14 ms·
Why Are US Presidential Elections So Close?
- codingdave 10y agoThe chart at the top of this article directly opposes their own premise that presidential elections for the last 100 years have been close to 50/50.
- bbctol 10y agoI'd at least want some idea of what to compare it to. That's certainly closer than if we assigned percentages at random. On the other hand, my intuition is they're less close than if every voter was picking at random, though I'm not sure if either of those counterworlds is relevant to the argument.
- mikeash 10y agoEach voter picking at random will get you almost exactly 50/50 every time, because the sample size is so large. The expected variance goes with the square root of the sample size, so with 100 million voters, you'd expect the outcome of each voter choosing randomly to be about 10,000 off from exactly 50/50. Here's a quick Python snippet to test it empirically: print sum(random.randint(0, 1) for x in xrange(0, 100000000)) (I strongly recommend using pypy to run it. CPython takes forever to complete.) With 8 runs, I got these results: 49995906 50003341 50009287 49996048 49996424 49993962 49989590 50002171 All of which require at least two decimal places in the percentage to be distinguishable from 50% each way.
- foota 10y agoParent is saying if we randomly chose the outcome, not the votes.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoSure. But why should we expect random percentages to have any relationship to reality? (I would argue that random votes isn't related to reality either...)
- mikeash 10y agoHuh? "than if every voter was picking at random" Sounds like what I showed to me.
- ryanmonroe 10y agoPretty amazing. If the outcome is determined by 100 million independent coin flips, the probability of a margin greater than one tenth of a percent is 1.5e-23. In R n <- 100000000 diff <- 0.1/100 a_wins <- n*(1-diff)/2 b_wins <- n*(1+diff)/2 p1 <- pbinom(a_wins, size = n, prob = 0.5) p2 <- pbinom(b_wins, size = n, prob = 0.5, lower.tail = F) p1 + p2 # = 1.523959e-23
- cafard 10y agoIndeed. Apart from Kennedy v. Nixon in 1960, the two really close elections of the 20th Century involved third parties: Wallace in 1968, Nader in 2000.
- bryanlarsen 10y agoI guess it's a matter of perspective. In my eyes, even the blowout of 1984 was fairly close. Mondale got over 40% of the vote, which is enough to win with a wide margin in most countries where there are more than two viable parties.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoTrue. But if there were more than two viable parties, Mondale wouldn't have gotten 40% of the vote...
- afterburner 10y agoReagan getting almost 50% more votes than Mondale is close to you?
- usefulcat 10y ago..and the '92 election had a third party (Perot) who got much more of the popular vote than Nader did in 2000 (I think it was 24%)
- vonklaus 10y agoPolling data is lagging, but the state department just released >300 emails. Not unlikely U.S is source of leak not Russia. Total media blackout. NYT, Bloomberg, CNN, WaPo, ect. 538 has a 3.1 popular vote margin and in the last 24ish hours Trump has gone from 80/20 to 60/40. Many sides manipulating information, so both amplify their candidate. Going to be very close
- DominikR 10y agoAnd the FBI Twitter account is also leaking information about the Clintons. If you ask me the FBI and other government agencies want to bring HRC down, probably for her reckless handling of classified information. Either this or these agencies are secretly controlled by Putin.
- dragonwriter 10y agoOr, not-secretly controlled by Republicans, in the case of the FBI.
- DominikR 10y agoHm, so it's a Russian-Republican FBI-CIA conspiracy against Hillary? Even though 2 weeks ago Comey was praised by the Democrats for not indicting HRC. They sure are all out to get her it seems.
- WillPostForFood 10y agoThat's weak sauce argument. If the FBI was controlled by Republicans they would have indicted Hillary Clinton for mishandling classified information instead of giving a press conference letting her off the hook. And they would have let General Petraeus (who was a potential Republican primary candidate) off instead of bringing charges against him. FBI was a hero to Democrats and a villain to Republicans a couple months ago and now it flipped. So the FBI probably isn't controlled by either party.
- dragonwriter 10y ago
- msluyter 10y agoA similar take on the issue in this old Slate article: http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/kausfiles_special/2002/10/fiftyfifty_forever.html http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/kausfiles_sp... Choice quote: "But why should we expect the deadlock to be broken at all? Think of it in ... well, cheap Darwinian terms. Imagine that we have a two party system, and each party is a collection of status-seeking individuals looking for power by winning a greater "market share" of the vote. Imagine that they each have their ideological principles --one is more to the left, one more to the right -- but these principles are quite flexible in the face of imminent or repeated failure at the polls. Over time, as each party crafts its message to maximize its appeal -- and adjusts its message after each election to regain any lost share of the votes -- wouldn't one expect the system to reach a roughly 50-50 equilibrium, in which every election was a cliffhanger?"
- ktRolster 10y agoThere is no position that either party holds so strongly that they wouldn't switch immediately if it became expedient. Which party is the 'pro-war' party? Which party is the 'pro-public healthcare' party? Which party is the 'small-government' party? Both parties have been on both sides of these lines in the last two decades. Yes, and you can see it happening after every election. For example, as soon as gay marriage passed the 50% level of popularity, both parties switched position, saying they favored it to some degree. Democrats switched faster (because of their local politics), but Republicans had a gay speaker at their convention. One of the toughest issues used to be abortion, until democrats softened on it somewhat, and they let anti-abortion candidates into the party (which is why Bart Stupak, a democrat, held up Obamacare based on opposition to abortion). Democrats were anti-war under Bush (but they voted for his wars anyway), and Republicans were anti-war under Clinton (but they voted for his wars anyway). If any view on an issue is clearly a loser, no candidate will espouse that view.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoAnd this is part of why voters are so angry at establishment politicians. They've figured out that politicians have positions, not convictions. Many of the voters, on the other hand, actually have convictions, and want to vote for people that share those convictions. This is what the Tea Party was about - people got tired of Republicans who were happy to vote for large government spending. Many Republicans quit voting for candidates who wore the "R" label but didn't have any actual convictions (at least, they voted against them in the primaries). But I think in this election cycle, the anger is higher than it's been in my memory, partly because neither presidential candidate's convictions are what anybody wants. Hillary doesn't have any convictions, except that she should be elected by any means necessary. Trump has convictions, though they change from day to day, and many of them are convictions that an honorable man would be ashamed of having ever thought, let alone spoken aloud.
- saalweachter 10y agotldr: Article claims elections are close because the two major parties are intentionally ideologically similar. I am not impressed by the article, which does not delve into actual party positions, reasons voters give for voting, or well-known blocks of voters, and instead gives an analogy about ice cream vendors.
- waqf 10y agoThen you missed the point of the article, which is about why the parties in a system like the US's can be expected to be ideologically similar, based on game-theoretic considerations. I mean, you may have the opinion that it's a trivial or incorrect point that wasn't worth expressing, but you seem not to be aware that it's there at all. (tl;dr: you didn't like the article because it had the temerity not to be the article you were expecting. Who knows, if one read such articles one might learn something one didn't already know!)
- saalweachter 10y agoWell no, it's more that I thought it was completely insane to state that the Republican and Democratic parties are ideologically similar. They diverge radically on a large number of issues that voters care about. So talking about "why they become similar" is inane.
- golemotron 10y agoThe Median Voter Theorem is too specific. Both sides don't have become as much like each as possible to compete. They can compete by taking positions on new issues progressively over a campaign to seek advantage or by reframing earlier positions.
- eli_gottlieb 10y agoWhile the article nicely deploys undergrad political science, I don't really think that the median voter theorem can possibly be true as described. The thing is, the nominal "center" around which the two-party system orbits moves, on timescales of decades. If we assume both parties gravitate towards a genuinely "privileged" (in the sense that the origin point of a coordinate system is privileged) center, it shouldn't do that: the center should remain exactly where it allows the two parties to split the country down the middle and never shift. Instead, what we observe is that our political center has been moved further and further into the Republican Party, ever since the '70s. Prior to that, during the fifth party system, the political center rested with a coalition of urban and Southern working-class Democrats. Now in our current election, the center seems to be moving into wealthy suburbs and Silicon Valley, libertarian-lite. The interesting question is what sort of forces move the center and alter the composition of the party-system at any given time.
- zeveb 10y ago> Instead, what we observe is that our political center has been moved further and further into the Republican Party, ever since the '70s. Perhaps in an economic sense, but hardly in a cultural sense (other than guns, is there a single Republican cultural issue which has been winning against its Democratic inverse?).
- eli_gottlieb 10y agoYou're right: the cultural center has shifted glacially to the left over time, with erratic jumps back to the right when the Republicans actually hold supermajority power, followed by further gradual leftward drift when they lose it. Though in an economic sense, yeah, my original point stands. And actually, it's strengthened in a way: how can we talk about the median voter theorem pushing the parties to the center if they spent the whole most recent party system both moving strongly to the right on economic issues while moving erratically but consistently to the left on social issues? That would mean there isn't even one center!
- marmaduke 10y agoThink tanks, reframing issues? I'm thinking of Lakoff's work.
- kordless 10y agoDissonance, basically. Dissonance manifests as diametrically opposed views in society. It's also what makes reality, reality. See "this video will make you angry" on Youtube for the meme context.
- komali2 10y agoThis is what I don't like about the current zeitgeist. Things are either black or white. You are either Red or Blue. Conservative or Liberal. Democrat or Republican. Right or Left. There is no room in this political system for a pro-life atheist, or a pro-gun liberal, or an anti-war economic conservative. There's no room on the internet for a third party voter, or someone who both believes cops lives matter AND civilian lives matter, or any other middle ground. You're either a 4chan user or a Tumbler user, you're either a Hillarybot or a Trumpbot. Reasons for this I believe include upvote/downvote trains on the internet, clickbait headlines, and networks streamlining content to cater to certain audiences. People who watch Fox news don't want to hear about Trump rape allegations, they want to watch news casters talk about Evil Hillary. It's the reverse for CNN. Remember in the Bush era how blatantly Fox news was a Republican news-horn, and how the case is the same now for CNN and Clinton? Euck. Can't stand it. No room for moderates, your voice won't get heard if you aren't making someone stamp their feet. Ninjaedit: I mean honestly how is it possible that of the 300 million people spread across one of the largest (geographical) countries in the world and one of the most diverse populations on the world, exactly half want one person to represent them, and exactly half want one other person to represent them. It doesn't make sense.
- mars4rp 10y agoanti-war economic conservative : Gary Johnson
- markonthewall 10y agoI always enjoy a leppo after a good workout!
- mars4rp 10y agoYou are watching too much TV. read the article, first reason : media !!!!
- saalweachter 10y agoIn a pluralistic, democratic society you don't get to have everything go your way. You have to compromise with your fellow citizens to adopt the policies least-objectionable to the most people. A fifth or sixth major candidate in the election with exactly your political views is almost exactly as superfluous as three hundred million candidates, so each of us gets a candidate with exactly our views and we don't have to compromise at all when voting. Figure out which of your beliefs and views are most important and which you're willing to compromise on. Or get used to being a very bitter member of a pluralistic democratic society.
- SapphireSun 10y agoHere's an analysis of the problems with First Past the Post which nearly always generates a two party system: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s7tWHJfhiyo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s7tWHJfhiyo
- sampo 10y agoUSA gets some slack for being more or less the first (still existing) democracy in the world. But in the modern world, First-Past-the-Post should not be considered full democracy anymore, but only some level of proto-democracy, since proportional representation systems are so much better. It's like, democracy-wise, Americans are all still driving around in Ford T-Models.
- mvid 10y agoIs there a way to have proportional representation for a single person elected office? I understand how it works in parliament or multiple person offices, but isn't there still a necessity for a direct voting mechanism when you are electing a single person?
- Retra 10y agoThe US used to take second place as Vice President, if I understand it correctly.
- SapphireSun 10y agoYou may not be able to have a proportional representation, but you can at least offer something like instant runoff or approval voting to ensure that you can vote for candidates you actually like rather than have to vote strategically for a major party candidate exclusively.
- sampo 10y ago> Is there a way to have proportional representation for a single person elected office? No. (Well maybe runoff voting would be a slight improvement.) My point was that with proportional voting, you get more than two viable parties in the parliament, and thus the whole political landscape will be different. And more than two parties will be putting forward their presidential candidates, too.
- mtw 10y agoThis would have been the perfect election to have a third alternative. But unfortunately, the american political system is not made for this. Time for change?
- merpnderp 10y agoBut which party is going to spearhead allowing for more party choice?
- knz 10y agoI don't disagree but I do wonder what that would even look like. Do we need to change the system? The players/politicians? Groups exerting influence onto the system (the media, big business, big unions)? Push more decisions to the State level? Good luck untangling that mess... we can't even agree to end crap like gerrymandering and voter suppression.
- wrsh07 10y agoThere's a "law" that describes this: Duverger's Law [1] Pedantry follows: First past the post is [more or less] the election system we have - you select one candidate. Candidate with plurality [that's a generalization of a majority, ie the person with the most votes even if they don't have > 50%] wins. There are lots of alternatives, and even a ballot initiative in Maine [2] to switch to a different type of voting system known as Ranked Choice Voting. New types of voting systems are exciting, but complexity lends itself to a poor user interface. So more sophisticated forms of voting actually depress poll #s [I'll just cite Harry talking about this ballot initiative in this podcast [3]]. If you're looking to ever have a real alternative to the big two, the path to that is convincing your local government to switch voting systems. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duverger%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duverger%27s_law [2]: https://ballotpedia.org/Maine_Ranked_Choice_Voting_Initiative,_Question_5_(2016) https://ballotpedia.org/Maine_Ranked_Choice_Voting_Initiativ... [3]: http://fivethirtyeight.com/features/elections-podcast-countdown-11-days/ http://fivethirtyeight.com/features/elections-podcast-countd... [Edit: put scare quotes around law]
- abecedarius 10y ago
- harshreality 10y ago> Also, Trump is not acting like a rational ice cream seller. He has not appeared to move his policy portfolio, to the extent he has one, toward the center. “Rational candidates end up pivoting, and trying to move as much as they can back toward the center. But of course right now there’s one presidential candidate who’s not doing that at all,” Tom Vogl, a Princeton economist, told me. Because the "rational" policy depends on politics being 1-dimensional. Trump has refused to deal with politics that way. The ice cream theory is how things work normally, the same way that Newtonian mechanics works normally, but when you find yourself in a situation with extreme gravity wells or high velocities, using Newtonian mechanics to solve problems can get you killed. Everyone knows politics isn't really one-dimensional. It just ends up being treated that way in plurality voting races because mathematics enforces it, unless you want to take a big risk and upset the apple cart. When you get an opponent who can triangulate an extreme non-centrist position in multi-dimensional politics, moving to the 1-dimensional center might be fatal because of negative traits that centrism implies on certain dimensions that the other candidate has made the campaign about.
- LordHumungous 10y ago>The competition for votes between the Republican and Democratic parties does not lead to a clear drawing of issues, an adoption of two strongly contrasted positions between which the voter may choose. Instead, each party strives to make its platform as much like the other’s as possible Problem with that theory is, the two parties aren't close in the slightest. Democrats prefer expanding the social safety net, minority rights, etc. Republicans prefer... the opposite.
- ktRolster 10y agoDemocrats prefer expanding the social safety net Which party had a healthcare plan in 2008? Was the 'individual mandate' a Republican or Democratic idea?
- ktRolster 10y agoDemocrats prefer expanding the social safety net Which party had a healthcare plan in 2008? Was the 'individual mandate' a Republican or Democratic idea?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- lutorm 10y agoThe other dimension is turnout. With the ridiculously low turnout in US elections, the people not voting could probably elect a third candidate if they all suddenly decided to. It seems that elections are won and lost at least as much by whose supporters bother to show up as by people switching allegiances.
- jlj 10y ago9% of American voters was all it took for Clinton and Trump to win the primaries. http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2016/08/01/us/elections/nine-percent-of-america-selected-trump-and-clinton.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2016/08/01/us/elections/n... The "public" debates are sponsored by a partisan non-profit that is controlled by the Democrats and Republicans. Ogliarchs do not like competition. Their tax-exempt status is being challenged in court but other lawsuits have been unsuccessful. http://www.shapiroarato.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/Memorandum-of-Points-and-Authorities.pdf http://www.shapiroarato.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/Memor... Polling requirements for other political parties are arbitrary 15%, but the media companies write the polls to exclude minor party candidates, and the major parties control the media. Billions $USD are spent on political advertising and propaganda. The Citizens United case allows unlimited spending for political activities. Congress does not have term limits, further consolidating power within the major parties. Most Americans don't know or don't care that there are other options. In WA there are 7 candidates on the ballot. But in the left/right paradigm that the powers insure is the only public dialogue, there will always be a race to the middle. This explains why: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Median_voter_theorem https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Median_voter_theorem I'll be voting for Gary Johnson. Ignoring biased media accounts of him, he's one of the few honest candidates and his platform mostly aligns with my own. Being public about this has cost me some relationships this year. I've never seen the amount of negativity and belligerance on social media. The only good thing to come of it, is I finally deleted my Facebook account. This election has brought out the worst in us, and we will get who we deserve on November 8th.
- rahrahrah 10y agoThe median voter theorem isn't the whole story, not even close. In particular, it assumes that most of voters are driven by what parties say about themselves in terms of policy, which is manifestly not true. When Trump says he won't cut social security, people from deep republican states say "yeah he cares about the american people, he's with the little guy", whereas when a democrat says the same thing they go "boo he wants to social medicine, commie". There was this study that showed when remove parties from policies, something like 90% of the population wants free health care for all, free education for all, richer people to be taxed more, not less. 90% isn't really split down the middle.