7 ms·
In College and Hiding from Scary Ideas
- vonklaus 10y agoNytimes should be banned from HN. It is paywalled and the information is dubiously sourced, if even true. This is not an acceptable source of news nor fact.
- hiou 10y agoSeriously? You have gotten to the point in your extremism that the New York Times, one of the most respected news sources in the entire world is not factual to the point it should be banned. How did the country seriously get to this point?
- vonklaus 10y agoI am on mobile, however I will amend with sources. The NYT dileberately held back stories and pushed forward the views if the Clinton campaign. If you accept that wikileaks emails are authentic, you can not accept NYT as legit. Maybe we can assume it was incompetence that their polling numbers (85-15) we wrong, and that is subjective admittedly. I personally feel this too was intentional. Edit: not to mention, like most media, it cant serve over https because of advertising refferers. How Their Polling Numbers Changed: https://twitter.com/wikileaks/status/796209661456347136 https://twitter.com/wikileaks/status/796209661456347136 How the HRC campaign used media to influence RNC and promote weakest candidates: https://twitter.com/wikileaks https://twitter.com/wikileaks Op Ed on why Wikileaks isn't whistleblowing: http://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/05/opinion/what-were-missing-while-we-obsess-over-john-podestas-email.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/05/opinion/what-were-missing-... here are some screencaps of various media companies front page and politics pages: http://imgur.com/a/v2huv http://imgur.com/a/v2huv I have to find the actual links to the wikileaks NYT stoiry placement emails, but this at least points out the narrative that was being crafted and why I dislike NYT. The fact that they were part of the reason we had Trump v. Cointon is enough for me to drp them. Trump & clinton are terrible people and the media (namely NYT) is the reason this was even possible.
- dominotw 10y ago>one of the most respected news sources Trump only has 20% chance of winning. Dow is going to tank a million points on Trump victory.
- vonklaus 10y agoI am no trump supporter, but their coverage was borderline dangerous. In the best case, wildly incompetent. Worst: bought & paid for propaganda. Hint: the receipts are in podesta & abedin's seized emails
- ashearer 10y agoIf they predict a 20% chance of rain, and it does rain, that doesn't show dishonesty. The second point needs a citation.
- rdiddly 10y agoIt does if rational interpretation of solid evidence led to a forecast of 70% but instead they reported 20%.
- ashearer 10y agoThat's the question then--is it the case that any rational interpretation of the polls gave an actual forecast of least 70%, and the NYT lied? The parent seemed to be saying that election's outcome alone proved that the 20% number was not only wrong, but dishonest on top of it. You need some more ingredients to prove either of those things, though.
- dominotw 10y ago>that doesn't show dishonesty. https://wikileaks.org/podesta-emails/emailid/4213 https://wikileaks.org/podesta-emails/emailid/4213 Not disclosing the 'veto' in the article is pretty dishonest. don't you think? Running 20 front page anti-trump articles everyday and no criticism of Clinton doesn't show any dishonesty?
- 10y ago
- makomk 10y agoIt's possible that respect isn't entirely earned - indeed, even that their own reputation caused the New York Times to get an overblown sense of its own importance: http://deadline.com/2016/11/shocked-by-trump-new-york-times-finds-time-for-soul-searching-1201852490/ http://deadline.com/2016/11/shocked-by-trump-new-york-times-...
- weberc2 10y agoIt's not paywalled, you just need to authenticate. Not the best, but not paywalled either.
- aaronchall 10y agoI was blocked. Felt a lot like a paywall to me.
- vonklaus 10y agoOn mobile I think it is a paywall.
- ipnon 10y agoIf the New York Times is not an acceptable source of news then I'm the President-elect.
- vonklaus 10y agoThis is the same stupid shit as the election. My point is that there is apparent proof of dubious tactics in the wikileaks disclosures, their failure to call te election polling close, and the immeadiate dismissal of the comey announcement. You can disagree with this evidence, but telling me "you feel" im wrong isnt intellectual.
- st3v3r 10y agoSame with you feeling you're right. And I cannot trust any wikileaks sources, so unless you've got something else, I don't see you backing up your argument.
- vonklaus 10y agoI havent double checked, however I believe the same batch came from the US State Dept
- majormajor 10y agoIt sounds like we're reading different NY Times regarding how they covered Comey's announcement. Immediate dismissal? And there was a world of difference in how the NY Times or Guardian covered trump and how "new media" liberal echo chambers like Vox or Huff Post did. Polling is hard and pretty much everyone was wrong on it, and we don't even know if it was "wrong" wrong or just on the wrong side of the margin of error... Shit happens. I will withold judgment on your wikileaks claims until there's specific links to look at.
- iainmerrick 10y agothere is apparent proof of dubious tactics in [...] their failure to call the election polling close I just want to address this one point. I think it's just untenable to imagine there was some big conspiracy to skew poll numbers in Clinton's favour. Why would all the pollsters fall in line, why wouldn't anyone break ranks and leak the story? It would be a huge story that would sell a ton of newspapers! The pollsters were mostly wrong, but they were fairly close, only a couple of points off. Just about everybody (notably the Princeton Election Consortium) was way overconfident, with the exception of FiveThirtyEight who gave Clinton a 70-30 chance over Trump. That's not a bad guess given the final result. FiveThirtyEight never claimed to be correcting anyone else's bias, they just clearly stated their reasons for thinking the result was very uncertain. It's a shame nobody else followed their lead but you can bet they will next time round. The one big outlier was the LA Times poll, which consistently put Trump ahead, but they put him way ahead, so they were actually one of the less accurate polls in absolute terms. It will be really interesting to see what caused that overall ~2% polling miss, but I would bet a large sum of money that it wasn't "dubious tactics". The worst we should accuse the media of is overconfidence. (For example, a few left-leaning outlets accused FiveThirtyEight of gaming the system in Trump's favour; that just makes them look stupid in hindsight.)
- bpodgursky 10y agoI agree that the NYTimes should no longer be viewed as a neutral source; that doesn't mean that articles cannot be taken for what they are, often intellectual interesting and well-researched. Refusing to read articles from left or right leaning sources on principle is ironically the point of this article.
- st3v3r 10y agoI don't get this argument against "paywalled sources". Do journalists not have the right to try and get paid for their work? Do you enjoy getting paid for your work? Why aren't you working for free for me?
- willvarfar 10y ago(Re paywall: use the "web" link above to bypass) Re sources: You propose we don't read this a article on education because they didn't back your candidate? Please.
- pyrophane 10y agoThe reason the Times is important isn't because their reporting is perfect, but rather because of their commitment to good journalism. They have made numerous mistakes in my lifetime, but they have generally owned up to them and tried to address what they did wrong. That is pretty rare today. On top of that, consider the important work they have done just recently on things like arbitration agreements, how the wealthy exploit tax loopholes, the exploitation of immigrants at NYC nail salons, and Amazon's corporate culture, to name just a few. Those are all significant pieces of investigative journalism that have made us much better informed about issues we wouldn't know nearly as much about without the hard work at the Times.
- iplaw 10y agoThis article is from March 2015, and shows that the writing has been on the wall for quite a while. The "safe spaces" movement is a plague, and I am sick of it. I hold extremely diverse viewpoints which span the political spectrum. Socially liberal and fiscally conservative. How can liberals claim to be accepting of all viewpoints but, in reality, only accept those that align with their pseudo-personal-Utopia outlook? It's bonkers. There is no right to not be offended. There is no right to not be uncomfortable. Welcome to real life, where you must be resilient to criticism and offense and countless other negative occurrences and feelings.
- cam_l 10y agoAre you offended by the idea of safe spaces? (you have no right to this) Are you offended by people acting on their ideas? (you have no right to this) Are you offended by people acting on their ideas impacting other people? (you have no right to this, umm.. wait, maybe you do) Would you prefer that people carefully segregated their ideas to certain places to avoid impacting on (or being impacted by) other people? (oh fuck, the world is complicated eh?)
- fnovd 10y agoI don't have a problem with safe spaces. To me, they're like office break rooms. Sometimes you just need a minute to disengage. But, if you're spending your whole day in there, I'm going to question why you show up to work in the first place.
- kayone 10y agothe problem is when you try to make the entire university campus a "safe space"
- Pigo 10y agoI think it sets a bad precedent, and fosters unrealistic expectations for when they leave. Most universities have counselors and psychologists you can talk to, for free, if your struggling with something. Bubbles and kittens don't help actual victims of violence.
- samsolomon 10y ago> I don’t see how you can have a therapeutic space that’s also an intellectual space. College should be a place where your beliefs should be challenged. If we've learned anything, echo chambers are strong and becoming stronger. The only way to combat that is with adversity.
- st3v3r 10y agoWhat if that belief is that you're fine being an LGBTQ person, and the "challenge" is from people who believe that you shouldn't exist or have the same rights as others?
- Miner49er 10y agoIf you believe you are right then why can't you simply disagree with it, rather than hide from anything that _might_ be a "challenge"?
- munin 10y agoBecause if you disagree with it you get your face bashed in?
- Pigo 10y agoDo you really? Then you call the police. The fact that these topics can't be discussed without escalation to violence (or people assuming it will lead to violence) should be troubling to everyone. In the free market of ideas, you win or lose by the merits of your ideas. If you're just spouting racism and bigotry then you will lose, and everyone will ignore you. But even then, there's no need for violence.
- 50CNT 10y agoThat's just plain violence and already illegal. You also have the right to defend yourself in those circumstances, and you don't need to have that kind of discussion all by yourself. I think some states go as far as letting you shoot your attacker, stand your ground laws and all. Cutting off communication between groups doesn't prevent violence. It creates echo chambers that allow them to drift further and further apart. At some point, the only way they can communicate is violence.
- 11thEarlOfMar 10y agoI am 50+ and this whole safe space movement is really perplexing. No, people should not be subjected to hurtful circumstances, but at the same time, they are a fact of life. Being a world citizen is a dicey proposition, and my gut reaction is that further insulating ourselves is the wrong way to go. I can't imagine how a military comprised of soldiers who have grown up in this movement can be expected to deal with the events of war. If a person is truly emotionally wounded and sensitive to common messages from typical life events, they should be afforded therapy so they can cope.
- tormeh 10y ago>world citizen Unsure if I understood you right, but being a world citizen requires a thick skin. It involves, by definition, dealing with other cultures' nasty bits without complaining.
- 11thEarlOfMar 10y agoBasically, yes. But more along the lines of the terrible things that humans can do to one another and the possibility that those things are brought to us. We can't all just run to safe spaces and hide.
- ipnon 10y agoI am 20+ and this trend seems to indicate that people are growing decreasingly familiar with traumatic experiences in their lives, which also seems to indicate a general increase in average quality of life.
- CaptSpify 10y agoI wonder if one could liken it to allergies. Your body is so insulated from bad things that your immune systems kicks in when it's not needed. This trend seems similar, as it seems to me that those who have had real and damaging traumatic experiences need these safe-spaces less than those that have had pseudo-traumatic experiences. I have no statistics to back this up, though, and would welcome evidence in either direction.
- st3v3r 10y agoNobody is hiding from "scary ideas". They're hiding from the fact that other people flat out believe that they shouldn't exist.
- tellitasitis 10y agoSo, if the schools and universities are turning out large numbers of people unable to cope without their "safe spaces" how long before society as a whole starts to atrophy when these precious snowflakes start taking their place in positions of authority or management?
- AWildDHHAppears 10y agoWhen the Left is in charge, they become bullies: Intolerant of any opposing viewpoint. This is part of the reason behind the election result.
- Pigo 10y agoIt's sad that this is old news now. But I'm sure the people who started these universities are still rolling in their graves. These free-thinkers celebrated civil discourse, and built universities to foster the marketplace of ideas. As iron sharpens iron, so one person sharpens another.
- solidsnack9000 10y agoIt is the same inclination to shut out the big bad world that is driving the religious right.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- nofinator 10y agoHas there been any empirical research done on this? Whenever this topic comes up on the Internet it is very charged and full of assumptions. I suspect that the creation/utilization of safe spaces and trigger warnings is actually rather low in a country with almost 14 million students in higher education.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- teh_klev 10y agoFrom last time around: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9245862 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9245862
- dorkrawk 10y ago"What will they do when they hear opinions they’ve learned to shrink from? If they want to change the world, how will they learn to persuade people to join them?" This seems like an important quote for those who are sad/disappointed/angry about the US election results.
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoThis is pretty key. To persuade someone, you have to understand what they believe, and why they believe it. When you approach a conversation with "the other side is stupid/backwards", their response will be that YOU are just stupid/backwards. One of the things very few partisans seem to want to admit right now, is that the other party is NOT just a bunch of hateful people. That both parties are made up of humans who, for the most part, want to make better lives for themselves and others around them. Mostly people who want to make this country a better place, but obviously disagree on what that "better place" looks like. And those beliefs are built on their life experiences, both what they've been told and what they've been through. And that one person shouting at them and telling them they're wrong isn't going to magically change that. And trying to invalidate their lives by going after their social class or their "privilege" isn't going to help anyone, and is tone deaf to the fact that people at all levels of class experience the same emotions, the same level of panic, fear, and trauma.
- rdiddly 10y agoIn other words, everyone reaches their conclusions because of reasons that are understandable. This is exactly what gets shut out when people resort to "othering" people they don't understand, out of laziness.
- a_lihu 10y agoWhy safe spaces? Diazepam doesn't work anymore? It seems there is an urgent need of psychiatric facilities around or in the campuses.