3 ms·

Not really (or at least you would lose privacy part), one reason why voting is anonymous is to prevent 1) intimidation 2) paying people to vote in favor of spec

by takeda 10y ago

Not really (or at least you would lose privacy part), one reason why voting is anonymous is to prevent 1) intimidation 2) paying people to vote in favor of specific issues. If block chain would be used it would be easy for someone buying votes to verify that the people who got paid voted in certain way.

myowncrapulence 10y ago
It's possible. But yeah, like you said, if your identity was linked to your address or hash you'd lose anonymity. You'd have to really trust whoever was keeping the records to have a secure db which we know is basically impossible and could allow for coercion if a malicious actor got hold of it. However if this problem was solved, it would allow for cryptographically provable elections.
tmaly 10y ago
I only mentioned it because I saw a post on HN the other day that mentioned zcash which is suppose to add anonymity to what bitcoin does. We get a lot of people claiming the machine switched their vote etc. Over the years, there have been stories of people forging paper ballots etc. I just wanted to raise the issue for discussion, why all the down votes?
- mistermumble 10y ago
  I don't understand why you were downvoted. Your question is valid and relevant. There are problems with the current election process, that were evident in the primary elections. There are many manufacturers of e-voting machines, but these are opaque, proprietary and possibly hackable (as has been demonstrated in past years by security researchers). With current wave of interst in blockchain technology, there are several new ventures that are exploring blockchain as an immutable, authoritative record or log that cannot be hacked. The problem is that it is too transparent (people may see who you voted for, not just that you voted). But I think this problem can be solved, and will likely be solved. It may take a few years. Here's an answer from Quora that I found helpful: https://www.quora.com/Can-blockchain-technology-be-used-in-securing-digital-voting# https://www.quora.com/Can-blockchain-technology-be-used-in-s...
- throwanem 10y ago
  > why all the down votes? Because "blockchain" is the new "rewrite". There's always someone who suggests it, whether or not it's applicable - which it almost never is.

by takeda 10y ago

myowncrapulence 10y ago

It's possible. But yeah, like you said, if your identity was linked to your address or hash you'd lose anonymity. You'd have to really trust whoever was keeping the records to have a secure db which we know is basically impossible and could allow for coercion if a malicious actor got hold of it. However if this problem was solved, it would allow for cryptographically provable elections.

tmaly 10y ago

I only mentioned it because I saw a post on HN the other day that mentioned zcash which is suppose to add anonymity to what bitcoin does. We get a lot of people claiming the machine switched their vote etc. Over the years, there have been stories of people forging paper ballots etc. I just wanted to raise the issue for discussion, why all the down votes?

mistermumble 10y ago
I don't understand why you were downvoted. Your question is valid and relevant. There are problems with the current election process, that were evident in the primary elections. There are many manufacturers of e-voting machines, but these are opaque, proprietary and possibly hackable (as has been demonstrated in past years by security researchers). With current wave of interst in blockchain technology, there are several new ventures that are exploring blockchain as an immutable, authoritative record or log that cannot be hacked. The problem is that it is too transparent (people may see who you voted for, not just that you voted). But I think this problem can be solved, and will likely be solved. It may take a few years. Here's an answer from Quora that I found helpful: https://www.quora.com/Can-blockchain-technology-be-used-in-securing-digital-voting# https://www.quora.com/Can-blockchain-technology-be-used-in-s...
throwanem 10y ago
> why all the down votes? Because "blockchain" is the new "rewrite". There's always someone who suggests it, whether or not it's applicable - which it almost never is.