. At least in California.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 10y agoThis is from reason.org, which would have pre-conceived notions about such a ban.
- pjlegato 10y agoThis is an "ad hominem fallacy." The attributes or beliefs of the entity making an argument are entirely irrelevant to whether the argument is correct. The argument must be evaluated solely on its own merits.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 10y agoWhat's your analysis on the phenomenon of people believing Onion articles?
- pjlegato 10y agoThey've failed to analyze the merits of the article sufficiently. They are, in fact, committing the "ad hominem" error -- they see what appears superficially to be a trustworthy news site, and they believe it unquestioningly, based on the supposed authority of the source, rather than independently evaluating the claims being made.
- barrkel 10y agoFrom the Irish perspective [1], when the bag tax was introduced in 2002: it was promoted as an anti-litter measure. By that metric, it was successful: plastic bags went from 5% of litter to less than 1%. This paper talks about the Irish experience but not from an anti-litter perspective, rather looking at how total plastic bag usage shifted. And it's definitely true with a bag tax in place, you need buy more bags, because they don't accumulate through grocery purchases. But that wasn't what the tax was for. And of course it raises revenue in a way that is easy to avoid if you're motivated, so it is naturally progressive. [1] http://www.marlisco.eu/The_plastic_bag_levy.en.html?articles=the-plastic-bag-levy-ireland http://www.marlisco.eu/The_plastic_bag_levy.en.html?articles...
- internaut 10y agoI veer in the direction of libertarianism but I can't refute the effectiveness of that tax. It works. In place of plastic bags the supermarkets put their good used boxes at the head of the store and I can handily truck my shopping away in one of them. That then winds up at the recycling center later on, and in the worse case scenario of it being chucked outdoors by someone cardboard is biodegradable. It is true that buying a 'bag4life' would emit more CO2 and extrude more plastic net but that wasn't the real issue since those effects are marginal. The amount of litter did reduce. Now I would like to see us implement the German approach to bottles. They pay people money to collect them, I think it is 25c per bottle, and this has been very effective at keeping them off the streets as well as putting some money into the hands of those who could do with a bit of cash. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ElYT8SMl-qI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ElYT8SMl-qI I reckon on this being cheaper than hiring more street cleaners and cleaner machines so I view it as using a market mechanism.
- amalcon 10y agoThis comes from reason.org, which immediately should raise everyone's suspicions, but it's pretty well written and organized. We can evaluate it ourselves, and since I find my city's ban pretty annoying, I thought "Why not?". Section 2.1 disagrees with the notion that plastic bags consume lots of natural resources by quoting someone who claims that they consume a lot of oil, and disagreeing with him, saying that they are made from mostly natural gas. This is just silly: technically they're not wrong, but their argument is only compelling if you for some reason believe that natural gas is a less valuable resource than oil. Section 2.2 starts off well, citing a study saying that HDPE bags aren't actually that big a component of litter overall. Point in favor there. They also cited the same study to demonstrate that plastic bags aren't that big of a storm drain problem. It goes downhill from there: the section on the marine ecosystem basically consists of them disagreeing with more reliable sources without actually citing any evidence. Then, it for some reason goes into a discussion of the Pacific garbage island, which seems irrelevant. That section turns around at the end, proposing a better way to reduce litter and citing a successful example of such a program. Section 2.3, on whether or not restrictions on HDPE bags actually reduce waste. The first section establishes that plastic bags aren't that big a fraction of landfill waste: This is the beginning of a good argument, but to complete the argument they would need to show that bag restrictions have cost larger than that small benefit, and they did not do this. Landfill decomposition: This is a good argument, +1 point here. Section 2.4, Global Climate: The life cycle analysis in section 3 does a good job of supporting the argument that plastic bags don't significantly contribute to climate change. Section 4 cites various anecdotes about the long term effectiveness of bag restrictions. There are only six such examples cited. That suggests cherry picking, since there were many more such examples even two years ago. This section does also reiterate the previous good argument that an effective plastic bag ban wouldn't help that much if at all with greenhouse emissions. Further on, in section 4.6, the document tries to make the argument that bag restrictions are expensive, but the numbers they describe seem similarly small to the damage described in section 2.3. While completing the argument, it doesn't actually make it compelling. The health argument is one I've heard a lot, so I won't try to address it here: that argument is all over the place. Overall the document makes some good points, some suspect ones, and some irrelevant ones.
- 99_00 10y agoCan't speak to this study, but now I have to buy plastic bags to line my garbage cans instead of reusing the ones stores give me. All in all I still throw out fewer bags.
- ZeroGravitas 10y agoDid the bags not have holes in the bottom to avoid children suffocating? If they did, would you not worry about fluids leaking out of the bin?
- 99_00 10y agoI don't put liquids in the bin. Food scraps are composted. I also used store bags to take my lunch. Does anyone not reuse plastic bags?
- gruez 10y agoI literally never encountered a grocery bag that has holes intentionally punched in. I do, however see them in product packaging.
- DanBC 10y agoThere's some drive to have them put in as a small suicide prevention measure. In the UK a few supermarkets had holes in their free bags. I haven't checked the new paid bags.
- dawnerd 10y agoHere in Portland we use paper bags. I have a nice pile of them that I use for holding recycling. There's no cost per bag either. More cities should go this route.
- WillPostForFood 10y agoYou'd need to show paper bags are less impactful than plastic before knowing whether to recommend them.
- TulliusCicero 10y agoPaper decomposes relatively quickly; plastic takes forever. This is already well known.
- Someone 10y agoForever? Depends heavily on the plastic. Plastic bags also are lighter and less voluminous, making transport of them to the customer (at first sight) less polluting. Paper bags also may see fewer reuses than plastic ones. The question whether paper bags are more environmentally friendly than plastic ones is not an easy one to answer. Most discussions on this I have read conclude you should bring your own bag, rather than single-use plastic or paper bags.
- dawnerd 10y agoWhen I lived in Socal and got plastic bags from target they all ended up in the trash because there wasn't recycling for them available nearby and I wasn't going to drive way out of my way to do it. Here I've been using the bags at least once again, and they always end up in recycling. The city even recommends using them for yard waste and other compostables as the bags are perfectly biodegradable.
- BobCat 10y agoPlastic grocery bags are now made to photodegrade. I guess this is not well known.
- douche 10y agoPlastic grocery bags are a disaster, purely from a utility standpoint. I really miss the days of the brown paper bags; you could fit as much in one paper bag as in four or five plastic bags, they were rugged enough to actually hold up, and you could compost them or use them for kindling.
- abalone 10y agoArguments shouldn't be disqualified based on their source alone, but at the same time they shouldn't be accepted just because they appear academically rigorous, have charts, etc. This comes from Reason which is a right-wing think tank funded by the Koch brothers and Exxon Mobil, among others. So, definitely some close examination is needed before accepting any of their conclusions. Have any of us taken a close look at the arguments contained within? I noticed that on page 44 where it finally gets into the meat of the argument in environmental impacts, it actually noted that given the projections of San Francisco's office of the comptroller, the ban actually has positive effects. Then it constructs its own "scenario 2" under which is would have negative effects. And then as far as I can see it never argues which scenario is valid! It just jumps to a conclusion later on (p56) that things are "uncertain" so a ban is therefore "irrational". That just smacks of propaganda draped in the clothes of academia. For some counter arguments see: http://mediamatters.org/research/2014/10/08/californias-plastic-bag-ban-myths-and-facts/201064 http://mediamatters.org/research/2014/10/08/californias-plas...
- BobCat 10y ago> For some counter arguments see: Personal experience - every single bag I get from the grocery store is used again to dispose of garbage. Doesn't everyone do that? Making me buy garbage bags is much more wasteful.
- dwaltrip 10y agoNot everyone does that.
- arawde 10y agoI do the same thing, but... grocery store bags are pretty small. I would imagine you would need to use a number of grocery store bags to hold the equivalent amount of a black drawstring bag most people use. I also use a reusable bag for most my grocery shopping. I know a number of people who use cloth bags. I do know there are programs which seek to collect plastic bags and recycle them, but I've never actually looked into what they are being used for. If you feel like your contribution of recycling grocery store bags is meaningful, I don't think you should stop.
- Zigurd 10y agoOnly one comment here mentions visual pollution. I've never seen paper bags snagged on a barbed wire fence. You can see plastic bags on fences a mile away. Much worse than cigarette butts.
- blondie9x 10y agoGo to Austin, go to SF, go to West LA. Plastic bans are already banned. Go to Orange County CA go to Mexico City go to Shanghai. Plastic bans are allowed. Compare. Latter cities have cleaner streets no bags on streets, in trees, hooked on fences, on the beach, in the water, etc. These bans work and it is evidence of how stricter environmental regulation or taxes are effective to prevent man from hurting man. Or man to hurt the nature he and his posterity depends on.
- justcuz 10y agoThe horrible risk of reusable tote bags was recently covered on the cartoon We Bare Bears in the episode "Tote Life".