5 ms·
Who thought making decent autonomous cars was going to take as long as 2020? I mean for regulations etc maybe, but not for the tech. Earlier this year I expecte
by sp332 10y ago
Who thought making decent autonomous cars was going to take as long as 2020? I mean for regulations etc maybe, but not for the tech. Earlier this year I expected it to be done later this year.
Edited for clarity (I hope).
- kyberias 10y agoWhat "it"?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dingo_bat 10y agoIn general, people tend to overestimate technological advancement in the short term.
- sp332 10y agoThat's kind of the opposite of the point of the article.
- ghaff 10y agoMany people. And I still don't expect to see general-purpose (secondary roads/cities, range of weather conditions) for decades.
- 60654 10y agoThis exactly. I did robotics in the late 90's and it's interesting to see how many fundamental problems still remain unsolved. And the trajectory of tech advancement is positive for sure, but not _nearly_ as fast as popsci and marketing articles suggest.
- revelation 10y agoNot to mention that, since you did robotics in the 90s, there might just be another point where the entire field of AI falls off a cliff, again.
- ghaff 10y agoOn the one hand, I'm inclined to think not. Having said that, I do wonder if the rapid improvements (and sometimes impressive results) in certain narrow domains are misleading a lot of people to assume that all that's needed is continued incremental improvement. As a case in point, while voice recognition has indeed gotten quite good with the right kind of microphones (e.g. Amazon Echo), the natural language processing and other "smarts" to use that as a basis for even a subpar by human admin standards digital assistant seems to still be reasonably far away. And that doesn't even require interfacing with the physical world.
- trashtoss 10y agoIt happens a lot. Hard problems are rarely just one hard problem, but until you solve the first hard sub-problem you won't even know what the other hard sub-problems are, let alone what proportion of difficulty each contributes. It's like climbing a mountain in the fog: you've found the way forward and if it holds out you can extrapolate when you will reach the top, only to find you dead end at the face of a sheer cliff...it will be awhile before you find the next way forward. It's progress but the destination remains further than it seems.
- ilaksh 10y agoWhat fundamental problems remain to be solved for self driving cars?
- sushirain 10y agoVehicle detection: detect any vehicle, even from the side, even if its shape is rare, even at dark, etc. This could be solved with data. Control: when to yield, without watching the face of the other driver, etc. Edge cases: obeying a police officer, yielding to an ambulance, cooperating with other cars.
- petra 10y agoWhy would secondary cities be an issue ? They seem big enough to incentivize mapping costs.
- ghaff 10y agoI was referring to secondary roads (not limited access) and cities generally. Sorry I was unclear. Major cities would actually seem to be the bigger challenge than smaller ones in general. Detailed and current mapping will likely be a necessary part of fully-autonomous systems at least initially. But there's nothing especially difficult about doing that mapping. It's just a question of economics.
- maaaats 10y agoAs someone not living a place with huge, straight highways with perfect asphalt, I haven't seen anything making me believe it will be generally available soon. Right now I'm in the mountains. Narrow, icy roads. Thick snow fall, making some of the sensors already available unreliable. The Google approach is to map everything before hand, and mostly easy conditions. Tesla somewhat more general, but still not too difficult roads. Volvo has been the only one I've seen with something that might tackle these issues.
- sp332 10y agoAudi had a car that would drift up Pike's Peak years ago. http://www.autoblog.com/2015/02/16/stanford-audi-tts-thunderhill-video/ http://www.autoblog.com/2015/02/16/stanford-audi-tts-thunder... Ford is making headway on snow and rain http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-3399315/The-driverless-car-cope-SNOW-Ford-vehicle-blizzards-tackle-slippery-corners.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-3399315/The-d... Last I checked, this was mostly a sensor problem. The dynamics of driving in slippery conditions is pretty well-studied.
- vic20forever 10y agoOne thing I hope the engineers are addressing: Google Maps recently directed me down a cobblestone street that required me to slow to a crawl. If an autonomous system attempted to maintain the speed limit on that road, I'm not sure the car would make it without anything being broken.