13 ms·
The fact that the term "clean coal" can be bandied about with a straight face says something about the state of science education of the general public. (Pretty
by stcredzero 10y ago
The fact that the term "clean coal" can be bandied about with a straight face says something about the state of science education of the general public. (Pretty much the same knowledge needed to instantly realize that various wind/solar operated water-from-air devices and Solar Freakin Roadways aren't viable from back of the envelope calcs.)
- leephillips 10y ago“Sunlight is abundant beyond the energy needs of the entire human race”. (Los Alamos National Laboratory [http://www.lanl.gov/discover/publications/1663/2015-may/perovskite-power.php http://www.lanl.gov/discover/publications/1663/2015-may/pero...].) This is their back of the envelope calculation.
- supergarfield 10y agoI don't think this is a reflection on the amount of usable sunlight on that hits the surface of the earth. It sounds more like a vague, general statement and isn't backed by calculations in the article. The late Professor McKay (whose book on information theory and ML is neat by the way) published a great book full of climate back of the envelope calculations, Whithout the Hot Air, which is available online[1]. He clearly disagrees with this statement, as seen in the recap figure on page 103[2]. [1] http://www.withouthotair.com/Contents.html http://www.withouthotair.com/Contents.html [2] http://www.withouthotair.com/c18/page_103.shtml http://www.withouthotair.com/c18/page_103.shtml
- toomuchtodo 10y agohttp://www.sandia.gov/~jytsao/Solar%20FAQs.pdf http://www.sandia.gov/~jytsao/Solar%20FAQs.pdf "This theoretical potential represents more energy striking the earth’s surface in one and a half hours (480 EJ) than worldwide energy consumption in the year 2001 from all sources combined (430 EJ)." Not back of envelope. Energy calculations worked through.
- patrickg_zill 10y agoIsn't 70% or more of the Earth's surface covered in water and thus, quite difficult to build a terrestrial structure upon? Asking for a friend.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoTotal land area needed to power the world on solar alone: http://i.imgur.com/Jg31dfw.png http://i.imgur.com/Jg31dfw.png Source: http://www.businessinsider.com/elon-musk-solar-panels-to-power-the-earth-2015-12 http://www.businessinsider.com/elon-musk-solar-panels-to-pow... EDIT: Solar is a better investment than the S&P500. If US corporations were looking for some place to invest those trillions of dollars they won't repatriate [1], seems like renewables would be a perfect fit. "Eight of the biggest U.S. technology companies added a combined $69 billion to their stockpiled offshore profits over the past year, even as some corporations in other industries felt pressure to bring cash back home. Microsoft Corp., Apple Inc., Google Inc. and five other tech firms now account for more than a fifth of the $2.10 trillion in profits that U.S. companies are holding overseas, according to a Bloomberg News review of the securities filings of 304 corporations. The total amount held outside the U.S. by the companies was up 8 percent from the previous year, though 58 companies reported smaller stockpiles." [1] http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-03-04/u-s-companies-are-stashing-2-1-trillion-overseas-to-avoid-taxes http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-03-04/u-s-compan...
- awj 10y agoGood thing an hour and a half is well less than 30% of the day, then.
- supergarfield 10y agoMcKay uses something very close to this (as you said) theoretical value as the starting point of its calculations for how much can effectively be extracted.
- stcredzero 10y agoThe fact that so many people simply stop there is a clear sign that science education has failed.
- SilasX 10y agoSure, as long as you can find a way to store and transport it and upgrade all capital equipment to use that mechanism.
- joeclark77 10y agoWell, if any President would ever propose a Dyson Sphere, it would be Trump.
- pfraze 10y agoCoal mining and related production is a large employer. It's about propping up small coal-towns.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoPut out of work coal miners on social security early at their full benefit and fund it with a carbon tax. This doesn't even need to be a carbon tax; simply a transfer from the general fund. The average coal miner salary is ~$22/hr, or ~$42k/year. 174,000 coal workers in the US @ $31,668k/year (the max SS benefit permitted) = $5.5 billion/year. This is not expensive, nor in perpetuity, only the years from now until they would've hit their full retirement age regardless, not to mention the cost savings from drug addiction and other social negatives currently occurring from the industry collapsing (please, please, please take the 2 minutes to read this footnote) [1]. People should not be harmed by our transition to renewables, and it is laughable that we can't afford to take care of those no longer employed within the economy. This is not unprecedented. The shipping industry used redundancy payments to transition longshoremen out of the workforce when containerization exploded, funded by profits from the efficiency gains of containerization. I'm simply arguing for the formalization of the process, and administration through the Social Security Administration (one of the most efficient orgs in the US government). To be clear: I am essentially advocating a bridge basic income for these workers. Not subsidies, not incentives. You quit your job at the coal mine or coal generator today, and you're retired from the coal industry. EDIT: @derekdahmer & @ArkyBeagle: I'm not requiring someone to retire if they don't want to. I'm simply ensuring they don't fall into poverty. What more can be done when your job is destroying the environment? Allow it to continue? That is unacceptable. I'm not proposing welfare, I'm proposing financial freedom to explore other options to find purpose and self actualize. [1] http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2016/01/07/us/drug-overdose-deaths-in-the-us.html http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2016/01/07/us/drug-overdo...
- myowncrapulence 10y agoand it is laughable that we can't afford to take care of those no longer employed within the economy But that would shift power away from entrenched industries. Big money is lazy.
- arcticfox 10y agoI think that's a little harsh. There's no first principle that the average citizen should know that says "clean coal" isn't possible. In fact, in 5-10 minutes of specifically looking at the topic I still don't see why you're mocking the concept.
- manicdee 10y agoSimple thermodynamics. We get energy from coal by burning it then extracting some of the heat. The waste products are basically carbon dioxide and heat. Clean coal is about capturing that carbon dioxide, which means spending energy to separate the CO2 from other gasses, then liquefy it. This sequestration process costs about 30% of the energy originally extracted from the coal. I fully support clean coal since it increases the price of coal fired electricity, meaning coal plants will become uneconomical sooner.
- TYPE_FASTER 10y agoIt doesn't have to. http://www.iea-coal.org.uk/site/2010/blog-section/blog-posts/can-microalgae-be-used-to-remove-co2-from-the-flue-gas-of-coal-fired-power-plant http://www.iea-coal.org.uk/site/2010/blog-section/blog-posts...? My issue with the coal industry is they pushed back on any sort of regulation for 30yrs instead of innovating. Imagine what they could have done if they had invested in clean coal technology in the mining areas of the US. Instead, they are now complaining because they got lazy and solar and wind capitalized on their inability to get the job done.
- triangleman 10y ago'clean coal' can also mean coal burned without harmful particulates/elements entering the atmosphere. CO2 is not really a 'dirty' emission.
- dbz 10y agoC02 is one of the worst 'dirty' emissions (methane is worse), and C02 is the most important gas for controlling the earth's temperature - http://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/Features/CarbonCycle/page5.php http://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/Features/CarbonCycle/page5.... "The current episode of global warming is attributed to increasing emissions of CO2 and other greenhouse gases into Earth's atmosphere. " - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_dioxide_in_Earth%27s_atmosphere https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_dioxide_in_Earth%27s_at... Also in the first few lines of wikipedia you will see that C02 is only 0.04% of the atmosphere. This small percentage has huge effects.
- bsilvereagle 10y agoYou may be interested to learn more about coal-direct chemical looping: https://www.osu.edu/features/2013/ohio-state-develops-clean-coal-technology.html https://www.osu.edu/features/2013/ohio-state-develops-clean-...
- fulldecent 10y agoA significant amount of coal is burned in the world today. Much of it is burned in an inefficient way. Retrofitting coal burning plants to burn cleaner would a large impact on global carbon emissions. Replacing coal with cleaner sources would also have a large impact. The important thing is: dollar-for-dollar, retrofitting is more effective than replacing.