11 ms·
This is what I don't like about the current zeitgeist. Things are either black or white. You are either Red or Blue. Conservative or Liberal. Democrat or Republ
by komali2 10y ago
This is what I don't like about the current zeitgeist. Things are either black or white. You are either Red or Blue. Conservative or Liberal. Democrat or Republican. Right or Left. There is no room in this political system for a pro-life atheist, or a pro-gun liberal, or an anti-war economic conservative. There's no room on the internet for a third party voter, or someone who both believes cops lives matter AND civilian lives matter, or any other middle ground. You're either a 4chan user or a Tumbler user, you're either a Hillarybot or a Trumpbot.
Reasons for this I believe include upvote/downvote trains on the internet, clickbait headlines, and networks streamlining content to cater to certain audiences. People who watch Fox news don't want to hear about Trump rape allegations, they want to watch news casters talk about Evil Hillary. It's the reverse for CNN. Remember in the Bush era how blatantly Fox news was a Republican news-horn, and how the case is the same now for CNN and Clinton?
Euck. Can't stand it. No room for moderates, your voice won't get heard if you aren't making someone stamp their feet.
Ninjaedit: I mean honestly how is it possible that of the 300 million people spread across one of the largest (geographical) countries in the world and one of the most diverse populations on the world, exactly half want one person to represent them, and exactly half want one other person to represent them. It doesn't make sense.
- mars4rp 10y agoanti-war economic conservative : Gary Johnson
- markonthewall 10y agoI always enjoy a leppo after a good workout!
- mars4rp 10y agoYou are watching too much TV. read the article, first reason : media !!!!
- saalweachter 10y agoIn a pluralistic, democratic society you don't get to have everything go your way. You have to compromise with your fellow citizens to adopt the policies least-objectionable to the most people. A fifth or sixth major candidate in the election with exactly your political views is almost exactly as superfluous as three hundred million candidates, so each of us gets a candidate with exactly our views and we don't have to compromise at all when voting. Figure out which of your beliefs and views are most important and which you're willing to compromise on. Or get used to being a very bitter member of a pluralistic democratic society.
- macawfish 10y agoIt's very well established that the U.S. federal electoral system is game-theoretically "rigged", to use Trump's words. I want proportional representation, not this phoney pluralism. I'm talking about something beyond "ranked choice". I want serious mathematical, scientific rigor to be applied in developing a new voting system that is humane and practically secure from gaming in the 21st century. To be perfectly frank, my internal reaction to your comment was infuriation. Don't take it personally, just know that I'm "triggered" by this kind of patronizing political attitude that has marginalized me out of the conversation since before I even became eligible to vote. I know I'm not alone in that. There are thousands of representatives local and federal levels. It's not unreasonable for people like me to be asking for a less "compromising" process. I'm from Minnesota, and I remember when I was 17 and Paul Wellstone was killed, very possibly assassinated, before the Iraq war vote. Meanwhile, many of my classmates, children of politically established Minnesotans, told me that a vote for Ralph Nader was just short of treason. I'm writing this comment right now to say that I reject these kinds of attitudes entirely. On the contrary, people falling in behind these busted-ass mainstream parties should be grateful that, given the state of U.S. politics, we even have political participation from marginalized positions at all. This election is an indictment on this split populism of the establishment 2-party. The U.S. political process needs to evolve in a serious way or it's going to result in social/political/spiritual upheaval... for better or worse. I know it might sound irrational to you, but I'm getting ready to vote for Jill Stein right now. I am not "a liberal". I see no good reason, at this point, to vote for either of the "two choices". Seeing as how I'm not in a swing state, it strikes almost me as duty to vote against the two parties. Maybe if I lived in Florida, I'd vote for Clinton. But right now my "strategic vote" is to send a strong warning to the DFL establishment that they need to take voting reform very seriously.
- branchless 10y agoI don't like the current system because it has lots of side issues where parties claim to differentiate yet none of these effect the ruling classes. Where is the choice on land value tax, on money creation as debt? Nowhere, because they only want us to have a choice on issues that might actually challenge the roots of the system.
- uabstraction 10y agoCall me crazy, but I feel like there has to be a full blown conspiracy between the two parties (not necessarily the individual candidates), to keep us fighting over petty social issues which have no bearing on the social order. We fight over issues like gay marriage and abortion which make no difference to the establishment, while the cable companies strategically raise rates while reducing service and avoiding competition. The medical industry extorts us so the insurers' can get a 20% cut off a larger pie. Police departments around the nation use civil forfeiture to pay their bills and buy margarita machines. As long as elections can be won on bullshit tired issues like abortion, we'll never see any political progress - and that's just how the robber barons want it.
- slededit 10y agoCall me crazy, but the ability to chose who to marry or whether or not its permissible to end a life seems slightly more important than Comcast raising their prices again. Your other issues are quite valid, but I thought that was a very poor lead example.
- branchless 10y agoIt's an example of something the establishment can concede having pretended they care, that has no effect on them. If you care they love it as you will fight harder and longer which keeps you away from things they know will destroy them, like land value tax and questioning how money works. So it's the ideal example.
- uabstraction 10y agoI completely agree with you dude. I don't mean to imply that these issues are irrelevant. What I'm getting at is these issues are so aggrivatingly clear cut from a personal liberties perspective that they should have been resolved decades ago. Allowing people to marry who they want to, and giving people full autonomy over their bodies doesn't hurt anyone. Yet we let these issues continue to decide our elections. For the top hat wearing monopolist, it's great because politicians/pundits are so busy campaigning for/against abortion that nobody points a finger at the soul sucking corporations who run this country.
- ihaveahadron 10y agoIt started with MySpace. It's not about kids or not kids. It's just dumasses who thought 5e brand "MySpace" actually meant they had "space" on the internet because they clicked a few things to make fucking INTERNET ACCOUNT. and there are people that struggle with even THAT.
- mxfh 10y ago"cops lives matter AND civilian lives matter" Who says otherwise, seriously? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_to_moderation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_to_moderation
- Practicality 10y agoRegarding your link: But the middle ground often is the best solution in politics (not necessarily exactly in the middle, but definitely not on the extremes). Some examples: The best government is between Authoritarianism and Anarchy, rather than one or the other. Likewise the best government has an economy that is somewhere between completely free-market and absolutely government controlled and regulated. Both extremes have issues. The best legal government is somewhere between ultra-capitalist and ultra-communist: We don't want only two classes, super-rich and super-poor, but we don't need to make everyone exactly the same either. Likewise, private investment is definitely a good thing, and we want incentives, but we also don't want CEOs or boards being completely blameless when things go wrong, and we want good pay and good rights for the employees. Most people are ok with CEOs getting paid more that most employees, but most would prefer they not be paid anywhere near as much as they are. On and on it goes. Generally, the best position is a moderate one. The extremes are where the failure comes from. (There are always exceptions, so that is why I say generally).
- actsasbuffoon 10y agoYes, but sometimes the middle ground is pretty bad too. Consider college tuition. If you take a completely leftist approach then college tuition would be covered by the government. Many people would have college degrees, which would devalue them somewhat, but at least students wouldn't go into a decade of debt for it. It's an okay solution. If you take a completely rightist approach then the government would have nothing to do with paying for college. Either your family can afford to send you (or have good enough credit to get a private loan), or you just don't get to go. Fewer people would go to college, which would make degrees very valuable. In other words, it's hard to get a degree, but worth it. The people who can't get them shouldn't be forced out of the work force, because most people wouldn't have degrees. This is also an acceptable approach. The combination of the two is what we have now. We want everyone to go to college, so we make it easy to get huge unsecured loans that are almost impossible to get rid of. The loans are easy to get, so everyone does. Now degrees are expensive, but not worth much, because every other applicant also has one. There are other examples (like housing and health insurance) where the same thing plays out. Sometimes you just have to pick a side, or you get the worst of both worlds.
- Practicality 10y agoI don't get why we don't just have a moderate party that represents the majority. Despite what the news would seem to have us believe most people are moderate, rather than one extreme or the other.
- barsonme 10y agoFirst, the two major parties are so incredibly established that third parties barely exist. So, starting a third party that can compete with the other two is near impossible. Second, since radio and television (media) started catering towards individual interests (echo chamber) people get so wrapped up in "Hillary/Trump/Somebody is so evil!" that they _don't_ want to experiment because it could cause the person they dislike to win. Third, nobody cares about politics. We get ~40% turnout in midterm elections, ~60% for presidential. That's pitiful. Those who vote are those who _really_ like voting--those who are engaged. To break the stranglehold you'd need: - people to stop consuming sound bite media (Now This, Twitter) and tailored media (talk radio, some major news stations) - better civic engagement at the local level (this is _the_ most important bit) - better civic knowledge (the previous bullet point is predicated on this one) - people willing to run for office as a third party _and_ not be a fringe weirdo
- myowncrapulence 10y agopeople willing to run for office as a third party _and_ not be a fringe weirdo I genuinely believe Bernie could have won if he stayed independent. The two political parties are owned and operated as Corporations. They can choose whoever they want to represent them. There are no laws governing their inter-party behavior. This is why non-party candidates need to be taken seriously.
- komali2 10y agoI voted for Bernie, but how could he win independent if he couldn't win the Democratic primary?
- 10y ago
- aokyler 10y agoI agree completely with this. The spoiler effect has never been so real.
- afterburner 10y ago> I mean honestly how is it possible that of the 300 million people spread across one of the largest (geographical) countries in the world and one of the most diverse populations on the world, exactly half want one person to represent them, and exactly half want one other person to represent them. They don't; just like the article says, it's an effect of the first-past-the-post election model. Two strong parties emerge out of that. Not sure why some people consider the Democratic party "extreme". They most definitely seem like a moderate party. The Republican party, well, they're just incredibly laser focused on cutting taxes on the rich.
- barsonme 10y ago> Not sure why some people consider the Democratic party "extreme". They most definitely seem like a moderate party. The Republican party, well, they're just incredibly laser focused on cutting taxes on the rich. And Republicans would say the opposite. This is why we never get anywhere.
- afterburner 10y agoI don't think we can so easily simply paint both parties as mirror images of each other. The Republican party seems obviously broken.
- ng12 10y agoIf you're referring to this election specifically I actually envy the Republicans. Trump was able to cut through the party and rally a huge base basically by himself. Even if he loses it's an amazing opportunity for the party to reinvent itself. Meanwhile the Dems double-down on the status quo year after year.
- CalChris 10y agoObama was the status quo? Bill Clinton was the status quo? Carter was the status quo? JFK was the status quo? How many times were Reagan and Nixon going to run before they got the nod? McCain? Romney? W's singular skill was being the son of a former President. Yeah, Hillary is running for Obama's third term. But otherwise Dems don't double down year after year. That'd be the Republicans. Trump's bull in a china shop approach doesn't change this.
- RandomName2020 10y ago> pro-life atheist, or a pro-gun liberal, I am both. And understand the pain of being a square peg.
- Practicality 10y agoYou sound like a fun person to have drinks with and discuss ideas :)
- RandomName2020 10y agoNot sure about it...
- baddox 10y ago> I mean honestly how is it possible that of the 300 million people spread across one of the largest (geographical) countries in the world and one of the most diverse populations on the world, exactly half want one person to represent them, and exactly half want one other person to represent them. It doesn't make sense. You're confusing how someone votes with what their ranked preferences are. I suspect that many people vote for someone who is not their most preferred candidate (particularly in this election, where the two major party candidates are extremely unpopular). And that makes sense, given that only one person can be President at a time and the USA uses first-past-the-post voting for presidential elections. This tends to lead to only two dominant parties (Duverger's law).
- btrask 10y agoI came up with a voting strategy that I call single issue tactical voting. The idea is that you pick what you think is the single most underrated issue, and announce you will either vote for your major candidate, or third party, depending on whether the major candidate agrees to support your issue. This works around Arrow's impossibility theorem and doesn't require any changes to the voting system. The goal is not to change the outcome of the election (if everyone is rational the outcome will be the same), but to influence the candidate's specific policies. I was partly inspired by this application of game theory: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=coWgbmlvRTU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=coWgbmlvRTU I've been meaning to do a full writeup but hesitant in the current election climate... :)
- ktRolster 10y agoIf you're going to do a writeup, you might as well just add your research to Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single-issue_politics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single-issue_politics
- jbpetersen 10y agoAFAIK Wikipedia only approves of third-hand or more distant accounts being used in its articles. Something has to be done, then talked about, then Wiki talks about the talking about it.
- mcv 10y agoThat's basically what Sanders did with Clinton. He supports her in exchange for her embracing many of his issues.
- tdb7893 10y agoI've always been under the impression that the two party system exists in an equilibrium and it naturally goes to about a 50/50 split. Both parties are fighting for support so if one party gets more than 50% of the vote there is a huge incentive to shift your positions to get back to equilibrium. Imagine if there were policies that would get Republicans reliably 70% of the vote, in this situation Democrats would want to adopt very similar policies and restore the balance. I think you'll see this happen with gay marriage in the next decade or so where both parties are for it.
- maxxxxx 10y agoI really wish that a party that gets a certain amount of votes would get representation in Congress without having to win districts. That's an incredibly high bar for a new party. One or two more parties in Congress would make the current obstruction tactics much more difficult.
- dsr_ 10y agoChanging to a parliamentary system would require a huge constitutional amendment. Remember that the innocuous Equal Rights Amendment has still not passed: the chance of a sweeping reform on that scale is probably very similar to the chance of having a successful revolt. So, in short, if you really want a parliamentary democracy, you'll need to move to one.
- maxxxxx 10y agoI have no illusions that the US system will change any time soon. But I think it's important to throw out ideas from time to time.
- farright 10y agoThe problem is people are taught from an early age that it's good to be an activist which means to focus on convincing people of a certain policy or viewpoint, instead of stating one's own reasoning. You'll often see "10 reasons to support X" which is unlikely to be intellectually honest since usually people will support X for 1 or 2 reasons, and might agree with certain arguments against X. E.g. I support something like basic income, but I notice two contradictory arguments are used. The first says that basic income increases the incentive to work for the poor. The second says that basic income releases the poor from being forced into low pay work, and allows them to use their free time on positive things. These are contradictory, but you never see basic income advocates arguing this point among themselves. Instead of encouraging people to be activists, we should be encouraging them to be intellectually honest. Very few issues are so important that they justify using marketing techniques that ultimately corrode the effectiveness of public debate.
- robomartin 10y agoHey, apparently now you can fire them both! Saw this earlier today on HN, don't have a link to the post handy. The site is easy to remember though: http://www.youarefired.com http://www.youarefired.com The guy/gal who posted was trying to figure out what to do after the elections. To your point, Maybe allow for more than two points of view? :)
- jimbokun 10y ago" People who watch Fox news don't want to hear about Trump rape allegations, they want to watch news casters talk about Evil Hillary. It's the reverse for CNN." I think you are falling into your own "black or white" trap here. Sean Hannity is singular in the way he is a sycophant for Trump. I struggle to think of a similar personality for Hillary on any other news network. I mean, CNN made a point to hire Trump's former campaign manager, and he seems to be on the air around half the time I randomly turn on their channel.
- notoothpaste 10y agoWhere is the coverage of the content of the Wikileaks emails? The Project Veritas undercover investigations of Clinton pseudo-PACs paid to cause violence at rallies? Huma's connections to the Muslim Brotherhood and Omar Naseef that funded Al Qaeda and Osama Bin Laden? That the Clintons were involved with child sex trafficker Jeffery Epstein, or that Bill flew to his child rape resort island over 20 times, often refusing Secret Service accompaniment? That Hillary has been involved with child trafficker Laura Silsby for at least 15 years and personally got her off the hook during the Haiti crisis? Any mention of George Soros? It's all completely, intentionally ignored, in favor of ridiculous false allegations against Trump. You cannot name a particularly egregious sycophant for Hillary because her handlers own the media.
- warlox 10y agoThe only ridiculous false allegations in your comment are the ones against George Soros. The allegations against Trump are neither (provably) false nor ridiculous. Donald Trump is just as involved with Epstein as Bill Clinton is.
- notoothpaste 10y agoNone of those statements about the Clintons give you pause or merit a response? Are you really ok with any of that? >The only ridiculous false allegations in your comment are the ones against George Soros. That is far too deep a rabbit hole to get into in an HN comment, but for starters, he is both one of Hillary's largest donors, and he owns the companies that make our voting machines. The very same voting machines that have already in early voting experienced a high frequency of "glitches" flipping votes from straight-ticket conservative ballots to Hillary. >The allegations against Trump are neither (provably) false nor ridiculous... Donald Trump is just as involved with Epstein as Bill Clinton is. He flew on his plane once when he needed to get from (IIRC) Florida to NYC quickly. Eye witnesses confirmed that there weren't any young girls on the flight, let alone females. The media doesn't push Trump + Epstein because they know they have nothing and that it would only backfire on the Clintons. Here's a bit from Wikipedia to me about the Trump child assault allegations. Unless you have your head in the sand and want to hate Trump, they sure sound like bullshit to me. "Another woman, identified as Katie Johnson, filed a lawsuit in California on April 26, 2016, accusing Epstein and Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump of raping her in 1994, when she was 13 years old.[52][53][54] Judges Ronnie Abrams and James C. Francis IV presided over the case against Epstein and Trump.[55] The suit was dismissed after it was determined that the address listed for "Katie Johnson" was a foreclosed abandoned home whose resident had died and the provided telephone contact information was also not a functioning contact.[52] A new lawsuit was filed in June 2016, this time in a Manhattan federal court, and without some of the initial accusations made in the initial lawsuit, including claims by the plaintiff that Trump threw money for an abortion at Johnson and that he called Epstein a "Jew bastard".[56] The lawsuit was voluntarily dismissed in September. Her lawyer stated that she would re-file the lawsuit and would provide an additional witness to substantiate the claims.[57] On September 30, 2016, a woman identified as "Jane Doe" (the same person previously identified as "Katie Johnson" in the California lawsuit) filed a new lawsuit in New York, with an additional witness identified by the pseudonym "Joan Doe".[58][59] There is no further information on these allegations outside the claims made anonymously by "Katie Johnson" and "Joan Doe".[52] Civil rights lawyer and legal analyst Lisa Bloom wrote in June 2016 that the claims by the anonymous individuals were credible.[54] However, journalist Jon Swaine reported in The Guardian in July 2016 that the "Katie Johnson" lawsuits appeared to be orchestrated by Norm Lubow, a former producer on the The Jerry Springer Show, whom he described as "an eccentric anti-Trump campaigner with a record of making outlandish claims about celebrities".[60]"
- pj_mukh 10y agoI'm all for America having multiple parties. But remember, for any execution to happen, for the Government to function, pass laws and stay adaptable, the multiple parties will have to align and agree. To not go to war, the anti-war economic conservative and the Code Pink socialists would have to agree to come together on the issue. The way America is divided, I don't see how this happens easily. It is difficult even in politically stable countries (see: Liberals and NDP in Canada). However, it is by and large the primary mode of operation for most democratic countries. The largest democracy, India, has 10's (100's?) of federal parties that organically align and dis-align to gain power on wedge issues.
- imgabe 10y ago> cops lives matter AND civilian lives matter This isn't an issue that needs a middle ground. Black Lives Matter never said that cop lives don't. It didn't need to be said that cop lives matter because cops were already treated as though their lives mattered. When a cop gets killed nobody says "Well, he probably had it coming".
- brandon272 10y agoBLM should really have been called Black Lives Matter Too
- mcv 10y agoThat would certainly have cleared up this confusion where some people seem to read it as "Only Black Lives Matter". Nobody ever said that, but opponents seem to be arguing that that's what BLM means.
- komali2 10y ago>Well he probably had it coming I've witnessed people saying exactly that. You can't argue that anti-cop violence is any less real of a problem than anti-black violence. What about the shooting in Dallas?
- jlj 10y agoThis is one reason why https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Median_voter_theorem https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Median_voter_theorem
- lsh123 10y agoIn my experience (including my experience on HN), people who are in the middle get slashed from both sides. Qui non nobiscum, adversus nos est.
- btbuildem 10y agoThe first part of your post is the answer to the part after "ninjaedit". If the political spectrum had more than one-bit resolution, you'd see all sorts of colours. Here, is only black or white. From afar, it looks grey, hence the apparent 50-50 split. Everyone falls into one of two buckets, and chances are roughly equal.
- odbol_ 10y ago> pro-life atheist, or a pro-gun liberal, or an anti-war economic conservative You just described Libertarianism