6 ms·
Tech workers at UCSF face layoff, training their low paid replacements
- chaz6 10y agoWhy does the company not consider offering pay cuts in the first instance before jumping straight to outsourcing?
- calvinbhai 10y agomy guess: unions
- modarts 10y ago> In a move that could spread to other universities, about 80 information tech workers at UC San Francisco are facing layoffs and have begun training their replacements — lower-paid tech workers from an Indian outsourcing firm. This should work out well...
- pekk 10y agoIs there any evidence that paying more for IT workers results in better quality of service? It probably won't succeed to complain about this on the basis that the result might be poor, if the real problem is that outsourcing firms are abusing the H1B visa to reduce wages.
- velocitypsycho 10y agoWhat happens is that those with the skills, even in India, demand enough that they aren't working for these outsourcing companies. This is why there are different connotations between "outsourcing" and "remote workers". One implies the lowest bid.
- jakelarkin 10y agosurprised to learn courts threw out the lawsuit against Disney for their similar H1B scandal http://www.orlandosentinel.com/business/brinkmann-on-business/os-disney-visa-lawsuit-dismissed-20161014-story.html http://www.orlandosentinel.com/business/brinkmann-on-busines... H1B applier must certify no current American employees harmed by the visa. But that isn't transitive from the outsourcer to Disney. :(
- thaumasiotes 10y agoIt's a fairly nonsensical concept, though. There's always someone who's harmed, and someone else who benefits. Why focus in particular on current employees? What makes them so much more deserving than future employees (who are hurt by the visa), or current customers (who benefit)?
- pekk 10y agoThe legal and ethical basis of H1B visas is that they are NOT designed simply to depress wages. But that is exactly what they are used for.
- jakelarkin 10y agothe intent and spirit of law is that the companies are hiring H1Bs for positions that could otherwise not be filled in sufficient quantity by Americans. Companies and Customers win, and American labor should experience no measurable harm. Not that I would but one could even argue that the way that AppleGoogleFacebookMicrosoft use them to hire students is even okay since they probably cannot fill the volume they need with American STEM grads. This end-run with the outsourcers is a particularly egregious perversion of the law because they're bringing H1Bs with the intent to fire and replace Americans. There's also an angle of age-ism where they are firing older IT professionals in their 40s, 50s, 60s who have accrued higher pay-grades , and replacing them with less productive but much less costly young foreigners. Only losers are employees who need quality IT help, but who cares about that.
- Spooky23 10y agoThe purpose of the law is to prevent the labor market in general and the H1-B workers in particular to be exploited. The purpose of H1-B is to make it possible for employees with extraordinary skills to work in the United States. Over time, companies have figured out ways to use intermediaries and others means work around the legal controls to exploit immigrant labor. If you work in the technology industry, this should concern you, as allowing organizations to do this sort of thing is ultimately reducing your compensation. If you don't believe me, look at the salaries & benefits (which are often public record) at regulated or government organizations that require US citizen labor. Line employees tend to make more in those environments.
- padiyar83 10y agoWhen US companies (and universities) can operate and profit by operating in other countries, like India. Why should we not allow employees from other countries (like India an China) to seek employment in US, if they can do the job better and at a competitive price point. Why should it be just a one sided gain model that always benefits US employees.
- british_india 10y agoIt's a myth that the quality is better. Experience with H-1B holders shows they produce worse quality.
- davidw 10y agoPeople worked really hard to be born in the US and expect to reap the advantages of it!
- toomuchtodo 10y agoSo you're saying deepening the labor pool doesn't push wages down? If you're going to advocate policies that reduce the compensation middle class workers can receive, don't be shocked when they vote for a candidate promising to stop free trade agreements. A government exists to protect the quality of life of its citizens.
- davidw 10y ago> So you're saying deepening the labor pool doesn't push wages down? Do you know what the current population of the US is compared to 100 years ago? And yet, we're much better off now. Economics is not a zero sum game. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lump_of_labour_fallacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lump_of_labour_fallacy Here are a few companies founded by immigrants or their children: http://www.forbes.com/sites/stuartanderson/2011/06/19/40-percent-of-fortune-500-companies-founded-by-immigrants-or-their-children/#4dc7a54c7a22 http://www.forbes.com/sites/stuartanderson/2011/06/19/40-per...
- 10y ago
- SnakePlissken 10y agoI rarely see in coverage of these mass replacements what kind of positions are being affected, just "IT workers". The article says they're mostly back-office staff but I don't know what that means at UCSF. Are these software engineers, systems admins, middle-managers, etc? Are they low level help-desk positions? Or is it a broad mix across the entire IT hierarchy? How does the answer in this case compare to other recent incidents (e.g., Disney)? I don't ask to insinuate "lower-skilled" workers deserve to be replaced or should have prepared for it; I'm merely trying to get a better grasp on the scope of these recent outsourcings.
- mc32 10y agoIt probably means some of their developers, the ones who glue systems together --also maybe the sysadmins for mundane things but will probably keep key people like LDAP/Auth dev, InfoSec, network architect and then move all the other routine operational stuff off-shore.
- product50 10y agoWhat I don't get from these articles is why are they only talk about outsourcing IT services and how it hurts US employees? Outsourcing manufacturing to countries like China also hurt employment - I don't see this to be much different than that. Comoanies should do whatever it takes to keep them profitable and in this era of globalization, the competition is not only from companies based in US but worldwide. As an aside though, I do feel that H1-B visa is being misused. I know a couple of friends who recently completed their MBA from reputed colleges in US but weren't able to get the visa due to the cap since Indian outsourcing companies nabbed majority of them. I feel there should be a separate category for visas for students who study in US so that they get a fair chance to participate in US workforce. Also, this will encourage talented folks worldwide to come to US since their future no longer will be decided based on a lottery
- lvs 10y agoOn your first question, I think the issue is that Americans have gotten accustomed to the loss of manufacturing sector jobs, but the argument had always been that we were slowly switching to a service and/or "knowledge" economy. The kind of outsourcing described in the article challenges the claim that Americans are competitive even in those employment sectors. As an aside, UCSF is not a company, so your point about anything-goes competition is in this case a non-sequitur.
- zanny 10y agoIt isn't a skills problem, its a salary problem. Cost of living in the US is astronomical compared to any of the nations you import IT labor from. The only leg up the US (still) has is that there is no accountability in bad business done overseas - if you get crap products from your outsourced developer team, you don't have a floor to go down the elevator to where you can yell at a project lead in person.
- mavelikara 10y ago> I feel there should be a separate category for visas for students who study in US so that they get a fair chance to participate in US workforce. Every year 20K visa are earmarked for exactly this - see http://www.immi-usa.com/h1b-2015-2016-masters-quota-determining-cap-eligibility/ http://www.immi-usa.com/h1b-2015-2016-masters-quota-determin...
- thejerz 10y agoI have worked in many companies with H1B workers, and the old adage always applies: "You get what you pay for." I don't mean this as a dig against H1B employees, but UCSF will definitely notice a substantial drop in quality of H1B work quality compared to their American counterparts.
- markonthewall 10y agoThat's my experience as well. Considered opening an office in Bangalore as I was thoroughly impressed by some candidates I had interviewed. Performance on the job was significantly different... like by several orders of magnitude. Taught me a lesson. Interviews can be gamed!
- pcurve 10y ago"We’re under a great deal of pressure,” Joe Bengfort, chief information officer at UCSF, told employees at a staff meeting" Should probably start with this guy's pay first. He was paid over $460,000 in 2013. http://compensation.universityofcalifornia.edu/reports/2013-annual-report-executive-compensation.pdf http://compensation.universityofcalifornia.edu/reports/2013-... The number of administrator jobs and their outrageous pay in public school system is shameful. Just look through the above PDF.
- cellis 10y agoI'm sorry, but why is that salary out of the question? Assuming he's actually worth his salt, he could make that at Google, probably easily, as an executive. Do you propose replacing him with someone who's worse, simply because they're paid less?
- Spooky23 10y agoThe CIO of most large US states, with dramatically more responsibility make less than $200k. Some make as little as $150k. Low risk, public sector jobs shouldn't be paid premium salaries.
- zanny 10y agoThere is absolutely no way a university is able to accurately judge the valuation of its chief information office vs competition. And no business at scale ever operates that way. Once your enterprise (including schools) is old enough, and the politics drop the meritocracy, all it takes is knowing the right people to be guaranteed gratuitous compensation regardless of job performance. Even without that, the only way you are going to weigh alternative candidates for any chief officer position would be to poach from competing businesses with the same department chair titles. The market is so limited on people who ever get those kinds of jobs anywhere to begin with that it is unreasonable to expect to ever be able to accurately claim if they are or are not "worth it". Success is more about aligning with the overall vision of the business and not causing conflict more than individualized performance. You could be worth a tenth your salary but as long as the other officers like you and the board does too you are set as long as you don't break anything.
- jmspring 10y agoSimply... public funded jobs should remain public not offshored. The UC system should face significant fines for this move.
- carsongross 10y agoWell, if we want to see the long declines in healthcare costs we all love so much continue, we are going to have to accept these sorts of capital efficiencies, now aren't we?
- dmode 10y agoAs someone on an H1 visa (although not working for an outsourcing company, but rather in a product org), this makes me mad. Not only due to the job losses, decline in quality, but also it will ruin a lot of people's lives who now have to attend daily status meetings at 9pm PT. In addition, these outsourcing companies don't even bother to hire local folks for the "onsite" positions. Even those positions need to be imported from India. That doesn't make any sense and I am not sure why the USCIS do not reject those applications.