4 ms·
So Mexicans start using bitcoin, amazon gift cards, or something like that. Or we end up with "underground banks" that can effectively transfer money across th
by mywittyname 10y ago
So Mexicans start using bitcoin, amazon gift cards, or something like that. Or we end up with "underground banks" that can effectively transfer money across the border without actually doing so, i.e., you buy a digital good at a physical location in the US, transfer it to a relative in Mexico, who then sells it back to the company at a slight discount for cash (which, as a side-effect, would be a great way to launder drug money).
Or I guess, you bounce money through Belize or something.
Either way, it doesn't sound very effective.
- mabbo 10y agoMy thoughts exactly. I'm going to go launch a Spanish bitcoin buy/sell website.
- smm2000 10y agoAnd you will go to jail really fast for operating unlicensed money transfer service. They will also add something about facilitating terrorism to add a few more years to your sentence.
- dsl 10y agoOperating a monetary transmittal service in the United States without implementing KYC-AML (which is what he is basing this on) is practically suicide. Even retailers will send you to customer service to complete a form for buying too many gift cards.
- awesomerobot 10y agoBasically it's like saying you want to ban illegal drugs from entering the country.
- throwawaymsft 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_prevalence_of_opiates_use https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_prevalenc... Singapore has the lowest rates in the world. Sometimes regulations have the intended effect.
- joesb 10y agoExcept drugs are physical while money doesn't have to be.
- awesomerobot 10y agoWhich only makes banning transfers additionally backwards
- throwawaymsft 10y agoYou realize this same logic could seemingly dismiss any regulation (assault weapons, child labor, tax evasion), right? "People will smuggle illegal guns from abroad. Or buy the parts and assemble them. Or get a machine shop and make them." A regulation, no matter its aim, does not require 100% compliance to be an effective deterrent. I'm not saying this plan will work, but a generic "people will get around it" argument is not illuminating.
- superbatfish 10y ago>You realize this same logic could seemingly dismiss any regulation Well, kinda, but not to same degree. Wired money is obviously way easier to smuggle than physical goods...
- throwawaymsft 10y agoSure; some rules are easier to circumvent than others. The real question is whether it's onerous enough to act as a deterrent, not whether some people will circumvent it. In this thread someone said it's like trying to stop the import of illegal drugs. Regulations seem to work for Singapore. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_prevalence_of_opiates_use https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_prevalenc...
- critiqjo 10y ago> The real question is whether it's onerous enough to act as a deterrent, not whether some people will circumvent it. Deterring what? "Illegal immigration" or "people walking across the border"? If it is the former, then that plan is just so stupid to be of any value. Banning transfer of money from US to Mexico to make Mexico pay for "building a 10 ft high border-wall" is ... wow, just saying that out loud feels weird. (PS: I'm neither an American nor a Mexican!)
- throwawaymsft 10y agoFrom Trump's perspective, Mexico benefits by having illegal immigrants in the US send money back to Mexico. There is no real reason for Mexico to enforce the border. Trump wants to deter this behavior (not enforcing the border) by assigning a cost (no more wire transfers back). I'm not making a judgment here, just trying to clarify the worldview.