5 ms·
Tried Facebook ads for Pokemon Go ( 2nd largest Facebook group in my country - Belgium), had some success there ( 330.000 people reach / week for a month). But
by NicoJuicy 10y ago
Tried Facebook ads for Pokemon Go ( 2nd largest Facebook group in my country - Belgium), had some success there ( 330.000 people reach / week for a month). But it's not worth it for regular businesses. I started a webshop and Google AdWords seems to be the way to go.
Side note, we did events. One Facebook group had 2x as many members and was also spanning the Netherlands, they had 1/10th of our ticket sales. We were the first to combine amusement parks with Pokémon Go ( and cheaper then normal tickets, our revenue was a % on the ticket price)
Facebook seems to be an empty bucket. The ones who share your posts, share everything from everyone, while you give things away for free. It's the only way to receive a lot of likes, but those aren't the people you want and going to buy your stuff.
You aren't anything with likes. Invest in newsletters and a decent email campaign, that way you don't have to pay for the people that 'subscribed' to you, to let them see posts.
Ps. Pokemon Go was 0,03 € / like. Normal businesses pay 1€ / like in my experience. Don't go that road :)
Ps2. I don't do remarketing too. But that's personal preference, as i don't want to stalk people. I want them to find me, when they are looking for me
Ps3. AdWords for me is 1€/ day, which is the minimum. And I'm quite happy with it for my niche, which gives me 10 visitors and 1 purchase every 2 days ( pretty high margin)
Ps4. If you want to go on Facebook, remember you have to pay for: promoting your post, promoting your page and promoting your website. So facebook passes 3 times at the cash register. Pokemon Go was all on max for several days, which is 50€ x 3 per day! And in case you forgot, likes !== Customers and you still have to write good content :)
- the_watcher 10y agoI've been running >$1M annually in ads on Facebook for real businesses (both B2B and B2c) to great success. They have a higher CAC than AdWords, but perform substantially better than display ads, and consistently bring in clients that are top of funnel, but turn out to be high quality.
- NicoJuicy 10y agoIt seems to be your business: https://www.survata.com/ https://www.survata.com/ ( no offence, i'm just carefull when it's someone's work, but you did mention it) i'm curious about any real stats actually :) - Eg. http://www.denverpost.com/2012/07/03/gm-reconsiders-paid-facebook-advertising/ http://www.denverpost.com/2012/07/03/gm-reconsiders-paid-fac...
- the_watcher 10y agoI don't mind discussing it. It's not a secret, as anyone on Facebook could simply visit our website and look forward to a Facebook ad :)! I first started running large scale Facebook campaigns at another employer (b2c) in 2013, ran them until I left there in mid-2014, and after a bit of a step away from them while moving across the country and getting a new job, we've begun running them again. While I can't share specific stats, we've acquired real leads that have turned into customers at a cost that we're comfortable with right now. I'll admit that at a company with different unit economics and lifetime behavior, the calculus would be different, but my point was simply that Facebook ads do work for businesses, if not all businesses. Also, have to give Facebook credit for continually improving the product (though the Power Editor remains insanely frustrating and I'd do anything for an offline AdWords Editor for Facebook). If you'd like to discuss in more detail, shoot me an email and I'll answer any questions I can.
- rufb 10y agoThere is no point in acquiring page likes, for two reasons: first, as you mentioned, after you paid to acquire the like you'll still have to pay to reach those people with your campaign (organic reach is peanuts these days); second, targeting ads at fans rather than any other segmentation makes no difference for your campaign cost structure. To be fair, all things being equal, Fans have better CPM than interest-based clusters ("people who like such pages and such topics") on average. But that's not a Facebook incentive, it's merely a statistical correlation between someone having liked your page and the likelihood of their reaction to your ads being positive (which drives the relevance score up, in turn bringing the CPM down). But you can find even better results with proper behavior-based targeting (in particular remarketing). When I'm surveying the competition, net fan growth is a useful metric to keep in hand because it leaks information. High churn is indicative of sponsored content targeted towards fans only (which usually comes hand-in-hand with outdated content strategies such as increasingly like-bait content and equally distributed total engagement across many posts), while positive net fan growth can be coupled with total engagements and views and some qualitative observations in order to ballpark competitor's budget and broad-strokes strategy. If I'm being honest, looking at the cost-effectiveness of both branding and performance campaigns on Facebook, it remains a secondary channel and gives no signs of ever meriting a prime role in my campaigns. Production costs, data lock-in opportunity costs and its highly kafkaesque tools and available metrics only make things worse. In my years in advertising it's been repeatedly demonstrable that about every other DSP performs better than Facebook (across all industries and campaign goals I've worked with), whose only clear strength seems to be having massive inventory with a pretty decent coverage, making it a one-stop-shop for small and medium businesses and making itself a required line item in large companies media planning. That's great for them, I'm sure, but they simply don't deliver as well as about anything else I work with, and that translates into a "when in doubt start by decreasing the Facebook budget and reallocating it somewhere else" pattern that you see everywhere. That may turn out to be a long term threat for them, I don't know. Their recent closing of FBX is telling: I for one had better results running Facebook campaigns through 3rd party DSPs than through Facebook itself, even at a premium on the CPM. ---- edit. – I realize I mentioned CPM 3 times and no other metric, here's why: most Facebook optimizations involve finding the cheapest inventory that is on-target (for branding campaigns) or high-conversion (for performance campaigns). So trying to grok your campaign results always leads back to CPM, even though my job is usually to deliver something more useful to the client such as low CPA, high ROI or even additional reach with better CPP for their TVC campaign.
- unclebucknasty 10y agoFacebook's encouragement of businesses to build FB pages, then have their own customers like them on Facebook seemed like a win-win--a mutual leveraging of cross-engagement. But, Facebook's later flipping the switch to make those businesses pay to reach their own customers was a completely underhanded bait-and-switch. Still leaves a bad taste in my mouth all of these years later.
- NicoJuicy 10y agoI absolutely agree. Also, the 'find people by their likes' is just good in theory. All of your likes are going to be of people who share everything
- Ntrails 10y agoThey probably also have 1000+ friends, half of whom have hidden their activity because it's all spam
- searine 10y agoHard lesson for companies that you need to own your subscribers, not lease them from twitter/facebook/instagram.
- stevesearer 10y agoThis is why I'm hesitant to switch my business Instagram account to be an official business page. I don't sell anything so the ecommerce/insight tools don't really appeal, but I can definitely see the future of having to "boost" posts to you followers.
- unclebucknasty 10y agoWhat's worse is that it's "buying" them (via hard-won marketing efforts), giving them to FB, then paying FB to lease them back. But, of course, that wasn't the original deal--else no one would have signed up for it.
- shostack 10y ago