8 ms·
It's the same short-termism you see in the sports world. Every season starting around now, the top clubs in Europe will start to fire managers who aren't perfo
by lordnacho 10y ago
It's the same short-termism you see in the sports world.
Every season starting around now, the top clubs in Europe will start to fire managers who aren't performing well. Despite the fact that a soccer team is something that has a bit of momentum and can't be changed all that quickly.
You then hire a new guy, and you have to pay a premium. For one, there are fewer people available because you're in a hurry. For another, any new guy will see there's a risk of getting canned, so he'll want more money to compensate. And finally, you'll have painted yourself into a corner because you need someone who is perceived to be better than the guy you just canned.
- The board members live off being board members. So just like analysts at banks, they herd together. Nobody is going to stick their head out on a candidate who is not like what they think everyone would want.
- There's an illusion of control. The idea that you can change outcomes predictably is a big problem. This guy will turn around sales. That guy is better with people. The reality is such judgements are quite blurry and likely to be spectral rather than binary. And a lot depends on environment.
- Desperation for action. If things are going badly, something must be done. This is something, so it must be done. (Yes Minister). This is another area where an understanding of statistics would help. Your team/company's losing streak is utterly natural. Replacing the guy at the helm when you get a streak is just likely to cause the next guy to get undeserved credit (which reinforces the cycle).
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Thlom 10y agoPlus you usually have to pay the old manager for his full contract.
- ythl 10y ago> Desperation for action. If things are going badly, something must be done. This is something, so it must be done. I see this in politics a lot. If things are going badly (another "mass shooting" happens), something must be done. Even if the solution is crap (ban "assault weapons") it is something, so it must be done.
- plurinshael 10y agoGiven that we cannot provide free or extremely inexpensive mental health care, or somehow get 340mil Americans not to behave like jackals and crass narcissists all the time, to actually treat each other with respect, dignity, and compassion, I do not see how banning assault weapons is a "crap" solution. Sure, other guns may still be available but at least it's something.
- pc86 10y agoThis is exactly what the GP is referring to. "We have to do something! This thing won't actually solve the problem but it lets me feel better because we did something, so let's do it! Pretty close to the definition of a crap solution.
- croon 10y agoIt won't stop any one occurence from happening, but it likely will mitigate the damage on that occurence. It's hard to argue it's not at least a step in the right direction. But I agree it won't solve the problem at heart.
- pc86 10y agoNot trying to get into an off-topic political discussion, but the AWB I'm familiar with is almost entirely cosmetic in nature and would not have prevented any of the tragedies that are often used to prop it up. There are many effective things that could be done to lessen gun violence without needlessly restricting something that has no connection to that violence. Barrel shrouds are cosmetic but they make something an assault weapon, as does a pistol grip on a shotgun (which makes it less accurate for 99.9% of users). Comprehensive, mandatory background checks? Of course. "This gun looks scary and is therefore dangerous?" Nonsense.
- Retric 10y agoIf it where purely cosmetic people would not be fighting it. Instead, there is opposition specifically because it is a meaningful, though small change. A purely cosmetic change would be requiring all guns to be panted orange. PS: Most people don't have tools or mechanical know how, making 'simple' changes difficult.
- mathattack 10y agoThe alternative is clubby environments where CEOs are removed from market pressures entirely - look at the US auto industry in the 60s and 70s.
- arethuza 10y agoThe "Politician's Syllogism": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Politician%27s_syllogism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Politician%27s_syllogism
- terravion 10y agoShort term thinking is often under-rated in business and people outside of business love to deride "quarterly thinking." Corporate cultures that manage to results and care about interim performance make sure their competitors never see the long term. Also these "quarterly profit driven companies" seem to be able to sustain long term investments like R&D--but R&D that's making progress each quarter.
- closeparen 10y agoThis is the only natural endgame of "you can't manage what you don't measure" and metrics-based results-driven accountability. Particularly when those metrics are quarterly.
- zzalpha 10y agoIt's the same short-termism you see in the sports world. Meh, if the ensuing thread below has taught me anything, it's that one person's short-termism is another person's rational, long-term solution. So couching the argument this way tells us nothing. It just gives us another lens through which we can see the world in a way that we're already predisposed.