9 ms·
It's unfortunate that it's like this, but I automatically do not believe any scientific breakthroughs that come from China. There has simply been too much frau
by ars 10y ago
It's unfortunate that it's like this, but I automatically do not believe any scientific breakthroughs that come from China.
There has simply been too much fraud for me to believe anything they say.
http://www.sciencealert.com/80-of-the-data-in-chinese-clinical-trial-is-fabricated http://www.sciencealert.com/80-of-the-data-in-chinese-clinic...
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoUtah had cold fusion, anyone remember that? Fusion research is tricky to evaluate (and false positive results are common).
- duaneb 10y agoA default position of skepticism works in both cases.
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoSure, we have to be careful about these things. Replication is key, which is where the Utah results fell down quickly. Not sure why I'm getting down votes on parent, but there it is.
- duaneb 10y agoPeople downvote the smallest things. I've found it's not as much of an obstacle to continuing the thread as you might think; certainly compared to, say, any moderately popular subreddit.
- Godel_unicode 10y agoI suspect it's your unequivocal use of the word "had". All we know for sure that they had was one unreplicatable experiment which has since been shown to be deeply flawed in both execution and observation.
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoIt was a big scandal at the time (late 80s), and a cautionary tale shared quickly with us Utah phd students. Cold fusion is (or was) synonymous with research break throughs promoted too early that are later found to be BS.
- dghughes 10y agoYou have to admit a bubble imploding and heating up to nearly 20,000C is pretty amazing even if it isn't fusion.
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoSure, I will be more excited when it is independently replicated as any science of this type should no matter where it comes from.
- kobeya 10y agoIt was replicated. It just was found to be an interesting result of cavitation, not fusion.
- fooker 10y agoIn a few decades, when most of the new inventions will start coming from China, this attitude is going to be very difficult to maintain.
- sbmassey 10y agoWhen.
- maxander 10y agoIt is quite possible that most of the new inventions will be coming from China, and also most of China's scientific production will be rubbish. China has been great with scaling up its scientific community, but the problem of establishing an academic culture of scientific honesty is harder.
- TheSpiceIsLife 10y agoI'm a bit confused by this comment. Are you implying that "an academic culture of scientific honesty" is something the non-Chinese world has but China doesn't? I'll concede it's probably a matter of degree.
- wastedhours 10y agoEspecially on the front of medical trials, a recent Chinese government probe found 80% of data used was falsified [0] [0] http://www.rfa.org/english/news/china/clinical-fakes-09272016141438.html http://www.rfa.org/english/news/china/clinical-fakes-0927201...
- Gigablah 10y agoSounds like a better track record than Theranos to me.
- kobeya 10y agoYou are demonstrating awareness of the point being made: if scientific fraud was as rampant here as it is in China, Theranos wouldn't even be remarkable and still unknown. But it is in fact rare enough to cause scandal. If you want to keep that attitude and make non-contributory quips, go back to Reddit. It is not appreciated here.
- narrator 10y agoThere was a reddit AMA in 2011 where a guy went to China and got stem cell treatments for his paralysis[1] and could walk now. Nobody on Reddit believed him. They basically spent the whole AMA trying to tell him it didn't happen. Then America did it 2016 and everyone was like "The Future is here and we did it first!"[2]. No, the future is already here, it's just not evenly distributed, or maybe it's already happening somewhere in China. 1.https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/k1hts/i_am_a_28yr_old_american_who_went_to_china_to/c2h3lm6/ https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/k1hts/i_am_a_28yr_old... 2.https://www.reddit.com/r/news/comments/2jvllq/a_cure_for_paralysis_world_first_as_man_with/ https://www.reddit.com/r/news/comments/2jvllq/a_cure_for_par...
- joering2 10y agoReminds me of the story of a young boxer from my gym. He eventually became very popular and gotten a World Kickboxing champion title. HE was very humble and trained at our gym all the time. There was this guy that challenged him few times over the span of his title and every time he endup KO the champion. So it was funny watching him being an undisputed champion on the TV, yet knowing he got beaten to KO few times by someone who hasn't been boxing professionally or did not make a career out of his box..
- debt 10y agothere's zero evidence in 1. that he 1) had paralysis 2) went to china 3) got stem cell treatment.
- sbierwagen 10y agoYou seem to have some cardinality issues in your numbering there.
- bdcravens 10y agoHe was listing points in reference to link #1. Don't see an issue.
- espadrine 10y ago
- akiselev 10y agoDo you automatically disbelieve everything coming out of Europe, the United States, or any other country that carries out scientific research or has a regulatory framework for medicine? If you don't believe in the ability of China to run a life and death regulatory agency without systemic fraud, what is your reason for trusting their journalists? It took only a few minutes to track down the original source for this claim to an article by the Economic Information Daily [1]. I don't speak or read the language but Google Translate did a pretty good job: the CFDA (Chinese FDA equivalent) report was neither made public nor shown to the journalist and the article is based on "an anonymous source within the agency." Putting aside the reliability of the source, according to the article their definition of fraud includes omission of adverse reactions and other clinical data. I'm sorry to break it to you but no other medical regulatory agency on earth is much better. There have been no conclusive studies on omission of data in clinical trials in the US or Europe so for all we know 100% of their trials fall under the definition of fraudulent used by the SFDA. This is a problem the FDA is painfully aware of because of their very public failures, like Rofecoxib (Vioxx), which were due to clinical data withheld by pharmaceutical companies. Regulations for mandatory reporting were only enacted by the FDA in 2008 and since then the system has been plagued by fraud driven by our top institutions [2]. Without access to that report and the raw data, the article is classic FUD. The same problems are systemic in agencies like the FDA which has nearly a century more experience regulating drugs than the CFDA. [1] http://www.chinanews.com/m/sh/2016/09-09/7998783.shtml http://www.chinanews.com/m/sh/2016/09-09/7998783.shtml [2] https://www.statnews.com/2015/12/13/clinical-trials-investigation/ https://www.statnews.com/2015/12/13/clinical-trials-investig...
- necessity 10y agoI do.
- chriswarbo 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nullius_in_verba https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nullius_in_verba
- ChuckMcM 10y agoThat is an unfortunate place to be in. Generally the question is what is said vs what is not said which can often provide the extra color commentary about how surprising the breakthrough actually is. So for example, they have a "file" photo rather than the current apparatus. One of the challenges everyone is working on is "apparatus erosion" in which containment causes parts of the assembly to become, well, more plasma. Then there is energy output, not a lot of details about how much energy they were getting out vs how much they were putting in. Running for 60 seconds should make possible a number of fairly accurate measurements of their efficiency. This is important because it is "easy" to make non-net energy plasmas that last for a long time, it is "hard" to create a plasma that providing the necessary environment for fusion to occur. Here is a great description of "H mode" confinement : https://www.euro-fusion.org/glossary/h-mode-h-regime/ https://www.euro-fusion.org/glossary/h-mode-h-regime/ which discusses that it is suceptible to ELM's (or bursts of plasma out of the side that eat away at your tokamak :-) As a result of what they do not say, and do not show, I think the term "breakthrough" is probably a bit over used here, more like "progress along the path of building a tokamak unit." And progress is good, you learn new things with each step.
- moogleii 10y agoTo be fair, fraud in Western research is prevalent as well. http://www.reuters.com/article/us-science-cancer-idUSBRE82R12P20120328 http://www.reuters.com/article/us-science-cancer-idUSBRE82R1...
- moogleii 10y agoTo be fair, fraud in Western research is prevalent as well. http://www.reuters.com/article/us-science-cancer-idUSBRE82R12P20120328 http://www.reuters.com/article/us-science-cancer-idUSBRE82R1...
- verroq 10y agoThere's significant differences between journals of medicine (and traditional chinese medicine) and journals of physics. Just like there's a significant difference between psychology journals and physics journals.
- johnwheeler 10y agoI wasn't aware of that. Their companies have the same problem with financial reporting when they're listed on U.S. exchanges. By default, you're supposed to be (extra) skeptical. https://www.sec.gov/news/press/2011/2011-123.htm https://www.sec.gov/news/press/2011/2011-123.htm
- Paul-ish 10y agoIt is hard to fault people in that area of the world for turning to folk medicine with fraud rates that high. It is probably just as effective.