6 ms·
Elon Musk thinks universal income is answer to automation taking human jobs
- partycoder 10y agoThis planet has finite resources, and a population that went from 2.5 billion in 1950 to now 7.4 billion people, and counting. By growing we have increased our consumption of fish, arable soil, oil, freshwater, lumber... everything. I think we will need to also get used to the idea that we will need to downsize our population to a level in which it is sustainable.
- saiya-jin 10y agodownsizing ain't theoretically that hard in near future - give free, painless contraception without side effects, plus no incentives to milk social system effectively by having 10 kids (ie roma problem in some parts of europe), and most people will have 1-2 kids, if any -> population will slowly go down. universal education not only in this topic should help too. reality is different though - STDs combined with slutty behavior from both genders all over the place. Poor billions of people not able to afford contraception (ie india), or not knowing how to use it. and so on
- prodmerc 10y agoOn the Roma problem - they don't have children to milk the social system. They have them because family is everything and fuck everyone else. Hence, make more family so you don't have to deal with anyone else. Weird culture.
- snarfy 10y agoWhenever I bring this up my inbox explodes.
- Numberwang 10y agoMy religion tells me you are completely irrational. I'm having 8 children and when they in turn grow up they will all have 8 and so on. Downsize all you want. We will take over.
- vixen99 10y agoYou are correct. Here's a map (a nod to the future) of the 'we'. http://globalfertilitymap.com/#-13.410994034321702,48.8671875,2 http://globalfertilitymap.com/#-13.410994034321702,48.867187...
- audunw 10y agoIf we extrapolate, the final population count of the world before population stagnates will be: America: 1 billion Europe: 1 billion Africa: 2 billion Asia: 5 billion https://twitter.com/hansrosling/status/270835563802791936 https://twitter.com/hansrosling/status/270835563802791936 2 billion in Africa is not that bad considering its size.
- audunw 10y agoDownsizing has already started. Most of the population growth from now on is simply young people growing up and having their 2 children. Further downsizing is not gonna happen without war, which is not something that will make any of the problems related to overpopulation any better. Basically, what we have to do is make this planet work with 10 billion people (a stretch, but not impossible), and from there on it should only get better. Unless we discover a way to revert aging. This isn't all that relevant to UBI though.
- partycoder 10y agoProbably in select countries but not in all regions. It is still growing fast and we might hit 9 billion in a couple of decades. Then, life expectancy and live births are growing, meaning people stay here longer.
- mstodd 10y agoWe also continue to more efficient at consuming, pricing, and allocating those resources.
- partycoder 10y agoLike producing very cheap plastic bottles and nylon bags that then are dumped everywhere?
- saiya-jin 10y agoUBI, the topic has been beaten to death. I like the idea, in theory and on the paper, but it will require complete restructuralization of whole society. When I look how mankind struggles to get simple stuff right (no wars, +-democracy and freedom for all humans), this is Star Trek. But then again, this guy seems very special. I wish all/most truly powerful people would be like him, not only doing charitable stuff for tax evasion purposes. His added value to mankind in long term seems to be immense, at least that's what I hope for.
- manmal 10y agoThe value he added is already immense - he had a big part in establishing e-vehicles as viable. I'd say he accelerated the transition by several years or more. Fear of him is the only thing driving BMW and co to tighten their e adoption schedules.
- whiskers08xmt 10y agoI don't think the challenge of BI is equal to all societies. In a place like Denmark, which has quite the extensive welfare-system, a large part of the BI could be funded simply by cutting out the bureaucracy of the welfare system.
- Fr0ntBack 10y agoI'd be interested to hear how this very website's basic income trial is going: www.qz.com/696377/y-combinator-is-running-a-basic-income-experiment-with-100-oakland-families/
- formula1 10y agoPros and Cons to universal income Pros - the average citizen isnt afraid to find out next meal - innovation can be more focused on convinience and love rather than people desperate to succeed - individuals or families burdened with loved ones unfit for work dont have to sacrifice in order to provide for them - homelessness becomes purely choice. Poverty is less of a motive for crime - small businesses can hire people who simply want to work there without giving a competitive wage. Cons - it will be hard to employ for difficult jobs such as mining. - the realestate or rental prices can all increase to just below universal income - cost of goods can increase knowing people can pay for them - the cost of US manufactured goods will increase since companies are now competing with the US gov to provide a competitive wage - may lead to a totalitarian gov if too much slowness occurs My argument against communism has always been "who works?". I dont think that more dependence of gov is as important as decentralization. Of goods as many services as possible. If your local community has a local greenhouse or robotics or etc you can take care, you have a job So long as that service can support more people than have to work it, you can make money. Making more time for innovation comes from an imbalance of supply/demand for jobs and who controls them. If you can survive and thrive locally, the more centralized entities will be more competitive with their offers. Rents will only increase enough that people wouldnt be willing to move elsewhere. With universal income, all rents would increase and companies arent competing with local work (where an individual can master their skills), they are competing with the US gov over peoples will to be a self starter. Im not entirely sure the Universal Income is the answer
- wojcech 10y ago> Pros and Cons to universal income Some criticism: > Pros > - homelessness becomes purely choice. Poverty is less of a motive for crime Unless health insurance is included and we change how we treat mental illnesses, homelessness will still be a problem(albeit smaller) > - small businesses can hire people who simply want to work there without giving a competitive wage. But it will be much harder to find cheap labour if the job sucks > Cons > - it will be hard to employ for difficult jobs such as mining. Well, it will be hard to find cheap employees. Force of the market right? > - the realestate or rental prices can all increase to just below universal income We don't know this, if you can survive just on the income in some rural areas, whereas the remaining jobs will be left in the cities you will still have different markets, some of which might have above and some of which might have below ui prizes > - cost of goods can increase knowing people can pay for them This is a bad thing? There will still be a market for stingy bastards...just like McDonalds has a market with stingy students > - the cost of US manufactured goods will increase since companies are now competing with the US gov to provide a competitive wage ...good? > - may lead to a totalitarian gov if too much slowness occurs As opposed to the current government trend which is the epitome of freedom and privacy > My argument against communism has always been "who works?". I dont think that more dependence of gov is as important as decentralization. Of goods as many services as possible. Those who want more money. This is not communism. This is finally decoupling humanistic society("we don't let people starve") from capitalistic free market economy("the government shouldn't control the economy"). An unconditional income means that you no longer need minimum wages, and even a staunch leftist like me would ease up on labour protection laws(where reasonable...health and safety still apply, but e.g. severance pay?gtfo) After all, it will truly be your choice to work there or not. > If your local community has a local greenhouse or robotics or etc you can take care, you have a job Unless there is another guy who does that already. > Making more time for innovation comes from an imbalance of supply/demand for jobs and who controls them. If you can survive and thrive locally, the more centralized entities will be more competitive with their offers. Rents will only increase enough that people wouldnt be willing to move elsewhere. With universal income, all rents would increase and companies arent competing with local work (where an individual can master their skills), they are competing with the US gov over peoples will to be a self starter. I don't understand this one > Im not entirely sure the Universal Income is the answer Not the whole one, and not the last one but I think like our current system it will be good for 50-100ish years I think
- TomMarius 10y agoWhy is no one talking about the possibility of a privately backed universal income (or pensions)?
- wojcech 10y agoBecause it probably won't happen. Just like the idea that "charity will step in", history gives us evidence against it
- soufron 10y agoThat's only true as long as... automation actually takes human jobs for real instead of simply "displacing" jobs. Looking at history, you as yourself where is the evidence for automation destroying human jobs... ... but Elon Musk is not a historian. He's a business man trying to increase the value of his automation and robotics ventures. It does not need to be true. It's just PR bullshit.
- addicted 10y agoMalthusian theory was completely right about human history until just about the time it was written. History is not always a predictor of the future because of technological changes. Many believe that we are upon such a technological change (and for good reason. Companies creating billions of dollars of value are generating a fraction of the jobs they once did. The jobs that are being generated tend to be part time instead of full time like they once used to be. Big data obviates a lot of thinking jobs as well. More precise automation makes a lot of skilled jobs easier to automate. There's just an order of magnitude between technology today that is easily replicable and intelligent in a way it never was, from the technologies of the past).