4 ms·
The consensus of both high-assurance security and top minds in general INFOSEC is that voting shouldn't be done with computers or shouldn't exclusively rely on
by nickpsecurity 10y ago
The consensus of both high-assurance security and top minds in general INFOSEC is that voting shouldn't be done with computers or shouldn't exclusively rely on them. They're black boxes connecting via black boxes with endless ways to be attacked. I've noticed all the ways that protect them from that just make the process more incomprehensible to both lay people and technical people. The paper ballots or hybrids where electronics spit out a human-verified one are best schemes. Fewer forms of fraud that are easier to detect by massive numbers of people. Better to just improve those systems.
Far as hybrids, the Scantegrity scheme was always interesting to me as the human-visible steps are straight-forward:
https://people.csail.mit.edu/rivest/pubs/CCCEx09.pdf https://people.csail.mit.edu/rivest/pubs/CCCEx09.pdf
Prior studies showed even it had usability problems. Someone interested in secure voting might want to tackle those for it or other stuff in the related work section.
- echlebek 10y agoNot only that, paper ballot voting scales well, creates jobs for people, and leads to increased trust in the system, since people are directly involved. Who does electronic voting benefit?
- jdavis703 10y agoPeople who live in states with strict absentee voting laws and who have to work on election day. Now perhaps the solution is to make election day a national holiday (and a real holiday where everyone but safety-critical workers are given the day off -- and no, cashiers at Walmart or car salesmen working for "our big election day sale" won't count as safety critical).
- echlebek 10y agoIf polling stations are numerous and accessible enough, an entire day isn't necessary. https://www.ontario.ca/laws/statute/90e06#BK18 https://www.ontario.ca/laws/statute/90e06#BK18 edit: Canada also has advance voting. Polling stations open 5 days before the election day and people can voting during business hours on those days.
- amelius 10y agoIt's not just a technical problem. With online voting, somebody can be forced to make a certain vote, for example, at gunpoint. Or blackmailing, bribing, et cetera. Voting offices protect against this.
- matt_kantor 10y agoWhat are your thoughts on vote by mail?
- colejohnson66 10y agoYou can always mail in the ballot, then go to a polling place and vote there. IIRC, that overrides your mail-in vote.
- greeneggs 10y agoHow would that even work? They wouldn't be able even to start opening ballots until after election day. In California, you definitely can't do that. Ballots are separated from the envelopes, for anonymity, before counting. The different counties even have web pages where you can check that your ballot was received and counted. (Mine was received 10/31, opened on 11/1, and counted on 11/2.)
- gizmo686 10y agoSome states already allow people to change their votes if they voted early.
- ascagnel_ 10y agoNot always -- it varies on a state-by-state level. I live in NJ, where you can do this. However, it only works because absentee/mail-in balloting is held until after election day, and in some cases are only counted if the election is within the number of absentee ballots, and an in-person vote will trigger them to manually throw out the mail-in ballot.
- ScottBurson 10y agoYes -- in this modern world where so many things are being made more convenient by doing them electronically/over the Internet, it's tempting to think that voting should be another such thing. But it has to be held out as an exception. This is one case where the old technology of paper is better.