4 ms·
Don't they say roundup ready crops require fewer biocides than their non GMO counterparts? Isn't one of their value propositions that you don't have to treat t
by mc32 10y ago
Don't they say roundup ready crops require fewer biocides than their non GMO counterparts? Isn't one of their value propositions that you don't have to treat them as much as conventional and organic varieties?
- gmac 10y agoCitation needed. One would have assumed that the point of a plant designed to be resistant to a herbicide would be that you could apply that herbicide with abandon.
- mc32 10y agoSure. Here are results from meta-analysis of the question[1]. Key takes: "On average, GM technology adoption has reduced chemical pesticide use by 37%, increased crop yields by 22%, and increased farmer profits by 68%. Yield gains and pesticide reductions are larger for insect-resistant crops than for herbicide-tolerant crops. Yield and profit gains are higher in developing countries than in developed countries." So pesticide use goes down, yields go up, resulting in fewer acres planted for the same yield resulting in even further pesticide use. [1]http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0111629 http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal....
- ricksplat 10y agoI noting that more and more meta-analyses are kind of falling out of fashion. They're increasingly being viewed as having dubious scientific merit and should be viewed similarly to "lit reviews". As well as some obvious biases there are other subtle issues, such as incomplete data or poorly matched data-sets. There's a list of short-comings on the wikipedia page which should provide a good primer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meta-analysis#Problems https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meta-analysis#Problems Basically, we need to be careful about accepting the results of meta-analyses as scientific fact. They are useful for illustrative purposes but really, at the end of the day if you're going to settle an argument you're going to need rigorous methodology, data-collection and reporting, as well as the all important reproducibility, falsifiability and verifiablity.
- GeneralMayhem 10y agoYes, but it also means you can use the herbicides that actually work. Less total volume required for the same effect, because it's a more effective (on plants) poison.
- DanBC 10y agoThe Monsanto claim is that the plant is resistant to the herbicide, and thus you can apply the product earlier in the growing cycle. That kills weeds and allows you to use less product. "Buy our GMO seeds and spend more on inputs" would be a fucking terrible sales pitch.
- wcummings 10y agoFarmers wouldn't use it if it didn't save them money.
- marcosdumay 10y agoOn the case of Monsanto soy, you can use a more widely effective herbicide, and because it kills more diverse species of plants, you can apply less of it. Roundup is a very effective herbicide.
- scaryspooky 10y agoRoundup is a Monsanto product and the hate is probably directed at Monsanto, not specifically about the amount of .*cides used.
- mc32 10y agoI believe this is the case and sadly it stems from a case where a Canadian farmer[1] got positive PR by playing the relative David to the Monsanto Goliath (to the detriment of Monsanto and by extension GMOS). IIRC, the farmer was in the wrong [by court decision --not wanting to pay IP fees] but people only recall the an overbearing corporation suing a farmer, whereas the farmer was trying to use GMO seeds without having to pay Monsanto their licensing fees. [1]http://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2012/10/18/163034053/top-five-myths-of-genetically-modified-seeds-busted http://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2012/10/18/163034053/top...
- ptaipale 10y agoRoundup is a Monsanto trademark, but the patent has expired decades ago, the product itself is manufactured by multiple companies all over the globe, and I wonder if Monsanto has even two-digits percentage of the market share.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]