3 ms·
Is there any actual evidence that natural resource wealth is strongly correlated with level of development? Sure - consider that an abundance of coal, when dis
by gaius 10y ago
Is there any actual evidence that natural resource wealth is strongly correlated with level of development?
Sure - consider that an abundance of coal, when discovered, kickstarted the Industrial Revolution in the UK, and hence, the entire world. Norway has managed its oil wealth very well. Australia exports minerals but is relatively well-developed.
But of course there are plenty of counterexamples, probably far more actually: Venezuela of course, Argentina ought to be and used to be stunningly wealthy, the oil-rich countries of the Middle East...
- adventured 10y ago> Australia exports minerals but is relatively well-developed. Have to say that's a significant understatement. Australia now has the world's #1 or #2 richest median household in regards to net wealth. Their economic boom the last 20 years was almost entirely due to commodities + China. Canada is in the same boat as Australia. Highly developed, well off middle class, high wealth creation the last 20 years. Almost entirely due to the commodity boom over that time.
- gaius 10y agoWe won't know until we see what happens at the point that the minerals are mined out, or demand for them drops off e.g. an economic downturn in China. They could be more-or-less OK like the UK was when coal became uneconomic to extract, or they could implode like Cuba when the Soviets stopped buying sugar.
- snrplfth 10y agoUh...minerals and fossil fuels are around about 4.5% of Canada's GDP, and declining as a percentage of the total. To say that the economic growth over the last 20 years has been "almost entirely due to the commodity boom" is completely at odds with reality.
- snrplfth 10y agoBut the abundance of coal didn't kickstart the Industrial Revolution. Coal is abundant all over the world - especially in Eastern China, Northeastern India, the Carpathian Mountains, the Urals, and so forth. Industrialization is just what allows you to exploit coal on a large scale, because you can mine and move it in large quantities when you have steam engines, railroads and hydraulics. It wasn't "discovered" in England at that time, it had been known about since the Roman era. Likewise large coal deposits were known about, and used, in many other places in the world. I don't know why this myth of "Britain finds it has coal -> industrial revolution" persists.