11 ms·
Nasty Gal is expected to file for bankruptcy
- firefoxd 10y agoIn seriousness, i thought this was about Hillary
- staticelf 10y agoNot that I've heard of this company before (I guess it's news because of the sex of the founder), but wouldn't they have survived hadn't they taken VC money? I don't understand this "we must grow or die scenarios".
- WhitneyLand 10y ago>>I guess it's news because of the sex of the founder You're suggesting it's some kind of feminism promotion piece? Any company with over $50MM in funding will get press. I might buy the idea that part of it relates to her being a high profile founder, but none of this relates to gender.
- totalZero 10y agoWhy does anyone care, aside from the "Nasty Gal" moniker and its implications? Edit: it's a serious question, not a rhetorically charged one. Small companies go bankrupt all the time.
- staticelf 10y ago> You're suggesting it's some kind of feminism promotion piece? No I'm suggesting it gets covered because of a female founder. A lot of companies in that size go broke all the time without being covered. Maybe it hasn't anything to do with her gender but I can't help to think it has since the news otherwise is incredibly boring.
- true_religion 10y agoThat and the company had a fairly provocative name, and targetted young women (read: teens) thus it was tailor made for family values controversy. Also, the female founder is an author who heavily markets her book on business techniques and has publishers who are dedicated to calling newspapers and getting her name in them. All press is good press after all.
- guptaneil 10y agohttps://duckduckgo.com/?q=site%3Atechcrunch.com+bankrupt https://duckduckgo.com/?q=site%3Atechcrunch.com+bankrupt Startup bankruptcies are a very common topic and Nasty Gal isn't any different. To suggest that it's news just because of the founder's gender is ridiculous and trivializes the hard work and emotional roller coaster everybody involved went through.
- weego 10y agoNo it doesn't, don't be ridiculous. 'Why is this getting voted up when I've never heard or the company' was my reaction to seeing it when skimming the top links this morning. It being a female founder helps answer that question without implying anything else other than what you willfully project onto others.
- ehnto 10y agoThe more likely reason is that you aren't the target demographic. Just like half the time I have never heard of the fintech startups that get thrown around here, because I am not part of the fintech news demographic. It also probably didn't come up here because it isn't a tech startup. However it is now a very interesting investment failure story, and that is something HN is interested in.
- staticelf 10y agoI disagree. Why would that "trivialize" the work behind building the company? Of course the people involved care deeply about the outcome. But for me, as a total outsider, this has 0 news worth since from my understanding the company has no real public interest except for their customers and founders/owners. AFAIK the company isn't even public so it isn't like anyone has anything invested in it. It is for me obvious that the company bankruptcy is covered because of the gender of the founder. Maybe I am wrong, but I don't really see any other reason to why.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- hedgehog 10y agoIt's news because they were an interesting idea that ran through $65M of venture money with some turmoil and then folded. If you you think you're seeing a generational change in the way retail works and you see a charismatic founder who has found what looks like a new winning formula it doesn't seem that crazy to back her and see what happens. If you're the founder and you think you have fair odds at going from all of a small business to a large slice of the next H&M by pushing growth really hard then maybe that sounds like a good idea. My guess is that was the decision and she decided to go for growth, it would be interesting to hear why it blew up though.
- jay_kyburz 10y agoperhaps somebody could summarise what was interesting about thier idea.
- 10y ago
- Ayraa 10y agoInteresting how she pushed hard her book GirlBoss while her business was alreafy floundering. And now it's filing for bankrutcy. Can you trust any of the advice from her book? If anything, she knew her business was in trouble so she hatched a backup plan: turn herself into an authority on how to be a successful businesseswoman while Nasty Gal still existed.
- nibnib 10y ago>Can you trust any of the advice from her book? This is pretty much the norm for business books. This time it just isn't backed by survivorship bias.
- tinco 10y agoOf course you can. She built a business from scratch to $100mm revenue and interesting enough for VC's to invest $65mm in. I'd love to be as succesful as that.
- grandalf 10y agoThe NYC fashion startup scene is evaporating.
- comeonman 10y agoJesus christ can we have heavier modding of people who need to RTFA on this site? It's a hundred times worse then the jokes to open the comment threads and see basic RTFA fails over and over and over again. "Amoruso founded Nasty Gal in 2006, when she was only 22, as a vintage shop on eBay. Over the years, she grew the Los Angeles-based company into an online business with around $100 million in sales. It was fueled by a passionate customer base among millennial women and a personal fan base, thanks in part to her New York Times bestseller “#Girlboss.” The company also operates two stores in the Los Angeles area." It's the fourth paragraph in the story. You have to get through one hundred and fifty-four words, man!
- zump 10y agoNext up StitchFix...
- lastforestlark 10y agoWhat makes you say that, out of curiosity? I feel like Stitch Fix is targeting a whole other subset of fashion needs, and I've personally been really impressed with their operation.
- FashionExist 10y agoIt is because Stitch Fix isn't doing anything new and fashion is incredibly fast, Stitch Fix has to depend on a supply chain (whole sellers) that lag behind in terms of trends and styles in terms of weeks, seasons are measured in weeks. It is also going to be incredibly hard for them to drive growth and their market position is dependent on their ability to match clothes for people.
- sage76 10y agoWere there other companies that attempted what Stitchfix is doing? Trunkclub and Stitchfix were early movers in this space as far as I am aware and others have copied them. Didn't get your point regarding whole sellers. As far as I understand this industry, the retailers generally source directly from brands and so does Stitchfix. "their market position is dependent on their ability to match clothes for people" That's their core competency though. That's what makes them successful.
- mtrimpe 10y agoFashion doesn't actually change measured in weeks. There is a fairly predictable flow from the next-season designs approved by the fashion elite (think Devil Meets Prada sort of stuff.) The not-too-risky designs there are quickly incorporated by the just-behind-the-curve brands to still make it into the next season and only a year (or more) later the aspects sufficiently palatable for the masses end up at regular retailers. That means that if you stay in touch with the newest developments it's actually pretty easy to still be sufficiently ahead of the masses to justify a service like this. And if that sounds remarkably similar to how tech works: I agree with you.
- smegel 10y agoWasn't she in the news a few days ago as some kind of up and coming billionaire?
- visakanv 10y ago"Nasty Gal's Sophia Amoruso Hits Richest Self-Made Women List With $280 Million Fortune" – http://www.forbes.com/sites/clareoconnor/2016/06/01/nasty-gal-sophia-amoruso-richest-women-net-worth/#46dce5bd44e1 http://www.forbes.com/sites/clareoconnor/2016/06/01/nasty-ga...
- madaxe_again 10y agoWorked in ecommerce for a decade, knew innards at NG through a few sources. They overspent on tech which they always thought would last forever. "Yeah, let's spend $11M on a redesign. It'll last forever" They bought way too much stock, and never worked with size curves, just flat ranges. These are common problems in small/young retailers - just most of them don't fail quite so spectacularly on other people's money.
- ovao 10y agoBy "flat ranges" you mean they bought approximately the same number of garments for each available size?
- madaxe_again 10y agoYes. Cheaper to buy, but harder to sell. Experienced fashion retailers (and wholesalers/"manufacturers") have crazy detailed models to buy exactly what they should sell and very little more. Demand velocity based mostly, and when done well, sliced by category/range. Unsold stuff usually goes through a bulk shredder - some of the more ethical ones send it to charity. What you see in outlets and seconds stores is usually made specifically for those outlets. I got very jaded after a decade of watching the madness, left a few months back.
- donatj 10y agoOuch. I worked in ecommerce for five years myself and thought the companies that spent 20-50k on a site we could knock out with prebuilt components in a week or two was rough. Apparently we should have been tacking some zeros on there.
- madaxe_again 10y agoThe agency I ran would charge at least £200k a year (full service) - and we were mid range - and when retailers choose to do things in-house or with a big provider, things go into the millions rapidly.
- marrs 10y ago
- djsumdog 10y agoWhen I hear about stuff like this, it takes me back to the Fucked Company days and the bubble bursting.
- ryporter 10y agoWhich bubble are you referring to? I'm not familiar with one in the retail clothing space.
- RichardCA 10y agoThe late 90's dot-com bubble. The idea that any business vertical can be converted into a .com and it will just work by default. We were supposed to have learned from that era but this is not always the case.
- mysterypie 10y agoWow, these VCs blew $65 million dollars on an online clothing store. Wozniak and Jobs funded their Apple I by selling an old car and an electronic calculator; probably a few thousand dollars at most. The Apple II was launched for $250K, or $996K in today's dollars. These are actual computers they designed, built, and sold. That's ICs, circuit boards, firmware, device drivers, cases, real engineering, programming, manufacturing, and selling -- all for less than a 1/65 of the money that an online retailer blew through selling clothes. To put it another way, instead of one clothing retailer, these VCs could have funded 65 (sixty five!) hardware tech companies at $1 million each (at the Apple II level of funding).
- adevine 10y agoThat wouldn't work today, though. People have a much higher expectation of what a piece of hardware can do and looks like.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- davidiach 10y agoNot necessarily, look at all the projects on Kickstarter. There are still a lot of products that can be designed and build for less than $1 million.
- maxerickson 10y agoDon't you need to look at the products that hit the mass market? A successful experiment on Kickstarter isn't really a fair comparison to the Apple I and Apple II, you need the Apple II of the Kickstarter project to make for an interesting comparison.
- jmkni 10y agoYeah, but those projects stand on the shoulders of giants. They are building on top of already existing open source hardware and software.
- softbuilder 10y agoDid VC tank the company? As I recall from her book and interviews, she built her business on revenue and only took on capital much later.
- ryporter 10y agoThere's a lot of dismissive hate in this thread, but this was a genuinely successful company before things went sour. I've heard about it many times from my wife. Amoruso has a very scrappy tale about how she launched the company, and she created a brand that many people loved. The site was well designed, and the company had very rapid growth. This wasn't an VC investment born out of the bubble. Retail requires more money than a startup that makes apps, and this one had a great growth trajectory. Obviously, things went south, but that does occasionally happen to a VC investment. Similarly, I don't think it's fair to dismiss Amoruso out of hand just because the company has now failed. Many startup founders are great at launching companies, but not so good at running them once they reach a certain size. This seems to be what happened here. There definitely is something to be learned by how she built the company and brand.
- IsaacL 10y agoI bought her book as a gift for my teenage sister, who is smart but also kind of a rebel. She loved it. Amoruso went from freegan anarchist going dumpster-diving to running a successful business, and so had lots of unique insights and perspectives. My sister would never read a standard life-advice book, but Amoruso is someone she could relate to. For people saying business books are all nonsense -- why is business seen as a uniquely luck-based activity? No-one says, oh, some bridges collapse and some don't, so books about civil engineering only reflect survivorship bias. Business can't be reduced to a formula, but it can be broken down into smaller areas, each with its own principles (sales, marketing, recruiting, product development, etc). Amuroso learned these areas very quickly when she was getting started, but made some mistakes when things got bigger and the challenges increased.
- theparanoid 10y agoBusiness isn't uniquely luck based that doesn't imply business books are useful, https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=YlVDGmjz7eM https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=YlVDGmjz7eM
- projektfu 10y agoI haven't read Amoruso's book but business books are generally mediocre because they usually are written with the same logical fallacies. Most of them are either a businessperson extrapolating their unique circumstance to the whole world, or they are a study of a few companies that have succeeded without searching for companies that have failed using the same practices. Every now and again there is a good "philosophical" sort of book that challenges the zeitgeist. Those are the ones I usually like to read.
- PaulHoule 10y agoThese were always cheaply made clothes that were not well designed. Good riddance!
- karinsabine 10y agoHello Sir/Madam, Do you need an urgent loan to start up business, or you need a loan for refinance, Do you need a loan to pay off debt? Do you need a loan to buy a car or a house? If yes worry no more, We offer all kinds of loan at an affordable interest rate without credit check!!! contact us today via E-mail. Email:sabinhelps@gmail.com Telephone Number: +1(303) 749 0667 Thank you. Mrs Karin Sabine
- kriro 10y agoI wonder what went wrong. Sounded like a pretty good concept overall. My guess is underestimating the volume of returns and generally margins in clothing retail. Possibly combined with a growth strategy that was too aggressive? Amoruso and her previous work/network/following makes up a good bit of the value of the company imo...could she just start anew with a smaller/more niche shop? Also curious...how would one go about buying the brandname/website etc. from this company once it's in bankruptcy (assets will be sold eventually, right)?
- debacle 10y agoAs a user of Nasty Gal, Ideeli before that, and any of the various other sites that are currently flooding the marketplace, some thoughts: - Way too much money on targeted advertising. I can't remember the name of the site, but I was looking for something in particular and so had some pretty specific search terms. I didn't find what I was looking for, but saw ads for the things I looked at for the next several weeks on every page load. Imgur, Facebook, news sites, Twitch. If the host had ads, I was seeing ads for this clothing site. A massive waste of money. - Searchability is atrocious. Good inventory search for women's clothing is an incredibly hard problem. What's teal to one person is aqua to another. What's the difference between off-shoulder and off-the-shoulder? What the hell is bodycon? Why am I seeing tee shirts when I'm looking for turtle necks? - Quality is obviously bad. When I was an Ideeli user (things have changed), I was never disappointed by anything purchased. Many of the items on these sites are either visibly low quality or massively overpriced. I was looking for a good pair of leather boots, and I was looking at either spending $80 on something that was clearly low quality or $250 on something that wasn't quite what I was looking for. - The bait and switch is real. This is just a general statement on the tactics of these sites. I click on an ad because I see something I like, either that item is out of stock, or I can't find it in the store. But here's thirty other items that no one is ever going to buy.
- profeta 10y agoexcept for the last item, you pretty much described amazon.
- samfisher83 10y agoThis is Chapter 11. It means that they get time to figure out their finances. It isn't chapter 7 where they are liquidating.
- inian 10y agoLol I thought the article was about Hillary
- iblaine 10y agoI created a womens ecommerce site with some friends, took $1M in VC, grew it to several million in revenue per year, then the business fell apart when we realized scaling would not solve our net income issues. Online womens fashion is a hard nut to crack. I'm not surprised to see Nasty Girl file for bankruptcy. I am surprised that someone can put out 2 books about success and not be successful themselves.