3 ms·
There's no point in having the Electoral College in the current state. - If it's meant to stop the mob from selecting the wrong person, it's not working. Most
by lordnacho 10y ago
There's no point in having the Electoral College in the current state.
- If it's meant to stop the mob from selecting the wrong person, it's not working. Most people would find it unacceptable to vote against what the voters voted for, so in that sense it's largely ceremonial.
- Most states are closer to 50-50 at each election than 100-0. Yet all the electors have to "vote" for the marginal winner.
- You might as well have a Parliamentary system like in Europe if you don't vote directly. Vote for MPs, the MPs pick one among them to be PM. That way you at least know whoever is elected can govern.
- walshemj 10y agoOr vote the electoral college votes in proportion or use stv or just OMOV (one member one vote) i.e. all the "Members" of the party in the state vote.
- anthony_romeo 10y ago> You might as well have a Parliamentary system like in Europe if you don't vote directly. Vote for MPs, the MPs pick one among them to be PM. That way you at least know whoever is elected can govern. Arguably, one can say that the electoral college decouples electing the head of state from possible corruption from an entrenched parliament while reaping the benefits [?] of not having them elected by the people directly. Realistically it means nothing, especially when states mandate that all of their electors vote for one candidate. What I really don't about the EC is that policy becomes dictated by less than a dozen "swing states". Who cares about Massachusetts or Mississippi when Ohio and Florida are angry about something?
- maxerickson 10y agoWho cares about Massachusetts or Mississippi when Ohio and Florida are angry about something? Every candidate. If they don't stand somewhere between Massachusetts and the swing states or Mississippi and the swing states, they aren't even going to be on the ballot.
- mountaineer22 10y agoDisagree. Once you have the nomination, there are less than 15 states that are important in our binary system.
- maxerickson 10y agoYes, but getting the nomination is sort of an important part of the system. Which is pretty much what I was saying above.
- humanrebar 10y ago> What I really don't about the EC is that policy becomes dictated by less than a dozen "swing states". If it were a purely popular vote, candidates would only visit particular urban centers instead of particular states. It would be just as arbitrary and unbalanced, just in a different way.
- jmanderley 10y agoAs opposed to now, where they only visit places in a handful of states. Getting rid of the EC would mean that candidates have to pander to voting blocs more. This would likely empower the rural population.
- humanrebar 10y ago> Getting rid of the EC would mean that candidates have to pander to voting blocs more. What's the difference between a 'voting bloc' and a 'special interest'? Is the pandering to farmers in the form of more ethanol subsidies and below-market-rate crop insurance? That vision sounds like there would be more power to lobbyists and less power for local political groups. That's a sideways move at best.
- jmanderley 10y agoTo the contrary, it would decrease lobbying influence. And every vote should be equal. One man one vote. Not a sideways move in any way.
- lordnacho 10y agoIt's 2016. It matters not a jot whether a candidate comes through your town. You can still hear what he has to say. In fact, you can barely avoid it.
- skylan_q 10y agoYet all the electors have to "vote" for the marginal winner. They aren't compelled to. One of the electors from WA says they won't vote if Clinton wins. It's pretty unprecedented, however.
- zwily 10y agoIn some states, they are compelled: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Faithless_elector https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Faithless_elector
- MichaelBurge 10y agoFrom your own link, "The Supreme Court has never ruled on the constitutionality of state laws that punish electors for actually casting a faithless vote." And, "no one faithful to our history can deny that the plan originally contemplated what is implicit in its text -- that electors would be free agents, to exercise an independent and nonpartisan judgment as to the men best qualified for the Nation's highest offices."
- WildUtah 10y agoNo penalty has been applied to faithless electors, partly because such a penalty is unconstitutional. Supreme Court cases US Term Limits v Thornton and Ray v Blair make it clear that states cannot force electors to vote in any particular way once elected, though they can require electors to solemnly promise in advance to do so. In practice, electors don't violate those promises unless the promise turns out not to matter. Sometimes an elector will chose to show off by choosing some other candidate to vote for from his promised choice, but always only after checking that it won't affect the final result. Parties pick people that are proven loyal enough over time to be depended on.
- davidw 10y ago> Parliamentary system like in Europe There are various systems in Europe. * England (the UK?) for instance has local elections in a given area with a first past the post winner. * In Italy, traditionally, you simply voted for a party, which selected the people who would go to parliament if it got X% of the vote, so you kind of know who you were getting. Both those systems have problems of their own. In Italy, you'd occasionally get a small party with, say, 10% of the vote that would 'ally' with some party that got 45%. The 'alliance' mostly meant the small party extracting as much as it possibly could from the large party, far out of proportion with its vote, until things get out of hand and the whole thing crumbled.
- lordnacho 10y agoSure, there are problems with all systems. Fundamentally, if people can't agree, it's hard to make a system where things get done. But in Europe, most of which has a multiparty indirect system (UK/Germany/Scandi/Spain), you have a government formed from a coalition of parties that doesn't have a majority against it. And you still have a semblance of voting for a particular leader, even though you're not actually. You know pretty well who will be your country's head if you vote for a particular party, at least until they resign. The problem of small parties is normally dealt with by having a lower limit. For instance in Denmark and Sweden there's a 2/4% minimum proportion. That way you need some support to be represented, though of course a 10% voting bloc can still swing itself around like it's 20%. That's hard to quantify anyway, because it's a matter of how much they value various policies. If you look at the US at the moment, you have a President that people voted for, who basically can't pass the laws that he promised everyone. You have ridiculous things like filibusters, where you can abuse the rules if you can't get what you want. You have seats that are safe in the election, but contested in the primaries. You have all sorts of issues about who is funding the parties. Children in school can see it's ridiculous. Time to try a few new things. Proportional representation is just one thing, obviously nothing is guaranteed. Will be hard though, with the current system.
- davidw 10y agoI think the current "low hanging fruit" in the US is gerrymandering. People can easily see that it's pretty wrong, and it's likely fixable without, say, modifying the constitution.
- douche 10y agoThere are two states that don't go winner-take-all with their electors, Maine and Nebraska[1]. This way, at least if different districts vote wildly differently, that would get reflected in the electoral college. Wider use of this system would probably drive the pundits and talking heads insane, because then that calculus for getting to 270 votes would become much more complicated. [1] http://www.fairvote.org/maine_nebraska http://www.fairvote.org/maine_nebraska
- mountaineer22 10y agoI agree with this. The calculus should not be easy to solve.
- WildUtah 10y agoNote that if every state used the Maine/Nebraska system, Trump would be guaranteed to win next week. There would not be another Democratic president for many years at least. Obama, for instance, would not have won in 2008 or 2012.
- douche 10y agoIs that because of deliberate gerrymandering, or are Democratic districts so overwhelmingly Democratic that their differentials in their districts currently carry the rest of the state? I.e. an urban district votes 95-5 Democratic, while the rural district votes 55-45 Republican, so under the winner-take-all, both electors go Democrat, vs the other system would be 1-1?
- WildUtah 10y agoIt's mostly a matter of deliberate gerrymandering. In years like 2012 and soon 2016, a large majority of voters pick a Democrat for Congress. In order to keep control of the body, Republicans have arranged the districts so that they are guaranteed to keep a majority regardless of any plausible scenario of how the people may vote.
- WildUtah 10y agoOn your first point, Most people would find it unacceptable to vote against what the voters voted for, so in that sense it's largely ceremonial: Two hundred seventy one electors—a majority—voted against what the voters voted for in 2000, choosing president Dubya. So that doesn't seem to be much of a problem.