8 ms·
The Chinese government actually has very little incentive to allow foreign internet companies inside China. By restricting outside companies they do the followi
by RcouF1uZ4gsC 10y ago
The Chinese government actually has very little incentive to allow foreign internet companies inside China. By restricting outside companies they do the following
1. Reduce the ability of outsiders to influence their people
2. Avoid Arab Spring like events where because the companies are foreign, the coordinating network is opaque to the government
3. Allow the domestic internet companies a chance to grow and develop without competition from established foreign companies
4. Retain and develop talent and technology (ie big data, machine learning) domestically
Because China has such a large population, they can easily develop and sustain their own internal internet industry without needing Western/American companies.
I think the Snowden leaks showed that the Internet has been weaponized by the United States and having American companies controlling large services like Amazon, Google, Facebook, Twitter gives the US government a massive trove of intelligence. It also enables them to influence citizens of other countries. I think a lot of countries in the near future will see the Internet as essential to their national security and thus try to limit foreign influence as much as they can with varying degrees of success
- csomar 10y ago> Because China has such a large population, they can easily develop and sustain their own internal internet industry without needing Western/American companies. Probably quite the opposite. Local internet business will rely on these restrictions to thrive rather than service, quality and features. They'll be shocked big when the market will open for foreign businesses.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoLast time I checked, it was Google and Facebook that were shocked by the features and quality of Chinese services. In that shock, they proceeded to blindly copy them of course.
- jahewson 10y agoThat's a great point, except for it being entirely false.
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoCitations please.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoChangelog to Facebook Messenger would serve as a great one.
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoI thought they were copying features from Line (both of them)?
- joncampbelldev 10y agoanecdotal, but visiting china and seeing the level of integration and support wechat (just one app) has in everyday life is way past the paltry "ooh look you can use apple pay in this store now" we have.
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoTrue, but the US has ubiquitous credit card usage while China never really had that (most corner shops/veggie stands lack unionpay POS terminals). Wechat pay feature has done great at solving China's problems, but it isn't likely to catch on in developed countries without those problems, while it is failing to move into markets in adjacent countries or Africa that do. When I visited Australia (while still living in Beijing) last year, I was amazed that people could just tap their cards at convenience stores to pay for whatever. It was like I went to the future where you didn't have to hold your phone screen clumsily up to a scanner.
- arcticbull 10y agoThe US banks actually issued these for a few years (called dual-interface cards) though with the less-secure MSD technology instead of EMV. The the poor rate of adoption and high cost per-card, they eventually backed down and issued chip-only cards. These get replaced every few years and now that terminals exist in the US, I wouldn't be surprised to see dual-interface EMV cards issued by most major issuers within the next few years.
- wmf 10y agoInternal competition won't increase quality? Or is there a cultural aspect?
- Canada 10y agoMaybe, but Baidu is awful compared to Google as far as search is concerned.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 10y agoAre you comparing English searches or Mandarin searches?
- Canada 10y agoBoth.
- justicezyx 10y agoBaidu is 50B+ Alibaba is 200B+ Tecent is 200B+ Baidu is continuously becoming irrelevant in the new wave of Internet economy. That, is the result of competition. I am not surprised that Baidu becomes next Yahoo in 5-10 years.
- dasil003 10y agoTrue, but WeChat is way better than any social feature/app Google has, and it has certain innovations beyond what Facebook, Snapchat or any other major social network have. There is definitely true innovation coming out of China, and it's easy to see how the GFW has enabled a lot of that innovation, even if it's a bit indirect or confused at times.
- Canada 10y agoPlease excuse me for being negative, but I hate WeChat. To a lesser extent I have to use LINE in parts of SE Asia, and it's crap too. I only use them because I have no choice. I don't want to be socially excluded. The positive thing I have to say about them is that the fact they use usernames instead of phone numbers make it feel like you're just making a casual connection, so everyone is more willing to connect with strangers.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- sho 10y agoYour comment has been downvoted, probably because of the hyperbolic "the Internet has been weaponized", but you bring up a good point. I've long thought it absolutely insane that governments all over the world blithely allow Facebook, and by extension the USG[1], to collect a comprehensive social graph of their entire citizenry. Who's friends with who, who talks to who, how often and about what, who works where, who goes where and when. This level of information about another country's citizens sounds like the wildest dream of an intelligence agency. It literally sounds like the onion: http://www.theonion.com/video/cias-facebook-program-dramatically-cut-agencys-cos-19753 http://www.theonion.com/video/cias-facebook-program-dramatic... Why did these other governments let FB & friends in? I think they just didn't see it coming, and by the time they realised the cat was out of the bag. Well, China saw it coming, and closed the door before it was too late. I'm not surprised China is doing that - I'm surprised other countries don't do it. [1] Does anyone seriously believe that at least parts of the USG do not have access to facebook's data?
- wavefunction 10y agoOne of the first investors in facebook was In-Q-Tel. I think most people who care about things like that already knew a long time ago.
- linkregister 10y agoI can't find any reference to In-Q-Tel ownership of Facebook: https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/facebook#/entity https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/facebook#/entity > I think most people who care about things like that already knew a long time ago. What does this mean? If you have something to say, you should just say it overtly.
- late2part 10y agoThis is false. Please provide supporting information for your assertion that In-Q-Tel invested in The Facebook.
- CamperBob2 10y ago
- cryoshon 10y ago>I think a lot of countries in the near future will see the Internet as essential to their national security and thus try to limit foreign influence as much as they can with varying degrees of success an alternative: weaponize critical thinking and distribute it widely, especially to traditionally backwards groups. a skeptical citizenry is unlikely to fall prey to foreign propaganda. hey, it's never been tried before. maybe it can win the information wars. i'm just kidding, of course. governments and their corporate partners are terrified of general enlightenment because it means their death
- mzw_mzw 10y agoIt's neat how the reaction to an authoritarian state further restricting its people's access to information from outside sources is "see, just another reason why the United States is evil, all hail Edward Snowden and the FSB."
- chrischen 10y agoThe US government only cares about the US and its citizens. So by its stated definition, all non US companies would see it as evil/against their best interests to some degree.