5 ms·
Anecdote time. A couple of weeks ago, my neighbors asked me for some help with their printers. Their wifi printer had suddently stopped working, then they boug
by gpderetta 10y ago
Anecdote time.
A couple of weeks ago, my neighbors asked me for some help with their printers. Their wifi printer had suddently stopped working, then they bought a new one (which of course costed less than a ink cartridge) which also didn't work.
After the initial shock of dealing with windows 10 (I hadn't used windows, especially a home version, for years), I found out, by plugging a cable, that the printer actually worked just fine. Checking the wifi router admin page showed that the printer was correctly connecting to the network.
At that point I suspected firewall issues. The Windows firewall control panel was disabled claiming to be managed by the antivirus. I looked at MSE, and it was also disabled. I asked my neighbors and they said that they had been using MSE but McAfee had somehow appeared recently on their computer (possibly sneakingly installed by some unrelated application).
And of course McAfee was there, already demanding protection money. I uninstalled it after clicking through dozen of scary popups warning that the computer would be overwhelmed by viruses, my bank account emptied and my identity stolen.
Immediately after that a popup appeared from Windows system tray telling me that my computer was unprotected and I should install Avast immediately. I quickly got rid of that only for yet another popup to appear (for some AV that I had never heard of).
Eventually I managed to get rid of all AVs, re-enabled MSE, and suddenly the printer started working again.
I think MSE should really just treat every other AV as malware, although I'm sure MS would get a lot of backlash.
- arkitaip 10y agoThis is part the AV/FW vendors fault, part Microsoft's fault. Yes, on Windows the security products are too often as nasty as the malware they claim to protect you from but Microsoft has failed to design a sane security experience that works with legit 3rd party vendors. Currently on Windows 10, it's surprisingly difficult for "normal" users to know if av/fw are available by default and how they work. How the built-in security works with 3rd party solutions is more confusing, even for power users.
- patates 10y agoI've lived through and heard about this so many times that it stopped being an anecdote for me a long time ago; it's just how hostile most of the 3rd party AV applications are. They, IMHO, should be given no system access and should only be allowed to implement something like IsHarmful(s DataStream) (bool, string) - maybe a little more and that's it.
- CapacitorSet 10y agoThe thing is, modern antiviruses rely on context to classify data as malware or not. It is fine if antivirus.exe is trying to remove itself; not so much if it is being removed by calc.exe.
- sp332 10y agoIt's much more useful to look for suspicious behavior than to try to classify streams of data as "harmful".
- markatkinson 10y agoMy parents Windows laptop came with a free copy of McAfee, which rendered it COMPLETELY useless. That is not an exaggeration. It wasn't a fast laptop but it should be able to browse mails and Internet. It couldn't. After Uninstalling the AV software it was like I had replaced the HDD with an SSD. I will never ever use any 3rd party AV software. It's just glorified bloatware as far as I'm concerned.
- mjevans 10y agoI'm upvoting because I agree that, in my experience, you get no more than what you pay for in relation to anti-virus. Those free AVs and ones bundled by mega ISPs? Prepare to pay in computer resources, and even then your protection is probably only mostly adequate. The only true anti-virus is awareness and user education. Risky behavior and unwise reactions to suspicious emails are the two infection vectors that secure software can't stop.
- zeta0134 10y agoThis has been my consistent experience with McAfee in particular. I worked for 4 years in low level tech support, fixing computers for people that were sold in retail. We were required to recommend Anti-Virus software to our customers, and the whole store consistently recommended Webroot (which we sold) not because it was particularly good, but because it was the only option we had that didn't slow the machine to a crawl. Replacing McAfee with almost anything else on the market felt like it doubled the machine's speed. I personally haven't run antivirus software for years on my own machines. I recommended that all of my customers learn basic security practice instead, and reminded them that the antivirus program they used is there as a tool to help them, and not a replacement for safe browsing.
- PaulHoule 10y agoTo be fair, kaspersky is better than the others. It screws up hour machine much less than most av programs.
- eitland 10y agoMine too. Mother-in-law called because she could connect to Internet. Turned out McAfee was just demanding their protection fee. So: McAfee bad. Cannot speak for Kaspersky, haven't used it for years. Defender is OKish. But one that I sometimes recommend is Vipre from Sunbelt Software. My builds are slightly faster with it and on one occasion it took down an infection that no other AV I tried managed. (Of course this can just be because the malware writers didn't care to code in resistance to it but then again it supports Kasperskys claim that diversity is good.)
- NetStrikeForce 10y agoI like anecdote time! When I was very young I had this job where I would go to people's houses to repair their computers. What I would often find would be computers so slow to the point of being unusable. After a few months I'd realized there were only two scenarios here: - Computer full of spyware. CleanUp / Restore and anti-spyware + anti-virus installation would often work wonders for the customers. - Computer running Panda Antivirus. Uninstalling Panda and installing Avast would always work wonders for the customers. Best thing was when they've asked how I solved their problem so quickly and I replied "uninstalling Panda". "But I paid for it" would be their response, to which I would follow up with a "call them and get a refund". Anti-virus, what an interesting industry!
- sireat 10y agoThe funny thing is that Avast which used to be my go to choice for the past 5-7 years has gotten quite bloated and intrusive as well. They even bought/merged with AVG which was quite annoying 10 years ago. So MSE it is for friends/relatives. I miss the days when one could run the virus scanner once a month and not have it always be on. In fact some of my Win7 computers behind NAT I run without any active anti-virus.
- stinos 10y agonice anecodete as well: http://stackoverflow.com/search?q=is%3Aanswer+avast http://stackoverflow.com/search?q=is%3Aanswer+avast not all of them are bad, but there sure are a lot of them along the lines of 'disabling/uninstalling Avast solved the problem'
- s_kilk 10y agoSame deal with my wifes machine. We just backed up her documents and gave it the ol' nuke-n-pave treatment. I can't be arsed dealing with that crap.
- devopsproject 10y ago> Anecdote time This isn't an anecdote. This is life for many, many users.
- seiferteric 10y agoI really think desktop computers are too complicated for the average user, and MS should move to a managed application model like apple is doing. Only apps approved by MS will be allowed to install UNLESS you disable this in the control panel somewhere with ample warnings. MS Could then force these companies to clean up their acts.
- paulryanrogers 10y agoWhile practical this creates instant monopolies.
- pryelluw 10y agoI had a similar issue with my dad a year ago or so. Solved with a chromebook.