3 ms·
My guess is that we've been approaching this from a moral standpoint (human rights, freedom of speech, etc) but those arguments have never budged China. If you
by joe_the_user 10y ago
My guess is that we've been approaching this from a moral standpoint (human rights, freedom of speech, etc) but those arguments have never budged China.
If you are ignorant on the subject, why not learn before randomly speculating?
I have only read moderately on the subject of China but I am certain the Chinese are aware of the argument that free speech offers economic benefits and many people have made that argument in fact. The Chinese government isn't interested in moral appeals but it is unlikely they're engaging these policies just to spite us for being moralistic. There's no reason to drop a moral approach since does put some pressure on China's image in the world. The Chinese have explicitly decided that security trumps economic opportunity and moreover they've learned that security can protect the interests of Chinese Internet firms.
- lunaru 10y agoWhich part am I ignorant about? The guess on our approach? I'm not in the closed doors conversations between our foreign policy leaders and China's and neither is anyone else, so we can only guess that's how we've been approaching it. As for the part about whether moral arguments have ever swayed China -- there's no ignorance there. They set their policies independently of moral lobbying. That's clear to everyone. Even now with the shift in China's policy on climate change (for example), that didn't come from outside pressure but rather internal pressure from the Chinese population. My point is that China is more likely to engage in conversation about selectively opening internet access to the West on economic terms rather than moral terms.