3 ms·
Nope. Once a crowd reaches a certain density you're pretty much just screwed. It's just physics at that point. You can't even get out (that's part of the pro
by lisper 10y ago
Nope. Once a crowd reaches a certain density you're pretty much just screwed. It's just physics at that point. You can't even get out (that's part of the problem). The best you can do is to never get yourself into a super-dense crowd situation in the first place.
- amelius 10y agoAs far as I can tell, all research on this topic assumes that all people behave in the same way. So it would be interesting to investigate how to change this.
- lisper 10y agoPeople in a super-dense crowd behave in the same way because they have no choice. A super-dense crowd is essentially an incompressible fluid with people as the constituent particles. If everyone stood perfectly still everyone would be fine, but that is not a stable situation. One person tries to move, but they can't because they are packed in so tightly. There is nowhere to move to. So that person's movements are transmitted directly to their neighbors. Again, if all of those neighbors just ignored the fact that there was someone wriggling next to them and continued standing perfectly still, they might be able to contain the problem, but that's not what happens. Some of the neighbors of the initial mover respond to the movement by trying to move themselves. As long as the average number of people responding to movement by moving by moving themselves is >1, the movement will inexorably amplify and spread.
- amelius 10y ago> People in a super-dense crowd behave in the same way because they have no choice. Yes, it seems like all research focuses on the situation where it is already too late (perhaps because the fluid equations are easier to handle). I'd like to see some simulations where: 1. Half of the people refuse to move. 2. Half of the people start moving in the opposite direction. 3. Half of the people stand still and try to hold hands with other people (of that group), effectively blocking other people.
- lisper 10y ago> Half of the people refuse to move. When someone shoves you, you can't "refuse" to move. Momentum has to be conserved somehow. > Half of the people start moving in the opposite direction. Which half? If you can somehow split the crowd cleanly and get the two halves moving away from each other that might help, but this is usually not possible. And getting a randomly selected half to move in a different direction than the crowd as a whole is simply not possible, again because of physics. A dense crowd is essentially an incompressible fluid. All of the particles in a local area have to be moving in the same direction. > Half of the people stand still and try to hold hands with other people (of that group), effectively blocking other people. You really don't have a good mental model of what a dense crowd is like. There's no need to hold hands. You are already pressed up against neighbors on all sides of you. In a dense crowd you are going to remain stationary relative to your neighbors whether you like it or not. That is the root of the problem.
- amelius 10y ago> You really don't have a good mental model of what a dense crowd is like. And you are clinging to much to your crowd-as-a-fluid abstraction. Abstractions often don't hold up in the real world, especially if you actively try to break them. Further, yes, if you squash people hard enough they behave like a fluid, but what can we do at or before the state-transition?
- lisper 10y ago> what can we do at or before the state-transition? Get the hell out of there as fast as you can while you still can.
- simonh 10y agoThat's what everybody else is doing. The suggestion above to try and work your way to the edge of the crown seems sensible, even if that edge isn't in the direction of the exit. I've been in dense crowds but noticed that there is sometimes a significant gap between the crowd and the walls.
- chiph 10y agoSomething I haven't heard mentioned is that humans are bipedal, and require a certain amount of movement to stay upright. Push someone beyond the point where their stabilizer muscles can handle, and they have no option but to move a foot to brace themselves (or fall over). This would likely amplify any crowd motion.
- digler999 10y ago> all people behave in the same way because once the reptilian survival instinct gets triggered, there's no hope of anyone behaving rationally. It's similar to drowning in a body of water. Once you start to panic, your instincts will trigger you to move any and all muscles in attempt to save yourself. In water, behaving this way will cause you to exhaust yourself and sink. In a crowd, it will cause you to shove and compress your neighbors which will trigger their survival instincts. Just like atoms undergoing nuclear fission.