18 ms·
Shyness: small acts of heroism
- exergy 10y agoVery nice read. I used to be a particularly shy person, but the difference between shyness and being anti-social in general, is that a shy person _wants_ to connect to others, but is afraid of the outcome of attempting to do so. This is why, I think, shyness cures itself as we move through life (for many if not most people). We come to realise that a) we don't matter as much as we think to the other person, and b) sharing our thoughts and feelings helps other people connect to us. Small aside: I like the idea that natural selection would encourage a variety of personalities in a social species, rather than uniform, homogeneous super-beings, so that different sections would be competent at different task, leading therefore to the collective improvement of the whole.
- coroxout 10y agoI like the last paragraph of the review, presumably quoted from the conclusion of the book, which I'll look out for. I think if shyness does not cure itself with age it can harden into "being anti-social", as with the quotes from Alfred Wainwright in this review/book. However, I disagree with the reviewer that this is necessarily a distinct condition from shyness; IME it can be a shyness that has become so resigned to avoiding social discomfort that the owner no longer recognises wanting to connect, or no longer believes that meaningful connection is a possible result of social interaction anyway so why try. (Too personal admission: at least, to some extent I see this happening to me, and perhaps I should try to fight it, with the author's conclusion in mind)
- nf05papsjfVbc 10y agoDo you mean 'asocial' or 'anti-social'?
- exergy 10y agoYou're right. I meant asocial.
- hibikir 10y ago>This is why, I think, shyness cures itself as we move through life (for many if not most people). We come to realise that a) we don't matter as much as we think to the other person, and b) sharing our thoughts and feelings helps other people connect to us. That depends heavily on how much you think and feel like the people around you. While it's true that for most people your conclusions are correct, for others it has the opposite effect. If your thought and feelings are significantly different from those of the people around you, the result is utter rejection, not connection. This could still be a good idea if you have the means to move around until you find others that are like you, but it's a very bad road for those who don't. At that point though, it's not shyness, but being reserved because they know society would reject them. See homosexuals in conservative societies, being conservative in some SV companies, having very different religious beliefs from those around you, and so on. This is why I'd say that shyness is the delta between how someone thinks their openness will be perceived by the average stranger vs reality. If most people would find you essentially likable, you are shy. If instead you would be looked down upon, rejected, or feared, you are not shy: you just know you live in enemy territory. This means why we can approach shyness with reason. My son, 7, is extremely shy: He is a good person and very good looking, so we work on getting him to realize that he just doesn't have bad interactions when he is open with strangers: His radar is just not accurate, and we just get to slowly teach him how far off his predictions are. I am not that fortunate, and yet , I realize that still, I am lucky because I can appear to be shy. There are people that are rejected for something that they can't hide, like skin color, a speech impediment, or a major physical deformity. We can't say that someone that wants to avoid an area because they would get attention by the police just by their looks is just shy.
- scandox 10y ago> I can rustle up a passable impression of a normal person because I know it is part of the deal... I feel like this, even though I'm by no means shy. I feel like everything I know about interacting with other people was learned in a very deliberate way. I'm conscious of not being what I appear - to the extent that I will also comfortably discuss that with someone.
- Pamar 10y agoSomething I did not find addressed in the article, but I think is relevant: would you agree that text communication (email/forum posts/chat) are making things easier (possibly "too easy") for shy people? I mean, how frequently you prefer to send a text message instead of just calling?
- vog 10y agoThis is pretty typical for shy poeple. "Just calling" means that you have to receive the reaction immediately, and moreover, that you have to react on that immediately, too. This is much more intimidating than waiting for a response, reading it whenever you feel like, and having enough time to think about your answer. Even on chat or instant messaging, it is generally accepted that it may take half a minute, or even 5 minutes, to take for a reply. So even these so-called "real-time" services are about two orders of magnitude less "real-time" than a phone call (0.5-2.0 seconds versus 30-300 seconds). Also, with text you can get help from trusted people that help you write answers, which is not so simple on a phone call.
- Pamar 10y agoI agree with most of your comment, except the last part. In my opinion if you actually ask for help to put together a written answer you are way beyond "shyness" and would have serious problems functioning in society. (Also, how would you ask someone else for help? I mean, that would be beyond embarrassing in itself, don't you think?).
- vog 10y agoTo my experience, it is a fairly common expression of shyness to use trusted people's help when communicating. I actually know some people doing that - not just for text, but also for phone calls (they hope one wouldn't notice, or so I guess). These are young and/or inexperienced people, and the helpers are usually best frieds, siblings or parents. Of course you can downturn them as having "serious problems functioning in society", but that's somewhat true for all sufficiently young people - they are still leaning, and I'm not to judge how people learn best.
- josephwegner 10y agoI've been procrastinating (for obvious reasons) sharing this for quite some time... but this seems like as good of a kick in the pants as any. I wrote a bit of a short story about my shyness/social anxiety. Hope helps people understand what goes on in the brain when anxiety strikes: https://stories.wegnerdesign.com/how-i-party https://stories.wegnerdesign.com/how-i-party
- sjcsjc 10y agoHaven't read this yet, but I just wanted to say well done for posting this. From your comment, it clearly took some guts on your part.
- fnovd 10y agoGreat read. We've all been there at one point or another. >The story that my anxiety was telling my head was entirely fiction. The emotion was real, but the reasons behind it were imagined. I don't yet have an answer on how to solve this. For me, this was a conscious decision to change worrying about how I come across to assuaging other people's worries about how they come across. It's easier to be your own wingman when you know how to be someone else's.
- yojex 10y agoHey, I really enjoyed reading this. I hear those thoughts 24/7, and they plan most of my days. You helped me put words to some of my own behaviors that I've mostly been lying to myself about. So thanks! And it was a well written story, besides.
- josephwegner 10y agoGlad it was helpful. I wrote it for the same reason - needing real words for what was happening in my head. <3
- julsonl 10y agoWow. You've described exactly what goes in my head during parties. I've been better at faking it / being able to emit short bursts of real gregariousness, but I've never been able to completely get rid of the anxiety.
- dwe3000 10y ago> "Our shyness is unique", he contends, "because we are alone in being gifted, and burdened, with self-consciousness ... meta-thought." Is it just me, or is it strange to accept the anthropomorphism of shyness but rule out self-consciousness? Just because they can't tell us, "Hey, I'm a cat, and I think about myself all the time."?
- Mz 10y agoI am not particularly shy, but have had enough negative social experiences that a) I have learned to tone things down a bit and b) I am highly skeptical of claims that shyness is some sort of maladaptive behavior that involves imagining terrible things that aren't realistic. People often treat other people pretty badly. Being afraid of the potential consequences is hardly irrational
- cheiVia0 10y agoIs being afraid of the potential consequences a good enough reason to become a hermit? Because that's what many shy people do, while desperately wishing there were some other way. It takes repeated reminders, constant effort and, above all, an unaccustomed determination to take social risks, for shy people to push past the idea that embarrassment, or other people's anger, or some other negative consequence, is reason enough to avoid engaging. More often than not (in my experience, anyway) these fears are completely overblown. And even knowing that, and seeing the imagined disaster not coming to pass, it's still an uphill battle to take the next risk. But even in the rare cases where some fear turns out to be justified, having someone get upset with you, or laugh at you, is not the end of the world that anxiety will try to tell you it is. It's certainly not a good enough reason to doom yourself to unwilling solitude.
- Mz 10y agoMy oldest son has serious social impairments. I have seen things go stupidly badly for him in ways that can lead to serious problems. I step in and can say the exact same thing he just said and get a completely different response. He has tremendous support from me and a good relationship to his brother. Otherwise he would end up a hermit and I would completely understand at this point. There was a time I would not have. Ideally, the world would have fewer assholes. But it is what it is. If this is a thing you struggle with, I hope you find practical solutions and a deeper understanding of the root causes as that can be extremely empowering.